Introduction
This forum publishes edited versions of the presentations from two sessions celebrating the centennial of the Conference on Latin American History (CLAH) in Chicago on January 10, 2026: one consisting of four senior scholars discussing the CLAH’s past, and another comprising four junior scholars reflecting on the CLAH’s future. Organized by Erika Denise Edwards, the Executive Director of the CLAH, both sessions were very well attended and featured robust and lively discussions, during which dozens of CLAH members provided additional insights. Together, the panels gathered an array of different perspectives about the premier organization devoted to the study of Latin American history in the United States. We are grateful for the opportunity to discuss the century mark of the CLAH and the future of the organization. We are even more grateful to be able to present edited versions of our papers in this space in The Americas, and we appreciate the help of John F. (“Fritz”) Schwaller in making that happen.
Titled “CLAH’s Institutional Past,” the “senior” panel was chaired by our vice president and president-elect, Herman Bennett. It featured presentations by a former CLAH president (Bianca Premo), a former executive director (su servidor), a self-described “guy behind the scenes” and editor of H-LatAm (John F. Schwaller), and an award winner and former AHA president (Barbara Weinstein). Each of us prepared individual reflections, followed by a vigorous discussion with audience participation. The panel found much to celebrate on the occasion of the CLAH centennial but also spent plenty of time discussing the challenges facing the humanities in general and Latin American history more specifically. We understood our gaze into the past as a reflection of the present and our hopes for and anxieties about the future. The first four articles that follow are edited and (in some places) expanded versions of the conference presentations.
Celso Castilho, the past president of the CLAH, chaired the “junior” panel, “CLAH’s Institutional Future.” This panel included four young scholars in the beginning stages of their career from a variety of institutions (both public and private, located in Texas, Illinois, New York, and Utah, respectively): Ricardo Álvarez Pimentel, Rachel Chery, Stephanie M. Huezo, and Daniela Samur. This panel worked collaboratively, offering individual reflections on a series of common questions. As a result, these four colleagues cooperated in writing an incisive and creative essay that is also an urgent call for action during a time of unprecedented challenges—required reading, indeed, for graduate students and junior faculty in our field.
Together, the five essays presented in this section provide a comprehensive and provocative set of perspectives on the past, present, and future of the Conference on Latin American History. It is our hope that these essays can spur future conversations about the state of the field in which The Americas is one of the preeminent journals. We are thankful for this opportunity and also appreciate Erika’s, Herman’s, and Celso’s assistance in facilitating our conversations in Chicago!
I honestly don’t remember attending my first CLAH/AHA annual meeting. That’s how natural it seemed. It was sometime in the late 1990s, and, since then, I’ve attended more annual meetings than not, making the CLAH part of my own personal and intellectual ritual calendar. Has a New Year really begun without poring over a talk one last time while pouring muddy hotel coffee in the lobby or opting for the weak version from the room’s filter-and-plastic contraption?
Another tradition is my personal, only occasionally vocal, annual resolution not to attend the next year, to space out my participation more. I am often convinced that people have grown weary of hearing about the incremental advances in my scholarship on this topic or that. I suspect this, because, frankly, sometimes watching others make slow history is like watching a pot boil: it’s hard to see the major shifts when you are up close to scholarly production year after year. How strange it would seem to the early founders of the CLAH, who at midcentury struggled to get the AHA to commit to hosting just two panels on Latin America, if they could hear my inner monologue looking at the programs: “Oh, him, talking about sodomy, again? “Or, her, with her work on colonial monsters, or, them, with the paper on the history of salsa music.” Yet, every call for papers or call of duty—to chair a committee, to join the Executive Committee, to run for leadership—has enticed me because it’s an honor to serve. And back again I go, to Boston, San Francisco, New York, Atlanta, learning as historians of Latin American sodomy, monsters, and salsa pry open, bit by bit, a new past for me to consider and, critically, to share with my students.
Like all the panelists that gathered for the one hundred years’ celebration, I am grateful for the CLAH. But I want to reflect on the ingratitude behind my broken vows to take years off. I confess, as the good Catholic I was raised to be, that I have taken the CLAH for granted. But, like the good Catholic I am, I do have to say that if I took the CLAH for granted over three decades, it wasn’t totally my fault. For so long it has seemed so solid, stalwart, dependable, that it almost seemed to have been laid into the very bedrock of History itself, at least for me.
Upon reflection, I’ve particularly taken for granted the way this yearly gathering affects the rest of my year through my teaching. Though the Centennial is a moment to be celebrated, the point of my contribution is like a tale of revelation, technically called an “apocalypse.” And this word is made poignant for me based on my recent experiences in the classroom in the state of Florida, as the link between teaching and research in universities threatens to unravel, and the enterprise of Latin American history as the CLAH historically imagined it is under attack.
In reading through the CLAH archive, it seemed like the possibility that some of us, but only certain of us, could make a secure living as professional researchers and as teachers of Latin American history in the United States was its very point.Footnote 1 From its first stirrings in the exclusive little group of Hispanist men, who gathered as the Hispanic American History Group at the AHA in 1926, the group always aimed to get bigger. I see the work of people such as Clarence Haring and Herbert Eugene Bolton in the 1930s, who, in Marshall Eakin’s comprehensive retelling, sent out a wave of missionaries of history like they were the first twelve Franciscans arriving in Mexico.Footnote 2 They inspired hundreds of their students to preach the gospel of Latin American history—a cadre of White Legendeering male missionaries researching and, critically, teaching the field, looking to add more to their ranks. By 1949, the famed Peruvian historian Jorge Basadre, writing an introduction to a book published by the Pan American Union called “Latin American Courses in the United States,” was able to provide a truly impressive catalog of classes being taught throughout the country, along with research-abroad experiences, graduate programs, and textbooks. He reckoned the number of students these courses touched were in the tens of thousands each year. He described his own moment as a “boom.”Footnote 3
That postwar generation “dragged the field” for Latin Americanist scholars in the US to hit the ball that Fidel Castro teed up, striking a scholarly homerun in the 1960s that Eakin terms “el Boom” (but which we might instead call el gran boom to acknowledge the existence of various eras of growth).Footnote 4 Imagine. Back then, there was a big Ford Foundation grant that permitted all kinds of activity, including CLAH publications, which were inaugurated with the two-volume Latin American History: Its Study and Teaching, 1898–1965, edited by Herbert Cline. The organization thrived, with federal support, along with the field.Footnote 5
Each boom came with a cycle of outreach to students. In 1966, Chairperson Harry Bernstein boasted of new programs for graduate student participation in the CLAH.Footnote 6 The 1968 chair Stanley Ross remarked on what he called “the population explosion” in the field, echoing, but positively, the larger demographic preoccupations around the so-called Third World in the era. He also remarked on the organization’s momentum. Priority was placed on creating a community of belonging for younger, up-and-coming professional historians, and a special letter was sent encouraging faculty to in turn encourage their graduate students to join.Footnote 7 Each time someone has called for more student involvement, the Conference has proved quite responsive. We might be surprised to learn that it was a group of dissatisfied “younger scholars” who complained about the CLAH luncheon being plagued by presentations of boring monographic presentations. In 1953, they asked that the luncheon talk be “devoted to interpretative papers delivered by the better established men in the field” and focus on historiography.Footnote 8
The mention of “men” here points us to areas where appreciation is not merited, even if celebration is. The member news section, “Personal and Professional Notes,” in 1968 counted just under one hundred entries. Four were about women. Not many more of those whose accomplishments were listed had Portuguese or Spanish surnames.Footnote 9 Over time, the CLAH had to become more inclusive to continue to thrive. I won’t recount the whole history, but in the thirty intervening years between el gran boom and the early 2000s, the face of the CLAH and its leadership slowly changed. At the new millennium, when I began to teach in my first position, the CLAH at last counted women as president for several successive years. The organization was on the brink of electing a significant number of Latino, Latin American, and Black leaders, though this transformation was, pace real life in US history, much slower to arrive, raising the question of how to appreciate something that took too long and required the dogged effort of some of those gathered here to achieve. During my time as CLAH President in 2019 and 2020, the organization at long last worked out a code of conduct and procedures for confronting the fact that this organization no longer belongs to that small, exclusive group of white male US Hispanophiles who founded it.
