Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-18T03:34:00.474Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Hominin Stone Flaking and the Emergence of ‘Top-down’ Design in Human Evolution

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 July 2020

Mark W. Moore*
Affiliation:
Stone Tools and Cognition Hub, Archaeology and Palaeoanthropology, University of New England, Armidale, NSW 2351, Australia Email: mmoore2@une.edu.au
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The philosopher Daniel Dennett argues that complex structures in the natural and cultural worlds emerge from two types of design. Bottom-up design involves the rote action of a simple algorithm in an environment constrained by physical laws. Top-down design involves deliberation and planning, and is unique to modern humans. Identifying the emergence of top-down design in the hominin lineage is an important research challenge, and the archaeological record of stone technology is our best evidence for it. A current view is that artefact types and flaking methods increased in complexity from 3.3 to c. 0.3 million years ago, reflecting improving capacities at spatial cognition and working memory, culminating in top-down design perhaps as early as 1.75 million years ago. Recent experimental work, however, has shown that a simple ‘remove flake’ algorithm constrained by the laws of fracture mechanics—a form of bottom-up design—can produce stone tool attributes thought to be evidence of top-down design. Here, these models are reviewed and critiqued in light of the new experimental evidence. A revised working memory-based model, focusing on the recursive aspects of stone flaking, is proposed.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © 2020 McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research
Figure 0

Figure 1.Examples of ‘bottom-up’ and ‘top-down’ design. Bottom-up design is demonstrated by a termite mound ‘cathedral’ in northern Australia (left) and top-down design is demonstrated by the Sagrada Família in Spain (right). (Dennett in Ananthaswamy 2017.)

Figure 1

Figure 2.The ‘local rules’ of stone flaking. Controlled stone flaking is tightly constrained by the mechanics of fracture in brittle solids (Cotterell & Kamminga 1987). The first step in striking a flake is to find a stone that is relatively siliceous and free of cracks or ‘grain’ (A). Next, the stoneworker must identify a ridge or zone of high mass on one face (B). This zone of high mass must be adjacent to a second face that can serve as a striking platform (C). Crucially, these surfaces must be oriented at an acute angle to one another, that is, less than 90° (D). This ‘acute angle rule’ is counterintuitive to novice stoneworkers, and the discovery of this rule is the breakthrough that led to controlled stone flaking. Once those conditions are met, the platform is struck with a glancing blow (E), creating a flake and a core (F). Both the flake and the core can be used as tools. The flake undercuts the high mass, and flake making is essentially the repeated removal of these high-mass zones (Moore 2010). Removal of the first flake from a core (G: 1, showing the ‘knapper's-eye-view’, looking down onto the platform surface) offsets the high mass to either side of the flake (H: 2 & 3). Removal of these new zones of high mass again offsets the high mass (I: 4, 5 & 6). The way mass is redistributed by flake removal is predictable, and it drives the developing morphology of the core. The distance a blow is struck from the edge (the platform depth) influences the size of the flake (Dibble & Whittaker 1981), and this distance can be adjusted relative to the size of the high mass (J, schematic side view of core). Removing a flake redistributes the mass on the core face by removing the high mass relative to the platform depth.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Oldowan stone tools and spatial cognition. Wynn (1981; 1985) applied Piagetian analysis (otherwise applied to the ontogenetic development of children) to Oldowan stone tools and concluded that early hominins possessed highly developed geometrical awareness. ‘Proximity’ refers to an ability to strike blows close to each other in the spatial field. Cores with flaking concentrated at one end show an ability to sense proximity and to act on it. ‘Boundary’ refers to the ability to divide up the spatial field. Boundary awareness is suggested by bifacial flaking, where flakes are removed to opposite faces of the core, which requires flipping from one face to the other. The spatial field is divided into two parts along the boundary defined by the bifacially flaked edge. A notion of ‘spatial amount’ is implied because the stoneworkers sometimes flaked stones until the diameters more or less matched. (Drawings after Leakey 1971. Not to scale.)

Figure 3

Figure 4.Symmetry in Acheulean handaxes. Wynn (2002) argued that an important cognitive breakthrough occurred when advanced spatial abilities were applied to impose bilateral symmetry onto stones, first seen in the handaxes of the Early Acheulean. This was done by trimming to match one side of the developing core to the other side. The edge attrition caused by flaking itself demonstrates boundary, proximity, and spatial amount (see Figure 3). In the example (left), trimming (white arrows) matched the handaxe's right edge to the unmodified left edge (dotted lines). The flaking created mirror symmetry along the vertical line. Shape matching like this requires the ability to see past the constraints offered by what the hominins have in front of them. This ability is called ‘frame independence’, and is accomplishing through the coordination of spatial abilities with a separate cognitive system concerned with shape recognition. In the Late Acheulean, handaxes show relatively precise reflectional symmetry in three dimensions: plan view, side view and end view. In addition to frame independence, this requires mental rotation: the ability to hold in the mind viewpoints that are not all visible at the same time. The stoneworkers must be able to imagine visual perspectives not centred on themselves; that is, to place themselves outside the visual field. This is known as ‘allocentric perception’, or ‘Euclidean spatial thinking’. For instance, when a flake is struck to remove a lump and improve the end-view symmetry in the example (right), the stoneworker must also anticipate how the attrition caused by removing the flake will simultaneously change the object's side-view and plan-view symmetries. Some argue that without this anticipation—based on mental rotation—it would not be possible to produce handaxes consistently with these symmetries. (Not to scale.)

