As neural implants transition from engineering design and testing into human subjects research, careful consideration must be paid to the ethical elements in developing research protocols. Although these ethical aspects may be framed by the design choices of the engineering, a number of challenging choices arise. In spite of many ethical considerations for neural implant technologies being shared with generic research ethics questions, there are subsets needing special attention. Even in considerations requiring increased attention, substantial overlap can be found with research ethics questions for general medical implants and for psychiatric pharmaceuticals.1
Hansson SO. Implant ethics. Journal of Medical Ethics 2005;31:519–25; Morreim EH, Webb GE, Gordon HL, Brody B, Cassarett D, Rosenfeld K, et al. Innovation in human research protection: The AbioCor artificial heart trial. The American Journal of Bioethics 2006;6(5):W6–16.
Past ethical missteps in the development of functional neurosurgery must be taken into account when developing any new protocol in the area of neural implants.2
Ford PJ, Henderson J. Neuroethics in the Operating Room: Functional neurosurgical interventions. In: Neuroethics: Defining the Issues in Theory, Practice and Policy. Illes J, ed. New York: Oxford University Press; 2005:213–228; Ford PJ, Henderson JM. The Clinical and Research Ethics of Neuromodulation. Neuromodulation 2006;9(4):249–52; Fins JJ. From psychosurgery to neuromodulation and palliation: History's lessons for the ethical conduct and regulation of neuropsychiatric research. Neurosugery Clinics of North America 2003;14:303–19.
Pressman JD. Last Resort: Psychosurgery and the Limits of Medicine. New York: Cambridge University Press; 1998; Ottosson J, Fink M. Ethics in Electroconvulsive Therapy. New York: Brunner-Routledge; 2004.
Baumeister AA. The Tulane electrical brain stimulation program: A historical case study in medical ethics. Journal of the History of the Neurosciences 2000;9(3):262–78.
The overwhelming majority of brain implants under study aim to provide an improved quality of life rather than an increase in survival. This provides an important element in considering the framework of appropriate risks for human subjects and applies to mortality as well as significant morbidity risks. Quality of life goals imply that outcomes must be measured in functional improvements rather than by simple statistical significance or physiological change. These considerations of the goals of neural implants should influence all aspects of protocol development.
Consideration One: Psychiatric Illness Exclusion
The first ethical consideration in neural implant research focuses on appropriate subject selection criteria. There are many interesting ethical issues to consider related to benefits, harms, justice, and so forth, when discussing inclusion and exclusion criteria. Although this general topic of inclusion criteria interfaces with the second and third considerations discussed below, the issue of inclusion of those with psychiatric conditions unrelated to the research question is of particular interest. To exclude all patients with psychiatric illnesses that are unrelated to the research question may sound inviting for researchers, given that it potentially reduces the complexity of patient mix as well as avoids consideration of which psychiatric illnesses could either negatively affect research results or could pose an increased risk to a subject. However, all populations should have the opportunity to both share in the risks and benefits of clinical research unless there exist good scientific or moral reasons to the contrary. Rebecca Dresser nicely uses the example of HIV research in the 1980s to emphasize the importance of inclusion and consultation with interested parties in deciding selection criteria and protocol development.5
Dresser R. When Science Offers Salvation: Patient Advocacy and Research Ethics. New York: Oxford University Press; 2001.
Appelbaum PS, Grisso T, Frank E, O'Donnell S, Kupfer DJ. Competence of depressed patients for consent to research. American Journal of Psychiatry 1999;156:1380–4.
National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. Use of psychosurgery in practice and research: Report and recommendations. 42 Fed Reg 26318; 1977; Nuttin BJ, Gybels P, Cosyns L, Gabriels B, Meyerson S, Andréewitch S, et al. Deep brain stimulation for psychiatric disorders. Neurosurgery 2002;51:519; See note 1, Morreim et al. 2006.
Consideration Two: Consent Revocation
Neural implants become part of the subject's body and have potential to influence cognition and judgment. Consent can be revoked very easily in general research. A simple request to withdraw from a study is respected. Regulations and guidelines emphasize the need for voluntariness of a research subject's participation. The question of consent revocation can be more complex with neural implants, when the removal of the implant may pose some risk, the implant may be very expensive, and the implant may affect cognition. A distinction may be important between “revocation of informed consent” and “informed revocation of consent.” In the first case, the emphasis is placed on an ease of revocation after a very arduous process of informed consent. The voluntariness to continue is given priority. In the second case, the emphasis is placed on a more arduous process of informed revocation in order to discontinue the research protocol. This voluntariness of discontinuing then becomes the priority. The informed revocation may be of more importance when a therapy is mature in terms of actually providing a therapeutic benefit and when the patient may have some transient device-related cognitive deficit. The revocation of informed consent may be more appropriate with risks of continued participation and no benefit to the particular subject.
In developing a research protocol, careful account needs to be taken of obligations of the subject to the research and the mechanism for revocation of consent. This involves not only the distinction mentioned above, but also the possibility of a patient refusing explant of a device when explant is part of the research protocol. For instance, is it unduly coercive to require a subject to pay for a device if the research protocol calls for the device to be explanted after a given time and there is refusal? If a physician–researcher believes that leaving the implant embedded in the patient poses a dire health risk, what measures can be taken? Can therapeutic privilege be invoked for explantation to be performed without informed consent? The refusal for explant may affect both the subject and the ability to complete the research project that could help future patients. These considerations should be addressed during the development of the protocol and contained in consent forms even at the risk of implanting the idea of revocation with the subject.
Consideration Three: Enhancement
Current research in animals has demonstrated improved learning with specific invasive brain stimulation.8
William ZM, Eskandar EN. Selective enhancement of associative learning by microstimulation of the anterior caudate. Nature Neuroscience 2006;9(1):562–8.
Ford PJ. From treatment to enhancement in deep brain stimulation: A question of research ethics. The Pluralist 2006;1(2):35–44.
Conclusion
Testing neural implants in human subjects requires considerable prospective planning that includes justice issues of inclusion/exclusion criteria, revocation of consent, and proper study of enhancement. These considerations are deeply influenced by the initial design and engineering of the device and the ways in which the media influence research, as well as later clinical considerations. It is important to be clear of the underlying values lost and gained by any choice in developing a protocol. These considerations should be reflectively built into the protocol long before a review by an ethics board.
