Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-w7t8q Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-18T08:26:32.941Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

What SSAP 24 can tell us about accounting quality

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 November 2011

P. J. Sweeting*
Affiliation:
Professor Paul Sweeting, School of Mathematics, Statistics and Actuarial Science, The University of Kent, Canterbury, Kent, CT2 7NZ
*
Contact addresses P. J. Sweeting, F.I.A. J.P. Morgan, Asset Management, Finsbury Dials, 20 Finsbury Street, London, EC2Y 9AQ U.K. Tel: +44(0)20 7742 0501. E-mail: paul.j.sweeting@jpmorgan.com
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Statement of Standard Accounting Practice (SSAP) 24 required, for the first time, particular levels of disclosure in relation to firms’ pension arrangements. Whilst this was a major step forward, it allowed a significant degree of discretion. This discretion meant that SSAP 24 was an observable measure of the quality and quantity of accounting disclosure for firms. This information can be used to determine the types of firms that give less information or use weaker assumptions. In my analysis, I find some evidence that large firms give more complete disclosures, but also that they are more able to exert influence on their actuaries to use weaker assumptions for the valuation of pension scheme liabilities. There is also some evidence that more profitable firms disclose less, so firms with a higher average tax rate might want to overfund their pension scheme. Finally, there is evidence that highly levered funds are less likely to give complete disclosure, and that when they do disclose their assumptions, they use a weaker basis.

Information

Type
Sessional meetings: papers and abstracts of discussions
Copyright
Copyright © Institute and Faculty of Actuaries 2011
Figure 0

Table 1Extent of disclosure within SSAP 24 (Data Used for Analysis); Net pre-retirement liability discount rate (i-e); Net post-retirement liability discount rate (i-p); Net dividend discount rate (i-d); Market value of pensions scheme assets (MVA); Actuarial value of pension scheme assets (AVA); Market value basis (MVB); and Pension scheme funding level (FL).

Figure 1

Table 2Predicted signs for the extent of disclosure of explanatory variables.

Figure 2

Table 3Predicted signs for the values of explanatory variables.

Figure 3

Table 4Difference between explanatory variables for firms disclosing/not disclosing the net post-retirement liability discount rate (i-p); Log-transformed variable.

Figure 4

Table 5Results of U Test for firms disclosing/not disclosing the net post-retirement liability discount rate (i-p); Ranked variables.

Figure 5

Table 6Difference in firms disclosing/not disclosing the net post-retirement liability discount rate (i-p) between economic groups.

Figure 6

Table 7Logit analysis of firms disclosing/not disclosing the net post-retirement liability discount rate (i-p).

Figure 7

Table 8Difference between explanatory variables for firms disclosing/not disclosing the net dividend discount rate (i-d); Log-transformed variable.

Figure 8

Table 9Results of U-Test for firms disclosing/not disclosing the net dividend discount rate (i-d) ranked variables.

Figure 9

Table 10Difference in firms disclosing/not disclosing the net dividend discount rate (i-d) between economic groups.

Figure 10

Table 11Logit analysis of firms disclosing/not disclosing the net dividend discount rate (i-d).

Figure 11

Table 12Difference between explanatory variables for firms disclosing/not disclosing the actuarial value of pension scheme assets (AVA); Log-transformed variables.

Figure 12

Table 13Results of U Test for firms disclosing/not disclosing the actuarial value of pension scheme assets (AVA); Ranked variables.

Figure 13

Table 14Difference in firms disclosing/not disclosing the actuarial value of pension scheme assets (AVA) between economic groups.

Figure 14

Table 15Logit analysis of firms disclosing/not disclosing the actuarial value of assets (AVA).

Figure 15

Table 16Dependent variable values in the analysis of asset-related disclosures, the net dividend discount rate (i-d) and the actuarial value of pension scheme assets (AVA).

Figure 16

Table 17Difference between explanatory variables for firms disclosing/not disclosing either the net dividend discount rate (i-d) or the actuarial value of pension scheme assets (AVA); Log-transformed variable.

Figure 17

Table 18Results of U Test for firms disclosing/not disclosing the net dividend discount rate (i-d) or the actuarial value of pension scheme assets (AVA); Ranked variables.

Figure 18

Table 19Difference in firms disclosing/not disclosing the net dividend discount rate (i-d) or the actuarial value of pension scheme assets (AVA) between economic groups.

Figure 19

Table 20Logit analysis of firms disclosing/not disclosing the net dividend discount rate (i-d) and/or the actuarial value of assets (AVA); Scenario 1.

Figure 20

Table 21Logit analysis of firms disclosing/not disclosing the net dividend discount rate (i-d) and/or the actuarial value of assets (AVA); Scenario 2.

Figure 21

Table 22Logit analysis of firms disclosing/not disclosing the net dividend discount rate (i-d) and/or the actuarial value of assets (AVA); Scenario 3.

Figure 22

Table 23Logit analysis of firms disclosing/not disclosing the net dividend discount rate (i-d) and/or the actuarial value of assets (AVA); Scenario 4.

Figure 23

Table 24Logit analysis of firms disclosing/not disclosing the net dividend discount rate (i-d) and/or the actuarial value of assets (AVA); Scenario 5.

Figure 24

Table 25Difference between explanatory variables for firms using/not using a market value basis (MVB); Log-transformed variables.

Figure 25

Table 26Difference between explanatory variables for firms using/not using a market value basis (MVB); Ranked variables.

Figure 26

Table 27Difference in firms using/not using a market value basis (MVB) between economic groups.

Figure 27

Table 28Logit analysis of firms using/not using a market value basis (MVB).

Figure 28

Table 29Data characteristics; Net pre-retirement liability discount rate (i-e); Net post-retirement liability discount rate (i-p); and Net dividend discount rate (i-d).

Figure 29

Table 30Difference in value of the net pre-retirement liability discount rate (i-e) between economic groups.

Figure 30

Table 31Regression analysis for the value of the net pre-retirement liability discount rate (i-e).

Figure 31

Table 32Difference in value of the net post-retirement liability discount rate (i-p) between economic groups.

Figure 32

Table 33Regression analysis for the value of the net pre-retirement liability discount rate (i-p).

Figure 33

Table 34Difference in value of the net dividend discount rate (i-d) between economic groups.

Figure 34

Table 35Regression analysis for the value of the net dividend discount rate (i-d).