Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 July 2017
Certains points d'histoire apparaissent plus comme des enjeux que comme de véritables objets d'étude. Chaque génération, chaque école viennent y prendre ce qu'elles cherchent sans trop regarder ce qui s'y présente et les discours historiens recouvrent peu à peu de leurs strates les sources historiques. Tel est le sort de la vie de Robert d'Arbrissel.
D'abord objet d'un long conflit entre apologistes et détracteurs, le fondateur de l'ordre double de Fontevraud ne trouva pas le repos au regard de l'Histoire. Plus souvent utilisé qu'étudié, il dut se prêter à deux grandes thèses.Pour les uns, Robert est le dfenseur des humbles contre les grands, sa prdication tapageuse est l'expression immature des aspirations populaires et sa vie est un dfil'ordre social.
Michelet and others after him thought of Robert d'Arbrissel, founder of the double order of Fontevrault at the turn of the XIIth century, as the defender of women ‘s rights. The truth, however is more complex. The success of Fontevrault was due to the conjunction between the man and his public. Robert 's followers were all women from the upper social class, all victims of the matrimonial crisis at the end of the XIth and beginning of the XIIth century. Robert's own attitude was ambivalent. He sought out women so that he could put his chastity to the test, and appointed an abbess at the head of his order, thus ensuring religious salvation by means of this unnatural subordination. But he proposed salvation to women as well: not that of Eve or Mary, but of Madalene, the forgiven sinner. If this represents feminine advancement, it is in more subtle terms than is usually implied by the concept.