No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 16 February 2015
The 1688 Revolution was the culmination of an eighteen-year campaign against James and his co-religionists as idolaters of bread. The Test Acts of 1673 and 1678 required an oath against Transubstantiation for public employment, and the parliamentary debate in 1673 showed that the ground for this was idolatry. It was a strange accusation, because the age was more inclined to atheism than idolatry and because virtually all the Christian world—Catholics, Orthodox, and Lutherans—worshiped Christ as bodily present in the Sacrament. In three recent councils between 1639 and 1672, the Orthodox Churches had accepted the term transubstantiation and condemned Calvinist teaching on the Eucharist. Stranger still, the accusation of idolatry was being raised not by Puritans, but by Anglican churchmen and a Cavalier parliament. The first Test Act of 1673 (25 Charles II, c. 2) excluded Catholics from all civil and military employment under the Crown under penalty of £500 pounds and disability in law, unless they would take this oath against Transubstantiation: ‘I do believe that there is not any transubstantiation in the sacrament of the Lord's supper, or in the elements of bread and wine, at or after the consecration thereof by any person whatsoever’.
1 The Statutes at Large, from the Twelfth Year of King Charles II [1660] to the Last Year of King James II. Inclusive, ed. Danby, Pickering (Cambridge and London: Charles Bathurst, 1763), 8: pp. 389–95.
2 Parker, Samuel, History of His Own Time (1686), translated from the Latin by Newlin, Thomas (London: Charles Rivington, 1727), p. 321; [Cartwright, Thomas], A Letter from a Clergy-Man in the Country, to the Clergyman in the City, Author of the Late Letter to His Friend in the Country: Shewing the Insufficiency of His Reasons Therein Contained for Not Reading the Declaration. By a Minister of the Church of England. ([London], 1688), p. 32; James II (1633–1701), The Life of James the Second King of England Collected Out of Memoirs Writ of His Own Hand. 2 volumes. Edited by Clarke, J. S. (London: Longman, 1816), pp. 147–48.
3 Wilson, John, Jus Regium Coronae (London: Henry Hills, 1688), p. 42.
4 [Palmer, Roger, Earl of Castlemaine], Full Answer and Confutation of a Scandalous Pamphlet Called A Seasonable Discourse ([Antwerp], 1673), p. 1.
5 [Gother, John], Papists Protesting against Protestant-Popery (London: Henry Hills, 1686), pp. 7, 12, 14, 22.
6 The Autobiography of Richard Baxter, ed. Lloyd Thomas, J. M. (1931; rep, London: Dent/ Totowa, N.J.: Rowman and Littlefield, 1974), p. 227.
7 [Cressy, Serenus], Fanaticism Fanatically imputed, (1672), ‘To the Reader’, pp. 7, 34, 188.
8 [Cressy, Serenus], An Epistle Apologetical of S. C. To a Person of Honour touching his Vindication of Dr. Stillingfleet (1674), pp. 3, 11–12.
9 Parker, Samuel, Reasons for Abrogating the Test Imposed upon All Members of Parliament Anno 1678 Oct. 30 (London: Henry Bonwicke, 1688), p. 35. Burnet, Gilbert replies in A Discourse concerning Transubstantiation and Idolatry (London, 1688), 21, accusing Parker of having originally secretly licensed Stillingfleet's book and having himself condemned Papists for idolatry in Defence and Continuation of the Ecclesiastical Politie (London: J. Martyn, 1671), pp. 285–6.
10 [Gother, John], Reflections upon the Answer to the Papist Misrepresented ([London], 1686), p. 19; [Cressy, Serenus], Epistle Apologetical, p. 73.
11 [Canes, J. B. V.], Stillingfleeton. Or, An Account given to a Catholic Friend of Dr.Stillingfleets late Book (Bruges: Luke Kerchove, 1672), p. 10.
12 A Letter from Dr. Robert Wild to His Friend Mr. J. J. (London: T. Parkhurst, 1672), pp. 13–14.
13 Parker, History, pp. 321–22, 12.
14 [Woodhead, Abraham], The Second Discourse, the Catholicks Defence, for Their Adoration of the Body and Blood of Our Lord, as Believed Really and Substantially Present in the Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist, in Two Discourses Concerning the Adoration of Our B. Saviour in the Eucharist (Oxford: Obadiah Walker, 1687), p. 35.
