1. Introduction
Initiatives aimed at driving change towards sustainability involve identifying where to act to increase the chance of achieving significant impact (Moser, Reference Moser2016; Pascual et al., Reference Pascual, Balvanera and Christie2023; Schneider et al., Reference Schneider, Giger, Harari, Moser, Oberlack, Providoli, Schmid, Tribaldos and Zimmermann2019). As every initiative is unique and context-dependent, much must be learned about the various conditions and mechanisms that could contribute to increasing their potential. Diverse approaches have been developed to guide or support these deliberate processes. For instance, some suggest loci for action, such as the three spheres of transformation (O’Brien & Sygna, Reference O'Brien and Sygna2013), or hegemonic power structures (Temper et al., Reference Temper, Walter, Rodriguez, Kothari and Turhan2018). Others posit that profound changes can be catalysed by working on specific mechanisms such as building learning communities or creating strategic alliances (Moore et al., Reference Moore, Riddell and Vocisano2015; Tuckey et al., Reference Tuckey, Harmáčková, Peterson, Norström, Moore, Olsson, Lam and Jiménez-Aceituno2023). Some others assert the relevance of engaging with individuals’ values, paradigms, and identities (Hoogstra et al., Reference Hoogstra, Silvius, De Olde, Candel, Termeer, Van Ittersum and De Boer2024), as emphasized by the most comprehensive and recent Transformative Change Assessment developed by the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services, which aims for a system-wide change across views, practices, and structures (IPBES, Reference O'Brien, Garibaldi, Agrawal, Bennett, Biggs, Calderón Contreras, Carr, Frantzeskaki, Gosnell, Gurung, Lambertucci, Leventon, Liao, Reyes García, Shannon, Villasante, Wickson, Zinngrebe and Perianin2024). However, despite the differences between these approaches, all agree that transformations are collective and social processes. Thus, the transformative potential of an initiative will always depend, at least to some degree, on people working together; therefore, social dynamics’ nuances cannot be overlooked and must be carefully addressed.
Collective and group work among different communities of practice is central to transdisciplinary approaches as these focus on co-producing diverse forms of knowledge, shared objectives and strategies to achieve desired outcomes (Chambers et al., Reference Chambers, Wyborn and Ryan2021; Moser, Reference Moser2016). Therefore, most accounts insist on the importance of building meaningful connections among the members of such communities. The literature also sheds light on the need to carefully design spaces for enabling interactions that can form strong bonds and trusting relationships within a group (McClure, Reference McClure2024). The notion of transformative spaces, conceived as safe-enough spaces for deliberation on complex issues, is central in this matter (Pereira et al., Reference Pereira, Asrar, Hesse Fisher, Hsu, Nel, Sitas, Ward, Vervoort, Selomane, Trisos, Malone, Zhang, Bhargava, van der Ende and University2019), yet further examination is needed to better understand how different forms of designing these context-dependent spaces contribute to the emergence of a collective change agent (Charli-Joseph et al., Reference Charli-Joseph, Siqueiros-garcía, Eakin, Manuel-navarrete, Mazari-hiriart, Shelton, Pérez-belmont and Ruizpalacios2023).
In this article, we argue that transdisciplinary learning communities aimed at catalysing fundamental and lasting changes need to consciously implement strategies to foster the development of partnerships over a project or initiative, particularly in the initial co-design phase (McClure, Reference McClure2024). This means placing special attention on generating a shared space for nurturing the emergence of meaningful relations and cultivating transformative potential (West et al., Reference West, Haider, Hertz, Mancilla Garcia and Moore2024). We describe the initial co-design phase of a Social-ecological Innovation Laboratory aimed at fostering a transition towards sustainable livestock production in the Mexican region of Los Tuxtlas, Veracruz. As such, we frame this experience as a paradigmatic case study (sensu Flyvbjerg, Reference Flyvbjerg2006) of the creation of meaningful partnerships among participants, reflecting the common conditions and challenges of transdisciplinary projects. From this experience, we present the process through which the participants of the transdisciplinary partnership collectively framed the issues of interest as an actionable shared world by co-designing a network of changes necessary for catalysing the overall transition, and becoming agents within particular change strategies. Based on these findings, we discuss how certain conditions within a space for crafting a shared actionable world might influence the formation and nurturing of meaningful partnerships, and how these are essential for enhancing the transformative potential of transdisciplinary initiatives.
2. Collaborative spaces for enacting change
Enabling transformative change towards more sustainable and just futures entails the implementation of collective spaces that facilitate the articulation of orchestrated transdisciplinary efforts of social interactions needed to catalyse change (Charli-Joseph et al., Reference Charli-Joseph, Siqueiros-garcía, Eakin, Manuel-navarrete, Mazari-hiriart, Shelton, Pérez-belmont and Ruizpalacios2023; IPBES, Reference O'Brien, Garibaldi, Agrawal, Bennett, Biggs, Calderón Contreras, Carr, Frantzeskaki, Gosnell, Gurung, Lambertucci, Leventon, Liao, Reyes García, Shannon, Villasante, Wickson, Zinngrebe and Perianin2024; Pereira et al., Reference Pereira, Karpouzoglou, Frantzeskaki and Olsson2018). Some of these transdisciplinary efforts have been typified as transformative spaces (Pereira et al., Reference Pereira, Karpouzoglou, Frantzeskaki and Olsson2018). These processes are centred in the collective experimentation of diverse alternative strategies (e.g., practices or actions, or forms of organization) conceived by a group as holding greater potential to enable transformative change towards sustainability (Marshall et al., Reference Marshall, Dolley and Priya2018; Pereira et al., Reference Pereira, Frantzeskaki, Hebinck, Charli-Joseph, Drimie, Dye, Eakin, Galafassi, Karpouzoglou, Marshall, Moore, Olsson, Siqueiros-garcía, Van Zwanenberg and Vervoort2020). Transformative spaces might take diverse formats or forms. For instance, Transformation Laboratories, an approach adapted from Social Innovation Labs (Westley & Laban, Reference Westley and Laban2015), intentionally pursues the involvement of a diverse range of visions beyond those that typically dominate in conventional participatory spaces to engage in experiential and reflexive processes aimed at activating the agency needed to open-up transformative pathways that challenge the status quo inertia (Charli-Joseph et al., Reference Charli-Joseph, Siqueiros-garcía, Eakin, Manuel-navarrete, Mazari-hiriart, Shelton, Pérez-belmont and Ruizpalacios2023; Pereira et al., Reference Pereira, Olsson, Charli-Joseph, Zgambo, Oxley, Van Zwanenberg, Siqueiros-garcía, Ely and Ely2021).