There are also some joyful continuities. In looking through old essays and newsletters, I really came to appreciate the CLAH’s long-standing insistence that this organization, and the research it produced, means nothing if it is not made meaningful to coming generations. There was a strong connection between research and teaching in almost all the materials I perused. It seems like we continually believe that we need to recommit to teaching—the recent Syllabus cum Teaching Prize established originally by Corinna Zeltsman and Casey Lurtz is evidence of this. There is a bit of déjà vu in all this, but it’s somehow comforting to see how the giants of the past such as Basadre struggled, just as we do, with figuring what to focus on in general courses in undergrad teaching. Lest we believe that metrics derived from the field of Education, such as explicit learning outcomes, are entirely new to the scene, Basadre urged professors and textbook writers to leave out more than they crammed in, to abandon the litanies of dates, names, and figures in favor of themes, to “think seriously about the objectives of this course,” and to have “compassion for … students’ memories.”Footnote 10
Basadre’s concern with the undergraduate classroom signals something fundamental about the CLAH. I remember being really impressed at my first CLAH meeting at seeing figures like Lyman Johnson, Asunción Lavrín, and Noble David Cook attend panels that were mostly focused on teaching. Then, in the early 2000s the CLAH was at the height of its membership, with more than one thousand dues-payers. In the years I served in various roles for the conference committee, the program was consistently expanding, rising to fifty and sixty sponsored panels. And our topics had, of course, changed, coming to incorporate next to corsairs, estimates of durable goods, and caudillos, the sodomists, teratologists and salseros whose appearance I came to take for granted. But our commitment to teaching had not. The CLAH in early 2000s were el Boom to me. And even as the job market began to dry up a decade into the millennium, then fade away, there were trends that seemed to bode well for our ability to continue to expose students to the Latin American and Caribbean past. The increasing emphasis on global cultural literacy, decoloniality, transnationalism, and the Atlantic world each gave our discipline boosts if not booms. But here it must be emphasized that these trends would have to be translated by an increasingly precarious teaching workforce, many of whom had little chance to contribute to ongoing research programs outside of the scholarship on teaching, if their heavy loads permitted even that.
From my privileged position on the tenure track, I guess I thought it would always be this way, boomlette and booster ameliorating any stagnation or setbacks from the market or missteps by the organization. The CLAH seemed to be always growing, expanding, a space that might accommodate the conventional as well as the unusual and come to center the once marginal because of its ever-expanding nature. A place for people who knew teaching and research went together.
But today I wonder if the real sin of my ingratitude in swearing off annual attendance, in turning away from the boiling pot, wasn’t so much an impatience at watching slow history cook. Rather it might have involved that other pot boiling cliché, the one involving frogs. Today, the water is at full roil, and I am, frankly, heartbroken and alarmed at the state of our profession. One hundred years of the CLAH comes at a perilous time, fellow CLAHistas, and, if the organization survives to see a bicentennial celebration, its celebrants should not look back and think that we today were less than alert to our moment.
Now, I really struggled with whether to raise the following two alarms. Not so much because I think a centennial must be unabashedly celebratory but because I know that you already know we are in trouble. And hearing it in the carpeted meeting rooms of a hotel or reading it in The Americas might do little to provide a blueprint for action. So I’ll simply highlight how the current trouble specifically affects the legacy of the CLAH on two fronts.
First, as may be evident, one of things that stood out to me in looking back over the CLAH’s history was how seamlessly research and teaching were considered part of the same endeavor at every kind of institution, from Vanderbilt to UT-Austin, from Syracuse to the University of Florida. Though colonialist Charles Gibson did note a growing divide between bloodless, objective academic history and more “emotional” romantic “popular” history, for the most part, he saw research innovation as having a major impact on teaching across the country and at diverse institutions.Footnote 11 In his day, it was the discovery of an Enlightenment in Latin America, that the Spanish like Las Casas had a humanistic side, that metropolitan laws could be obeyed but not followed in the colonies. In ours, it is that sex and gender are unstable categories, that the topic of monsters contained debates about metaphysics and monism, that salsa cannot be understood or appreciated without a knowledge of the way “Latin” music was homogenized and marketed in the hemisphere from places like New York and Miami. Should the attacks on federal funding and tenure at many institutions translate into slowdowns or shutdowns of faculty research agendas, be those agendas fast or slow, we will be entering an unprecedented new phase in which we might continue to innovate how we teach but stagnate in terms producing new stuff to teach. Again, this crisis will be exacerbated by the casualization of labor, specifically in public universities and the possible emergence of a two-tier system in which scholars at private institutions produce new monographic scholarship, while those at public ones, especially those on annual contracts without research assignments, are disincentivized to create new history.
The second alert is that the core mission of Latin American history in the US is under threat. What is that mission? Basadre said that it was equipping US citizens with an understanding and appreciation of the region in its uniqueness and variety while dispelling negative stereotypes drawn from implicit comparison with the US and the rest.Footnote 12 This threat, for me in Florida, has not been abstract. It has come down to a battle over the very presence of Latin American history as an offering fulfilling a general education requirement.
Now, let me say I’m aware that the existence of Latin American history as fulfilling a general education requirement, as opposed to a World or Western Civilization course, is a luxury many of us don’t have. But at a Hispanic-Serving large R1—Florida International University enrolled almost sixty thousand students in recent years, and almost 70 percent are classified as Hispanic—it seems rather central to our mission. In fact, it’s easy to argue it is fundamental to civic education. The state is positioned, like many others with large Latino/x/e populations, to see Latin America and the Caribbean as critical to understanding not just regional history, not just hemispheric history, but all history. And indeed, a survey course on Latin America was, for over a decade, a general education option at most of the eleven universities and many of the state schools in the Florida system. But beginning around 2023, it was clear that something was going to have to change to prove to the Board of Governors and the Department of Education the value of an introductory course on Latin American and Caribbean history.
Thanks to the vaunted “Stop Woke” law, there was increasing pressure on and within the universities in the state to pare down general education lists and to exclusively offer lower-division requirement-fulfilling courses that contained the so-called “Western canon” and whose content venerated the US’s Founding Fathers. I was interim chair of the History Department at the time, and I could see that there was going to be a hard decision to make. Either Latin American History was going to be eliminated from the choices of courses undergraduate students could take to fulfill general education requirements (along with African History), or the policymakers in the government and the university system were going to have be convinced that it was “Western” and contained the “canon.”
Too pained at the possibility that lower-division students might miss an opportunity to discover or deepen their appreciation for the rich and varied past of the region, my colleagues and I opted to sell those in power on the idea that Latin America is Western. We filled a sample syllabus with primary documents that hit the best-known figures and trends in the region such as Bartolomé de las Casas, Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz, Simón Bolivar, and Mario Vargas Llosa. We added course goals that gestured to the centrality of Latin America to the development of the West. And it worked. Momentarily. At FIU, the course was spared from elimination for a year. (Florida currently reviews the general education list annually for conformity with the legislation.) At other state institutions, the course was eliminated from the list, along with courses including introductions to Sociology, Women and Gender Studies, and African Studies. When Basadre wrote in 1949, he talked about how the typical Latin Americanist scholar would have to “leap walls and cross borders in the landscape of knowledge laid out by more isolationist cultivators” in order to teach. Could he possibly have anticipated the intellectual barbed wires and disappearances in the US landscape of higher education today?
Some of you might look askance at our compromise. But I hasten to remind you, not only are colleagues’ livelihoods on the line; so too are the minds of the very coming generations that the CLAH has long claimed it was established to cultivate. And in any case, the compromise, as frequently happens when one side acts in bad faith, has not stuck. It was followed by a volley of demands that the sample syllabus we submitted to make a point about the West become a standard syllabus—that every professor teach 450 years of history exactly the same way—and that we not be permitted to assign any interpretative secondary works to accompany the primary documents lest they run afoul of the prohibition on “woke” teachings about the US, race, and identity. We’ve temporarily made a case to include secondary works in our courses, but every assigned text is now visible on a website for anyone to see, and we must sign an attestation saying no word of it counters state law, including associated laws making violations certain kinds of criticism of the US or making students feel guilt for past occurrences. Think of the appeal of standardized, sanitized, courses to administrators, bureaucrats, and anti-woke crusaders, and pair that with their squealing zeal about AI, and the current landscape becomes even bleaker still.
