Published online by Cambridge University Press: 09 May 2014
On 18 March 1898 Okolu, an Ijesa man, accused Otunba of Italemo ward, Ondo of seizing and enslaving his sister Osun and his niece. Both mother and daughter, enslaved by the Ikale in 1894, had fled from their master in 1895, but as they headed toward Ilesa, the accused seized them. Osun claimed the accused forced her to become his wife, “hoe a farm,” and marked her daughter's face with one deep, bold line on each cheek. Otunba denied the slavery charge, claiming he only “rescued [Osun] from Soba who was taking her away [and] took her for wife.” Itoyimaki, a defense witness, supported the claim that Osun was not Otunba's slave. In his decision, Albert Erharhdt, the presiding British Commissioner, freed the captives and ordered the accused to pay a fine of two pounds. In addition to integrating Osun through marriage, the mark conferred on her daughter a standard feature of Ondo identity. Although this case came up late in the nineteenth century, it represents a trend in precolonial Yorubaland whereby marriages and esthetics served the purpose of ethnic incorporation.
Studies on the roots of African ethnic identity consciousness have concentrated mostly on the activities of outsiders, usually Euro-American Christian missions, repatriated ex-slaves, and Muslims, whose ideas of nations as geocultural entities were applied to various African groups during the era of the slave trade and, more intensely, under colonialism. For instance, prior to the late nineteenth century, the people now called Yoruba were divided into multiple opposing ethnicities. Ethnic wars displaced millions of people, including about a million Yoruba-speakers deported as slaves to the Americas, Sierra Leone, and the central Sudan, mostly between the sixteenth and nineteenth centuries.
1 Albert Erhardt, journal, 18 and 22 March 1898, Ondo Div. 8/1, Nigeria National Archives, Ibadan (NAI).
2 See Mann, Kristin and Bay, Edna, eds., Rethinking the African Diaspora: the Making of a Black Atlantic World in the Bight of Benin and Brazil (London, 2001); Heywood, Linda, ed., Central Africans and Cultural Transformations in the American Diaspora (Cambridge, 2001); Falola, Toyin and Childs, Matt D., eds., The Yoruba Diaspora in the Atlantic World (Bloomington, 2004); Baba'a, Ahmad, Mi'raj al-Su'ud: Replies on Slavery, annotated and translated by Hunwick, John and Karrak, Fatima (Rabat, 2000); Vail, Leroy, ed., The Creation of Tribalism in Southern Africa (Berkeley, 1989); Spear, Thomas and Waller, Richard, eds., Being Maasai: Ethnicity and Identity in East Africa (Oxford, 1993); Ambler, Charles, Kenyan Communities in the Age of Imperialism: the Central Region in the Late Nineteenth Century (New Haven, 1988); and Bravman, Bill, Making Ethnic Ways: Communities and Their Transformations in Taita, Kenya, 1800-1950 (Portsmouth, NH., 1998).
3 See Koelle, S. W., Polyglotta Africana, or a Comparative Vocabulary of Nearly Three Hundred Words and Phrases (London, 1854), 6; Peel, John D. Y., “The Cultural Work of Yoruba Ethnogenesis” in Tonkin, Elizabeth, McDonald, Maryon, and Chapman, Malcolm, eds., History and Ethnicity (London, 1989), 198–215; Law, Robin, “Ethnicity and the Slave Trade: “Lucumi” and “Nago” as Ethnonyms in West Africa,” HA 24(1997), 205–19; and idem., “Yoruba Liberated Slaves Who Returned to West Africa” in Yoruba Diaspora, 349-65.
4 Peel, J.D.Y., Religious Encounter and the Making of the Yoruba (Bloomington, 2000).
5 For a related thesis see Northrup, David, “Becoming African: Identity Formation among Liberated Slaves in Nineteenth-Century Sierra Leone,” Slavery and Abolition 27(2006), 1–21.
6 See Roper, Edward, “What I Saw in Africa: Sketches of Missionary Life in the Yoruba Country, Part II,” Church Missionary Gleaner 3(1876), 35–38; British Parliamentary Papers (hereafter PP) C5144, encl. 1 in no. 8, Samuel Rowe to Derby, 18 May 1888; Johnson, Samuel, The History of the Yorubas from the Earliest to the Beginning of the British Protectorate (Lagos, 1921 [1976]), 178–283; Biobaku, Saburi, The Egba and Their Neighbours, 1842-1872 (London, 1957); Awe, Bolanle, “The Rise of Ibadan as a Yoruba Power 1851-1893”, DPhil, Oxford University, 1964; Ajayi, J. F. Ade and Smith, Robert, Yoruba Warfare in the Nineteenth Century (London, 1964); Morton-Williams, Peter, “The Oyo Yoruba and the Atlantic Slave Trade, 1670-1830,” Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria 3(1964), 24–45; Hopkins, Anthony G., “Economic Imperialism in West Africa: Lagos, 1880-1892,” Economic History Review 21(1968), 580–606; Akintoye, Stephen A., Revolution and Power Politics in Yorubaland, 1840-1893: Ibadan Expansion and the Rise of Ekitiparapo (London, 1971); Oroge, Emmanuel A., “The Institution of Slavery in Yorubaland with Particular Reference to the Nineteenth Century” (PhD., Birmingham, 1971); Law, Robin, The Oyo Empire c.1600—c. 1836: a West African Imperialism in the Era of the Atlantic Slave Trade (Oxford, 1977), 245–302; Shields, Francine, “Palm Oil and Power: Women in an Era of Economic and Social Transition in Nineteenth Century Yorubaland (South-Western Nigeria.” (PhD., Stirling, 1997); Akinjogbin, Idowu A., ed., War and Peace in Yorubaland 1793-1893 (Ibadan, 1998); and Mann, Kristin, Slavery and the Birth of an African City: Lagos, 1760-1900 (Bloomington, 2007).
