The first collected edition of Hobbes's correspondence was published in 1994.Footnote 1 In its preface, the editor asked the question, ‘How can an editor of an author's complete correspondence know that his edition is complete?’, and replied: ‘The short answer is that he cannot.’Footnote 2 Given that Hobbes lived to the age of ninety-one, and had a wide range of intellectual contacts in England and abroad, the tally of his surviving correspondence (roughly 211 items, depending on how a letter is defined) is surprisingly small; this encourages the belief that other letters must remain in the archives, as yet undiscovered. But since 1994 only one new item has been published: a letter sent to Hobbes in Paris by his old friend Robert Payne in 1649. That letter is a document of unusual importance, as it represents, in effect, an attempt to parry or soften the anti-episcopal arguments of Leviathan at a time when that book was in preparation.Footnote 3
Nothing else of comparable significance has yet come to light. The purpose of this article is to put forward a number of more modest discoveries, some of which amount only to small fragments or traces of letters which are known to have been preserved for a long time after Hobbes's death, but which are as yet unlocated. (With a figure of Hobbes's stature, nevertheless, even the smallest fragments may be of some value to future researchers.) First it presents the text of a complete letter to Hobbes, found by Dr Arnold Hunt in Lambeth Palace Library. Then it gives the details of three letters: two addressed to Hobbes and one by him. The present location of these letters is not known; the details of them were found by Mikko Tolonen when making a systematic study of entries in catalogues issued by nineteenth-century dealers and auction houses. Further, a few new examples are given of what were described in the preface to the 1994 edition as ‘non-letters’ (items referred to elsewhere, incorrectly, as letters to or from Hobbes); their listing here may, it is hoped, save future researchers some time and trouble. And, finally, details are given of additional manuscript versions of two letters which were printed in that edition.
I
The following item, a letter from Thomas Barlow to Hobbes of 30 August 1658, is in Lambeth Palace Library; it was given by Miss H. Barlow (through the Friends of Lambeth Palace Library) in 1975.Footnote 4 The earliest trace of this item in the sales catalogues is in the Sotheby's sale of 17 June 1842, where it was described as ‘Dr. Barlow, an eminent divine, to Thomas Hobbes, August 28th 1658’; the annotated copy of the auction catalogue notes that the letter was sold to ‘Pickering’ for 6s.Footnote 5 This was the bookseller and publisher William Pickering, whose collection of manuscripts, sold after his death in 1854, also included one of the manuscripts of Hobbes's Elements of law.Footnote 6 But William Pickering did not keep the Barlow letter for long: it next appeared in a catalogue issued by the dealer Thomas Rodd in 1845.Footnote 7 Presumably a member of the Barlow family bought it, out of familial piety, and it thus passed eventually to Miss H. Barlow, who gave it to Lambeth Palace.
Thomas Barlow to Hobbes, from Oxford
30 August [/9 September] 1658
Original, in Barlow's hand
Sr.
I receaued (by ye hands of your great seruant, and my freind Mr. Stubbe)Footnote 8 that excellent booke you sent me,Footnote 9 for which I returne my most harty thankes, and shall keepe it as a lastinge monument of your (euery way) vndeserued kindnesse. I must confesse (with that liberty and fredome which all ingenuous persons giue and take) that I cannot (at p[re]sent) giue my consent to all that you haue said, nor dare I suddenly censure or condemne, what soe eminent a p[er]son hath writt, and vpon seacond thoughts, and mature deliberation published. But for ye maine of your booke (especially the Optique part)Footnote 10 the ingenuity of the invention, and perspicuity of ye Demonstration is such, as will possibly haue envy from this age, and certainely honor from posterity – Extinctus amabitur &c.Footnote 11 Sure I am, ye great benefitt I haue gott by diuerse of your learned workes, and your many Ciuilities to me, are high obligations to loue and honor you, and if euer it by [sic] in my power to serue you, or any friend of yours, be assured of this, you may haue many more able, but none more willinge then –
(Sr.)
