No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 30 June 2026
Suicidal and homicidal behaviors are typically assessed as distinct risk domains, despite overlapping psychopathology in psychosis and severe mood disorder. We introduce the new concept Suicide by Proxy as a psychodynamic formulation in which homicide (or attempted homicide) represents a displaced enactment of suicidal intent when direct self-destruction is inhibited. Drawing on Freudian models of internalized aggression, persecutory superego dynamics, and object-related conflict (Oedipal/Electra configurations), we aim to illustrate how self-directed destructive drive may be externalized toward a symbolic other.
Three retrospective forensic psychiatric case reports were analyzed using a psychodynamic framework. All cases involved severe mental disorder (schizophrenia-spectrum or major depressive episode with psychotic features), documented suicidal ideation and/or attempts, and a homicide or attempted homicide. Data sources included clinical interviews, collateral histories, medical/legal records, and psychological testing (including MMPI and SIMS). Identifying details were removed or altered to preserve confidentiality without changing clinical meaning.
Case 1:A 26-year-old man with paranoid schizophrenia and persecutory delusions purchased a firearm intending suicide but reported inability to act. He subsequently killed an unknown man in a mosque, then left the weapon beside the body. The act is conceptualized as displacement of self-destruction onto an authority-linked symbolic target, enabling rebellion against a persecutory superego without direct suicide or parricide.
Case 2:A 39-year-old woman with psychotic depression and intense suicidal communications stabbed her sleeping father after planning to kill herself in his presence, then attempted self-stabbing. This is formulated as a negative Electra configuration: ambivalent attachment and rage toward a passive betrayer father, with psychosis collapsing boundaries between self-attack and object-attack.
Case 3:A 36-year-old woman with schizophrenia, shaming maternal criticism, and relapsed hallucinations broke a mirror and attempted to attack her mother with glass while concealing suicidal intent. The mother is conceptualized as a proxy self-representing the rejected, humiliated part of the patient targeted for annihilation.
Across cases, homicidal acts functioned as symbolic self-attacks emerging from internalized aggression, persecutory superego pressures, and unresolved parental-object conflict. Suicide by Proxy may help forensic clinicians integrate suicidality into violence formulations, prompting dual-screening for suicidal and displaced homicidal risk in severe mental disorder. Further empirical work is needed to test the model beyond case-series evidence.
Abstracts were reviewed by the RCPsych Academic Faculty rather than by the standard BJPsych Open peer review process and should not be quoted as peer-reviewed by BJPsych Open in any subsequent publication.
eLetters
No eLetters have been published for this article.