Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T23:16:19.786Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Designing for Charging Experience in the two-way Consumer Grid

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 November 2026

Kartikeya Acharya*
Affiliation:
Delectro Pty Ltd, Australia
*
Corresponding author: Kartikeya Acharya; Email: karthikeya.acharya@gmail.com
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Everyday charging of personal devices, electric vehicles (EVs) and home batteries now contributes to a significant and growing share of domestic electricity demand. Yet aligning charging practices with renewable energy rhythms to improve demand flexibility remains a persistent challenge. Drawing on a qualitative synthesis of three design and ethnographic reports from a digital energy futures project, followed by multidisciplinary expert interviews, this article introduces Charging Experience (CgX) as a design domain for the two-way consumer grid. Through abductive analysis of charging-related contexts, themes and experiential considerations, five theme-coded categories: User Control, Rhythms and Routines, Incentives, Learning and Collective Ownership, were derived from the project reports. These categories were subsequently examined through expert interviews spanning battery material chemistry, building energy efficiency, EV charging services and user experience research. From this multidisciplinary synthesis, the article distils three interrelated interaction design procedures, Composing, Aligning and Signalling, for designing charging experiences to support greater household participation in the two-way consumer grid.

Information

Type
Research Article
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Term and code analysis chartTable 1. long description.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Two stage project process and methodology.

Figure 2

Figure 2.The CgX procedural wheel.Figure 2. long description.

Author comment: Designing for Charging Experience in the two-way Consumer Grid — R0/PR1

Comments

Dear Editors-in-Chief,

Please find enclosed our manuscript entitled “CgX: A Design Framework for Charging Experiences in Domestic Energy Transitions” for consideration as a Research article in Cambridge Prisms: Energy Transitions.

The article introduces CgX, a five-point design framework for charging experiences across personal devices, electric vehicles, and home batteries, grounded in a qualitative synthesis of the Digital Energy Futures project reports from Australia. Drawing on social practice theory and user experience research, the paper reframes everyday charging as a site for domestic demand flexibility and contributes a user-centred perspective to demand-side energy transition research.

The manuscript is original, has not been published previously, and is not under consideration elsewhere. All authorship, ethical, and disclosure requirements of the journal have been met. Any use of AI-assisted tools was limited to language editing only, with all conceptual development and analysis undertaken by the author.

I confirm that I will have no editorial role in the handling or review of this manuscript and will recuse myself fully from the editorial process.

Thank you for considering this submission. I would be pleased to respond to any questions or revisions the reviewers or editors may suggest.

Yours sincerely,

Dr Kartikeya Acharya

Founding Director

DELECTRO

EnergyLab,

Sydney, Australia

Review: Designing for Charging Experience in the two-way Consumer Grid — R0/PR2

Conflict of interest statement

Reviewer declares none.

Comments

Alternative Title Suggestions:

“Beyond Automation: A User Experience Framework (CgX) for Domestic Charging Practices in Renewable Energy Transitions”

Emphasizes the human-centered approach vs. technical solutions

“CgX Framework: Designing Equitable Charging Experiences for Household Energy Flexibility Through Practice Theory”

Highlights equity and theoretical foundation

“Aligning Human Rhythms with Renewable Energy: The CgX Framework for Domestic Charging Experience Design”

Poetic yet informative, emphasizes the core tension

“From Individual Devices to Collective Action: A Design Framework for Domestic Charging in the Energy Transition”

Captures the scale progression and social dimension

The manuscript follows a relatively standard structure but could benefit from reorganization.

Methodology

Strengths: Clear description of data sources; transparent about analytical approach

Areas for improvement: Lacks justification for choosing abductive design approach; limited discussion of limitations

Suggestions: Add inter-rater reliability measures; discuss potential biases; include a methodology diagram

Critical Changes

Add a theoretical background section grounding the work in established literature

Include a related work section positioning CgX against existing frameworks

Strengthen methodology section with reflexivity and limitations discussion

Add a visual comparison table of CgX vs. other approaches

Important Improvements

Include preliminary validation data (expert interviews or stakeholder feedback)

Develop fuller discussion section with theoretical and practical implications

Add quantitative estimates of potential energy/carbon savings

Create a clearer visual framework diagram (current figure needs refinement)

Review: Designing for Charging Experience in the two-way Consumer Grid — R0/PR3

Conflict of interest statement

Reviewer declares none.

