Group work is key to the learning process, and that social interaction forms the basis of complex thinking and understanding.
A heterogeneous, or diverse, mix of students in each group provides the best chemistry for interaction and achievement of a task.
Introduction
This article will explore the factors that can influence group work and collaborative learning. It also explores my role in delivering a presentation for a student-led symposium with concepts that have been most influential.
The principles of collaboration and group work are discussed along with factors that can influence group dynamics and success, highlighting relevant teaching theories and research. Benefits to personal teaching skills and development have also been identified.
Group work
Group work encourages students to deliberate on topics, hypotheses and strategies by comparing ideas and interpretations with each other, thus developing their understanding of a subject [Brown, Reference Brown1992]. It is also an effective method of learning that facilitates problem solving and interaction and in how the most meaningful learning in higher education occurs [Race, Reference Race2006]. Within the healthcare profession, there is an increasing need for professionals to demonstrate sound communication skills by sharing and gathering information from clients and colleagues. Teamwork is essential in most work places that involves listening, retrieval of information, and motivating and inspiring others to provide safe patient care [Clark, Reference Clark2009]. Importantly, group work can provide workers [students, employees] with the opportunity to develop and evaluate their own level of knowledge and promote autonomy and independence while building self-confidence and self-esteem. However, collaborative work can also be problematic and often differences of direction, opinion and levels of knowledge lead to frustration and conflict [Orr, Reference Orr2010].
The term collaboration is often associated with the joining of organisations or groups to undertake and achieve a common goal. The importance of collaborative group work in education was identified by theorist Lev Vygotsky in the 1970s who argued that group work is key to the learning process and that social interaction forms the basis of complex thinking and understanding [Frey et al, Reference Frey, Fisher and Everlove2009].
Collaborative work can be broken down into two clearly defined areas that will influence the outcome, along with the collation and presentation of data. These are:
1. Content – the subject content and what it is the group are investigating and presenting.
2. Process – the method by which the ‘group’ collect information along with determining factors such as group size, cohesion, task structure and goals.
When planning and preparing the symposium day, these two areas were the first to be discussed and identified before any group work was undertaken. Subjects that were identified for presentation included:
• Enquiry-based learning;
• Action learning;
• Problem-based learning;
• Simulation;
• Clinical supervision;
• Emotional Intelligence; and
• Role ambiguity.
The process of group work is identified in Tuckman's Stages of Group Development (Reference Tuckman1965): Forming, Storming, Norming and Performing, with the amalgamation of ideas coupled with conflict and differences of opinion. These stages are elaborated below.
Forming stage
In the first stages of team building, the forming of the team takes place. The individual's behaviour is driven by a desire to be accepted by others, and to avoid controversy or conflict. This is a comfortable stage to be in, but the avoidance of conflict and threat means that not much actually gets done. The team meets and learns about the opportunities and challenges, and then agrees on goals and begins to tackle the tasks.
The group was mixed in terms of age, gender and clinical background with members working in mental health, the community and acute care. Such variance, I feel, was beneficial because having group members of the same speciality leads to a shared perspective and the presentation of findings reflected this. Different ideas from different care settings lead to a more diverse approach with data collection, interpretation and presentation.
In terms of group dynamics, it can be suggested that a heterogeneous, or diverse, mix of students in each group provides the best chemistry for interaction and achievement of a task. Factors such as age, sex and personality are both influential and unpredictable because it is difficult to foresee what effect these variants have on team dynamics until such groups are formed [Douglas, Reference Douglas2000]. Individual students behave and work differently according to group make-up and the characteristics of other students. Work is undertaken and achieved through the amalgamation of ideas, behaviour, language, knowledge and participation of group members.
I have identified ‘Emotional Intelligence’ [content] as the area of most interest within the group. This interest was shared by three other members of the cohort and we formed a small subgroup to present information on this subject area.
Storming stage
Next, every group will enter the storming stage in which different ideas compete for consideration. The team addresses issues such as what problems they are really supposed to solve, how they will function independently and together and what leadership model they will accept. Team members open up to each other and confront each other's ideas and perspectives. The storming stage is necessary to the growth of the team.
