No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 08 May 2015
Since W.K. Pritchett's discussion in 1965 of a Hellenistic site on the sandbar at Pylos there has grown a considerable body of support among scholars for the existence of the sandbar in 425 B.C. Nowadays it links the southern tip of the promontory of Coryphasion, which the Athenians occupied, to the mainland near Gialova, and to its north lies Osmanaga lagoon which it cuts off from the main body of Navarino Bay. The promontory is linked at two points to the mainland, at the sandbar and at the dunes to the north which curve round the bay called Voidokoilia. Thucydides in his account of the Pylos campaign at the beginning of Book Four does not mention a sandbar, and supporters of its existence generally assume that his text can be read so as to accommodate it in his account. This I believe is mistaken, for the plan attributed to the Spartans of besieging the fort only makes sense as described if there was no sandbar to use as a land bridge. The aims of this article, therefore, are first to remind readers that the plain meaning of the text at 4.13.1 strongly implies that there was no sandbar in Thucydides' day (this is the older view, clearly expressed by A.W. Gomme); second to show that Pritchett's influential inference from the Hellenistic site to a substantial fifth-century sandbar is not compelling; third to show that attempts to read the text in such a way that it is compatible with the sandbar's existence fail; and fourth to show that there is as yet no reliable scientific information to prove that in the fifth century the sandbar existed in any way that is relevant to the Pylos campaign. In these circumstances there is no reason to reject the plain meaning of the text. Further, this meaning is consistent with what few indications there are about the condition of the sandbar in the fifth century.