Your affectionate freind, and serut
Th. Barlow.
Q. Coll. Oxon
Aug. XXX. M.DC.LVIII.
[addressed:] For my most honored and worthy friend Mr. Thom: Hobbes
these
[endorsed by James Wheldon:]Footnote 12 Dr. Barlow Aug. 30th. 1658.
Thomas Barlow (1608/9–91) was a significant figure in Interregnum Oxford, where he served as Keeper of the Bodleian Library (from 1652) and Provost of the Queen's College (from 1658). He enjoyed not only a high reputation as a scholar, but also good relations with more than one part of the religious-political spectrum: scholastic in philosophy, Calvinist in theology, and a moderate Anglican in ecclesiology, he kept in contact with royalist Anglicans and was cherished by the Independents (above all, by his former pupil John Owen) as a useful ally in their campaign against presbyterianism. It was evidently with that campaign in mind that Henry Stubbe, the maverick Independent and Hobbesian who served as Barlow's deputy at the Bodleian, tried to create friendly relations between Hobbes and Barlow, and encouraged Hobbes to send a copy of the English version of his De corpore to Barlow in 1656. (That volume also included Hobbes's Six lessons to the professors of the mathematiques, with its stinging attack on the intellectual leader of the presbyterians in Oxford, John Wallis.) Barlow's long letter of thanks for that gift, while emphasizing that ‘I doe not concurre with your judgement in euery thinge’, did plainly state that ‘I concurre in what you say of ye Scotch Diuines’, and maintained a friendly and respectful tone throughout.Footnote 13
This new letter indicates that Stubbe was still making similar efforts two years later. But this time the gift – Hobbes's De homine, a treatise on optics and psychology – was less suitable for establishing an ideological connection; Barlow's letter, while still respectful, is shorter and more non-committal. The actual volume sent by Hobbes to Barlow survives in the library of the Queen's College, and the notes added to it by Barlow provide further evidence that may explain the cautious nature of this letter.Footnote 14 While the optical parts of the book receive no annotation whatsoever, there is a small flurry of underlinings and marginal notes in chapter 14, ‘De religione’. Against the first paragraph, where Hobbes defined religion as the external worship of God and also stated that faith and worship are the two parts of religion, Barlow underlined the definition and wrote in the margin: ‘If religion is external worship, how does it come about that faith is a part of it?’Footnote 15 Against the third paragraph Barlow noted, with evident disapproval, Hobbes's view that ‘faith is opinion’, and then summarized his argument that ‘in supernatural matters, no one should be believed unless he performs miracles’ – an argument with potentially devastating consequences for almost any form of modern ecclesiastical authority.Footnote 16 In the next paragraph, Barlow's anxious pen underlined parts of the sentences in which Hobbes argued first that ‘Religion, therefore, is not philosophy but rather, in every commonwealth, law – and therefore should be obeyed, not argued about’, and then that ‘The things that are argued about are only those things over which one person disagrees with another; which things, therefore, are not matters of faith in God.’Footnote 17 At the sixth paragraph, Barlow repeated in the margin Hobbes's argument that ‘the death of Christ was not a punishment for our sins’.Footnote 18 And finally, in the next paragraph, where Hobbes strongly objected to the Protestant claim that justice and other moral virtues are, considered purely in themselves, ‘shining sins’, Barlow underlined part of the sentence, ‘For indeed, if they were sins, the more someone exceeded other people in holiness, the less that person should be believed, on the grounds that he must be less just.’Footnote 19 Here Barlow may have suspected that Hobbes's arguments, hitherto damaging enough to traditional notions of faith, the church, and controversial theology, were now becoming tinged with sarcasm and ridicule; and the suspicion may not have been incorrect.