CLAHistas, the crisis in Latin American and Caribbean history in the US is no longer one of too much repetition at conferences, of overwhelming students by including information about all twenty countries, or even of whether it is taught by adjuncts or tenure-track faculty. It is not even only the massive crisis that AI has sprung on us all. The concession that was made in Florida—the return of the so-called West as the orbit around which history must turn to be taught lest it not be taught at all—is to my mind, the most pressing issue we must confront if we hope to make it another one hundred years. As we figure out how to do so, I’ll try not to skip any upcoming meetings.
Before sharing my personal experience with the CLAH, and especially as a longtime Executive Director of our organization, I want to start with a historical note, complementing the excellent summary that Bianca presented. We are at the beginning of our centennial year rather than its end. Until 1992, the American Historical Association (AHA) met between Christmas and New Year each year. The initial conversation that led to the CLAH’s formation occurred in Rochester, NY, on December 30, 1926. Therefore, the CLAH will officially turn one hundred years old next December 30. So we can celebrate all year while also reflecting upon the serious current challenges that Bianca has described.
I joined the CLAH in 1992 because my advisor, Gil Joseph, told me that I had no choice. As Gil put it, I should consider joining both LASA and SECOLAS, our regional Latin American Studies association, but I needed to become a CLAH member. At the time, I was a poor PhD student about to enter the job market for the first time. I asked Gil, “So what is the CLAH going to do for me?” He told me about the James R. Scobie Awards for initial doctoral research and (more pertinently for me at the time) the Lewis Hanke Award that would help turn a dissertation into a book. There were also book or article prizes. At that time, for a twentieth-century Mexicanist interested in political and economic history, the only available book prize was the Herbert E. Bolton Prize (now Bolton-Johnson Prize), awarded to the book adjudged to be the best in the field published in the previous year. Gil stressed that I would most likely never get anything financially from the CLAH. Instead, what the CLAH could most offer me was networking and community. For an international graduate student from Germany whose paternal grandparents were born in Mexico and who entered the job market on a J-1 student visa, this community was most valuable, especially in making connections with other Latin Americanists who shared my research and teaching interests.
Of course, the community of which Gil spoke was still largely white and male, as Bianca has related. While women held the executive secretary position for a majority of the period from 1928 to 1990, including the first incumbent, all but two of the presidents had been men at the time of my first dues payment to the CLAH. According to the CLAH website, Madaline W. Nichols served as the first woman president in 1949–1950, and Peggy Liss served in 1987. It took until 1994 for women to lead the organization with regularity. Since then, eleven of the past seventeen presidents have been women. Asunción Lavrín became our first Latina president, as late as 2001, and Ben Vinson was our first Black president, beginning in 2021.Footnote 1 Thus, change has been slow to arrive. I agree with you, Bianca, that we should not be proud of such belated transitions that merely reflected change in the historical profession overall.
Before I go on, I will suggest that there is one area where we are behind, one that puzzled me even as a young Mexicanist looking over our list of sections (which has since expanded with the addition of Atlantic World Studies). I have long wondered about the absence of a section devoted to studying the Latin American and Caribbean diaspora in the United States—call it Latine, Latinx, Latino, Latino/a, Hispanic, or any term that you prefer. The CLAH is still an orthodox area-studies organization in some ways. In separating Latin American and Latine history, we build a wall in our heads that does not need to exist. Some colleagues may say, well, those are two different fields, and the experience of the communities of Latin American descent is a part of United States history. But that kind of thinking constructs an artificial separation between the United States and the rest of the Americas. Historians like Kelly Lytle Hernández and others have pushed back against a rigid separation between Latin American and Latine history.Footnote 2 Greg Grandin’s new book, América, America argues that the histories of the United States and Latin America are inextricably linked. Each region is not only porous but also shapes the institutions, laws, and values of the other.Footnote 3 These are not entirely new ideas. As early as 1932, Herbert E. Bolton’s address to the American Historical Association in Toronto attacked the exceptionalism of US historiography. Each national history, Bolton asserted, “will have clearer meaning when studied in the light of the others; and … much of what has been written of each … is but a thread out of a larger strand.”Footnote 4
A section devoted to the history of the Latin American and Caribbean diaspora in the United States can also advance important conversations that will remind the public that Latin American Studies is more than simply “area studies,” a term often associated with Cold War terminology. The United States’ rise to unquestioned regional hegemony in the wake of the Mexican Revolution and World War I created an environment that facilitated the teaching and researching of Latin American history in the United States. The Hispanic American Historical Review first published in 1918, and the CLAH was formed eight years later. The Cold War generated new funding streams as the US government tried to keep left-wing social movements out of what it considered its “backyard,” but it did not create our field.
My first AHA/CLAH meeting was the last one held in December, in Washington, DC. In 1992, I was on the job market and met other Latin Americanists at the Job Register, also known as “the meat market.” I’m from a farming background, and the cattle calls shouted out above the din of an anxious crowd sounded too familiar. That terrifying and humiliating experience was, of course, nothing like what my female colleagues endured in facing interviews in hotel rooms conducted by often all-male search committees. I could not even think about attending panels, let alone the CLAH luncheon. It was not until 1997 in New York City—after my first book had already appeared in print and I had spent the preceding AHA on the other side of the interviewing table, representing what was then Wingate College—that I was able to attend my inaugural CLAH luncheon. I have not missed one since then. That fact may reveal more about my inability to enjoy a proper vacation and family time between the rigors of the fall and spring semesters than it does about my dedication to the CLAH as the community of Latin American historians in the United States and, increasingly, a place that offered me a chance to see my friends in the field at least once a year. As a junior scholar and even as an associate professor, I did not do much for the CLAH. My first committee assignment was as a member of the Bolton-Johnson Prize Committee.
All of that changed one day thanks to Jerry Dávila, who is with us today and who was my colleague at UNC Charlotte until 2013. In 2006, when I was director of Latin American Studies at UNC Charlotte, Jerry suggested that he submit a bid for the executive secretariat of the CLAH to follow Tom Holloway’s successful term at UC-Davis. I thought that was a wonderful idea. At the time, we had a young Latin American Studies program. We only had maybe ten majors, and we were about to add a master’s degree program, but we were very small. I thought that hosting the CLAH was a wonderful way to showcase our role in the university and to grow our program. Jerry’s bid was successful, and for the next five years, I watched Jerry do an outstanding job as the CLAH’s executive secretary. Meanwhile, the new graduate program in Latin American Studies thrived in part because of the presence of the CLAH: students from Brazil, Mexico, and US states as far away as Arizona and Massachusetts chose UNC Charlotte for their graduate education, even though Duke University and UNC Chapel Hill (my alma mater) were a mere two-hour drive away. During our long period as the host (2007–2023), the CLAH helped put UNC Charlotte on the map as a place to study Latin America, even though we do not offer a humanities PhD.