A common aim of transdisciplinary partnerships is to foster social actors’ engagement throughout a collaborative process by co-designing and co-implementing projects based on community interests and needs (Loureiro et al., Reference Loureiro, Romero and Bilro2020). Moser (Reference Moser2016) highlights that collectively engaging in the initial co-designing phase of an initiative can build and strengthen the relationships between the diverse partners involved, yielding benefits such as enabling more transparency and accountability, while increasing the sense of collective responsibility and ownership when planning long-term sustainability outcomes (Hale & Mauzerall, Reference Hale and Mauzerall2004; Horan, Reference Horan2019; Martens, Reference Martens and Martens2007; Pattberg & Widerberg, Reference Pattberg and Widerberg2016). Moreover, effective partnerships within transdisciplinary learning communities depend on building enduring relationships and shared stewardship by nurturing trust, commitment, understanding, and empathy (Bieluch et al., Reference Bieluch, Bell, Teisl, Lindenfeld, Leahy and Silka2017; Merçon, Reference Merçon2021, Reference Merçon2022). Augenstein et al. (Reference Augenstein, Lam, Horcea-milcu, Bernert, Charli-Joseph, Cockburn, Kampfmann, Pereira and Sellberg2024) emphasize a people-centric approach, placing relationships at the core of research, fostering a culture of care, and recognizing shared responsibilities for transformative change. Thus, interpersonal relationships significantly influence how partnerships perform (Bieluch et al., Reference Bieluch, Bell, Teisl, Lindenfeld, Leahy and Silka2017). By nurturing collaborative environments to share and co-construct diverse forms of knowledge and understandings, partnerships have the potential to stimulate the emergence and articulation of innovative strategies to tackle complex sustainability challenges (Adams et al., Reference Adams, Jeanrenaud, Bessant, Denyer and Overy2016) and envision alternative pathways for transformative change (Charli-Joseph et al., Reference Charli-Joseph, Siqueiros-garcía, Eakin, Manuel-navarrete, Mazari-hiriart, Shelton, Pérez-belmont and Ruizpalacios2023; Nightingale et al., Reference Nightingale, Gonda and Eriksen2022).
However, many partnerships have been ineffective in catalysing change (Hale & Mauzerall, Reference Hale and Mauzerall2004; Martens, Reference Martens and Martens2007; Pattberg & Widerberg, Reference Pattberg and Widerberg2016). Challenges or hindering conditions for this include for instance the omission to address asymmetrical power relationships (Plummer et al., Reference Plummer, Blythe and Gurney2022), a lack of conflict resolution mechanisms, poor skills to both navigate persistent tensions (Caniglia et al., Reference Caniglia, Freeth, Lüderitz, Leventon, West, John, Peukert, Lang, von Wehrden, Martín-López, Fazey, Russo, von Wirth, Schlüter and Vogel2023) and facilitate group processes when sensitive topics and disrupting attitudes emerge, and insufficient understanding of the particular socio-cultural and political dynamics in which an initiative is embedded (Cabello, Reference Cabello2024).
Although there is an increasing understanding of the numerous challenges and mechanisms related to creating and maintaining transdisciplinary partnerships (Plummer et al., Reference Plummer, Blythe and Gurney2022; Stott & Murphy, Reference Stott and Murphy2020), there is still a need to further explore which enabling conditions might generate the types of partnerships needed for fostering transformations. In particular, we posit that it is paramount to further examine the design of spaces promoting care of interpersonal relationships aimed at enabling the emergence of collective action, and how it contributes to catalysing transformative change. This involves participants framing shared issues of interest in ways that recognize each other as legitimate partners for concerted action. Such mutual recognition is essential for building deeper relationships that form a collective that can act effectively as an agent. In this article, we reflect on the relevance of co-designing a ‘shared actionable world’ as a means to create meaningful partnerships centred on mutual acknowledgement (Plummer et al., Reference Plummer, Blythe and Gurney2022).
3. Transforming livestock production
Extensive livestock farming in tropical areas is characterized by grazing cattle in monocultures of exotic grasses across vast areas for extended periods, resulting in high rates of deforestation, an increase in local temperatures, soil fertility depletion, and the loss of biodiversity and local water sources, all with strong negative impacts on animal well-being (Alkemade et al., Reference Alkemade, Reid, Van den Berg, De Leeuw and Jeuken2013; Chará et al., Reference Chará, Rivera, Barahona, Murgueitio, Deblitz, Reyes, Mauricio, Molina, Flores, Zuluaga and Montagnini2017). Moreover, because costly external inputs (herbicides, pesticides, food supplies, etc.) are needed to sustain milk and meat production (Hernández-Medrano & Corona, Reference Hernández-Medrano and Corona2018), this model has culminated in inefficient and unsustainable systems and a disinterest in livestock farming among younger generations (Rivera-Huerta et al., Reference Rivera-Huerta, Rubio Lozano, Padilla-rivera and Güereca2019).