II
Auction catalogues and dealers' catalogues offer a rich – and surprisingly under-utilized – resource for intellectual historians and literary scholars. If the catalogues of sales of manuscripts and autograph letters of the major dealers (Sotheby's, Christies, Puttick and Simpson, Thomas Thorpe, Thomas Rodd) were digitized and combined in a searchable database, this would be of great assistance to many lines of inquiry, and would very probably yield a significant quantity of hitherto unknown items by philosophers and other writers. (To give just one example: a search among such catalogues for items of David Hume's correspondence has brought to light records of more than twenty letters that are not contained in the modern edition.)Footnote 20
The following three Hobbes items have been brought to light by such researches. In each case, the present location of the letter is unknown.
(i) Hobbes to William Cavendish, third earl of Devonshire, from Paris, [1/] 11 June 1641
This letter was sold by Sotheby's on 3 June 1895. Nothing is known of its contents; the lot description was merely as follows: ‘Hobbes (Thomas) Philosopher, A. L. s. [sc. Autograph Letter, signed] 1 p. 4to, Paris, June 11, 1641, to the Earl of Devonshire, portrait, rare’. It came from the collection of William and Thomas Bateman, and was sold to ‘Pearson’ for £19 5s.Footnote 21 William Bateman (1787–1835) was a Derbyshire antiquary who assembled a ‘fine library and museum’, and his son Thomas (1821–61) devoted much of his life to the history and archaeology of the region.Footnote 22 Presumably this letter was acquired by one or other of them for the sake of its local associations: the Cavendishes of Chatsworth were the leading family in Derbyshire, and Hobbes had written a poem about the Peak District.Footnote 23 ‘Pearson’ was John Pearson of Pearson and Co., an important dealer and collector, whose personal collection was sold at Sotheby's on 29 March 1922; but this item was not included there, and its fate is unknown.
Since this letter took up only one quarto page, it may have been little more than a dutiful letter of compliments to Hobbes's former employer. Another short letter from Hobbes to the earl survives (though only in a nineteenth-century facsimile – its present location is also unknown), dated 23 July/2 August 1641, so it would seem that Hobbes was writing fairly often to the earl at this time.Footnote 24 But that letter does include some comments on contemporary developments in England, and on the relationship between church and state; something of similar significance might well have been included in the missing letter of [1/] 11 June.
(ii) Theodor Mustert to Hobbes, from London, 10 [/20] September 1656
This letter was listed in no fewer than five catalogues issued by the dealer Thomas Thorpe between c. 1834 and 1843.Footnote 25 The signature was apparently hard to read: in the first catalogue the name was given as ‘Theodorus M. Stert’, while in the others it was ‘Theodore Mistert’. The first catalogue also reproduced the wording that followed the signature: ‘Phil. et. Med. Studiosi, Frisii Orientalis’ (‘one who studies philosophy and medicine, from East Friesland’), and described the letter as ‘Treating generally of the Cartesian Philosophy.’Footnote 26 The second and third catalogues quoted a sentence, presumably from the end of the letter: ‘Quaeso, si placet, responsum mittere ad Thomam Johnson Bibliopolam in Caemeterio Sti Pauli’ (‘I beg you, please, to send your answer to Thomas Johnson, bookseller, in St Paul's Churchyard’).Footnote 27 All catalogues described the letter as ‘autograph’ and in Latin; the second and third quoted the place and date verbatim, ‘Londini, 10 Septembris, 1656’.