I learned several things from Jerry that I would like to list here because they remain important as we face our challenges. First and foremost, Jerry always emphasized a constructive relationship with the American Historical Association. Of course, we are a separate entity from the AHA. We are an affiliate society, but both the AHA and the CLAH have their own officers and governing structures. Our close connection comes from the decision, made a long time ago, to hold our meeting in conjunction with the AHA to utilize their infrastructure, job register, and book exhibit. This decision meant that we did not have to organize our own meeting with all of the related expenses. To maximize this relationship, Jerry synchronized panel submissions to the CLAH Program Committee process with those sent to the AHA Program Committee. In many years, the AHA adopts most of the panels organized by CLAH members. This synergy was a crucial ingredient in the growth of the CLAH. When members submit a panel to the CLAH in February for the meeting in the coming January, they also send it to the AHA. As a result, Latin Americanists have a greater chance to get accepted to present during the meeting. This dynamic is especially important when we meet in hotels contracted with strict space limits, such as those in New York City or Washington, DC, where the CLAH has maybe twenty-five to thirty panel slots. In our heyday, ninety panels were CLAH offerings—either cosponsored panels with the AHA or stand-alone. One year, Jerry told me that Latin Americanist panels published in the CLAH program made up a quarter of the program of that year’s AHA meeting. We need to remember that. When we deal with the AHA, we know we need them, but they also need us in a big way. When necessary, we should act with confidence with regard to the AHA in light of all of the hotel rooms that we are booking, all of the meeting spaces that we are filling with our attendees, and our overall importance to the vibrancy of the AHA even though they are a larger organization. Another thing that I learned from Jerry was the significance of sound financial management. I will spare you details, but the CLAH didn’t always have sound financial management in the past. For example—and Fritz will talk more about this in a minute—the CLAH had lost track of the balances of the individual prize and award endowments. Jerry, Fritz, Jeff Lesser, and I conceived of a system where the CLAH was able to use a rolling 4 percent endowment draw each year to fund the prizes. That meant that membership dues could go toward annual meeting expenses. Those expenses are a considerable and growing strain on our annual budget and will remain a significant challenge going forward.
These reforms made it easy for me to continue to host the CLAH in Charlotte after Jerry’s term was over and he left for a much-deserved endowed chair position at the University of Illinois. I remain tremendously grateful to Jerry, who is also a dear friend. What I thought was only going to be five years as executive secretary—an office renamed as executive director in the 2019 reforms that Bianca spearheaded as president—turned into eleven years. Five and a half of them with Erika Denise Edwards, and the last six months with Oscar de la Torre, who helped put together the annual meeting. I have fond memories of this period because that was when we finally became more ethnically and racially diverse as an organization. In addition, we made significant strides toward including more graduate students on our panels and ultimately on our Council, as well. We were less successful in our goal of including more Latin American scholars in our conference, in part because of the expense and, recently, the harassment that many international scholars and students face in visiting the United States.
We could not have hosted the CLAH in Charlotte without significant help. Nancy Gutierrez, the longtime dean of what was then the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences, generously funded a graduate assistantship during each of the CLAH’s sixteen years at our university. A long series of graduate students in our MA program in Latin American Studies held this assistantship, and they parlayed their experience in helping to run a nonprofit organization into highly sought-after skills on the job market as well as networking at the CLAH Information Table at the annual meeting. In order of their service, these students included Gloria Lawing, Sarah Levy, Audrey Henderson, Candie Almengor, Nicole Hanna, Lucy Stroud, Rossmery Palacio, and Madison Green. During my tenure as a sole executive secretary (2012–17), I also received tremendous assistance from two annual meeting directors: Audrey Henderson and Marissa Nichols. Finally, I would also like to recognize the dedicated CLAH presidents who made working for the organization a true pleasure: Jeff Lesser (2007–08), Mary Kay Vaughan (2009–10), Cynthia Radding (2011–12), Jane Landers (2013–14), Jerry Dávila (2015–16), Lara Putnam (2017–18), Bianca Premo (2019–20), Ben Vinson III (2021–22), and Celso Castilho (2023–24). All these leaders were unceasing champions of our organization, and all devoted six years to CLAH as members of our Executive Committee: two as vice president and president-elect, two as president, and two as past president. Thirty-six colleagues served on the Council and provided essential advice to the running of the organization, and another 173 presided over our eleven sections. At a time when the neoliberal technocratic university claims so much of our energy, and when the humanities are under relentless attack, it is amazing to see such dedication to the CLAH.
I genuinely enjoyed serving the CLAH and its more than 660 dues-paying members at our peak. Leading or co-leading the CLAH office for eleven years allowed me to do some of the things I cherish the most about being a tenured professor, such as learning about research far removed from my own, facilitating financial resources for junior faculty, and getting to know hundreds of colleagues whom I would never have met otherwise. It also taught me much about nonprofit management, including the importance of a balanced budget so that the CLAH can continue to organize the high-quality annual meetings to which we have all become accustomed. More than anything else, the opportunity to lead the CLAH office was a way to help other people who care about Latin American history just as much as I do.
As we enter our second century, we have our work cut out for us. Nevertheless, I want us to take a moment to celebrate the tremendous strides we have made as an organization, and the mere feat of surviving during a turbulent century. Thank you.
Greetings all, I am John Schwaller. On this panel we have former presidents of the Association, an executive director of the Association, and award winners. I am none of those. I have not had any significant position of responsibility in this organization. I would like to think I might be remembered within the CLAH as the guy behind the scenes. This is important because some “stuff” has happened, hopefully for the good, perhaps for the bad, and maybe it could be traced back to me. My recollection is that I joined the CLAH in 1974, right before I went to Mexico for my field research for my dissertation. That is a long time ago, fifty-two years. It is half the life of the organization. My two dissertation advisors at Indiana University were very different people. Both took me under their wings, almost like a competition. My official dissertation advisor, because he was the senior professor, was Robert Quirk, who worked on the Mexican Revolution. My effective dissertation advisor was John Lombardi, because he was a colonialist. They both offered me strong advice. It was very clear—just as in other cases presented today—that I was supposed to join these professional organizations. It was just not even to be debated. At that point, I joined AHA, the CLAH, and LASA. These organizations became an integral part of my being as a scholar.
Presenting a paper at the AHA/CLAH annual meeting is something of a rite of passage for most young PhDs, or ABDs. I think I gave my first paper in 1978, having recently returned from Mexico and Spain with my dissertation almost completed. I remember the room very well. I also remember that some members of the audience started to criticize me because I was doing an analysis of the Church clergy that they had not heard before. It was a new kind of analysis of the social origins and career patterns of the clergy. During the discussion, there was a priest sitting there in his clerical collar who stood up and said, “No. Dr. Schwaller is absolutely correct. We need to listen to this.” It was Stafford Poole. From that moment on, he became one of the most important persons in my life, other than my advisers.
Since then, I have served on several committees within the CLAH, notably the Mexico and the colonial sections. Back in the ’80s, I helped to create a historical statistics committee, which was eventually merged with the Demographics Committee. I also was program chair for the CLAH meeting when John Lombardi was president of the Association. More recently, I have been a very active supporter of the teaching committee, as we have sought to create an endowment for a teaching award. One of my former students at Florida Atlantic University, Jackie Kent, went on to Tulane for her doctorate. She was one of the two founders of the discussion group of H-LatAm. In those days, it was known as a listserv. It eventually became incorporated into the H-Net family of discussion groups. Interestingly, when she was my student, I had started a listserv on Bitnet, which was the predecessor of the internet, about Nahuatl. In my mind, I hoped that maybe I somehow was the godfather of H-LatAm. I am now the senior editor of H-LatAm.
I think that my major contribution to the CLAH occurred in 2006–08, a period known as the Great Recession. Many of you do not know, but back then the finances of the organization were quite confused. The secretariat had moved from UC-Davis to UNC-Charlotte. Some records were lost, and, because of the financial issues in the country, it was difficult to run the organization as a result of irregular dues collection. The biggest problem was that the CLAH had a potential fiscal crisis where we possibly could not pay our bills for the simple reason that we depended upon dues for our ongoing activities. During the Great Recession, because of issues like job insecurity and financial instability, members were slow in paying their dues. But we still had the prizes we had to pay for. We still had the meetings that we had to pay for. As a result, four of us, admittedly white guys, got together, and we started discussing the situation. We knew that the CLAH was not bankrupt, nor would we default on any payment. We are blessed with an endowment that gives us a large degree of flexibility to address issues like this.