Although more sustainable, productive, and ecosystem-based alternatives for cattle ranching are available today, particularly in highly diverse tropical regions (Murgueitio et al., Reference Murgueitio, Chará, Barahona, Cuartas and Naranjo2014; Parra-Trujillo et al., Reference Parra-Trujillo, Pérez, Rey, Herrera González, Molina Ramírez, Ramírez Gaitán, Pulido Aranda, Hernández Trujillo, Nañez and Chamorro Viveros2018), transforming conventional cattle ranching towards more sustainable food systems also entails fundamental structural, political, economic, and socio-cultural changes towards more plural and just mechanisms to enable access of food for everyone (Baudish et al., Reference Baudish, Sahlin, Béné, Oosterveer, Prins and Pereira2024). This depends on the possibilities to challenge unjust and entrenched paradigms that underpin conventional cattle ranching and associated distribution market chains, and to enact alternative forms of sustainable livestock practices (Baudish et al., Reference Baudish, Sahlin, Béné, Oosterveer, Prins and Pereira2024). Common challenges include moving beyond the dominant and culturally embedded narrative surrounding conventional livestock practices, as well as overcoming the inertia produced by state paternalism and welfare dependency, whereby the adoption of new productive practices is contingent on the availability of government subsidies. In countries such as Mexico, livestock production has also been shaped by rising levels of insecurity linked to the presence of organized crime. This broader context has contributed to high historical rates of deforestation, particularly in the Los Tuxtlas region of Veracruz – one of the states with the largest cattle populations in Mexico, where approximately 60% of forest cover has been lost (Von Thaden et al., Reference Von Thaden, Laborde, Guevara and Venegas-barrera2018).
Thus, pathways towards more sustainable cattle ranching should not only focus on the means (i.e., practical innovation enhancing livestock productivity while preserving ecosystem functions), but also, and fundamentally, on the manners (sensu Bentz et al., Reference Bentz, O'Brien and Scoville-simonds2022) through which meaningful partnerships can emerge to co-design more transformative endeavours centred on recovering and nurturing relationships between the diverse forms that co-inhabit our planet.
4. Theoretical and methodological approach
Within the burgeoning literature on transformative spaces, co-design processes have been typified as processes occurring in safe-enough spaces, as political spaces that allow respectful critical dialogue and deliberation (Pereira et al., Reference Pereira, Frantzeskaki, Hebinck, Charli-Joseph, Drimie, Dye, Eakin, Galafassi, Karpouzoglou, Marshall, Moore, Olsson, Siqueiros-garcía, Van Zwanenberg and Vervoort2020, Reference Pereira, Karpouzoglou, Doshi and Frantzeskaki2015). Conceiving deliberate and dialogic processes of transformative change as fundamentally relational in nature (Drimie et al., Reference Drimie, Magner, Pereira, Charli-Joseph, Moore, Olsson, Siqueiros-garcia, Zgambo, Biggs, De Vos, Preiser, Clements, Maciejewski and Schlüter2021), we posit that processes of co-design within these spaces hold the potential to generate high-quality, meaningful relationships. As Moser (Reference Moser2016) illustrated, although co-design per se can be a fundamental enabler for transformative change across different aspects, it also has a significant role in transforming group dynamics and participants’ relationships. Particularly, dialogues that question pre-existing narratives and allow the reframing of issues first perceived as stagnant or impossible to address (Charli-Joseph et al., Reference Charli-Joseph, Siqueiros-garcía, Eakin, Manuel-navarrete, Mazari-hiriart, Shelton, Pérez-belmont and Ruizpalacios2023) can further nurture the significance of interpersonal encounters. In this section, we first introduce our conceptual framework and second, our methodological approach.
We conceive meaningful partnerships as alliances defined by high-quality interactions that cultivate collaborative praxis. These partnerships can foster collective identity and common practices that guide learning and actions, while also nurturing a sense of belonging through supporting relationships (Merçon, Reference Merçon2021). Inspired by the idea of public space and plurality, we posit that interactions are shaped by recognizing one another as equals, from the uniqueness and differences of all individuals, which is an essential condition of plurality (Arendt, Reference Arendt1998; Benhabib, Reference Benhabib, Arendt, Habermas and Calhoun1992, Reference Benhabib2003; Loidolt, Reference Loidolt, Szanto and Moran2016). Experiencing these forms of relating with others is not given. Thus, exploring different conditions within particular encounters and contexts that might enable meaningful interactions within transdisciplinary partnerships still entails further investigation. In our case, we approached this matter through interrelating the co-construction of a transformative space as a public space and the co-design of an actionable shared world within such space.
The concept of public space implies that participants can express themselves as they truly are (Arendt, Reference Arendt1998; Loidolt, Reference Loidolt, Szanto and Moran2016). Viewing transformative spaces through this lens enables participants to reveal themselves as genuinely as possible, where genuineness can be understood as a contextual creative potential. From a methodological lens this entails facilitating relational experiences (West et al., Reference West, Haider, Hertz, Mancilla Garcia and Moore2024) in which sharing (sometimes also questioning) diverse positionalities shaped by prejudices, entrenched visions and biases, and particular dynamics influenced by power asymmetries (Boonstra, Reference Boonstra2016), might contribute in opening-up to mutual understandings and thus, in creating more meaningful relationships between the individuals involved (Charli-Joseph et al., Reference Charli-Joseph, Siqueiros-garcía, Eakin, Manuel-navarrete, Mazari-hiriart, Shelton, Pérez-belmont and Ruizpalacios2023).
