Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-lpg2g Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-15T14:38:41.410Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Affective Matter: designing human-material interactions to enhance health and wellbeing

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 December 2024

Athina Papadopoulou*
Affiliation:
Massachusetts Institute of TechnologyNew York Institute of Technology
*
Corresponding author Athina Papadopoulou athpap@mit.edu; apapad@nyit.edu
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Our emotions do not always surface into our awareness, making it difficult to manage them and communicate them to others. Even when emotions do not reach our awareness, they still express themselves as physiological changes, often unperceived by ourselves and others. To aid in emotion self-regulation and increase the bandwidth of emotion communication, I designed a programmable affective sleeve that translates physiological aspects of emotions into material haptic action. The affective sleeve has been developed as a case study for Affective Matter. Affective Matter suggests a method for human-material interaction that enhances health and wellbeing.

I first discuss the three foundations of Affective Matter underlying the design of the affective sleeve: Embodiment, Entrainment, and Material Intelligence. I then proceed to the methods and results of an exploratory study I developed and conducted that tests the psychophysiological impact of the sleeve on 36 participants. The study results suggest that the pace of the affective sleeve’s haptic action can be programmed to regulate the wearer’s breathing pace to either have a calming or a stimulating impact on the wearer. The results also show varied affective responses to distinct haptic stimuli. Discussion of the results suggests future research directions and therapeutic applications for the benefit of individuals with mental health and neurodevelopmental disorders.

Information

Type
Research Article
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Conceptual diagram showing the sleeve as a medium for emotion self-regulation and communication.

Figure 1

Figure 2.A prototype of an affective sleeve, used in prior study, made from felt fabric and a shape memory alloy (nitinol). When electrical current passed through the nitinol wires of a sleeve’s cuff, the cuff changed shape producing slight warmth and pressure. Developed by the author and collaborators (Papadopoulou et al.2019).

Figure 2

Figure 3.The procedure of the prior study testing an affective sleeve included a baseline, testing, and survey phase. Participants were distributed to the Fast, Slow, and Control groups. In the Fast and Slow groups, the haptic action was equal to 125% and 100% of individual relaxed breathing rates respectively. The study included physiology and self-report measurements (Papadopoulou et al.2019).

Figure 3

Figure 4.Sketch showing the natural behavior of a fabric bladder upon pressurization (top), the behavior of a programmable pneumatic fabric actuator based on common approaches in prior inventions and science literature (middle), and the behavior of the programmable pneumatic actuator I developed (bottom).

Figure 4

Figure 5.The pneumatic affective sleeve was comprised of five cuffs that curved around the arm upon pressurization and also included embedded heatpads. The sleeve was designed to be modular to accommodate different body sizes (left). Preliminary prototype of the pneumatic affective sleeve showing how the novel material mechanism forces the air towards the skin increasing felt pressure and eliminating any ballooning effects (right).

Figure 5

Figure 6.Close-up photograph of the prototype of the pneumatic affective sleeve used in the study.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Experimental procedure and setup: The study lasted approximately 45 minutes (60 maximum) and comprised of four phases: Consent, Baseline, Testing, and Interview. Testing included a brief habituation session and seven testing conditions. A survey followed the habituation and each of the testing conditions. During testing participants sat at a desk, in front of a desktop computer, and wore the sleeve on their non-dominant hand, the electrodermal activity sensor on their dominant hand, and the breathing activity sensor on their chest.