15 [Cartwright, Thomas], Letter from a Clergy-Man, p. 23.
16 Poems 1685–1692, edited Miner, Earl and Vinton, A. Dearing, in The Works of John Dryden, ed. Swedenberg, H. T. Jr., et al. 20 vols. (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1956). Hereafter I will cite The Hind and the Panther in my text.
17 [Clagett, William], An Answer to the Representer's Reflections upon the State and View of the Controversy (London: Richard Chiswell, 1688), p. 9. This book was in answer to John Gother.
18 Parker, History, pp. 378–86.
19 William, A. Speck, Reluctant Revolutionaries (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1988), p. 171.
20 Parker, Reasons, p. 9.
21 Statutes at Large, 8:427–32.
22 Parker, Reasons, pp. 9, 71.
23 North, Roger, Examen (London, 1740), p. 348.
24 Sir Roger, L'Estrange, A Brief History of the Times (London: R. Sare, 1688), preface, p. 120.
25 [Gother, John], Good Advice to the Pulpits (London: Henry Hills, 1687), pp. 15–16. See for instance, Stillingfleet, A Sermon Preached on Nov. 13, 1678, before the House of Commons.
26 Vox Cleripro Rege, (1688), pp. 8–9.
27 This is among the letters from Barillon to Louis XIV in Charles, James Fox, Appendix to a History of the Early Part of the Reign of James the Second (London: William Miller, 1808), lxxxi and xci. Other letters revealing how Louis XIV, through Barillon, gave large bribes to the Whigs during the Popish Plot years, so they would destabilize the government and keep English troops out of Europe, can be found in Sir John Dalrymple's Memoirs of Great Britain (1771), and Jusserand, J. J., Angleterre, Vol. 2: 1666–1690, in Recueil des Instructions données aux ambasssadeurs et ministres de France (Paris: E. De Boccard, 1929).
28 H. M. C. Lindsey, ed. Bridgeman, C. G. O. and Walker, J. C. (London: Historical Manuscript Commission, 1942), pp. 270–72. This conversation occurred on 18 November 1687.
29 [Cartwright, Thomas], Letter from a Clergy-Man, pp. 26–27.
30 G[iles], S[hute], A New Naked Truth; or, The Sandy Foundation of the Sacramental Test Shaken (London: George Larkin, 1688), pp. 3–4.
31 [Cartwright], Letter from a Clergy-man, pp. 33–34.
32 James II, Life, p. 70.
33 D[arrell] W[illiam], S.J., The Lay-Mans Opinion, Sent in a Private Letter to a Considerable Divine (London, 1687), pp. 6–7.
34 [Gother, John], Good Advice, ‘To the Reader’, pp. 49–50.
35 James II, Life, p. 70. The Protestant clergyman was Samuel Johnson.
36 [Gother, John], An Agreement between the Church of England and the Church of Rome (London: Henry Hills, 1687), preface.
37 [Cartwright], An Answer of a Minister of the Church of England to a Seasonable and Important Question, Proposed to Him by a Loyal and Religious Member of the Present House of Commons (London: J. L., 1687), pp. 23–25; A Letter from a Clergy-Man, p. 35.
38 Miller, John, Popery and Politics in England, 1660–1688 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1973), p. 209.
39 See The Metallick History of the Reigns of King William III and Queen Mary (London, 1747), pp. 2–5. I am indebted to Reverend Professor Leo Elders of the Netherlands for identifying the sacred objects which the priest is holding in the medal entitled ‘Emanuel’.
40 A Discourse concerning the Idolatry Practised in the Church of Rome, and the hazard of Salvation in the Communion of it. Second Edition. (London: Henry Mortlock, 1672), pp. 3–4, 98, 103, 108, 110, 118.
41 The attribution is by Thomas Clancy, S.J., and 1674 is the likely date of publication.
42 Jupiter Doctor Stillingfleets True God blessed for ever more [1674], pp. 1, 8, 13, 15–16.
43 Ibidem, pp. 2–6, 11–12, 20, 23.
44 The True Interest of the Legal English Protestants, Stated in a Letter to a present member of the House of Commons (London: Nat Thompson, 1687), pp. 2–5.