4.1. Group composition
The process of inviting participants to be part of the co-design effort prioritized diversity across three dimensions. First, we included a range of sectors with different degrees of influence or agency across the region of Los Tuxtlas. Second, participants had a variety of unique capabilities or attributes (independently of their work sector and formal role) instrumental for catalysing collective agency, such as different forms of knowledge, actionable social networks, empathy for others, openness to experiment with alternative approaches, sense of place attachment, and willingness to challenge the current status quo (Charli-Joseph et al., Reference Charli-Joseph, Siqueiros-garcia, Eakin, Manuel-navarrete and Shelton2018; Merçon, Reference Merçon2021; Westley et al., Reference Westley, Tjornbo, Schultz, Olsson, Folke, Crona and Bodin2013). Lastly, the diversity of prior relationships among participants, if any, was considered, including the type (professional, personal, or kin), and the perceived nature (i.e., positive or conflictive) of such relationships.
The overall group configuration, summarized by sector, was composed by: 1) 10 livestock producers, owners of their land and that had already implemented, or had the interest to implement, some innovative sustainable cattle ranching practices; 2) four members of four NGOs experienced in working with local communities through grassroots innovations to tackle diverse challenges within the region of Los Tuxtlas; 3) nine government officers: four from the local level, four from the state/regional level, and one from the federal or national level), mainly involved in efforts related to agricultural and livestock production, as well as in the conservation of biodiversity; and 4) seven academics from three education and research institutes, with different backgrounds (from biophysical to social sciences), and experience in working on particular topics relevant for the overall project aims, and/or in the region. Within each sector, most participants knew each other from previous independent interactions, but fewer knew each other across sectors.
4.2. The co-design process
Once the group was formed, the interactions for the co-design process entailed a series of participatory workshops (five online and one in-person) designed by three members of the academic group, experienced in facilitation techniques. Different activities were articulated for participants to engage in various dialogues to share understandings and framings of problems or situations around cattle ranching in the region, reflect on their role in potential solutions, and commit to experiment with practices that later could become pilot innovations. We first conducted five participatory online workshops, each composed of 7–10 participants from a particular sector, all aimed at co-defining which changes were perceived as necessary to enable the overall shared goal, and how these could be arranged in a temporal sequence or cause-effect network. For this reflection, we adapted components of the Theory of Change approach (Mayne, Reference Mayne2020), and used the Miro software to facilitate a backward planning process. The first step was to place the desired goal at one end, and then reflect, discuss, and delineate which immediate changes were perceived as required for achieving the ultimate goal. Subsequently, in sub-groups, participants from the same sector envisioned prior changes needed to occur to enable the previously elicited changes. This step was repeated until participants collectively decided that the network of changes was finished as the last elicited changes became clearer, more tangible, and specific. Finally, from the derived network of changes, participants were asked to select the changes in which they felt the group could have a particular influence, and to suggest 3–5 project objectives and associated activities, leveraging the diverse expertise and capacities within the group.
The five networks of changes resulting from all workshops were integrated into a network summarizing coincidences and eliciting unique features. Connectivity maps and an attribute table of the nodes of this network were created and comprised the sector suggesting each change, and the number of sectors that proposed it. The network of changes was then analysed using Cytoscape (Shannon et al., Reference Shannon, Markiel, Ozier, Baliga, Wang and Ramage2003) to obtain information about its structural properties (for more details, see the supplementary material at https://github.com/jmsiqueiros/Tuxtlas). To summarize and better visualize the envisioned changes, we condensed the network of changes into broader categories, grouping related changes associated with i) capacity building, ii) governance and public policies, iii) land management, iv) livestock practices, and v) economy, which further allowed the identification of what we named trajectories of change towards sustainable cattle ranching.
The next part of the co-design process entailed the creation of Avatars: symbolic visual representations of each participant with self-identified skills and capacities. The objective of this tool is to situate the self within particular aspects of the problem domain (i.e., in some of the co-designed changes) by self-identifying the core attributes or capacities (the avatar powers) that best describe each individual (e.g., to coordinate; to innovate; to connect people) (Charli-Joseph et al., Reference Charli-Joseph, Siqueiros-garcía, Eakin, Manuel-navarrete, Mazari-hiriart, Shelton, Pérez-belmont and Ruizpalacios2023; Ruizpalacios et al., Reference Ruizpalacios, Charli-Joseph, Eakin, Siqueiros-García, Manuel-Navarrete and Shelton2019). During the in-person participatory workshop, participants created their own avatar (e.g., a fantastic character) by drawing it on a sheet of paper, naming it, and listing its 5–6 main powers. Each person then presented his or her avatar to the rest of the group. The last step, one not previously planned by the facilitators but proposed in the moment, was to copy each avatar symbol onto 2–3 Post-its and place these on the particular changes in which each participant wanted to be involved. This allowed us to situate participants’ agency in specific activities within a given change, and to form working groups related to each task.
From the objectives and activities proposed in the different workshops, and the changes chosen by most participants, we identified as actionable and prioritized those that i) most sectors considered as essential, ii) ensured their achievability within a 3–5-years’ time frame, and iii) leveraged the diverse expertise within our transdisciplinary collective to execute the designed activities agreed as instrumental for fostering changes towards the shared goal. From this exercise, we co-defined next steps, objectives and activities to be developed by the partnership.
5. Insights of co-design
In this section, we describe the findings of the co-design process, organized in three subsections: i) Co-creating a desired world from a joint goal, by eliciting changes and articulating these into networks; ii) Envisioning collective efforts within the desired world, through co-defining objectives and activities to address the prioritized changes; and iii) Situating agency for an actionable shared world, by reflecting on the capacities and skills for enabling these changes, and eliciting particular strategies to engage in and ways to organize the overall endeavour.