Four of us, Jürgen Buchenau, Jerry Dávila, Jeff Lesser (from Emory), and I, started a series of discussions as to how to stabilize the finances of the organization. The discussions lasted about a year and a half. At that point, I had a day job that put me in touch with my financial side. I was managing a university budget, as a college president. The four of us put our heads together and figured out how to best manage the finances of the CLAH. In this effort, we created the system that we currently have. It is working rather well. In the system that we developed, we recognize that have a comfortable endowment for a society of our size. We did not understand how to meet the needs of the organization while keeping the endowment from suffering. It was a management issue. What we did was to consider the endowment as a corpus, a whole entity, not as bits and pieces associated with individual prizes. Because the secretariat had moved a few times, the organization did not have the records to determine which piece of the endowment was associated with which particular prize. Our plan was to then draw 4 percent of the earnings of the whole endowment in any given year. This was calculated on a three-year rolling average. Association leadership would calculate what the average earnings were over a three-year period, and that became the amount that we could withdraw. Research has shown that in using around 4 percent of the corpus to pay for the prizes, the endowment will continue to grow faster than inflation. In general, endowments have grown by 8 percent over the last century.
Thus, the first part of the plan was to judiciously use the endowment. The second step was to make certain that the organization had cash on hand equal to about two years of expenses. In this way, if the stock market would crash and there would be widespread financial instability resulting in delayed dues payment, we would still be able manage for two years. These are the two elements of the system that we currently use. When the CLAH meets in New York or San Francisco, where the costs are just extraordinary, we can draw a little bit more money out of that cash reserve. But then, when we meet in a less expensive venue, the theory is that we are supposed to put some of that cash back in the two-year reserve. Keeping the cash reserves where we need them is difficult but essential, in that it provides a cushion against high-expense years. The Executive Committee of the CLAH will continue to have the debate about the cash reserves. As a result of this, one of the things that I am particularly proud of with Dávila, Buchenau, and Lesser is that we have helped to stabilize the finances of the organization.
Coming back to my original point, I want to be known as the guy who worked behind the scenes, and who helped to keep the organization viable and ongoing, because we all love it so much. Over the years, the CLAH has allowed me to stay in contact with my profession. Most of you know that, in the last twenty-five years of my career, I was an administrator. When I became an administrator, I set for myself a goal to keep abreast of the new research in Latin American history. I taught classes regularly. I had to work every day to stay in abreast of the field. I wrote books. I served on an editorial board of a journal. I reviewed books. This is something that most deans, provosts, and presidents do not do. But I did it because of my love for Latin American history. It defined me more than being an administrator did. I knew that, on any given day, it was possible that I would be fired from my administrative position. Thankfully, I always had tenure as a faculty member, so that I could always return to those duties. The CLAH is the organization that provided me with the needed contact with the larger profession. When I was a young scholar, I would go to the meetings and to the cocktail party. I would just sit in awe. There was Charles Gibson. There was Woodrow Borah. These were scholars whose work I idolized. When I became a professor myself, the meetings were wonderful because I could meet the people that I knew who had done graduate work with me, or who had been in the field with me. Sylvia Arrom and I became very close friends while researching our dissertations. We almost got killed while we traveled in the Mexican countryside with our spouses. My wife and I became close to Elinor Melville when she was a graduate student. Later she would live with us at our home in Cuernavaca for a week here or there. It was the CLAH that provided the reason to renew our friendship annually. The CLAH cocktail party was a moment in which we could get back together and talk. Then I could also meet all the new grad students coming up. I remember my son’s dissertation advisor when he was a graduate student, Matthew Restall. Over the years he and I have also become close as colleagues and supported one another’s research. Now, when I go back to the cocktail party, I do not know most of the people. But that is because the profession does go on. We continue to be interested in solving the issues that help us to understand Latin America better, and to spread that information to the world at large. This is the heart of the CLAH. We support one another, and we send that information out into the world.
First, I have to apologize, because these are going to be very informal and maybe slightly incoherent remarks. That means they will be a direct contrast to Bianca Premo’s incredible presentation, which practically reduced me to tears. It was really hard to hear the details of what is happening in Florida, though it made me even prouder to be a New Yorker and a constituent of Mayor Zohran Mamdani.
My association with the CLAH extends back more years than I want to count. Aside from being present at many CLAH luncheons (where I never actually had a good meal, but heard many good talks), and participating in or attending many CLAH panels, I’ve been chair of the Brazilian Studies committee, a member of the CLAH Council, and with my dear colleagues at the University of Maryland, Mary Kay Vaughan and Daryle Williams, I was editor of the HAHR for five years. Forgive me for repeating things that have already been said by others on the panel, but I know from my time on the AHA Council that the CLAH is very crucial to the health and welfare of the American Historical Association. It is really the CLAH that guarantees that every single meeting has a very large representation from the field of Latin American history. The AHA is beholden to the CLAH for ensuring that a certain number of people in our field show up for the meetings, and that an area beyond the US and Europe always has a robust presence. And yet, I have to say that, until recently, I think the Association struggled to recognize this. I’ve been on the program committee for the AHA meetings twice, once as the Latin Americanist on the committee and the second time as the co-chair. When I was the Latin Americanist on the committee, for the 2001 meetings, I felt that there was still some reluctance to allot “so many” slots in the program to Latin American panels. I am pleased to say that by the time I was co-chair, in 2005, this had noticeably receded as a concern. You could see a shift away from the previous overwhelming emphasis on US and Europe. One of the more pleasant tasks I had when I became AHA president (2007) was to appoint the chair of the program committee for that year. Eager to continue to push the AHA program in new directions, I chose Pete Sigal, who had done some very innovative work on colonial Latin America, and who I knew would be likely to oversee an “edgier” AHA program than the usual fare. I think it was a wise choice, but I do remember the AHA executive director being slightly taken aback when the program chair for the 2008 meetings arrived sporting a black leather jacket and a neon blue mohawk. This may have permanently imprinted on her an image of Latin Americanists as renegades in the usually genteel field of history. In any case, I think the committee produced a really interesting program for the AHA meetings that year.
My own early experience with the CLAH was similar to that of others on this panel, dating back to my first AHA meeting in the 1970s. I was still a graduate student, and I could attend because there was a meeting in New York City. I did not have to come up with any money to travel and didn’t have to stay at a hotel because I was at Yale and so it was not far away. The CLAH immediately gave me a home within the massive AHA convention, which was very intimidating to a young graduate student. It was crucial to have something like the cocktail party where you could meet other young scholars as well as eminent members of the field. I do have to say that I was politically opposed to the idea of idolizing my senior colleagues, but I certainly respected them and appreciated being able to put faces to the names of people whose work I was reading. Overall, I feel very indebted to the CLAH; I had wonderful experiences at the panels and other activities that the CLAH sponsored.
But now I am going to recall some aspects of life in the historical profession that were not always so comfortable, specifically, the experience of being a young woman going to a CLAH meeting at a time when there was not a single tenured woman in any of the major universities for training doctoral students in Latin American history. This is hard to believe, and I may be wrong, but I think in the mid-’70s this was literally the case. There were a couple of junior women, some of whom did not get tenure, like Karen Spalding at Columbia. It is sort of ironic because the two people I worked with most closely as a graduate student were Emília Viotti da Costa and Karen Spalding, both women. Emília did not get tenure until I was almost out of the doctoral program. Thus, even she was not an exception. There were some women who were Latin Americanists who were already at research universities, but the only woman I could recall who was at a major university, but not one then known for training in Latin American history, was Nancy Farriss at the University of Pennsylvania, who got tenure in 1971. Thinking about major Latin American history programs of the day like Berkeley, UCLA, Chicago, Michigan, Wisconsin, Yale (until Emília came), and Columbia, there were no tenured women. As a result, if you were going to study Latin American history, you were going to study it with a man, probably a white man.
This meant that coming to CLAH meetings in those days felt a little weird; first of all, there were very few older women, and every woman knows that one of the ways in which younger women feel more comfortable or not so out of place is if there are older women present. I also think that because most of the men in the room had little experience interacting with women as their intellectual equals, they fell back on what would be the usual ways to interact with women who they assumed were not their intellectual equals: which was either to be fatherly, or to flirt, or worse. There were, to be sure, many men in the room who behaved absolutely wonderfully, but there were others who did not. Thus, for a number of years, I was eager to go to the CLAH luncheon, eager to go to CLAH panels, eager to go to the CLAH cocktail party, but I also always tried to hang out with a cluster of other young women so as to feel a little less uneasy about the situation. As Jürgen correctly noted, women were not yet involved in the CLAH leadership in those days, but of course it wasn’t that women did not want to be; it was only that we were all so junior—graduate students or brand-new assistant professors. The convention in our field was that somebody who was still a graduate student or who had just gotten their PhD would not hold a leadership position, even serve on the program committee, let alone be eligible for the presidency of the CLAH. That was and is the standard hierarchy in the academic profession. But what it meant is that there were really almost no women who were in positions of authority within the CLAH or held other positions of responsibility.