The writer of this letter has not found his way into any standard reference works; but a few details can be established. An entry in the matriculation register of the University of Groningen for 4 March 1652 reads: ‘Theodorus Mustert, Emdanus, Phil.’.Footnote 28 This identifies him as both a student of philosophy – hence the special interest in ‘Cartesian Philosophy’, a matter much discussed at Groningen University – and an inhabitant of Emden (which matches the statement in the letter that he was from East Friesland).Footnote 29 The Musterts were a successful merchant family in Emden in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries: Peter or Pieter Mustert, who was probably Theodor's father, was a corn-trader with strong connections to the Netherlands; he was a controller of the city markets, a member of the council of the city between 1640 and his death in 1645, and, as nominated by the council in 1640, a member of the ‘collegium’ of administrators of the Estates of East Friesland.Footnote 30 It would appear that, having completed his degree at Groningen, Theodor went on the sort of travels that were commonly undertaken by graduates of Dutch and north German universities. (‘Phil. et Med. Studiosi’ could mean that he had also enrolled as a student of medicine, in which case the travels may perhaps have been an interlude between two degree courses.) While in London he sent a letter, probably at a venture, to Hobbes; his action here was not unlike that of the young French physician Pierre Guisony, who wrote to Hobbes while on a visit to England in 1659.Footnote 31 It is noteworthy that Hobbes did reply to Guisony (though that letter has not survived); possibly he replied also to Mustert, responding to his questions about the ‘Cartesian Philosophy’, in a letter which has yet to be discovered in a Dutch or north German archive.Footnote 32
(iii) William Cavendish, first earl and first marquess (later first duke) of Newcastle, to Hobbes, from Welbeck Abbey, Notts., 13 [/23] February 1661 [/1662]
This item was offered for sale by Thomas Thorpe in 1833. He described the letter, and gave extracts from it, as follows:
Letter, entirely autograph, ‘For my worthy Friend, Mr. Hobbs,’ dated Welbeck, the 13th of Feb. 1661, fine condition, with Seal, 18s.
Requesting Hobbes to superintend the having some cases or tuns made for the glasses that are to be sent up from Welbecke, ‘because ther Is Exselente worke-men att London, which by your directions will make them Exactlye Exselente. Sir Paule Neale Is a great predender [sic], so that hee may Informe you of the best worke-men.’ Hopes to see him in the summer at Welbeck; desires the bills may be given to ‘Powell, a seruante to my son Mansfield, whoe shall paye them.’Footnote 33
Apparently the letter failed to sell; four years later Thorpe advertised it again, listing it merely as ‘Newcastle (W. Cavendish, Earl of) Autograph letter to T. Hobbes, 15s. Welbeck, 1661’.Footnote 34 Its eventual fate is not known.
This letter is of interest for more than one reason. What happened to Hobbes's relationship with this William Cavendish in the latter part of their lives has long been one of the minor mysteries of Hobbes's biography. In the 1630s the earl of Newcastle and his brother, Sir Charles Cavendish, played an essential role in stimulating Hobbes's development as a philosopher – not merely as rich patrons, but as people whose active intellectual interests strongly coincided with his. Hobbes's relations with them were resumed in Paris in 1645–8, when Newcastle took an interest in both his work on optics and his combative views on ‘liberty and necessity’. Thereafter, however, although Hobbes kept up some connection with Sir Charles Cavendish (until the latter's death in 1654) and with Newcastle's wife (whom he thanked for the gift of one of her books in February 1662), evidence of direct contacts between Hobbes and Newcastle has been entirely lacking.Footnote 35 This letter, however, suggests that quite a cordial and familiar relationship continued between the two in the early Restoration period; so it seems that a misleading impression has been created merely by the fact that much of Newcastle's personal archive from that period has not survived. Since Hobbes's letter to Newcastle's wife, thanking her for her book, was dated 9 [/19] February, it looks as if this letter from Newcastle was prompted by the receipt of Hobbes's letter, or of an accompanying letter to Newcastle himself; this need not indicate a pattern of regular correspondence, but the greeting, ‘For my worthy friend’, and the remark about hoping to see Hobbes at Welbeck in the summer, do suggest that personal relations between them were still quite close.
A search for corroborative evidence among Newcastle's household papers has yielded the following item, which sheds more light on this episode. It is a letter from Humfrey Poole, the third earl of Devonshire's steward at Chatsworth, to his opposite number, Andrew Clayton, the marquess of Newcastle's steward at Welbeck, written just three days after the letter listed above.