Comments

Overview

The paper advocates for a shift toward charging experience (CgX), focusing on the user experience of charging devices within the context of future energy demand. Emerging from a project on Australian household digital lifestyle trends, the article aims to provide conceptual building blocks for designers, engineers and policymakers. The methodology utilises a qualitative analysis of four research reports, employing the Taguette tool to identify recurring themes via the search term “charg.” This process yielded five meta-narratives (incentives, learning/education, ownership, rhythms/routines and user control) and three contextual categories (personal devices, EV charging and home charging).

Strengthening the demand-side argument

The paper makes a case for a demand-side approach to charging, but the argument requires more robust evidence to be fully persuasive. Currently, the “value proposition” of this approach is not sufficiently compared against traditional supply-side or technical efficiency efforts.

Including a more detailed argument in existing literature between expected demand-side benefits versus technical efforts (e.g. hardware/software battery optimisation) would strengthen the justification for this framework. Specifically, what are the projected savings – monetary, energy or otherwise – that a demand-side, user-centric approach offers that technical efficiency alone cannot achieve?

Furthermore, evidence on the particular challenges and opportunities of demand-side approaches should be highlighted. For example, what does literature from behavioural economics, like nudge theory, or the attention or experience economy say about demand-side efforts, and how can these inform the framework? This seems particularly critical as the paper argues for “reframing charging as a socio-technical challenge that can be shaped by design.” (line 392-393)

Conceptual framework and metaphorical clarity

While the paper introduces the “architectural build metaphor” (lines 171-172) to structure its findings, the necessity of this specific framing remains under-justified. The author notes that “each theme can be engaged independently” (line 215), which creates a tension with the use of an overarching architectural metaphor.

The author should explicitly clarify why the metaphor is essential for the CgX framework – particularly when compared to what analogies or mnemonics afford in the context of design. For example, a mnemomic would seem more appropriate if, as the author states, it is to be memorable (line 175). If the themes are modular and independent, the paper must explain how the metaphor adds value rather than additional conceptual complexity.

Operationalisation and utility

The paper argues for the usefulness of the proposed CgX framework, yet it lacks detailed consideration for how it would be used in specific circumstances. To move from a conceptual block to a developmental tool, the effectiveness of the framework needs to be considered in the context of how different users of the framework might use it, when they use it and for which contextual categories (personal devices, EV charging and home charging).

The author should consider foregrounding how the framework might adapt or change depending on who is using it, and for what. For example, is there a difference between how a designer might use it versus an engineer or policymaker? And how do these different stakeholders use it when considering the different devices they are designing for (e.g. phone versus electric car)? This would strengthen the model’s utility for meeting the paper’s stated aim of providing conceptual blocks for new energy products, services and systems. Furthermore, does the stage of product/service/systems development influence the framework as well - when it is used? For example, are components more relevant at the early stages of development (concept stage) compared to later stages (testing, prototype or trial stage)?

Review: Designing for Charging Experience in the two-way Consumer Grid — R0/PR4

Conflict of interest statement

Reviewer declares none.

Comments

Firstly, thank you to the author for submitting this work, which is both timely and relevant in relation to energy futures and sustainable transitions. The paper examines a critical area associated with increased electricification strategies and the nature of charging (combined with the ubiquity of batteries, at various scale) - and the impact this has on the historical rhythm of the electrical grid and its ability to service electrical demand.

The paper adopts a methodology using CADQAS software to uncover word frequency analysis from a series of outputs from the project Digital Energy Futures, examining associations with the word stem “charg” in order to occurrences and frequency of terms used as “charge”, “charging”, “charges”, etc. Thematic analysis and content coding associated with components of the overall textual corpus reveals 5 main themes, across three scaled areas of concern related to domestic practices related to charging of personal energy devices. From this, a framework entitled CgX is distilled and presented, suggested as being useful for designers engaged in User Experience (UX) of devices requiring charging.