By the same token, very few of the existing book and article prizes went to women historians. I checked the list and can confirm that some twenty years passed before Doris Ladd won the Bolton Prize (created in 1956) for her 1976 study of the Mexican Nobility at the time of independence. Though I have to admit that my pleasure at discovering that a woman had finally won the best book prize was dampened a bit when I saw honorable mention that year went to Warren Dean’s immensely influential study of coffee and slavery, Rio Claro: A Brazilian Plantation System, which I will venture to say has had a more enduring influence than Doris Ladd’s fine yet very Mexico-specific book, reflecting a more general pattern of underestimating scholarship on Brazil. But I will get to that second part of my somewhat grumpy (if still affectionate) remembrances of the CLAH from the early decades of my career in the next paragraph. Before moving on to that, I want to acknowledge how thoroughly the composition of the field has changed, particularly with regard to gender, and how fully that transformation is reflected in every aspect of the organization. If, for the first fifty years of the CLAH’s existence, exactly one woman served as chairperson (the position that, after 1987, was renamed “president”), during the last twenty years, over half have been women. The extreme gender imbalance of my early years in the field has been so radically transformed that it might almost seem unnecessary to mention it, especially considering the persistence of other forms of imbalance. But as Bianca Premo’s presentation makes evident, we can never take any transformation for granted, as it is never necessarily permanent. I do not think anyone is proposing to kick women out of the historical profession, the way Pete Hegseth wants to kick women out of the military. But I do think that every kind of victory, no matter how resounding, has to be consciously acknowledged in order to guard against reversals.
While the lopsided gender composition of the CLAH was painfully obvious back in the 1970s and ’80s, another perception I had about the CLAH reflected something that for me was significant but perhaps not so apparent. That was the somewhat awkward or uneasy position of Brazil and Brazilianists in the collective life of Latin American historians. Some of the reasons for this—a different language, a different empire—might be obvious, but I think there’s more to it than that. Thinking back to the scholars that Schwaller mentioned in his comments, you can see the way in which Latin American history emerged from a kind of “civilizationist” approach to historical inquiry. Those who worked on the great empires, more specifically the Spanish Empire, and empires that the Spanish conquered and their descendants—those were the scholars whose work fit most easily into the notion of what a historian should be doing as the field of Latin American history was emerging and coalescing. I have observed this in the intellectual trajectory of Frank Tannenbaum, whom many considered the “dean” of Latin American history in the mid-century decades, but who didn’t get his first permanent academic job, at Columbia, until 1935, at the age of forty-two, and had previously published on a remarkably wide array of subjects. I think it was not random or coincidental that Tannenbaum, when he finally got hired by Columbia (as their only Latin Americanist, of course), decided to turn his attention to Peru, and eventually drafted the first of a projected three-volume history that began with the pre-encounter period and the Conquest (The Age of Gold) and then was to continue through the colonial and independence eras (The Age of Silver), and end with the postcolonial period (The Age of Copper). For those wondering why they have never read or even heard of this opus on Peru, the reason is simple: none of it, not even the drafted first volume, saw publication. Tannenbaum sent it to Luis Valcárcel and Jorge Basadre, the two leading historians of Peru at that time, and received positive feedback, but the years between the end of World War II and the Cuban Revolution could be described as the doldrums for publishing on Latin America. Unless it was something that directly connected to the United States, no editor wanted to publish it, even his good friend Alfred Knopf. Yet Tannenbaum somehow felt that he had to write something like that to be a “proper” Latin American historian.
I do not want to make too much of the awkward position that Brazilian history occupied in the CLAH, because many of us study countries or societies or issues that haven’t been particularly central to the historiography of Latin America. But it is noteworthy that, if we look at the Bolton over the years, the prizes have gone overwhelmingly either to colonialists or historians of Mexico and the Mexican Revolution. During the approximately fifty years that I have been aware of and engaged with the CLAH, only five books on Brazil have won the Bolton/Bolton-Johnson Prize for best book. There are quite a few honorable mentions of books on Brazil, but during a long stretch of time, scholarship on Brazil occupied a somewhat problematic place (I am tempted to say a “marginal” place, but that seems a little too extreme) in the field of Latin American history, and this was reflected and reproduced in the limited recognition it received from CLAH prize committees. What rescued Brazil from this awkward position, I would argue, was the surging interest in slavery, slave emancipation, and the African diaspora in Latin American studies. Emblematic of this was the awarding of the 2017 Bolton-Johnson Prize to Celso Castilho’s outstanding study of popular abolitionism in Brazil. The recognition of Castilho’s work was especially meaningful because it had been several years since any book on slavery or slave emancipation had been honored in this way. Needless to say, many of our colleagues working on the colonial period in Spanish America, or on Indigenous peoples, are doing fascinating research, and none of my remarks should be interpreted as disparaging that. But I would say that the CLAH—which in principle encompasses every facet of Latin American history—was relatively slow to fully embrace the significance of the African experience in the Americas and the centrality of enslaved labor in Brazil and elsewhere in Latin America.
Still, I want to conclude on an upbeat note and again acknowledge how extraordinarily important the CLAH has been for me and for everyone I know in the field of Latin American history. And so whatever criticisms or concerns I ever harbored have always been mixed with a great deal of gratitude for all the time and effort that our colleagues have volunteered to keep the Conference on Latin American History a vital, welcoming, and stimulating aspect of our scholarly community.
Since its conception in 1926, the Conference on Latin American History (CLAH) has advocated for the importance of researching, studying, and teaching Latin American history. During this century, the organization’s structure and membership have changed, but its commitment to “furthering the study and teaching of Latin American history and a desire to encourage the diffusion of knowledge about the region and its people” remains the same.Footnote 1 A hundred years later, we hope the CLAH will continue its commitment to the study of Latin American history, to the advancement of the field within the broader historical discipline, and to the professional development of its members. All of us have directly benefited from the CLAH’s existence and from participating in the various opportunities the organization offers to its members. We have served as panelists, commentators, and chairs of panels at the annual conference in January and have done so not only to share our research and work in progress, but more importantly to contribute to the professional community of scholars committed to Latin American history. Over the past few years, some of us have also served as section secretaries and chairs, on the Executive Committee, and as members of prize committees. In doing so, we have been able to closely learn about how the CLAH works as an organization, what its current challenges are, and what potential paths it can take in the future.
When the CLAH called on us to participate in a panel on the organization’s future during the 2026 annual meeting in Chicago, we did not hesitate to join, because we understood the importance of the CLAH for the professional development of Latin Americanists. As we commemorate one hundred years of the CLAH’s existence, we celebrate the support that generations of scholars have received, and the work that the CLAH and its members have done to advance the study of Latin American history. Centennials, however, are never just about the past, but about the present and future. As we celebrate, we also take this as a moment of reckoning. This piece is a result of our interventions at the panel, the conversations we had with each other and the audience, and the exchanges and reflections the four of us continued to have in the months thereafter. It is an effort to ponder how the CLAH has served us during our journey to become professional historians and the opportunities we see to strengthen the organization, to defend the importance of Latin American history and historical inquiry more broadly in our current times, and to build the CLAH of the future collectively and collaboratively.