Good Mr Clayton:
I haue lately recd a letter from Mr Hobbes; and according to his desire, I should now haue attended vpon my Lord Marquis of Newcastle, with certaine perspectiue glasses, to bee deliuered to him, But Sir; I am at present, (and haue been most of this winter,) so extreamly obstructed, in, and about my Splen; that I can scarse goe twenty yards on foot for want of winde, and therefore, as vnfitt, as vnable, to appeare now to his Lordship: But Mr Clayton, I haue now sent my sonne with those glasses and all their appurtenances, iust, and exactly, as they were left wth mee, desiring, that you will please, to lett my Lord Marquis know of his coming, and business; If I had been able now to haue come myselfe with these to Welbeck; I should, (as Mr Hobbes also wild mee) haue offerd my seruice, the best I can, about mounting the Longe Tubes, to make them vsefull; For, haueinge ofte obserued, That Mr Hobbes, when hee indeauor'd, to shew my Lord of Deuonshire, The Starrs, Saturne and Jupiter, or almost any other farr remote object, with these famous: & longe Tubd perspectiue glasses; hee was alwaies much cumberd & troubled in his attempts, but could neuer attaine to shew my Lord: or himselfe, any thinge, to any purpose, and that meerely, for want of fitting Tubes and frames, which I conceiue must of necessity bee had, before they can bee made vse of; I therefore (observing the defect) did thinke of making fitt Tubes, and frames, with a deuice, to raise and depress them, aptly to any object, And easily and steadily; to direct and fix them with speed; to any visible marke or starr: And I haue fitt materialls ready for such a purpose, and a workman near mee that can by my direccion, effect (no doubte) the thinges I ayme at, If my Lord Marq: shall please to accept of them …
yors affectionately to bee Commanded
Humfrey Poole
Hardwick 16 Febr. 1661
[addressed] These For My much respected friend. Mr Andrew Clayton at WelbeckFootnote 36
This letter indicates that at least some of the telescope-lenses which Newcastle intended to send to London were lenses which had been under Hobbes's care at Chatsworth. And this in turn makes it possible, via a paper-chain of evidence, to identify the telescopes as ones that had originally belonged to Newcastle himself. While he and his brother were in Paris in the 1640s, they assembled a collection of seven telescopes by the finest manufacturers in Europe: one by Francesco Fontana, two by Evangelista Torricelli, and four by Eustachio Divini. Some of these were very large. ‘Toricellus his greate Glass’ was nearly sixteen feet long, Fontana's was eighteen feet long, and the largest by Divini was described as follows: ‘Eustatio Divino, his Greate Glass, for the great Tube, being marked with 37 Palmes and a halfe, is to draw 28 Foote, and 8 Inches, besides foure Inches for the convex Glass, at the Eye.’Footnote 37 When Newcastle left Paris in July 1648 he put the collection in Hobbes's hands, while also borrowing 100 pistoles (roughly £92) from him; it was later agreed that Hobbes should keep the telescopes in lieu of repayment of the loan.Footnote 38 Somehow Hobbes managed to get these telescopes back to England; most likely it was during this move, for ease of transportation, that the tubes and cases of the largest ones were discarded. When the move occurred is not clear, but it was probably by May 1658, when a Chatsworth account-book recorded payment to a locksmith for work on ‘one of the doores of those presses [sc. ‘the Presses in the Library’] to put perspectiue glasses in'. The same account-book listed several items of expenditure in February 1659 as follows: to a locksmith ‘for hookes & pins to draw the Tube frame within ye Library’; ‘For 12. square hoopes & 12 spikes for Mr Hobbes his devise there’; and ‘for the new Tube in the Gyant Chamber to tye Mr Hobbes his perspectiue glasses’.Footnote 39 A document dated 13 [/23] April 1659 recorded that the ‘Prospectiue Glasses’ had now been bought from Hobbes; it listed the seven items by Fontana, Torricelli, and Divini, and added: ‘Memorandum there are Tubes onely for ye 4. last mentioned glasses.’Footnote 40 The purchaser, as another account-book shows, was the earl of Devonshire.Footnote 41 And Humfrey Poole's letter to Andrew Clayton suggests, in turn, the reason why the earl may have been willing, a few years later, to give or sell the collection back to its original owner. (That there is a comic element to Poole's account of Hobbes's astronomical efforts is undeniable; but it should not be forgotten that Hobbes was, by this time, seventy-three years old, and had suffered from ‘the shaking palsy’ – probably Parkinson's disease – for many years.)
