Published online by Cambridge University Press: 08 May 2015
Virtually all modern editors and commentators regard this dialogue as non-Lucianic, despite its presence in the best manuscripts. The three most distinguished Lucianic scholars of this century, Helm, Bompaire, and Macleod are all of this persuasion. Their usual objections are based on the alleged inferiority of the Greek style and language employed in the piece, and on the grounds of its inferior satirical qualities and general lack of inspiration. By contrast, I hope to show in this paper that these objections can be rebutted, and that there is no good reason to reject the work. I believe that the dialogue does contain some of Lucian’s best characteristics, and that it fits into the general context of second-century discussions of Demosthenes very effectively.