The CLAH’s Networks and Opportunities
We are all early-career historians who have been a part of and participated in the Conference on Latin American History for several years. Like many of our peers, the CLAH has been an important component of our professional lives since graduate school. Our first introduction to the CLAH was through advisors, professors, and graduate-school friends who viewed the organization as a space to share works in progress with a community of Latin Americanists eager to support each other. As we developed as researchers in graduate school, studying Haiti’s twentieth-century transnational radio history (Rachel), the materiality of state-formation in Colombia (Daniela), right-wing politics in twentieth-century Mexico (Ricardo), and popular and political consciousness in Salvadoran communities (Stephanie), the CLAH fostered formal and informal opportunities crucial to all of us at critical junctures in our careers.
The annual meetings in January have been and continue to be especially important in offering both formal and informal avenues for graduate students and early-career scholars to develop academically and professionally. For a number of students, the CLAH’s annual meeting has served as their first opportunity to present at a conference, providing a supportive environment in which to build confidence and refine presentation skills. Beyond the act of presenting, the CLAH’s collegial and welcoming atmosphere has fostered students’ intellectual growth, as audiences have engaged in thoughtful dialogue and provided helpful feedback on their work. For Rachel, as a PhD student focusing on the Caribbean, having the opportunity to attend panels and workshops that allowed her to see how the issues she was considering intersected with histories across the hemisphere challenged her to think more expansively about the possibilities for her work. More broadly, the CLAH’s broad regional approach encourages critical exchanges that unite both Latin America and the broader Caribbean, making room for a new wave of questioning. For his part, Ricardo has found it helpful to attend the yearly Mexico section panels as an opportunity to catch up with old friends, network with new scholars, and remain up-to-date on the latest research. These conversations were particularly useful to him during graduate school, as he returned from a four-semester leave of absence following the birth of his son. The breadth of the panels, along with informal coffee chats and hallway conversations at the annual meetings, has offered all of us opportunities to think more expansively about our projects at critical points in our dissertations and, later, book projects.
Moreover, the CLAH has and continues to offer graduate students like Rachel broader opportunities to think through their archival material, and to refine and deepen their dissertation ideas by working out their arguments in conversation with senior scholars and peers, both at the conference and through other networks and opportunities for dialogue the organization offers. For tenure-track faculty like Stephanie, Ricardo, and Daniela, the CLAH fosters an academic community that supports the transformation of the dissertation into a monograph and the development of a second project, all while navigating the tenure-track system across a broad spectrum of universities, from Catholic institutions to state schools and small Christian universities. The mentorship from senior faculty and conversations with peers in similar trajectories also support early-career scholars as they become teachers and develop new courses and embark on new forms of service to their respective departments, schools, universities, and the profession. By coupling this with financial support, particularly at early-career stages, through the Scobie, Hanke, and Lydia Cabrera Awards, the CLAH fosters a space where career transitions are possible, especially as academic career paths and funding opportunities become more precarious.
Our experiences demonstrate that these spaces and informal interactions also offer opportunities for networking and supporting students and early-career scholars as they navigate the various transitions through different stages of their academic and personal trajectories. The CLAH also provides individuals of all backgrounds (academics and independent scholars alike) the opportunity to build networks of support and engage in community building. The annual conference is a time to see old friends, make new ones, remain connected to the field, and meet scholars whose work has inspired us. Equally important are the peer networks that emerge at the CLAH, which extend beyond the conference itself and become enduring intellectual communities. For example, Stephanie’s participation in the Central American section panels has led to invitations to other institutions to share her research. She also used this space as an opportunity to recruit scholars to contribute to her upcoming co-edited volume on Central American studies. Daniela’s participation on a panel at the 2024 conference led to an invitation to write an article for a special issue for a journal, and she greatly benefited from the feedback and support from the co-panelists and invited editors, all of whom came together through the CLAH. Ultimately, the networks of care, support, critical feedback, and collegiality enabled by the CLAH keep us all connected and engaged. At the same time, the opportunities we have had to forge intellectual and social communities through the CLAH have shaped who we are and our trajectories as scholars. We hope that the CLAH will continue to be a space that aids us all and that it continues to support the study of Latin American history, especially as we navigate uncertain times.
History Matters and the CLAH Matters
It is a platitude to state that our discipline is at risk. Over the past several years, and at an increasingly accelerated pace, undergraduate enrollments have been decreasing (at some places), graduate cohorts have been shrinking, and grants, fellowships, and jobs have been disappearing. The termination of fellowships from the National Endowment for the Humanities in 2025 is just one example of this dilemma. Public and private universities continue to increase teaching loads, and more worryingly, rely on the labor of graduate students, lecturers, and adjuncts who often do not receive most of the benefits granted to other teaching and research faculty. In the name of “efficient restructuring,” the senior leadership at universities across the United States have been following the neoliberal playbook of austerity, leading university budgets to become leaner—at least those that do not are entirely siphoned off for units promising supposedly higher returns. In the past few months and years, public and private universities have diminished or eliminated entire programs, units, departments, and colleges, and amidst these so-called efforts at “cutting costs,” faculty have been offered “early retirement plans.” Some universities have settled on hiring freezes for the foreseeable future and reduced or even halted graduate admissions.Footnote 2 Others have closed altogether.Footnote 3 Financial precarity, underemployment, and the increasing likelihood of not getting a job after graduation together make the future look grim. Meanwhile, the restrictions on, and elimination of, federal research funding have already begun to exacerbate disparities between academic institutions. We fear that the colleges and universities that most depend on these opportunities will grow more limited in their ability to train graduate students and support student and faculty scholarship. For Latin Americanists, this involves language training, international conferences, and research trips outside the United States. Without the support of external funding, it is likely that only certain kinds of institutions (e.g., Ivies, wealthy private colleges, or large state schools) will be able to provide their faculty and students with these resources, thus deepening structural inequalities and limiting the places where Latin American history can be studied, written, and rewritten.
Moreover, federal and state legislatures have been questioning the role of tenure and pushing for its elimination, and in states like Florida, Texas, Oklahoma, Ohio, Kentucky, and Tennessee, antitenure bills have already been passed.Footnote 4 Many of them call for assessing faculty adherence to “intellectual diversity,” replacing lifetime tenure appointments with renewable contracts, and establishing provisions for evaluating and terminating tenure altogether. Others have also tried to establish mechanisms to oversee course content, make all syllabi publicly available, ban certain topics, and replace courses on history with ones on “civics” or Western civilization.Footnote 5 And to receive withheld funding, many universities have caved in. The attacks on the historical discipline that have led to a rejection of difference, the erasure of previous injustices, and the dismissal of diverse perspectives and competing interpretations of the past are shocking and destabilizing. The recent politicization and erasure of the past, coupled with the questioning of the work historians do, can be seen in the fabrication of facts, the distortion and negation of slavery and other well-documented forms of oppression, and the destruction of monuments commemorating the struggles of marginalized groups (e.g., The Stonewall Inn in New York). Indeed, these developments prove that history matters, and that history is a powerful tool. Still, the assault on what historians say and write has brought fear, anger, and despair to the academic community. It has also had profound material implications: many of our colleagues, students, and friends have already lost their visas, jobs, and livelihoods.
Against this backdrop, we continue to believe in the CLAH’s mission of promoting the study and teaching of Latin American history for political, professional, and personal reasons. Some of us are from the regions we study, whether through birth or heritage, and we are now living in the diaspora. We thus have a deep commitment to learning and disseminating knowledge about the region, and to uncovering voices, perspectives, and events not highlighted in the established academic literature. Ultimately, we cannot divorce our work from politics, which inevitably touches all that we do. As historians, we seek to contribute to the public’s understanding of how the past informs the present. And our research enables us to do that, regardless of our regional and thematic expertise. By looking at the importance of solidarity formation through radio (Rachel), the intersections between race, gender, and authoritarian politics (Ricardo), the materiality of state formation and space-making (Daniela), and processes of grassroots organizing through popular education in El Salvador and its US diaspora (Stephanie), our research helps to inform current-day realities in both Latin America and the United States.