Figure 4

Figure 5.Levallois Method and ‘predetermination’. The Levallois Method sensu stricto involves flaking the core in such a way that it ‘predetermines’ the shape of the flake struck from it (Boëda 1994; 1995). One face of the core is flaked to provide platform surfaces to strike different sorts of flakes from the opposite face. This creates a zone of high mass of specific shape, often a dome. A platform is then prepared and struck at the end of the dome, which is removed as the intended Levallois flake. For the success of the method, the stoneworker maintains what is known as a ‘hierarchy of surfaces’ (A). Relatively steep, short flakes are struck from one surface (A, left) to provide a continuous platform for shaping a dome on the opposite surface (A, right). The dome is shaped by striking flakes in such a way that they created ‘convexities’ on both lateral sides as well as at the core's distal end (shown by lines). The shape and location of the convexities control the path the flake takes through the dome, anticipating the flake's ‘rupture point’ (van Peer 1992) (B, left, dotted line) as it detaches from the core. The platform surface is carefully prepared to match the intended rupture point on the core face (B, right). The Levallois flake is then struck (C).

Figure 5

Figure 6.Chunking in long-term memory. Enhanced working memory allows expert performance in motor-action skills like stone working because of the way actions are ‘chunked’ in long-term memory. A chunk refers to the way that the information is encoded into memory and retrieved from it, involving an aspect of cognition referred to as ‘procedural memory’. Memory chunks are composed of memory cues, retrieval structures (called memory ‘scaffolds’) and motor-action algorithms. A ‘cue’ is an aspect of the physical world that brings to mind the scaffold. In the hypothetical example (A), the cue is an excurvate edge on the developing core. Observing the cue invokes quick access to a generalized memory scaffold—the scaffold is tethered to it—that perceives the mismatch in core symmetry (see Figure 4). The scaffold then triggers the flake-removal algorithm (B), a unit of action-based knowledge that can be applied without conscious attention (Moore 2010). Application of the algorithm (in this example, three times) removes the cue (C), in this case enhancing the symmetry of the core. The cue fades rapidly from working memory but the scaffold is stored until invoked by a new cue. In expert performance, memory chunks are the key to enhanced working memory because they ensure that technical information does not fade. (Not to scale.)

Figure 6

Figure 7.Recycled chert core and ‘forward thinking’. The light-coloured, ‘fresh’ scars on this core from southern Arabia were created by a Late Bronze Age stoneworker, 1750–1300 cal bc (Weeks et al.2018). They intrude into dark patinated flake scars created by a much earlier stoneworker, possibly during the Neolithic. The intentions of the earlier knapper were irrelevant to the Bronze Age knapper—reduction could continue regardless. This shows that forward thinking is not necessary for successful flake making. (Scale bar 50 mm.)

Figure 7

Figure 8.Protocols of the spandrels experiments. The ‘spandrels experiments’ mimicked bottom-up design in stone flaking (Moore & Perston 2016). All viable platforms were identified on the stone according to the ‘maximization protocol’ (A) and a random number generator was used to select one of the platforms—Platform 5 (circled) in the hypothetical example. The flake was removed (B) and the reconfigured core was re-evaluated, with new platforms identified. In the example, the flake took away three platforms—5, 6, and 7—and created two new platforms—9 and 10. The next platform was randomly chosen from this new configuration, and the flake was removed (not shown). The experimental procedure was repeated until the core size dropped below an arbitrary size threshold.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Results of the spandrels experiments. The spandrels experiments mimicked bottom-up design in stone tool manufacture by eliminating complex intentions from the process (Moore & Perston 2016), but produced cores that seem to show elements of top-down design. For instance, without an intention to do so, the experiments produced objects that demonstrate boundary (A, top), proximity (A, bottom), and spatial amount (B) (see Figure 3). Bilateral symmetries developed similar to those seen on Early Acheulean handaxes (C) which ostensibly require frame independence, hidden perspective and a Euclidean sense of space (see Figure 4). The experiments produced objects classifiable as ‘handaxes’ (C) without ‘holding them in the mind’ during the knapping process—this was not required and it suggests that handaxes can be reproduced without teaching and therefore without an advanced ‘theory of mind’. The experiments created domed core faces through convexity control (C, right; D, top) (see Figure 5), as well as Levallois-like cores (D) and flakes, without an intention to do so. This shows that not all aspects of the Levallois Method sensu stricto require complex intentions, challenging the links between the enhanced working memory model and the archaeological record, as currently formulated. (Not to scale.)

Figure 9

Figure 10.Abang, a captive orangutan, smashing a rock in a flake-making experiment (stills from a film of the process). Although Abang was successful in fracturing the flint to produce sharp tools for procuring food (Wright 1978), he did not demonstrate abilities at controlled stone flaking.

Figure 10

Figure 11.A model of increasing stone-flaking complexity based on elaborations in procedural memory. In this schematic model, procedural memory ‘chunks’ of increasing complexity are nested inside each other, showing how recursion is a fundamental property of stone flaking. The simple memory chunk (bottom) drives the removal of a single flake through cues and scaffolds described in Figure 1. The simple chunk is automatized within the ‘short chunk’ (middle). In this hypothetical example, described in Figure 6, three flakes are removed in response to a geometrical cue on a spandrel. The short chunk, in turn, is automatized with the ‘extended chunk’ (top). Technical procedures like striking flakes from prepared platforms are automatized by modern knappers within extended chunks. In this schematic model, three short chunks are automatized within the extended chunk, which in turn required nine simple chunks; in practice, many more flake removals are possible within automatized memory chunks. Recursion cannot proceed indefinitely, and staged-based sequencing—and therefore top-down design—may have emerged after recursive flaking within chunks reached its cognitive limit. Bottom-up design is demonstrated by unguided application of simple chunks, which produces spandrels (Moore & Perston 2016), and, in theory, unguided application of simple and extended chunks may increase the frequency of those spandrels. Although an increase in spandrels may appear to reflect intentional, top-down design, it might instead be explained by the application of rules governing bottom-up design to memory chunks of greater complexity.