5.1. Co-creating a desired world
During each workshop, participants collectively elicited those changes perceived as necessary to foster more sustainable local livestock production systems in the region of Los Tuxtlas. Afterwards participants also identified which changes would need to occur prior to those proposed initially, considered to have a direct influence. The integrated network of changes resulting from the five networks had a total of 45 changes related to the following aspects: a) capacity building (6 in total); b) governance and social networks (9); c) productivity and technical solutions (13); and d) environmental (9), or economic (8) aspects (for more details, see the table and figures in https://github.com/jmsiqueiros/Tuxtlas). After identifying the sequence and type of changes envisioned in this integrated network, we elicited three trajectories of change that included several envisioned changes (Figure 1).
Complementary trajectories of change towards more sustainable cattle ranching in Los Tuxtlas, Veracruz, resulted from the co-design process. Participants from different sectors proposed changes or actions along three dimensions: Strategies situated in the territory (T1); Alliance building and exchange of experiences (T2); Training programmes and public policy advocacy (T3). Text in black corresponds to changes associated with more than one trajectory.

1 Long description
Trajectories of change towards more sustainable cattle ranching in the region of Los Tuxtlas. Three labeled sections appear as three horizontal bands: T1 Strategies situated in the territory, T2 Alliances building and exchange of experiences and T3 Training programs and public policy advocacy. Multiple labeled items in each band are connected by lines that converge toward a cluster of items on the right. T1 Strategies situated in the territory: Definition of strategic areas for water security and forest connectivity. Development of participatory planning activities within ranches. Planting native trees for forage production and local water self-supply. Establishment of demonstrative ranches with sustainable cattle ranching practices. T2 Alliances building and exchange of experiences: Exchange and dissemination of experiences on sustainable cattle ranching practices. Articulation of local learning networks to promote sustainable cattle ranching. Production of hazards and reduction of unsustainable cattle ranching practices. Implementation of sustainable cattle ranching locally with strategic alliances. T3 Training programs and public policy advocacy: Training of social actors particularly technicians and ranchers on the implementation of sustainable livestock production systems. Implementation of public policies and government support for sustainable cattle ranching. Encouragement of interest in products and practices among the public. Implementation of mechanisms for co-responsibility among academia, government and cattle ranchers, including the organization of health and traceability programs. Establishment of criteria for safety and zoonosanitary control for health and traceability in the production chain. Right-side connected items: Reduction of expenses and increase of cattle rancher profit. Establishment of fair market for sustainable livestock products. Consolidation of commercial networks for sustainable livestock products with added value. No numbers or statistics are shown.
The first trajectory (T1 in Figure 1) involved changes in territorial strategies at different scales, from the definition of strategic zones for water security and biodiversity conservation to the particular redesign of productive activities within cattle ranches. Participants emphasized environmental priorities such as the recovery of springs and forest restoration to preserve local biodiversity in areas not suitable for cattle ranching. The avoidance of herbicides, the installation of water networks, planting trees around water sources, and diversifying forage species, including shrubs and trees, were also suggested. These actions, in turn, were coupled with technical or cattle management practices that were considered necessary to foster a transition towards sustainable cattle ranching.
The second trajectory (T2 in Figure 1) was related to the consolidation of alliances and knowledge sharing through the exchange of experiences of sustainable cattle ranching practices in groups and learning networks. The implementation of demonstrative ranches through mechanisms of participatory planning and the creation of handbooks and flyers were suggested as fundamental to motivating more people to adopt sustainable cattle ranching practices.
The third trajectory (T3 in Figure 1) focused on creating public policies to consolidate capacity-building programmes in sustainable cattle ranching, together with funding programmes to boost the adoption of this activity. All three trajectories converged into a set of economy-related conditions to increase the rentability of cattle ranching as a business, including the reduction of external inputs needed, the involvement of local livestock unions in advocacy and outreach efforts, and the creation of a cooperative and commercial network of sustainable cattle ranching products in local and regional markets. Last, to activate these markets, participants envisioned the need for promoting a wider interest in consuming products derived from sustainable cattle ranching, reflecting a framing of a broader societal shift towards a more integrated approach (environmentally and socially responsible) for cattle ranching practices.
Coincidentally, the formal analysis of the network structure revealed the distinction of two sub-networks: Sub-network A comprised nodes that point to subsequent changes associated with education and capacity building for sustainable cattle ranching, from which we identified the trajectory of change T2. Sub-network B focused on changes around the implementation of practical solutions and the emergence of markets for sustainable products, containing nodes included in both trajectories T1 and T2 and the coincidental changes at the end (see the supplementary material for more details: https://github.com/jmsiqueiros/Tuxtlas).
5.2. Envisioning collective efforts within the desired world
In each workshop, participants collectively defined particular changes to be addressed through actions to be undertaken by the transdisciplinary collective. From an overall total of 45 changes, participants selected a first subset of 15 changes, considered more relevant with regard to the collective’s potential incidence). Lastly, from this subset, four changes were identified (for their coincidence across most sectors, and through a multisectoral agreement) as those to focus the collective endeavour (circled changes in Figure 2).
Situating agency within trajectories towards sustainable cattle ranching. Once the needed changes had been defined, participants jointly selected those to be addressed by the partnership in the subsequent steps of the project (highlighted with circles), based on the range of capabilities within the group, the available funding, and project time constraints. Participants then placed their avatars on the changes they were most interested in enacting; red numbers indicate the number of avatars assigned to a given change.

