Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T14:12:31.655Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

‘CLUMSY AND ILLOGICAL’? RECONSIDERING THE WEST KIRBY HOGBACK

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 November 2016

Howard Williams*
Affiliation:
Department of History and Archaeology, University of Chester, Parkgate Road, Chester CH1 4BJ, UK. Email: howard.williams@chester.ac.uk
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper presents a fresh reading of a significant early medieval recumbent stone monument from West Kirby, Merseyside (formerly Cheshire). Rather than being a single-phased hogback, later subject to damage, it is argued that West Kirby 4 might have been carved in successive phases, possibly by different hands. It is suggested that the carvers had different abilities and/or adapted their work in response to the time pressures of a funeral or a shift in the location or function of the stone. While a single explanation for the character of the West Kirby monument remains elusive, the article proposes that, rather than ‘clumsy and illogical’, the stone was more likely a coherent but experimental, distinctive and asymmetrical, multi-phased and/or multi-authored creation. Through a review of the monument’s historiography and a reappraisal of the details and parallels of its form, ornament and material composition, the paper reconsiders the commemorative significance of this recumbent stone monument for the locality, region and understanding of Viking Age sculpture across the British Isles. As a result, West Kirby’s importance as an ecclesiastical locale in the Viking Age is reappraised.

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© The Society of Antiquaries of London 2016 
Figure 0

Fig 1Map of the immediate context of the West Kirby site, showing the principal locations producing early medieval stone sculpture, possible early church sites and the linear earthworks of the Mercian frontier mentioned in the paper (incorporating information from Bailey 2010 and Edwards 2013). Map: © Howard Williams

Figure 1

Fig 2Black-and-white photographs of West Kirby 4, sides A to D. Photographs: K Jukes; © Corpus of Anglo-Saxon Stone Sculpture

Figure 2

Fig 3Colour photographs of West Kirby 4, sides A to D (the oblique angle for side C is unavoidable, given the monument’s current display position). Photographs: © Howard Williams

Figure 3

Fig 4The distribution of monuments traditionally defined as ‘hogbacks’. Map: © Patricia Murrieta-Flores and Howard Williams

Figure 4

Fig 5W G Collingwood’s illustration of side A of West Kirby 4. Image: after Collingwood 1928

Figure 5

Fig 6West Kirby 4 in St Bridget’s Church, West Kirby, showing its busy setting around Easter and the war memorial behind. Photograph: © Howard Williams

Figure 6

Fig 7Side A of West Kirby 4 as represented on the glass doors of West Kirby Museum. Photograph: © Howard Williams

Figure 7

Fig 8The 3D-facsimile of West Kirby 4 on display at the Museum of Liverpool. Side A (top) faces visitors; side C (below) is just discernible from the side of the display case and is rendered blank. Photographs: Liz Stewart; © Trustees of National Museums Liverpool

Figure 8

Fig 9Binding motifs from Viking Age stones: 1= Gosforth, Cumbria; 2= Kirkby Stephen, Cumbria; 3= Leeds Minster, West Yorkshire; 4= Leeds Museum, West Yorkshire; 5= Sockburn, Co. Durham; 6= Andreas, Isle of Man. Not to scale. Image: redrawn from photographs by Howard Williams

Figure 9

Fig 10Detail of the Dyserth 1 cross-slab (left) and Dyserth 2 cross-base (right). Photographs: © Howard Williams

Figure 10

Fig 11West Kirby 4: laser scans of the long face A (top) and C (middle) and the central ridge from above; the narrow faces B and D are shown lower left and lower right respectively. Image: © Patricia Murrieta-Flores and Howard Williams, courtesy of National Museums Liverpool

Figure 11

Table 1Asymmetries in the ornamentation on West Kirby 4

Figure 12

Fig 12Oblique views of West Kirby 4’s broad sides A (top) and C (middle) with details of the central ridge below. Image: © Patricia Murrieta-Flores and Howard Williams, courtesy of National Museums Liverpool

Figure 13

Fig 13The centre-top of West Kirby 4, with face A above and the damaged face C below. The wheel-and-bar ornamentation is demonstrably present on both sides of the damaged ridge. Photograph: © Howard Williams