Given the timing of Newcastle's letter to Hobbes and Poole's letter to Clayton, it may be surmised that Hobbes had written at more or less the same time to Poole, instructing him to send the telescopes to Welbeck, and to Newcastle, informing him of their imminent arrival, and commenting on the fact that some of them lacked tubes or cases. Newcastle's concern for having ‘some cases or tuns [tubes?] made’ was probably prompted, therefore, by Hobbes's own comments. By the time Newcastle received the lenses from Poole's son, he would also have known of Poole's offer to supply the cases himself. Whether that offer was accepted is not known; but if Newcastle persisted with his original plan to send these items to London, his letter suggests that Hobbes may, as a result, have been introduced to Sir Paul Neile, who was not only an acknowledged expert on telescopes, but also one of the central figures in the early Royal Society.Footnote 42
III
A few items have come to light that have been described, incorrectly, as letters to or from Hobbes. They are presented here in chronological order.
(i) An unknown person to Hobbes, 1 September 1623 (about the defeat of ‘Alberstat’, and with a reference to Polyphemus).
(ii) An unknown person to Hobbes, 27 October 1623 (about the new pope).
(iii) Hobbes to Sir Gervase Clifton, dated 1630 (about Bassompierre).
These three items are listed in the catalogue of the papers of E. G. Jacoby which are now in the library of the Victoria University of Wellington.Footnote 43 However, the first two can be identified as letters from Fulgenzio Micanzio to William Cavendish, the future second earl of Devonshire (letters which survive in translations by Hobbes, but of which he was not the author), and the third is a letter to Sir Gervase Clifton not from Hobbes, but from Clifton's son (also Gervase), whom Hobbes was accompanying on his Grand Tour at the time.Footnote 44
(iv) Hobbes to William Cavendish, first earl (later first marquess, later first duke) of Newcastle, 9 May 1640.
A manuscript of such an item, described as a signed autograph letter, was listed in the catalogue of the R. B. Adam collection in 1929.Footnote 45 It was subsequently reported (in Kristeller's Iter Italicum) to be in the private collection of Mary Hyde, Viscountess Eccles; and it is now in the Houghton Library, Harvard (MS Hyde 10 (337)), where it forms part of the large Hyde bequest.Footnote 46 As Hobbes scholars will recognize from its date, however, this text is the dedicatory epistle of Hobbes's manuscript treatise, The elements of law. This manuscript is neither in Hobbes's hand nor signed by him. It is in a scribal hand, identical to that of one of the copies of the treatise now in Chatsworth (MS Hobbes A 2 A); indeed, it must have come from that manuscript, which lacks the dedicatory epistle.Footnote 47 Probably this ‘letter’ was detached by an autograph collector at some time in the nineteenth century, when the manuscript was passing through the market.
(v) Sir William Davenant to Hobbes, from Cowes Castle, Isle of Wight, 1650.
In the mid-eighteenth century Theophilus Cibber described, in his account of Davenant's life, the poet's capture at sea by parliamentary forces in May 1650, and his subsequent imprisonment in Cowes Castle. He added:
Upon this occasion, it is reported of Davenant, that he wrote a letter to Hobbes, in which he gives some account of the progress he made in the third book of Gondibert, and offers some criticisms upon the nature of that kind of poetry, but why, says he, should I trouble you or myself, with these thoughts, when I am pretty certain I shall be hanged next week.Footnote 48
This very probably arises from a confused reminiscence of the ‘Postscript to the Reader’ printed at the end of the first edition of Gondibert, which is dated ‘Cowes Castle in the Isle of Wight, October 22. 1650’. It begins with the statement, ‘I Am here arriv'd at the middle of the Third Book, which makes an equal half of the Poem’, but then explains that ‘I am threatned with Death’, and comments: ‘even in so worthy a Designe I shall ask leave to desist, when I am interrupted by so great an experiment as Dying’.Footnote 49 The rest of the postscript, nevertheless, is taken up with more general comments on heroic poetry, and on the motives for writing it. It thus corresponds to all the features of the ‘letter’ described by Cibber. While this postscript is not addressed to Hobbes, the ‘Preface’ to the same volume is; hence, presumably, the confusion.Footnote 50
(vi) and (vii) Hobbes to John Aubrey, 15 October 1675, and John Aubrey to Hobbes, 23 October 1675.
