Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-8tzhz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-19T20:24:26.947Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Fair-value analytical valuation of reset executive stock options consistent with IFRS9 requirements

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 January 2020

Otto Konstandatos*
Affiliation:
Finance Department, University of Technology Sydney, NSW 2007, Australia
*
*Corresponding author. Email: otto.konstandatos@uts.edu.au
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Executive stock options (ESOs) are widely used to reward employees and represent major items of corporate liability. The International Accounting Standards Board IFRS9 financial reporting standard which came into full effect on 1-Jan 2018, along with its Australian implementation AASB9, requires public corporations to report their fair-value cost in financial statements. Reset ESOs are typically issued to re-incentivise employees by allowing the option to be cancelled and re-issued with a lower exercise price or later maturity. We produce a novel analytical Reset ESO valuation consistent with the IFRS9 financial reporting standard incorporating the simultaneous resetting of vesting period, exercise window, reset level and maturity. We allow for voluntary and involuntary exercise. Our analytical result is expressed solely in terms of standardised European binary power option instruments. Using the multi-state mortality model of Hariyanto (2014, Mortality and disability modelling with an application to pricing a reverse mortgage contract, PhD thesis, University of Melbourne), we estimate longitudinal disability and death transition probabilities from cross-sectional data. We determine survival functions for pre-vesting forfeiture or post-vesting involuntary exercise for use with weighted portfolios of our formulae to illustrate the effect of survival on the fair value. We examine the IFRS9 method of valuation using expected time to option exercise and demonstrate a consistent overestimation of fair value of up to 27% for senior executives.

Information

Type
Paper
Copyright
© Institute and Faculty of Actuaries 2020 
Figure 0

Table 1.Effect of the image operator on power binaries

Figure 1

Figure 1Structure of the Reset Executive Stock Option (ResetESO).

Figure 2

Table 2.ABS survival data used for attrition.

Figure 3

Figure 2Reset ESO price (equation (28)) versus reset level L. Original component $\mathcal{RESO}_{\mathcal{O}}$ (equation (31)), reset component $\mathcal{RESO}_{\mathcal{R}}$ (equation (32)) and non-overlapping exercise windows $[T_1,T_2] = [3,6]$, $[T^{\prime}_1,T^{\prime}_2] = [6,9]$.

Figure 4

Figure 3Reset ESO price (equation (28)) versus reset level L. Original component $\mathcal{RESO}_{\mathcal{O}}$ (equation (31)), reset component $\mathcal{RESO}_{\mathcal{R}}$ (equation (32)) and overlapping exercise windows $[T_1,T_2] = [2,5]$, $[T^{\prime}_1,T^{\prime}_2] = [3,6]$.

Figure 5

Figure 4Unadjusted Reset ESO price (equation ((28)) and survival-adjusted price ${}_{\text{Adj}}\textrm{ResetESO}$ (equation (34)) versus reset level L for survival functions in Table 2 for senior executive aged $\bar{n}= 60$.

Figure 6

Figure 5Unadjusted Reset ESO price (equation (28)) and survival-adjusted price ${}_{\text{Adj}}\textrm{ResetESO}$ (equation (34)) versus reset level L for survival functions in Table 2 for senior executive aged $\bar{n}= 65$.

Figure 7

Figure 6Unadjusted Reset ESO price (equation ((28))) and survival-adjusted price ${}_{\text{Adj}}\textrm{ResetESO}$ (equation (34)) versus reset level L for survival functions in Table 2 for senior executive aged $\bar{n}= 70$.

Figure 8

Figure 7Left: Pricing with expected time to involuntary exercise $\left\{ \bar{T}, \bar{T}' \right\}$ compared with unadjusted (equation (28)) and attrition-adjusted (equation (34)) prices (using ABS:0). Right: Errors in pricing for each survival function in Table 2. Executive aged $\bar{n} = 60$.

Figure 9

Figure 8Left: Pricing with expected time to involuntary exercise $\left\{ \bar{T}, \bar{T}' \right\}$ compared with unadjusted (equation (28)) and attrition-adjusted (equation (34)) prices (using ABS:0). Right: Errors in pricing for each survival function in Table 2. Executive aged $\bar{n} = 65$.

Figure 10

Figure 9Left: Pricing with expected time to involuntary exercise $\left\{ \bar{T}, \bar{T}' \right\}$ compared with unadjusted (equation (28)) and attrition-adjusted (equation (34)) prices (using ABS:0). Right: Errors in pricing for each survival function in Table 2. Executive aged $\bar{n} = 70$.

Figure 11

Figure 10Left: Pricing using $\left\{ \bar{T}, \bar{T}' \right\}$ compared with unadjusted and attrition-adjusted prices (using ABS:0) as a function of exercise multiple M. Right: Errors in pricing for each survival function in Table 2. Executive aged $\bar{n} = 60$.

Figure 12

Figure 11Left: Pricing using $\left\{ \bar{T}, \bar{T}' \right\}$ compared with unadjusted and attrition-adjusted prices (using ABS:0) as a function of exercise multiple M. Right: Errors in pricing for each survival function in Table 2. Executive aged $\bar{n} = 65$.

Figure 13

Figure 12Left: Pricing using $\left\{ \bar{T}, \bar{T}' \right\}$ compared with unadjusted and attrition-adjusted prices (using ABS:0) as a function of exercise multiple M. Right: Errors in pricing for each survival function in Table 2. Executive aged $\bar{n} = 70$.