Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T11:05:37.112Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Were Acheulean Bifaces Deliberately Made Symmetrical? Archaeological and Experimental Evidence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 July 2018

Ceri Shipton
Affiliation:
Centre of Excellence for Australian Biodiversity and Heritage, Australian National University, Canberra, ACT 0200, Australia Email: ceri.shipton@anu.edu.au
Chris Clarkson
Affiliation:
School of Social Science, University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia Email: c.clarkson@uq.edu.au
Rommy Cobden
Affiliation:
School of Social Science, University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia Email: rommy.cobden@uqconnect.edu.au
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Acheulean bifaces dominate the archaeological record for 1.5 million years. The meaning behind the often symmetrical forms of these tools is the topic of considerable debate, with explanations ranging from effectiveness as a cutting tool to sexual display. Some, however, question whether the symmetry seen in many Acheulean bifaces is intentional at all, with suggestions that it is merely the result of a bias in hominin perception or an inevitable consequence of bifacial flaking. In this paper we address the issue of intention in biface symmetry. First, we use transmission chain experiments designed to track symmetry trends in the replication of biface outlines. Secondly, we use archaeological data to assess the symmetry of Acheulean bifaces from British, East African and Indian assemblages in relation to reduction intensity; the degree of bifaciality; and the symmetry of four Middle Palaeolithic bifacial core assemblages. Thirdly, we look at specific examples of the reduction sequences that produced symmetrical Acheulean cleavers at the sites of Olorgesailie CL1-1, Isinya, Chirki, Morgaon and Bhimbetka. All three lines of evidence support the notion that symmetry was a deliberately imposed property of Acheulean bifaces and not an epiphenomenon of hominin visual perception or bifacial technology.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research 2018 
Figure 0

Figure 1.An example of symmetry achieved with very few retouch scars on a flake blank cleaver from Olorgesailie. Scale in centimetres.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Initial images that were copied by the first participants. Bilateral symmetry was measured using the FlipTest with the results ranging from highly symmetrical on the left (0.9) through intermediate levels (2.95 and 4.05) to highly asymmetrical on the right (11.94).

Figure 2

Figure 3.The mean generational trajectory in the index of asymmetry of the four handaxe drawings. Each line is the average of four transmission chains and each link in the chain was drawn by a different participant.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Examples of the 20 transmission chains. A and B show symmetrical handaxes becoming less symmetrical. C and D show the most asymmetrical handaxe becoming more symmetrical in both the main experiment (C) and the single participant repeat (D).

Figure 4

Figure 5.The mean trajectory in the index of asymmetry over eight generations of a single participant copying their own drawings.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Boxplot comparing FlipTest scores of Acheulean biface assemblages (Chirki: N = 32; Olorgesialie CL1-1: N = 27; Morgaon: N = 30; Bhimbetka: N = 35; Hitchin: N = 42; Kariandusi: N = 76; Isinya: N = 37; Swanscombe Middle Gravels: N = 33; and Boxgrove: N = 37) with Middle Palaeolithic discoidal, hierarchical disc and recurrent Levallois core assemblages (Gorham's Cave: N = 33; JKF12: N = 20; JSM1; N = 17; Dhaba: N = 17).

Figure 6

Table 1.Results of regression analyses testing the relationship between flake scar density and bilateral symmetry for samples of handaxes and cleavers from various Acheulean assemblages.

Figure 7

Table 2.Results of regression analyses testing the relationship between bifaciality and bilateral symmetry for samples of bifaces from various Acheulean assemblages.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Three cleavers from Olorgesailie CL1-1. Cleaver A has been unifacially flaked on opposing edges and surfaces (l. 145 mm, FlipTest score 2.64); cleaver B is bifacially flaked on both edges (l. 152 mm, FlipTest score 2.85); cleaver C is bifacially flaked on one edge (the left in dorsal view) and unifacially flaked on the other edge (l. 168 mm, FlipTest score 3.24).

Figure 9

Figure 8.Three cleavers from Isinya. Cleaver A has been bifacially flaked around most of the perimeter (l. 203 mm, FlipTest score 1.86); cleaver B has been bifacially flaked along one edge only (l. 203 mm, FlipTest score 1.76); cleaver C has been unifacially flaked on opposing edges and surfaces (l. 201 mm, FlipTest score 2.09).

Figure 10

Figure 9.Three cleavers from Morgaon. Cleavers A (l. 132 mm, FlipTest score 4.15) and C (l. 121 mm, FlipTest score 3.24) were largely unifacially flaked, while cleaver B (l. 122 mm, FlipTest score 3.69) was bifacially flaked on one edge (the right in dorsal view) and unifacially flaked on the opposing edge.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Three cleavers from Chirki. Cleavers A (l. 113 mm, FlipTest score 3.44) and C (l. 131 mm, FlipTest score 4.01) were bifacially flaked on one edge (the right in dorsal view in both cases) and unifacially flaked on the opposing edge, while cleaver B (l. 135 mm, FlipTest score 5.16) was unifacially flaked on both edges.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Three cleavers from Bhimbetka. Cleavers A (l. 146mm, FlipTest score 3.45) and B (l. 123mm, FlipTest score 2.07) are bifacially flaked on one edge (in dorsal view the left edge for cleaver A and the right edge for cleaver B) and unifacially flaked on the opposing edge, while cleaver C (l. 125mm, FlipTest score 4.69) was bifacially flaked but with only a few removals.