Figure 2 Long description
The infographic outlines trajectories of change towards sustainable cattle ranching in Los Tuxtlas. It is structured into three main sections: strategies, actions and outcomes. 1. Strategies Situated in the Territory: - ′Definition of strategic areas for water security and forest connectivity.′ - ′Planting native tree species for local wood resources.′ - ′Establishment of demonstrative ranches with sustainable practices.′ 2. Alliance Building and Exchange of Experiences: - ′Articulation of local learning networks to promote sustainable practices.′ - ′Encouragement of interest in products among the wider population.′ - ′Production of bioinputs and sustainable practices.′ 3. Training Programs and Public Policy Advocacy: - ′Training of social facilitators for technical assistance.′ - ′Implementation of training programs and public policy advocacy.′ - ′Reduction of transaction costs in the agricultural value chain.′ - ′Establishment of a network of demonstrative ranches.′ Arrows indicate the flow between these sections, showing progression from strategies to outcomes. Red numbers represent the number of avatars assigned to each change, indicating participant interest. The highest count is at ′Establishment of demonstrative ranches,′ showing significant focus. Avatars symbolize participant engagement in each change. The layout follows a top-to-bottom and left-to-right reading order, enhancing screen reader compatibility.
Based on the four selected changes, the following general objectives of the project were collectively formulated: i) define strategic areas to foster the transition towards sustainable cattle ranching; ii) implement demonstration ranches with sustainable cattle ranching practices; iii) foster local networks for social learning and capacity building; and iv) promote the recognition of sustainable cattle ranching practices across diverse sectors. From the above-mentioned objectives, the laboratory was configured into three working transdisciplinary groups: The first group addressed the first objective and comprised academics, NGO´s members, local and State authorities, and communities’ members within the strategic areas. The second objective was developed by a group of innovative producers, academics, local veterinarians, and representatives of a local NGO. The last two objectives, in turn, were pursued by NGO´s members, academics and producers.
5.3. Situating agency for an actionable shared world
The process of further situating participants’ sense of agency within their co-designed world entailed moving from envisioning a shared world to configuring it as an actionable world. As described in the theoretical and methodological approach section, the Avatars tool allowed the participants to reflect on their individual core skills or powers, and then identify in which particular changes each person foresaw having an active role (regardless of the changes collectively chosen for setting the project objectives).
Out of 43 different powers identified during the activity, the most frequent ones, recognized by at least five participants, were: to inspire, to communicate, to build alliances, to innovate, to endure or persist, and to coordinate. Seven participants from four different sectors chose the wide implementation of sustainable practices across the region, and eight visualized their agency in the creation of demonstration ranches with sustainable practices. Noteworthy, six participants from all sectors envisioned their powers to foster local networks for learning and sharing sustainable cattle ranching practices, and nine participants, also from all sectors, were interested in training of social actors on the implementation of sustainable livestock production systems. For activities related to public policies and markets, it was not surprising that, except for one producer, none of the participants felt they could have any direct influence (marked in red in Figure 2 is the total number of avatars placed in a particular change).
6. Discussion and conclusion
As described throughout this article, the initial co-design phase of the Laboratory entailed: i) co-creating a desired world from a joint goal, by eliciting changes and articulating these into networks; ii) envisioning collective efforts within the desired world, through co-defining objectives and activities to address the prioritized changes; and iii) situating agency for an actionable shared world, by reflecting on the capacities and skills for enabling these changes, and eliciting particular strategies to engage in and ways to organize the overall endeavour. In this section, we discuss relevant findings to examine the conditions that contributed to enabling possibilities for a meaningful transdisciplinary partnership by: i) promoting horizontality among participants; ii) reframing participants’ sector-specific identities into genuine relational subjects from within a safe-enough space; and iii) visualizing collective agency through the institutionalization of a shared actionable world. We conclude by highlighting the importance of nurturing the quality of social interactions within transdisciplinary partnerships to increase the transformative potential of initiatives.
6.1. Promoting horizontality among participants
Given the importance of making visible and addressing asymmetric power relations in co-production endeavours (Blythe et al., Reference Blythe, Silver, Evans, Armitage, Bennett, Moore, Morrison and Brown2018; Boonstra, Reference Boonstra2016; Fritz & Binder, Reference Fritz and Binder2020; Plummer et al., Reference Plummer, Blythe and Gurney2022), the first workshops were held separating participants by their sector to move aside possible entrenched and normalized hierarchies that perpetuate power asymmetries within multi-sectoral dynamics. Moreover, recognizing the varying abilities to engage in online activities and discussions, we considered that participants – especially producers – would feel more keen to openly and actively contribute with peers from their own sector. Later in-person workshops, however, fostered multi-sectoral interactions in a more friendly environment, facilitating a space to connect and engage as a collective. This was fundamental because deliberately creating a space of suspension of the everyday world allowed participants to shape relationships from ‘scratch’. We acknowledge that some asymmetries were present within the group at the outset: whereas participatory co-production processes were unfamiliar to most producers and government officers, researchers and NGO members appeared visibly more at ease with the activities and dynamics involved. Yet, as the process unfolded, producers gradually seemed more comfortable and confident in their participation, narrowing these early gaps. Thus, throughout the transdisciplinary co-design process, we observed a growing sense of ownership over the project and of shared group identity, expressed in part through a sustained and palpable enthusiasm – factors that may positively influence participants’ engagement as a project progresses (Bieluch et al., Reference Bieluch, Bell, Teisl, Lindenfeld, Leahy and Silka2017; Charli-Joseph et al., Reference Charli-Joseph, Siqueiros-garcía, Eakin, Manuel-navarrete, Mazari-hiriart, Shelton, Pérez-belmont and Ruizpalacios2023; Schneider et al., Reference Schneider, Giger, Harari, Moser, Oberlack, Providoli, Schmid, Tribaldos and Zimmermann2019).