Figure 7

Figure 8.The affective sleeve was designed with the intention of entraining the wearer’s breathing activity to the sleeve’s haptic action. A cycle of haptic action (HAC) was defined as the duration of pressure/temperature activation (Cuff ON) and deactivation (Cuff OFF) of a sleeve’s cuff. A relaxed breathing cycle (RBC) was defined as the duration of a participant’s average relaxed breathing cycle, including inhalation and exhalation, as measured during the baseline. HAC’s length was 30% slower than, equal to, or 30% faster than the length of the wearer’s RBC in the Slow, Regular, and Fast groups, respectively. HAC’s occurrence differed based on the conditions of haptic action: In conditions with a full HAC (conditions 1, 2, 3, 4), a cuff or series of cuffs was activated after a full HAC of any previously activated cuff. In conditions with a half HAC (conditions 5, 6), a cuff was activated after a half cycle of any previously activated cuff. The length of activation (Cuff ON) as opposed to deactivation (Cuff OFF) was always equal to 50% of a HAC.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Participants were tested on seven conditions of haptic actions in randomized sequence: (C1) Sequential pattern consisting of pressure in full cycle; (C2) Sequential pattern consisting of pressure and warmth in full cycle; (C3) Simultaneous pattern consisting of pressure in full cycle; (C4) Simultaneous pattern consisting of pressure and warmth in full cycle; (C5) Sequential pattern consisting of pressure in half cycle; (C6) Simultaneous pattern consisting of pressure and warmth in half cycle. (C7) Control Condition.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Graphs showing responses to the questions “If 5 is the highest and 1 is the lowest intensity of warmth/pressure you felt during this session, what was the maximum warmth/pressure you felt in the area covered by each of the five cuffs?” Bars represent intensities for warmth (red) and pressure (blue) for each of the five cuffs. In conditions with sequential pattern of haptic action (C1, C2, C5, C6), pressure and warmth felt more intense at the ends of the sleeve and lower in the middle. In conditions with simultaneous pattern of haptic action (C3, C4), warmth and pressure felt more intense in the middle of the sleeve and lower at the ends.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Radar charts showing the affective evaluation per condition for all participants per group. Individual evaluations for each condition are mapped on the affective circumplex creating a collective affective map per condition per group. The collective affective maps of the Slow group gravitate towards affective states of low arousal and slightly negative valence, like calmness and tiredness. The collective affective maps of the Regular group gravitate towards the center of the circumplex, expressing a neutral affective response. The collective affective maps of the Fast group gravitate towards affective states of high arousal and positive valence, like excitement and happiness.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Graphs showing the change of electrodermal activity (EDA) from baseline per condition for each group. The relative change of EDA levels (top) and the absolute change of EDA response (bottom) demonstrate that conditions with simultaneous pattern of haptic action in full cycle (conditions 3 and 4) had on average the greatest increase in EDA. There were no important consistent differences between conditions with pressure alone and conditions with pressure and warmth.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Plot of the electrodermal activity (EDA) of one participant of the Fast group during baseline and testing. The participant was tested in a randomized sequence of conditions (conditions 2, 5, 6, 1, 3, 7, 4) according to the study protocol. The red dotted line represents the average baseline measurement. The continuous lines represent the start of each of the conditions of haptic action. The black dotted lines represent the beginning of the UI surveys following each condition. In this typical example of EDA activity, we observe that the EDA levels drop during the conditions, while the sleeve is active, and increase during the surveys, when the sleeve is inactive.

Figure 13

Figure 14.Graph showing the mean change (slope) of electrodermal activity levels (EDA-L) within each condition and within each subsequent survey per group. EDA levels decreased during the conditions but increased during the surveys. In the Slow and Regular groups, the amount of decrease during the conditions was typically greater than the amount of increase during the succeeding surveys. In the Fast group, the amount of decrease during the conditions was approximately equal to the amount of increase during the succeeding surveys. The combined results suggest a longer and more relaxing effect of the sleeve in the Slow and Regular groups as opposed to a faster acting and stronger impact of the sleeve in the Fast group, which possibly had an energizing impact in the short term.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Graph showing the mean relative percent change of breathing rate from baseline for each group using the mean values for each participant. The results are aligned with the study’s first hypothesis as they suggest a positive correlation between the wearer’s breathing rate and the pace of the sleeve’s haptic action. Participants in the Slow group exhibited on average 4.79% decrease in BR from baseline; Participants in the Regular group exhibited on average 2.08% decrease in BR from baseline; Participants in the Fast group exhibited on average 7.20% increase in BR from baseline.

Figure 15

Figure 16.Scatterplots showing the mean relative percent change of breathing rate from baseline for each individual participant in Slow (S), Regular (R), and Fast (F) groups. Values of each participant are represented with distinct colored dots. More participants show a decrease in breathing rate in the Slow group than in the Regular. Values of the Fast group are concentrated above zero. The values in the Regular groups are more spread out than in the other two groups. Although the trends are aligned with the study hypothesis, more studies would be needed to arrive at a more concentrated distribution of the data, leading to statistically significant results.