Aside from researching the past of places we are from, care about, and/or are interested in, we teach about the entire Latin American region and its connections to the wider world. We do so at very different places but similarly demonstrate how the stories of the past are very much alive in our present. Like all of us, many of our students, their families, and loved ones have connections to Latin America. Others have traveled through the region, or speak Spanish, Portuguese, Quechua, Haitian Creole, Garifuna, Guaraní, or many of the other languages and dialects, thereby acquiring a sense of familiarity and belonging. Many do not have either of those backgrounds or experiences. Yet, our responsibility is to make these histories relevant to all of our students so that they become aware of what we know too well—despite geographical distance, our lives in the United States are intimately tied with those in Latin America and the Caribbean. The ability to purchase pupusas from a Salvadoran street vendor in Washington DC, listen to people speak Haitian Creole in South Florida, attend a Colombian Independence parade in New York City, or call Native and formerly Mexican territories part of the US Southwest, highlights this intimacy. We aim for our students to understand the impacts of US westward expansion and Manifest Destiny just as much as we emphasize how the Cold War’s foreign and neoliberal policies toward Latin America resulted in migration and diaspora, stressing too the role of the region’s own racial, ethnic, gendered, and class inequalities in shaping these connections. These histories are important not only to those of us who have devoted our professional careers to studying and teaching Latin America, but also to our students who are living in a globalized world. Learning about these histories, as well as the historical skills that help us to understand them, become necessary to combat misinformation and the erasure of Latin American stories and voices. We try to make sure that our students learn about Latin America and its peoples on the region’s own terms, and not as a “backyard” or a mirror of the US Empire. We thus stress that people in Latin America are agents of their own lives, and not passive recipients of things that happen up North. We believe that a more acute and nuanced exploration of Latin American history will help students develop empathy and understanding with people throughout the hemisphere. These skills are vital for the future of US–Latin American relations and for raising a healthy public awareness around the issues that bind the two regions together.
The CLAH has been essential in helping us to do so. By pursuing pedagogically oriented conference programming, the CLAH has helped us become better teachers and not just better historians. Spaces like the annual Teaching and Teaching Material section panels have allowed us to think through pedagogical materials and methodologies to better serve our diverse student bodies. Over the past six years, the CLAH has also organized online panels, talks, and most recently a book launch to help us expand and adapt our teaching strategies, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. Awards such as the CLAH syllabus award and the Teaching Award highlight the importance of teaching and the CLAH’s commitment to this major component of our profession. Besides these more structured opportunities, informal conversations with colleagues at the annual meetings also teach us about assignments that students enjoy and from which they learn best, or about articles or books that work well for particular themes or learning objectives. All these exchanges and opportunities to learn enable us to improve our syllabi design, try out new teaching approaches, redefine how we conceive “active learning,” and adjust general principles to the specifics of our classrooms and students. These opportunities are even more necessary today as we grapple with an ever-changing world in which rapid techno-political tools try to challenge our know-how and seek to dismiss and trivialize the past. Our shared knowledge and expertise, and the bonds we have built, we believe, are crucial for navigating these times and maintaining our commitment to promote the research and teaching of Latin American history.
Conclusions: The CLAH’s Future
Because of our commitment to ourselves, our communities, our students, and, more broadly, the history of Latin America, we, like so many other members, have invested our time and energy to make sure the CLAH continues to serve all of us. We all want the CLAH to continue to grow as a space for learning, reflection, and potential action.
As such, we envision that the CLAH can continue to serve us and future generations by expanding the support for graduate and early-career members. To be more inclusive, we might consider adding an undergraduate section like the AHA (American Historical Association) has done to encourage undergraduate students to take an interest in Latin American history and to provide a space for mentorship. While costs may be a barrier for undergraduate students to attend the conference, we could attract undergraduates local to the city where the conference is held and have the CLAH members serve as mentors for the paper they will present at an undergraduate-only panel. We could also provide students with opportunities to volunteer to defray the cost of attending or presenting.Footnote 6 The Teaching and Teaching Material section can help facilitate connecting students to mentors. More importantly, as members, we should commit to attending students’ panels and supporting them. Along those lines, mentorship should be provided for all career stages. Undergraduate and graduate students can benefit from mentorship on various issues, from applying to surviving graduate school, writing Honors, Master’s theses, and PhD dissertations, and learning how to win fellowships and grants in a shrinking pool of support. Early and mid-career support can also include tools for applying for fellowships and workshops for book proposals or for chapters in-progress. While senior scholars in our field have been important mentors to the younger generations of scholars, peer mentorship can be equally relevant. It can be useful, for instance, as a means to share successful strategies to continue publishing, to develop a second project, to balance new research and teaching projects simultaneously, or to find support in different service roles, such as members of search committees, departmental executive committees, Directors of Graduate Studies, or directors of Departments or Centers for Latin American Studies.
As a national organization, the CLAH could consider hosting virtual and in-person regional meetups. These could take the form of informal networking events, book talks, archival presentations, or paper workshops. All of us also consider that having more systematic workshops to support students and faculty at different stages in their careers would also be an encouraging and helpful tool. Recently, President Alejandra Bronfman started a writing workshop, setting a wonderful precedent for similar ones. Some of us would love to see workshops on the job market for graduate students, on identifying reviewers for tenure files for early-career faculty, or on second-book projects for those in their mid-career. Online exchanges and conversations might also involve panels and information sessions around current events and developing situations. Of course, we recognize that these types of initiatives would require volunteers and additional communication, but if we strive to create an inclusive and supportive community, seeing our colleagues from across the country more than once a year may be enough motivation to set aside some hours for these kinds of gatherings. Like all things at the CLAH, all these efforts will rely on our voluntary labor. We believe that the CLAH belongs to all of us, and that it falls on each member to promote its growth and sustainability.
In the political climate that we currently live in, it is inevitable that we feel an urgency to protect and support our discipline and our communities. But doing advocacy work and being politically active or vocal might mean something different to each of us. And while we all might agree that history is important, we might never agree as to how we can best convey how and why. We believe that the CLAH could or should play a stronger role in advocating for its members and for history as a discipline, although we do understand that some CLAH members do not consider that to be the organization’s responsibility, and that it is in no position to do so. Whatever one’s position, what we have taken from the conversation during and after the panel is that we do need to stand together, to find ways to stay connected, and to support each other. Such aspirations might also sound like platitudes. So, we need to find the means to make them a reality. Most of us are aware that public statements condemning the attack on our members or the violation of the sovereignty and self-determination of the countries we study and/or from where we come do not do all that much to help. They are important as expressions of support, but virtue signaling alone is not enough.
A potential project that we all consider important and useful in the near future is for the CLAH to embrace the organization of workshops, roundtables, or information sessions about current issues, as other associations have done. Doing so would provide opportunities to disseminate much-needed information and resources among member and offer spaces to think, debate, and learn—which is what we already do elsewhere. Experts on a particular country can do a panel to discuss what is happening in moments of crisis, for instance. Information sessions and publications on current events or pressing historical questions are just one way to share information and create networks of support. Some of these initiatives, we believe, could eventually become special issues in journals. The CLAH could also invite its members to collaborate on creating reading lists or suggesting teaching materials that might be helpful for all of us, as we try to address current issues in our classrooms. One model to follow here would be LASA (the Latin American Studies Association) or some of the work done by the AHA, or MESA (the Middle Eastern Studies Association). While the CLAH is a much smaller organization with less overall structural capacity, it should not be an excuse to stay silent. With our diverse range of expertise and skills, the CLAH membership can do something impactful. Like some of these other professional organizations, the CLAH could host not just scholars, but diplomats, activists, or other notable public figures to raise awareness of the issues at hand. It could also host its own film screenings, though perhaps not an entire film series (as LASA does), as a way to connect members to meaningful conversations around topics of social justice or current interest that are relevant for the hemisphere.Footnote 7
As we think about where the CLAH will be in one hundred years, we envision an organization that takes proactive stances before the issues of our present time: namely, attacks on academic freedom and the historical discipline, geopolitics, and the precarity of the academic job market. More importantly, however, we hope that in the decades to come, the CLAH will continue to foster community and professionalization as integral parts of who we are. We recognize that many of the objectives highlighted in this article might seem overly ambitious. But if there was ever a time to aspire to bold action, it’s now.
Hasta la victoria siempre / Men anpil, chay pa lou.
Ever onward to Victory / Many hands make the load light.
