Published online by Cambridge University Press: 19 January 2015
This paper discusses a series of archaic poems in which one poet responds directly to the work of another, identifying the other by name or by direct allusion (for example, Simonides frag. 542 PMG, Solon frag. 20 West, Sappho frag. 137 Voigt). Such responses often disagree with their models, and this disagreement is frequently constructed in terms of a correction, not only to the subject matter, but also to the way in which the original is composed. These responses, therefore, not only reflect the pattern of improvisation and ‘capping’ common to much Greek poetry, but form an ongoing debate on the nature and role of the poet and his poetry. The construction of such responses also serves to underline both the importance of improvisation and the permanency of the fame conveyed by the completed poem.
This paper was given, in various forms, in London, Wellington and Glasgow. I am grateful to audiences for their discussion of it, and in particular to John Davidson, Stephen Epstein, Alan Griffiths, Fiona Hobden, Liesl Nunns, Richard Rawles, Benet Salway, Jeff Tatum, Janet Watson and the anonymous reviewers for Antichthon for their comments on different drafts.