While the ambition of the paper is to be commended, and its relevance to active engagement by the design community involved in the energy transition, the devil is always in the detail.

Structurally, it is worth noting that in two places, there is sentence duplication (lines 95-96; lines 136-137). Aside from this, there are some major concerns with the paper, primarily methodologically and analytically. These might be straightforward to overcome if the claims made by the paper were tempered to some degree, since what is advocated as key findings may be over-emphasised based on the approaches adopted to bring us here. I explain my concerns in three main critiques below, with an author recommendation on how to potentially move forward to address these concerns.

Methodology

The use of CADQAS software (such as Taguette) is a common approach to addressing qualitative data such as text and image, through iterative approaches to coding (for more on coding, see Saldana (2015) for a wonderful overview of theory and technique). However the corpus under examination is constructed from 3 main documents as outputs from a singular research project - itself qualitative and likely to be using similar tools to address interviews and ethnographic data from within the context of the larger study. It would also be helpful to have a better understanding of the actual coding practices which were undertaken to support the analysis and construction of the framework. Details of coding practices are not provided, particularly if there are multiple coders involved (or whether this was an individual practice). If multiple coders involved, I’d have expected some mention of inter-coder reliability being addressed; if done solely by the author, I’d have anticipated some statement about how the coding practices were done in such a way to ensure findings were robust and the process could be reproduced. Simply searching for word stems does not necessarily qualify as a coding exercise, but this is the one aspect of the methodology that is best explained. More could be done.

Data and sample size

A corpus of three documents (from a common source compiled from a single research project) is arguably a small selection for data analysis. It is also one that is potentially biased, since it all comes from the same research team and common authors. While the exercise involved with coding and thematic extraction is useful, any analytical insights and frameworks generated from this data will need to be understood with a caveat that it cannot make major claims (as it does) from such a small and localised sample size. What may have been more productive (and robust) would have been to request the raw data from the research team themselves and conduct the same exercise on the larger corpus from the original research project - thereby also avoiding a need to address the original author’s analytical bias which is inevitably to be found within the generation of the reports being examined.

Framework

The generation of 5 key themes (referred to in the paper as “meta categories”) is a useful distillation of the reports from the Digital Energy Futures project under examination, but as outlined above it is somewhat more challenging to make generalised assumptions about communities of energy practice more widely from such a small and targeted sample and corpus. In a similar fashion, it is unclear how the translation is being made from these meta-categories to what is argued as being a more design-centric framework, utilising architectural metaphor. An associated diagramme outlining the framework and the associated constituent parts is included - again, it is unclear how these relational components have been assembled into this form of framework. The framework itself is descriptive, and there is no indication that it has been employed within a design protocol, brief, or practice, allowing feedback for understanding how it works, and whether it addresses efficiencies and design improvements as articulated. The paper suggests that the framework itself is a result of abductive approaches to thinking and analysing the materials here, implicating that it perhaps is the result of design - not necessarily a framework yet ready for design.

Path to improvement.

Arguably, much of this criticism outlined here is encapsulated in the final paragraph by the author themselves - but sadly, that reflection doesn’t mean that this exempts the paper nor the work from exclusion of this criticism, leaving it to be addressed “for future work”. That itself seems to be an acknowledgment by the author that this paper is not ready for publication -and as presented, I would agree. I think it would be much more helpful to present the paper as what it is - an quick scan of prior research outputs using appropriate qualitative, text based tools in order to distill insights leading to a useful tool that could be useful by designers and design teams in addressing charging behaviour (as part of an energy transition). With this, I’d anticipate that less is made of the framework itself as an outcome of herculean research activity and coding - and some effort is made to actually put it into a community of design practice to see whether it actually can produce identifiable results in addressing battery charging practices. I recognise this may take time (if it is understood that the framework is commercially relevant), but it would be worth perhaps thinking about this framework as a design output and seeing where it stands on other measures - say for instance, where does the author feels it might appear in the Technology Readiness Level (TRL) framework? I’d argue this is TRL1 or TRL2, with a goal of this paper being a demonstration of how the framework operates (well, or not), is improved through iteration (as opposed to abduction) and provides some evidence that changes made through empirical testing improve it’s standing in TRL levels. While I do not expect (nor advocate) that the use of the TRL framework is to be literally deployed as a validation or verification method - something does need to be done to bridge the gap from what is arguable a concept towards what might be a useful and useable framework for deployment in the field. If more work is to be done to achieve this, that is fine, but that statement should not appear at the end of the paper, rather - set out up front that this is the case from the onset - managing readers and colleague’s expectations of what is to be understood from this work.