Through open dialogue, members of the ‘Emotional Intelligence’ group discussed ideas and ‘brainstormed’ different approaches to use when presenting our findings. It is through group discussion that we learn to understand one another by sharing and listening to ideas. From the overall formation of the task, it was evident that members became aware of both their individual and group responsibility.
Norming
Concurrence occurred within the team as we all identified our role within the group process. Tuckman asserts that this process can be facilitated through leadership and this was evident with my group as I inadvertently took on the role of guiding and co-ordinating the planning process. The roles and responsibilities of each member were clear and agreed and decisions on the order of presentations were made through collective agreement. Although a majority of planning occurred through email correspondence, we were still able to discuss ideas and there was a mutual respect and cohesiveness within the group. In his ‘Stages of Group Development’, Tuckman refers to this process as ‘norming’.
Performing
Some teams will reach the performing stage where teams are able to function as a unit as they find ways to get the job done smoothly and effectively without inappropriate conflict or the need for external supervision. Team members have become interdependent. By this time, they are motivated and knowledgeable. The team members are now competent, autonomous and able to handle the decision-making process without supervision.
My role within the group process involved opening the presentation on ‘Emotional Intelligence’ and discussing what was meant by the term. This involved the use of a brief mock quiz and scenario along with a PowerPoint© presentation that gave examples of its use in work and education.
Relating the experience to my own personal development, I feel that I have overcome a small hurdle in terms of improving my communication skills and gaining confidence in my ability to teach. I attempted to use Fleming's VA(R)K Model (1991) in my presentation encompassing not only PowerPoint© slideshows (Visual), but a mock quiz (Kinaesthetic) and open discussion (Auditory) to emphasise specific points and ensure group interaction, and feedback from my fellow students regarding this approach was positive.
Reflection
Reflecting back on the process of planning and the sharing of ideas and findings within our small group, I found communication to be disjointed and very sporadic. Although each of the members knew what was required of them, conflicting demands such as work, family and additional coursework from a concurrent module led to preparation of our presentations being left until the last minute. Furthermore, owing to the logistics of group members locality, it was difficult to meet up. Communication took place mostly by electronic mail with a number of messages being sent back and forth in relation to presentations, timings and order of delivery. On reflection, although this was an effective way of communicating, it impeded certain areas of communication such as non-verbal, verbal and group interaction. Vahabi [2007] asserts that when using written communication, people often make assumptions that the reader [receiver] can read and understand what is written and information can be imparted from a particular message that adds to his or her knowledge. This approach to communication fails to address a person's level of understanding, bias and personal influence leading to misinterpretation of what is being said [textually; Taylor et al, Reference Taylor, Fieldman and Altman2008]. When working within a group, verbal communication and interaction involves the use of body language, intonation and verbal cues that subconsciously provide members with information and guidance. It can be suggested that written communication removes this process and impedes effective interaction and, as a result, we sometimes do not say what we intend to.
When the learning process and symposium were discussed on the closing day of the module, there were mixed responses to the way in which we communicated as a small group. Some members felt that had we met up before the day, there would have been greater pressure to produce and finish our work earlier and this could have led to conflict. Equally, some elements of the presentations did not prove popular with other members of the group, which could have led to disagreement. Overall, choosing not to meet and finalise our work until the day of the symposium prevented conflict and put a greater emphasis on ‘trust’ within the group.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the use of a specific ‘collaborative’ paradigm for a unique group of students can be restrictive when applied to a discrete modular learning piece. However, having only a single window in which to familiarise with a one-off group did not allow for a wide diversity of models to be used. I could not assume homogeneity either, in that each member of the group who contributed to the teaching session seldom had identical methods and ideas to his or her peers. Nevertheless, it is fair to say that on this occasion a collective approach was developed from the points raised that undoubtedly improved both individual and group learning regardless of these differences.
The use of Tuckman's model allowed for reflection and evaluation that could be applied as qualitative analysis through discrete feedback on a learning continuum. The key requisite from this will be planning any new teaching sessions with points taken from previous evaluation and feedback.
The move from a simple didactic approach to an androgynous approach has identified positive outcomes in the learning process, even though time was limited, with the use of group work and collaboration allowing for a holistic approach to teaching.
Furthermore, although there may have been a perceived reluctance to work in a group by some of its members, I feel that focus, communication and participation occurred by the fact that both the learning and teaching was interactive and student centred.