6.2. Reframing participants’ sector-specific identities to genuine relational subjects
The different sectors engaged in the transdisciplinary learning community brought together a diversity of perspectives and experiences, crucial to fostering the discovery of novel strategies and pathways towards sustainability. However, diversity per se does not guarantee plurality. We posit that approaching transformative spaces (Pereira et al., Reference Pereira, Frantzeskaki, Hebinck, Charli-Joseph, Drimie, Dye, Eakin, Galafassi, Karpouzoglou, Marshall, Moore, Olsson, Siqueiros-garcía, Van Zwanenberg and Vervoort2020, Reference Pereira, Karpouzoglou, Doshi and Frantzeskaki2015, Reference Pereira, Karpouzoglou, Frantzeskaki and Olsson2018) as safe-enough public spaces (Arendt, Reference Arendt1998; Benhabib, Reference Benhabib, Arendt, Habermas and Calhoun1992) that open possibilities for participants to set their sectoral persona aside can enable participants to share or express perspectives that go beyond the dominant narratives of their respective guilds. Therefore, the criteria for involving participants in the co-design processes were not limited to belonging to a sector. Furthermore, we confirmed the importance of identifying potential change agents by delving into personal attributes such as empathy towards different ways of knowing, being keen to experiment with alternative practices, motivating others to innovate, recognized by others as trustworthy and honest (Charli-Joseph et al., Reference Charli-Joseph, Siqueiros-garcia, Eakin, Manuel-navarrete and Shelton2018; Westley et al., Reference Westley, Tjornbo, Schultz, Olsson, Folke, Crona and Bodin2013).
The Avatars tool (Charli-Joseph et al., Reference Charli-Joseph, Siqueiros-garcía, Eakin, Manuel-navarrete, Mazari-hiriart, Shelton, Pérez-belmont and Ruizpalacios2023; Ruizpalacios et al., Reference Ruizpalacios, Charli-Joseph, Eakin, Siqueiros-García, Manuel-Navarrete and Shelton2019) was central to this reframing process as it contributed to separating the socially assigned role (e.g., a sector-specific position) from the personal attributes and skills unique to each individual – defined by oneself and acknowledged by others – which is essential to promote plurality. In this sense, these types of tools can play a fundamental role for enabling participants to bring out themselves to others as a ‘who’, as opposed to a ‘what’ (a farmer, an activist, an academic, etc.), and thus to mutually acknowledge particular skills, qualities and expertise, as a function of a situated and lived social arrangement (Mancilla et al., Reference Mancilla, Abunge, Bandeira, Cheupe, Combane, Daw, Drury, Hertz, Mubai, Muthiga, Sonetti and Shauri2024). Moreover, besides eliciting unique powers, discovering coinciding powers further contributes to connecting participants to consolidate the shared actionable world: a network of subjects able to act in a more coordinated manner by supporting each other through their own particular capacities. We found that choosing which particular changes or activities participants would engage based on their core capacities or powers was paramount to unveil a situated sense of agency.
6.3. Visualizing agency through the institutionalization of a shared actionable world
The dissociation of embodying a sectoral persona to becoming a genuine subject cannot occur in isolation, as it is a relational endeavour determined by the dynamic relations developed among the members of a collective (Braidotti, Reference Braidotti2011). In this sense, the reflection of genuine subjects on particular activities within the network of changes through their avatars allowed to situate participants’ agency on specific activities within the actionable shared world, and led to the formation of working groups according to the participants’ interests, skills and knowledge. The formation of action groups, in turn, was central to strengthening meaningful partnerships, as no one can reach the desired world alone. This further unveiled the tacit recognition of the mutual interdependence among participants and the need for a collective effort to enact the envisioned future. In this context, meaningful partnerships stand on the fact that they build power to act to shape our lives in a certain and desired way (Bedrof & Herrmann, Reference Bedrof, Herrmann, Bedrof and Herrmann2020). Thus, we insist that the power to act towards more sustainable futures can only be built through meaningful collectivities.
Because new forms of interaction forged from scratch only have value if they materialize, their institutionalization is necessary. By institutionalization we mean the manifest and material expression of a system of social relations organized around a collectively defined domain. In our case, the domain was the shared actionable world collectively built within the safe-enough space. Thus, once the shared desired world was co-defined, its institutionalization occurred when transformed into a shared actionable world, as working groups were organized to develop the co-designed objectives of the Transdisciplinary Social-ecological Innovation Laboratory. Moreover, this institutional character extended to other domains. For example, as part of the trajectories of articulated changes, participants underscored the significance of capacity building and education as a crucial initial phase, which entailed the establishment of demonstrative ranches exhibiting sustainable practices in cattle ranching, and the development of social learning spaces and networks. Overall, by focusing on organizational, capacity-building, and relational aspects, we believe that the co-designed trajectories of change have the potential to mobilize systemic change towards sustainable livestock productive systems.
This project was part of a public initiative aimed at addressing social-ecological issues of national significance for Mexico through creating transdisciplinary partnerships that engaged in co-production processes. In this regard, this was an exceptional opportunity for the exploration of the conditions to foster meaningful and lasting partnerships for transformative changes. Overall, bringing together a group of participants with diverse experiences, perspectives, interests, roles, and capacities was instrumental in envisioning novel and actionable strategies to foster sustainable cattle ranching in the region. Furthermore, initial alliances of actors who had previously collaborated, driven by common objectives related to sustainable cattle ranching, acted as seeds intended to germinate into broader and more complex transdisciplinary collectives. While the project has now ended, this article addresses only its initial co-design phase. Analysis of how the consolidation of meaningful partnerships shaped networking, learning, collective agency, and empowerment in the subsequent phases is reserved for forthcoming work.
