Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-18T06:59:43.076Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

A review of Solvency II: Has it met its objectives?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 January 2018

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Solvency II is currently one of the most sophisticated insurance regulatory regimes in the world. It is built around the principles of market consistency and embedding strong risk management and governance within insurance companies. For business with long-term guarantees, the original basis produced outcomes that were unacceptable to the member states. The original design was amended through Omnibus II. The working party has looked back at the outcome of the final regulation and comments on how well Solvency II has fared, principally from a UK perspective, relative to its initial goals of improved consumer protection, harmonisation, effective risk management and financial stability. We review Pillar 1’s market consistent valuation (including the risk margin and transitional measures) as well as the capital requirements (including internal models). We look at the impact this has on asset and liability management, pro-cyclicality and product design. We look at Pillars 2 and 3 in respect of the Own Risk and Solvency Assessment, liquidity and disclosure. Finally, we stand back and look at harmonisation and the implications of Brexit. In summary we conclude that Solvency II represents a huge improvement over Solvency I although it has not fully achieved the goals it aspired to. There are acknowledged shortfalls and imperfections where adjustments to Solvency II are likely. There remain other concerns around pro-cyclicality, and the appropriateness of market consistency is still open to criticism. It is hoped that the paper and the discussion that goes with it provide an insight into where Solvency II has taken European Insurance regulation and the directions in which it could evolve.

Information

Type
Sessional meetings: papers and abstracts of discussions
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted reuse, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Copyright
© Institute and Faculty of Actuaries 2018
Figure 0

Figure 1Improved customer protection has been achieved. Conference workshop: Votes 43, average 3.1, SD 0.9.

Figure 1

Figure 2Effective risk management across Europe has been achieved. Conference workshop: Votes 55, average 3.0, SD 0.95.

Figure 2

Figure 3Harmonisation across Europe has been achieved. Conference workshop: Votes 54, average 2.0, SD 0.85.

Figure 3

Figure 4Financial markets are more stable. Conference workshop: Votes 56, average 1.4, SD 0.55.

Figure 4

Figure 5The aspects of Solvency II that are not market consistent (e.g. matching adjustment (MA), Ultimate Forward Rate (UFR)) should be removed. Conference workshop: Votes 59, average 1.9, SD 1.25.

Figure 5

Table 1Number of Undertakings Split by Type and Method of Solvency Capital Requirement Calculation

Figure 6

Figure 6Internal models are too complex. Conference workshop: Votes 51, average 3.8, SD 1.3.

Figure 7

Figure 7The capital requirements should be adapted to allow insurers to introduce management actions or allow for markets to find new levels. Conference workshop: Votes 43, average 3.5, SD 0.95.

Figure 8

Table 2Summary of Use of Regulatory Flexibility for Insurers in Various Countries

Figure 9

Figure 8The Pillar 2 requirements – governance/Own Risk and Solvency Assessment (ORSA)/Board responsibility/Prudent Person Principle (PPP) – add to financial stability. Conference workshop: Votes 54, average 4.2, SD 0.75.

Figure 10

Figure 9The benefits of Pillar 3 disclosure requirements are not proportional to the cost of their implementation. Conference workshop: Votes 55, average 3.9, SD 1.2.

Figure 11

Table 3Number of Quantitative Reporting Templates (QRTs) Required

Figure 12

Table 4Disclosure Comparison Between Solvency II and Solvency I

Figure 13

Figure 10The UK regulator has gold-plated Solvency II. Conference workshop: Votes 57, average 3.9, SD 1.36.

Figure 14

Table A1Results From a Survey Carried Out at the Life Conference 2016

Figure 15

Table A2Key Events in the UK Insurance Market in the Last 20 Years

Figure 16

Table A3Overview of the Evolution of Solvency II

Figure 17

Table A4Summary of Solvency II disclosures at 31 December 2015