Afterward

I do believe this paper discusses important and relevant work relevant to the energy sector transition, including changes to sociotechnical challenges at the domestic level. What is presented is cursory work in this area that has potential to develop - but this needs to be clearly articulated and a clearer plan for future work and how to address concerns must be included - or (better yet), actually done. It is worth writing about what this work actually is (honestly) rather than attempting to celebrate what this work might eventually be. To make this happen, I believe the paper needs to be rewritten to include major update - either including some user testing and validation, or further discussion of the importance and relevance what is already done in nascent form on a theoretical level.

Recommendation: Designing for Charging Experience in the two-way Consumer Grid — R0/PR5

Comments

Many thanks for submitting your paper to Cambridge Prisms: Energy Transitions.

Upon review of the comments and suggestions made by the three reviewers, I recommend that this paper needs some Major Revisions. I think the reviewers make some compelling and interesting arguments and suggestions which I think if addressed systematically, the paper and its contribution will be significant and worthy of being published in this journal.

I truly believe that if these parts are addressed and discussed with the co-authors, this will be an excellent paper and I would encourage you to make the changes which will then lead to publication.

Please follow the instructions given and return your revised manuscript before the stipulated date in order to send back to the reviewers and make inroads to having this paper in the journal.

Please get in touch if you require any assistance.

Decision: Designing for Charging Experience in the two-way Consumer Grid — R0/PR6

Comments

No accompanying comment.

Author comment: Designing for Charging Experience in the two-way Consumer Grid — R1/PR7

Comments

Dear Dr Eliza Hotchkiss,

Please find enclosed the revised version of manuscript ETR-2025-0014, entitled:

“Designing for Charging Experience in the Two-Way Consumer Grid”

I would like to sincerely thank you, the handling editor, and the three reviewers for the careful evaluation of the manuscript and for the constructive and insightful comments provided during the review process. The suggestions have been invaluable in strengthening both the clarity and the contribution of the paper.

In response to the reviews, the manuscript has undergone substantial revision. The principal changes include:

1. Addition of a second empirical stage consisting of multidisciplinary expert interviews to refine the preliminary framework;

2. Substantial revision and clarification of the conceptual framework and its contributions;

3. Restructuring of the manuscript to more clearly reflect the two-stage research process;

4. Expansion of the methodology and discussion sections, including explicit acknowledgement of methodological limitations and future work;

5. revision of the title, figures, references, and overall presentation of the manuscript.

A detailed point-by-point response to all reviewer comments has also been submitted as a response to the decision letter.

I hope that the revisions satisfactorily address the reviewers' comments and that the manuscript is now suitable for publication in Cambridge Prisms: Energy Transitions.

Thank you again for your consideration and I look forward to hearing from you.

Yours sincerely,

Dr Kartikeya Acharya

Founder, Delectro Pty Ltd

EnergyLab

Sydney, NSW, Australia

Recommendation: Designing for Charging Experience in the two-way Consumer Grid — R1/PR8

Comments

Dear Corresponding Author,

Many thanks for your detailed corrections and considerations after the round of reviews.

I have checked these, and can read that you have addressed most of these.

Therefore, I am happy to accept this latest version and for it to continue onto the processing stage.

Please take careful attention on the guidance and requirements.

Many thanks

Dr Julio Bros-Williamson

Senior Editor

Cambridge Prisms: Energy Transitions

Decision: Designing for Charging Experience in the two-way Consumer Grid — R1/PR9

Comments

No accompanying comment.