Published online by Cambridge University Press: 09 May 2014
The body of knowledge that constituted British imperial writing, and the expression that interacted with it were attempts to engage European readership on the imperial adventure in Africa in the age of the new imperialism. This study is an attempt to address the complex issues involved in the production of historical knowledge about precolonial Benin to justify British colonial rule. The argument advanced in this paper is that, since imperial discourse set out to deal with history in terms of civilization, British imperial writing was a struggle to articulate certain ideas about Benin into a position of dominance before the British public. As Mary Louise Pratt explains, “depicting the civilizing mission as an aesthetic project is a strategy the west has often used for defining others as available for and in need of its benign and beautifying intervention.” British imperial discourse will form the basis of the discussion in this paper.
Imperial discourse and its subjectivity raises questions about issues of power and privilege of those writers who were determined to sustain their voices in the debate on European imperialism in Africa. Their approach to the constitution of knowledge about Benin was one of many ways that opened the frontiers of knowledge about African states and societies to redefine civilization, albeit for the purposes of understanding various meanings and implications in this intellectual assault. This provides a vital entry point for examining the European colonial approach to the construction of the image of Africa. The aim is to demonstrate how this process suggests a connection from imperial expansionism to forms of knowledge and expression that reaffirmed metropolitan authority in the context of colonial subjugation.
1 Pratt, Mary Louise, Imperial Eyes: Travel Writing and Transculturation (London, 1992), 205.
2 Goetz, Philip W., ed., “The Study of History,” The New Encyclopaedia Britannica (15th ed.: Chicago, 1986), 20:621.
3 See Osadolor, Osarhieme Benson, “Contested History in Colonial Hstoriography” in Oyetade, Adebayo, ed., The Foundations of Nigeria (Trenton NJ, 2003), 61.
4 For details see Ryder, A. F. C., Benin and the Europeans, 1485-1897 (London, 1969).
5 See, for example, Jones, Adam, Brandenburg Sources for West African History, 1680-1700 (Stuttgart, 1985); idem., German Sources for West African History, 1599-1669 (Wiesbaden, 1983); Matthews, Noel, Materials for West African History in the Archives of the United Kingdom (London, 1973); and Ryder, A. F. C., Materials for West African History in Portuguese Archives (London, 1965).
6 João de Barros, Da Asia, First Decade, book iii, ch. 3, quoted in Crone, G. R., The Voyages of Cadamosto and Other Documents (London, 1937), 124–47.
7 de Pina, Ruy, Chronica del Rey Dom João II, ch. 24, translated in Blake, J. W., ed., Europeans in West Africa (London, 1942), 178–79.
8 Ibid.
9 This is attested by the letter from Duarte Pires, the Portuguese representative in Benin, to Manuel I, dd 20 October 1516. For the translated letter see Hodgkin, Thomas, Nigerian Perspectives: an Historical Anthology (London, 1960), 99–100.
10 Cited in ibid., 99.
11 Ibid., 100-01
12 Adams, John, Remarks on the Country extending from Cape Palmas to the River Congo (London, 1823), 114.
13 Quoted in Jones, , German Sources, 43.
14 See Osadolor, , “Contested History,” 57–77. See also Wolf, Eric, Europe and the People without History (Berkeley, 1982), passim.
15 Pratt, , Imperial Eyes, 205.
16 Nevins, H. N. and Aveling, H. G., “Intelligence Report on the Benin Division of the Benin Province.” (1936), 13: National Archives Ibadan (NAI) Ben Prof. 4/3/4.
17 For the debate see Samuel, Raphael, ed., People's History and Socialist Theory (London, 1981).
18 Home, Robert, City of Blood Revisited: a New Look at the Benin Expedition of 1897 (London, 1982), 7.
19 Both works (London, 1897).
20 Bacon, , Benin, 1.
21 The newspapers in London published the accounts of Ralph Frederick Locke.
22 Home, , City of Blood Revisited, 99
23 (London, 1899)
24 Ibid., 88.
25 See particularly Talbot, P. A., The Peoples of Southern Nigeria (2 vols.: London, 1926).
26 (Halifax, 1903).
27 This view only began to attract scholarly interest with the investigations of Flora Kaplan and Paula Girshick Ben-Amos, whose studies have enhanced our knowledge of the art, history, and politics in Benin.
