Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-19T03:13:47.761Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Methodological Issues in Longitudinal Research on Cognitive Recovery after Traumatic Brain Injury: Evidence from a Systematic Review

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 September 2013

Regina Schultz*
Affiliation:
Rehabilitation Studies Unit, Northern Clinical School, Sydney Medical School, University of Sydney, Australia
Robyn L. Tate
Affiliation:
Rehabilitation Studies Unit, Northern Clinical School, Sydney Medical School, University of Sydney, AustraliaRoyal Rehabilitation Centre Sydney, Australia
*
Address for correspondence: Regina Schultz, Rehabilitation Studies Unit, University of Sydney, PO Box 6, Ryde, NSW 1680, Australia. E-mail: reginas@med.usyd.edu.au

Abstract

Background: Previous research addressing cognitive recovery after traumatic brain injury (TBI) in adults has predominately used cross-sectional methods. This systematic review examines longitudinal research into cognitive recovery in the first 2 years following moderate-to-severe TBI in adults and aims to identify apparent methodological issues with the existing literature.

Design: Systematic review of the first 2 years post-trauma.

Setting: Data were extracted from three electronic databases and manual searches of published articles until October 2012.

Participants: Two hundred and forty-two participants with severe TBI and 281 comparison participants were used to calculate effect sizes.

Results: Twenty papers met the selection criteria, with effect sizes computed from four studies. Moderate-to-large effect sizes were initially observed between the TBI and comparison groups on most measures (range: d = 0.2–2.8). Recovery continued in all five cognitive domains over the 2 years post-injury.

Conclusions: Results demonstrated that cognitive recovery was continuous throughout the first 2 years following moderate-to-severe TBI. Findings also indicated different rates of recovery for the specific cognitive domains, highlighting the heterogeneous nature of cognitive recovery after TBI. The review highlighted several methodological issues within the limited existing literature; recommendations were developed to improve the evidence base.

Information

Type
Systematic Review
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Australian Academic Press Pty Ltd 2013 
Figure 0

TABLE 1Measures Identified in Systematic Review and Corresponding Classification by Cognitive Domain (indicates the number of studies that included each measure)

Figure 1

FIGURE 1PRISMA flow diagram of the different stages of the systematic review.

Figure 2

TABLE 2Assessment Time-points and Measures Used in Each Paper

Figure 3

TABLE 3Descriptive Data, t and p Values for Analyses of Demographic Characteristics of the TBI and Comparison Groups Included in the Effect Sizes

Figure 4

TABLE 4Effect Sizes for Each Measure Classified by Cognitive Domain

Figure 5

FIGURE 2Effect sizes from the measures in the attention domain.

Figure 6

FIGURE 3Effect sizes from the measures in the general cognition domain.

Figure 7

FIGURE 4Effect sizes from the measures in the executive function domain.

Figure 8

FIGURE 5Effect sizes from the measures in the memory and visual-perception domains.