45 Reasons, pp. 11, 47, 64.
46 True Interest, pp. 2–5.
47 [Gordon, John], Pax Vobis: or, Gospel and Liberty: against Ancient and Modern Papists. By a Preacher of the Word. The Fifth Edition (1687), p. 27.
48 Catholics no Idolaters. Or, a Full Refutation of Doctor Stillingfleet's Unjust Charge of Idolatry against the Church of Rome (1672), pp. 222, 225, 301.
49 Catholics no Idolaters, pp. 233–34, 256, 261, 267–68.
50 R[obert], F[uller], Missale Romanum Vindicatum. Or, the Mass Vindicated from D. Daniel Brevents [sic] Calumnious and Scandalous Tract (1674). Only his initials appear at the end of the dedication, but the book is attributed to him because his name is on the manuscript.
51 Brevint, Daniel, Missale Romanum, or the Depth and Mystery of the Roman Mass, Laid open and Explained, For the Use of Both Reformed and Un-reformed Christians. (Oxford: at the Theater, 1672).
52 Brevint, Missale Romanum, p. 72.
53 Saul and Samuel at Endor (Oxford: at the Theater, 1674), Preface.
54 Missale Romanum Vindicatum, pp. 160–62, 166, 168.
55 Missale Romanum Vindicatum, Dedication.
56 Thorndike, Herbert, Just Weights and Measures: that is, The Present State of Religion Weighed in the Balance (London, J. Martin, 1662), marginal note in eh I. Cited in Fuller, pp. 157–160.
57 Missale Romanum Vindicatum, pp. 105, 117.
58 [Cressy], Epistle Apologetical, p. 64.
59 Parker, Reasons, pp. 68–70.
60 [Woodhead, Abraham], Dr. Stillingfleet's Principles, giving an Account of the faith of Protestants, Considered by N. O. (Paris, 1671), p. 3.
61 Stillingfleeton, 2; Ashby, Richard, Some Generali Observations upon Dr Stillingfleet's Book (1672), pp. 5–6.
62 Concerning Images and Idolatry (Oxford: [Obadiah Walker], 1689), 76, 78, 81, 82. In a copy held by the Bodleian library [A 11.17 Line], a 17th-century reader noted on the title page that though the book was printed, ‘the greatest part of the Edition was seized’ in the stables of University College where Obadiah Walker had his press.
63 Concerning the Adoration of our B. Saviour in the Eucharist in Two Discourses (Oxford: [Obadiah Walker], 1687), pp. 19, 26–27, 29.
64 Ibidem, pp. 29–30. Woodhead gave several references to some of his own works, such as Guide in Controversies, and to the French tomes of Grande Perpétuité then attributed to Antoine Arnauld, but also the work of Bossuet, Eusebe Renaudot, and Pierre Nicole. There the Eucharistie beliefs of the Orthodox Churches was thoroughly sifted in answer to Jean Claude's allegations.
65 [Woodhead, Abraham], Considerations on the Council of Trent, being the Fifth Discourse, concerning the Guide in Controversies (1671), p. 64.
66 [Warner, John], A Revision of Doctor George Morlei's Judgment in Matters of Religion (1683), pp. 36–37.
67 Burnet, A Discourse concerning Transubstantiation and Idolatry (1688), p. 9.
68 Dr. Stillingfleet's Principles, pp. 19–21.
69 Wake, William, A Discourse of the Holy Eucharist, in the Two Great Points of the Real Presence and the Adoration of the Host in Answer to the Two Discourses lately Printed at Oxford on this Subject. Second Edition. (London: Richard Chiswell, 1688), pp. 116–17.
70 Wake, Discourse, Preface ii, pp. 24, 27, 31, 58, 74.
71 ‘Animadversions upon the Reply to the Two Discourses concerning the Adoration of our B. Saviour in the Holy Eucharist’, Appendix 2 to [Woodhead, Abraham], A Compendious Discourse (Oxford: Obadiah Walker, 1688), p. 207.