28 Hegel, G. W. F., The Philosophy of History (New York, 1956), 99.
29 Mockler-Ferryman, A. F., British Nigeria: a Geographical and Historical Description of the British Possessions Adjacent to the Niger River, West Africa (London, 1902), 2.
30 Perham, Margery, Native Administration in Nigeria (London, 1937), 1
31 Pratt, , Imperial Eyes, 219.
32 Forde, C. Daryll, “Foreword” in Bradbury, R. E., Benin Studies (London, 1973), xi.
33 Ibid., x.
34 Bradbury, R. E., “The Social Structure of Benin, with Special Reference to the Politico-Ritual Organisation (the Village Community)” (PhD., University of London, 1956).
35 (London, 1957).
36 For a listing of these see Bradbury, , Benin Studies, 287–88.
37 Peter Morton-Williams, “Introduction” in ibid., xiii.
38 Ibid., xvi.
39 Ibid., xx.
40 Ibid., xxi.
41 See Dike, K. O., “The Benin Scheme,” Ibadan 1(1957), 2–5.
42 Dark, P. J. C., An Introduction to Benin Art and Technology (Oxford, 1973).
43 See, e.g., Ben-Amos, Paula Girshick, Art, Innovation, and Politics in Eighteenth Century Benin (Bloomington, 1999); Blackmun, B. W., Icons and Emblems in Ivory: Sacred Art from the Palace of Old Benin (Chicago, 1997); Ezra, Kate, Royal Art of Benin: the Perls Collection in the Metropolitan Museum of Art (New York, 1992); Freyer, Bryna, Benin Royal Art in the Collection of the National Museum of African Art (Washington, 1987); Ben-Amos, Paula Girschick and Rubin, A., eds., The Art of Power, the Power of Art (Los Angeles, 1983); and Kaplan, Flora, Images of Power: Art of the Royal Court of Benin (New York, 1981).
44 Ryder, , Benin and the Europeans, ix.
45 Ibid., ix.
46 Ibid., x.
47 Ryder, Materials, “Benin State and Region: History” in Encyclopaedia of Africa South of the Sahara (New York, 1997) 1: 179–81; “The Benin Kingdom” in Ikime, Obaro, ed., Groundwork of Nigerian History (Ibadan, 1980); 109–20; “The Rise of the Benin Kingdom” in Oliver, Roland, ed., The Middle Age of African History (Oxford, 1967), 27–33; “The Dutch Trade on the Nigerian Coast during the Seventeenth Century,” Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria 3(1966), 195–210; “A Reconsideration of Ife-Benin Relationship,” JAH 6(1965), 25–37; “A Note on the Afro-Portuguese Ivories,” JAH 5(1964), 363–65; “The Benin Missions,” Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria 2(1961), 231–59; and “An Early Portuguese Trading Voyage to the Forcados River,” Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria 1(1959), 294–321.
48 Igbafe, Philip, Nemesis of Power: Agho Obaseki and Benin Politics, 1897-1956 (Lagos, 1991); Benin under British Colonial Administration: the Impact of Colonial Rule on an African Kingdom 1897-1938 (London, 1979); Obaseki of Benin (Ibadan, 1972); “The Pre-Colonial Economic Foundations of the Benin Kingdom” in Akinjogbin, I. A. and Osoba, S., eds., Topics on Nigerian Economic and Social History (Ile-Ife, 1980), 19–34; “Benin in the Pre-Colonial Era,” Tarikh 5(1974), 1–16; “The Fall of Benin: a Reassessment,” JAH 11(1970), 385–400; “British Rule in Benin, 1897-1920: Direct or Indirect Rule?” Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria 4(1967), 701–17; “The Head District System in Benin, 1914-1935,” Odu 3(1967), 3–21.
49 Osadolor, Osarhieme Benson, “The Military System of Benin Kingdom 1440-1897” (PhD., University of Hamburg, 2001).
50 Edo, Victor Osaro, “The Benin Monarchy, 1897-1978: a Study in Institutional Adaptation to Change” (PhD., University of Ibadan, 2002); Usuanlele, Uyilawa, “Colonialism and the Environment: the Deforestation of the Rainforest of Benin and Ishan Divisions, 1897-1960” (Ph.D., University of Ibadan, 2003).
51 For details see Osadolor, Osarhieme Benson, “Intricacies of a Great Past: a Survey of the Non-Academic Historiography of Benin” in Harneit-Sievers, Axel, ed., A Place in the World: New Local Historiographies from Africa and South-Asia (Leiden, 2002), 111–34.