These items are contained in a volume of the papers of the nineteenth-century antiquary Canon John E. Jackson, now in the collection of the Society of Antiquaries of London; both are copies in a nineteenth-century hand (not Jackson's own).Footnote 51 That the letters are crude forgeries is most easily demonstrated simply by printing the text of the first of them, which is as follows:
To my verie worthie ffriend and Neighbour the Worshipfull John Aubrey Esquier
Sr,
I take the libbertie to inform your honour that being att ye age of ffour score yeares I have had my Effigies painted by an eminent Limner in this place soe that when all mie workes are perhaps fforgotten even mie Lleviathan which is now thought to bee my most ffamous worke Posteritie may know somewhat of mie personall appearance att my present age – I trust that itt may chance to fall intoe the handes of some eminent Antiquarie in ffuture times and soe bee the meanes of mie being remembered by those whoe maye succeed us in those darke and evil daies – With my humble duetie I rest worthie Sir
your most sincere and constant ffriend to serve you att all commands
Tho: Hobbes
From my House att Malmesburie this 15.th Oct. Annoq: 1675
[addressed:] To mie worthie and singular good ffriende the Worshipfull John Aubrey Esquier att his House att Easton Piers nigh to Keynton St. Michaels Wiltes.
These p[re]sentFootnote 52
In reply, Aubrey comments that ‘I have also bidden Loggan ye Graver to make a likeness of mie unworthie self: that thus I alsoe may be remembered by my workes and writings. Liber A. and Liber B. and my countenance to be handed down to future ages in ye Ashmolean Museum where I shall deposit my writings.’
The orthography is characteristic of neither writer, and the anachronisms are glaringly obvious: Hobbes did not live in Malmesbury in 1675, and indeed had not lived there since 1608 at the latest; his eightieth birthday was in 1668; Aubrey no longer lived at Easton Piers (his ancestral home), having sold it in 1671; and in 1675 there was no ‘Ashmolean Museum’.Footnote 53 So crude are these forgeries, indeed, that it must be doubted whether they were intended to deceive anyone; they seem more like something hastily concocted as a jeu d'esprit, perhaps to accompany a portrait of Hobbes as it fell ‘intoe the handes of some eminent Antiquarie’.Footnote 54
(viii) Sir William Petty to Hobbes (undated).
This item has been described by the Royal Commission on Historical Manuscripts as follows: ‘n.d. No title. Latin letter to Thomas Hobbes on his theory of monarchy. 6 pp.’Footnote 55 But it refers to Hobbes throughout in the third person; nor does it have the form of a letter, bearing neither salutation, nor valediction, nor address.Footnote 56
IV
Finally, in the case of two letters which were printed in the Clarendon edition, some details of other manuscript versions of those letters (not mentioned there) can now be added. The letter from Adrian May to Hobbes (dated tentatively to 1647), containing a disquisition on the nature of sensation, exists also in a transcript in the papers of Thomas Smith in the Bodleian Library.Footnote 57 And the letter from Samuel Sorbière to Hobbes of [22 January/] 1 February 1658, containing the rules of the de Montmor ‘academy’, exists in an English translation by John Evelyn. This translation was made not from the original letter (in French) received by Hobbes, but from the Latin translation which Sorbière himself published in 1660: it is headed, ‘A Lettre of Monsieur De Sorbiere to Mr: Hobbs, being the Lxxix of his discourses printed at Paris 1660.’ It is also endorsed, by Evelyn, ‘Translated by Command of our Society: 1661 & read to them.’Footnote 58