72 Burnet, Gilbert, Discourse, p. 4.
73 [Basset, Joshua], Reason and Authority; or the Motives of a late Protestants reconciliation to the Catholic Church. Together with Remarks upon some late Discourses against Transubstantiation (London: Henry Hills, 1687).
74 Reason and Authority, pp. 77, 82–83, 89.
75 Reason and Authority, pp. 95, 99, 126.
76 More, Henry, A Brief Discourse of the Real Presence (1686), 1. This book received an Anglican imprimatur.
77 Patrick, Simon, A Full View of the Doctrines and Practices of the Ancient Church Relating to the Eucharist Wholly Different from Those of the Present Roman Church, and Inconsistent with the Belief of Transubstantiation (London: Richard Chiswell, 1687), pp. 79, 83.
78 Sclater, Edward, Consensus Veterum: or, the Reasons of Edward Sclater Minister of Putney, For his Conversion to the Catholic Faith and Communion (London: Henry Hills, 1686), p. 29.
79 Consensus Veterum, pp. 87, 89.
80 Consensus Veterum, pp. 88, 90, 92.
81 For example, see Wake, Discourse, p. 114.
82 Tenison, Thomas, Mr Pulton consider'd (London: Richard Chiswell, 1687), p. 85.
83 This was confirmed to me by Kallistos Ware, Orthodox leader of Oxford, at an Anglican-Orthodox conference held at Worcester College, Oxford, in 2001.
84 Consensus Veterum, pp. 94, 97.
85 [Palmer, Roger, Castlemaine, Lord], The Catholique Apology, 3rd edition (1674), p. 103.
86 Horneck, Anthony, An Account of Mr. Edward Sclater's Return to the Communion of the Church of England and of the Publick Recantation he made at the Church of St. Mary Savoy, the 5th of May, 1689 (London: Samuel Lowndes, 1689). His letter to Sancroft where he pleads for his ‘ruined’ family is on p. 26.
87 [Tillotson, John], A Discourse against Transubstantiation (London: Brabazon Aylmer and William Rogers, 1684), 2. This work was reprinted in 1685.
88 Reason and Authority, pp. 45–46.
89 Three Sermons upon the Sacrament in which Transubstantiation is impartially considered, as to Reason, Scripture, and Tradition. By N. N. Preacher in Ordinary to their Majesties (London, 1688).
90 Three Sermons, pp. 62, 65, 67.
91 Three Sermons, p. 99.
92 Three Sermons, pp. 7–8, 11, 18.
93 de la Ville, Louis,. Sentimens de M. Des Cartes Touchant l'essence & les proprietez du corps, opposez a la doctrine de l'Eglise, et conformes aux erreurs de Calvin, sur le suject de l'Eucharistie (Paris: Estienne Michallet, 1680), answered by [Bayle, Pierre], Recueil de quelques pieces curieuses concernant la Philosophie de Monsieur Descartes (Amsterdam: Henry Desbordes, 1684).
94 Three Sermons, pp. 11–12, 16, 20, 39.
95 Three Sermons, pp. 28–29.
96 Three Sermons, pp. 81–82, 84.
97 Reason and Authority, p. 128.
98 A Liturgical Discourse of the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass (1670), 187. It was reprinted in 1675 probably as part of the ongoing response to Stillingfleet.
99 A Full View of the Doctrines, preface.
100 Transubstantiation Defended, and prov'd from Scripture: in Answer to the First Part of a Treatise [by Tillotson, John Dr.] entitled, A Discourse against Transubstantiation (London, 1687), pp. 4–10.
101 Pulpit-sayings, or, the Character of the Pulpit-Papist Examined (London, 1688), pp. 6, 22.
102 An Answer to a Discourse against Transubstantiation [by John Tillotson] (London, 1687), pp. 63, 75.
103 Answer, pp. 15, 40, 55, 75; The Primitive Fathers No Protestants: or, Vindication of Nubes Testium from the Cavils of the Answerer [Gee, Edward] (London, 1687), p. 37.
104 Primitive Fathers, pp. 43—44, 47; Answer, p. 53.
105 Answer, pp. 5–9, 36–37.
106 Animadversions’, p. 200.
107 Revision, pp. 36–7.