Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 July 2017
En 1982, Eddie Mabo, originaire des îles Murray, intente avec quatre autres membres de sa communauté, une action en justice contre l'État du Queensland devant la Haute Cour australienne pour obtenir la reconnaissance absolue de leurs droits fonciers. Au nom de leur peuple, les Meriam, ils invoquent l'occupation ancienne de ces îles situées au nord de l'Australie dans le détroit de Torres par des groupes probablement venus de Papouasie Nouvelle-Guinée dont ils sont les descendants directs. Ils invoquent aussi la continuité de leur présence, le développement d'une agriculture soignée, la complexité de leur système social et surtout l'élaboration d'une tenure foncière qui définit clairement la propriété de chacun. Eddie Mabo et les siens ne remettent pas en cause la souveraineté de la couronne britannique imposée en 1879 sur les îles Murray au profit de la colonie du Queensland mais défendent, sous le couvert de cette souveraineté, le maintien de leurs droits fonciers.
In 1992, for the first time in its history, the High Court of Australia was presented with a case involving recognition of the ancestral land rights of an indigenous community, the inhabitants of the Murray Islands in the Torres Straits. The court ruled in favour of the islanders in the Mabo Case, creating a new legal category in Australian common law: native land rights, or native title. The decision provoked a storm of controversy in Australian public opinion. The repercussions of the decision went far beyond the specific case of the Murray Islanders as it amounted to a recognition of the “customary” land rights which all indigenous Australians were held to inherit from the period preceding European colonisation. The ruling thereby overturned one of the fundamental legal principles of the Australian nation: the doctrine of “terra nullius”. This article discusses the stakes in the current debate by reviewing the genesis of a “white” Australia based on the wholesale rejection of its first inhabitants through the legal doctrine that the continent was uninhabited before the arrival of the Europeans. What was the origin of the idea of “terra nullius” and what did that principle mean? How was it applied and accepted as legitimate for more than two hundred years? In what circumstances was it finally overturned and what are the major consequences of that ruling ? The Mabo Case points to a series of historical and legal questions which have profoundly challenged the whole of Australian society, its perception of the country's past and the nation's conscience.