In turn, larger learning communities with meaningful partnerships could have the potential to foster networking, empowerment, and learning, proposed as essential features to encourage social-ecological transformations (Merçon, Reference Merçon2022; Moore et al., Reference Moore, Riddell and Vocisano2015; Tuckey et al., Reference Tuckey, Harmáčková, Peterson, Norström, Moore, Olsson, Lam and Jiménez-Aceituno2023). However, this type of learning endeavour faces a challenge that relies on the manners and approaches to promote learning and capacity development to allow different ways of thinking to tackle complex social-ecological challenges (O’Brien et al., Reference O’Brien, J., A., A., M., I. and H.2013). In particular, the potential for active learning (and not just education) in the quest for building agency and capacity to enact transformative change towards more equitable and sustainable outcomes should be analysed and traced as a project develops (Lotz-Sisitka et al., Reference Lotz-sisitka, Mukute, Chikunda, Baloi and Pesanayi2017).
Identifying the potential of initiatives aimed at fostering transformative changes to sustainability remains a challenge and warrants further research (Beck & Forsyth, Reference Beck and Forsyth2020; Hoogstra et al., Reference Hoogstra, Silvius, De Olde, Candel, Termeer, Van Ittersum and De Boer2024; Pascual et al., Reference Pascual, Balvanera and Christie2023; Tuckey et al., Reference Tuckey, Harmáčková, Peterson, Norström, Moore, Olsson, Lam and Jiménez-Aceituno2023). An increasingly significant part of the literature focused on collaborative or co-production processes suggests that meaningful partnerships within transdisciplinary communities are essential to build this potential for transformative change (Plummer et al., Reference Plummer, Blythe and Gurney2022; Stott & Murphy, Reference Stott and Murphy2020). Thus, and not surprisingly, care, empathy and trust have been presented as factors playing a central role in promoting meaningful relationships driving change towards sustainability (McClure, Reference McClure2024; Merçon, Reference Merçon2022; Nightingale et al., Reference Nightingale, Gonda and Eriksen2022; Stott & Murphy, Reference Stott and Murphy2020), underscoring the essential role of social interactions in co-production processes (West et al., Reference West, Haider, Hertz, Mancilla Garcia and Moore2024). However, maintaining the quality of such relationships depends on how participants care about and nurture them. Future research might therefore examine outcomes across different experiences operating under similar conditions (e.g., institutional welfare dependence, insecurity, and environmental degradation), in order to identify the conditions, relationships, and processes needed to foster meaningful partnerships and to clarify the circumstances under which such partnerships are most likely to drive transformative change.
From our experience, we posit that transformative potential, which we conceive as the latent power of a collective to deliberately influence a social-ecological system or territory from within or as being part of it, can be triggered by co-designing an actionable shared world. Such world can be visualized as trajectories of change towards sustainability, enacted by agents that, based on their unique capacities for enabling change, are situated in particular strategies and roles. This process, however, should be grounded in orchestrating enabling conditions for fostering a mutual recognition of participants as both equal and unique individuals. Without this recognition, partnerships risk becoming hierarchical, with some participants dominating over others and with outcomes suitable only for a few. Furthermore, iterative spaces designed to facilitate more reflexive forms of critical dialogue and learning during the co-design phase of a project can allow the questioning of pre-existing knowledge systems and the reframing of issues perceived as stagnant, fostering more empathetic understandings and trust-building among participants. Thereby, when co-design processes are based on allocating enough time for creating a caring, respectful, and responsible foundational horizontality for finding meaning in interpersonal relationships, collaborative praxis can per se be transformative, and thus become an essential ingredient for transdisciplinary partnerships seeking transformative change. As a paradigmatic case study (Flyvbjerg, Reference Flyvbjerg2006), our work offers concrete, context-dependent insights into conditions common to transdisciplinary projects. Ultimately, it illustrates the broader relevance of a co-design phase focused on the quality of social interactions, pursued through three fundamental strategies: (i) promoting horizontality among participants, (ii) reframing participants’ sector-specific identities as genuine and relational subjects, and (iii) co-constructing and institutionalizing a shared, actionable world.
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to all participants in the collective ReGaSo (Red de Ganadería Sostenible) for their time, enthusiasm, trust, care, and perseverance along this shared journey. We also thank Patricia Pérez Belmont (Director of the NGO ‘Umbela Transformaciones Sostenibles A.C.’) for her facilitation during the in-person workshop.
Author contributions
K.B., L.C.-J., P.M.G.-M., J.M.S., and R.C.-C. conceived the central rationale and the design of the methodology. M.M.-B., P.M.G.-M., L.C.-J., and K.B. facilitated the participatory interactions and collected the information. M.M.-B., J.M.S., L.C.-J., and K.B. analysed the information. J.M.S. led the framing of the theoretical approach in close collaboration with L.C.-J. L.C.-J., K.B., and J.M.S. led the writing of the manuscript. L.C.-J. and K.B. contributed equally to this work and are thus acknowledged as co-first authors. L.C.-J. developed the figures. All authors contributed to critically discussing how the insights could contribute to deepening the understanding of the enabling conditions for transformative change, as well as to writing the manuscript and approving its publication.
Data availability statement
All data are available as supplementary material at: https://github.com/jmsiqueiros/Tuxtlas.
Ethics and approvals
Informed consent to participate in the various activities was obtained from all individuals – verbally during the online sessions and in writing for the in-person workshop.
Funding statement
Funding for this work was provided by the Secretaría de Ciencia, Tecnología, Humanidades e innovación (previously CONAHCyT: PRONACE 2019-05-308865 and PRONAII-319075).
Competing interests
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