7 Oguntomisin, Gabriel, “Political Change and Adaptation in Yorubaland in the Nineteenth Century,” Canadian Journal of African Studies 15(1981), 223–37. Also see J. F. A. Ajayi, “Nineteenth Century Wars and Yoruba Ethnicity;” Isola Olomola, “Demographic Effects of the Nineteenth Century Yoruba Wars;” Gabriel Oguntomisin and Toyin Falola, “Refugees in Nineteenth Century Yorubaland;” and Oladeji, Niyi, “Language in Ethnic Rivalries: an Analysis of Ethnocentric Use of Yoruba in Nineteenth Century Yorubaland” all in War and Peace, 9-19, 371-79, 381-98, 451–60.
8 Richard, and Lander, John, Journal of an Expedition to Explore the Course and Termination of the Niger, (2 vols.: New York, 1832), 1:181; Church Missionary Society Archive [hereafter CMS], CA2/049b, David Hinderer to Henry Venn, 26 October 1855; National Archives of United Kingdom (hereafter NAUK), FO84/1061, Benjamin Campbell to Clarendon, 27 and 28 March 1858; Burton, Richard, Abeokuta and the Camaroos Mountains: An Exploration (2 vols.: London, 1863), 1:81–82; NAUK, CO 147/133, “Evidence of J. P. L. Davies” in Denton to Chamberlain, 4 June 1898; CMS, G3/A2/0/191, “Notices of the Villages;” Talbot, P. Amaury, The Peoples of Southern Nigeria (2 vols.: Oxford, 1926), 1:124; NAI, CSO 26/29939, R. L. V. Wilkes, “Intelligence Report on the Central Awori Group in the Ikeja and Badagry District of the Colony;” Barnes, Sandra T., Patrons and Power: Creating a Political Community in Metropolitan Lagos (Bloomington, 1986), 23, 27–36; and Smith, Robert, ed., Memoirs of Giambattista Scala: Consul of His Italian Majesty in Lagos in Guinea, 1862 (Oxford, 2000), 65.
9 CMS, CA2/049b, Hinderer to Henry Venn, 26 October 1855; NAUK, FO 84/976, Campbell to Clarendon, 7 December 1855; and Johnson, , History, 324, 381.
10 CMS, CA2/056, “Report of James Johnson, August 1877” and Akinyele, I.A., Iwe Itan Ibadan ati die Ninu Awon Ilu Agbegbe re bi Iwo, Osogbo, Ikirun (4th ed.: Ibadan, 1980), 209.
11 Robertson, George, Notes on Africa (London, 1819), 290–91; Law, Robin, “Trade and Politics Behind the Slave Coast: the Lagoon Traffic and the Rise of Lagos, 1500-1800,” JAH 24 (1983), 343–48; Mann, Slavery; and O'Hear, Ann, “Ilorin as a Slaving and Slave-Trading Emirate” in Lovejoy, Paul E., ed., Slavery on the Frontiers of Islam (Princeton, 2004), 55–68.
12 See Johnson, History and Akinyele, Iwe Itan Ibadan.
13 Samuel Crowther, journal, 3 March 1851. Cf. Church Missionary Record 12(1852), 277; PP, 1852, vol. lxiv (221), Henry Townsend to John Beecroft, 20 March 1851; Bowen, Thomas J., Adventures and Missionary Labours in Several Countries in the Interior of Africa Front 1849 to 1856 (London, 1968 [1857]), 120; and Johnson, , History, 354.
14 See “Description of a Slave [Joseph Wright of Aku]” in Beecham, John, Ashantee and the Gold Coast (London, 1841), 349–58; Irving, Edward, “The Ijebu Country,” Church Missionary Intelligencer 7(1856), 69; Tucker, Sarah, Abbeokuta or Sunrise within the Tropics (London, 1853), 17; CMS, CA2/075, Daniel Olubi, journal for 1870; and Johnson, , History, 331-54, 377–82. Soldiers and the elderly were also victimized as a form of breaking the political cohesion of a community and by that prevent future resistance. In Johnson's words “[t]he distress caused [by warfare]… cannot be described. Aged people who could not be carried were left to perish.” See Johnson, , History, 200-201, 205.
15 Ibid., 450-51.
16 May, Daniel, “Journey in the Yoruba and Nupe Countries in 1858,” Journal of Royal Geographical Society 30(1860), 213.
17 “The Yoruba Mission,” CMI 6(1855), 250; also see Awe, Bolanwe, “Iyalode Efunsetan Aniwura” in Awe, , ed., Nigerian Women in Historical Perspective (Ibadan, 1992), 57–71; Afolayan, Funso, “Women and Warfare in Yorubaland During the Nineteenth Century” in Falola, Toyin and Law, Robin, eds., Warfare and Diplomacy in Precolonial Nigeria: Essays in Honour of Robert Smith (Madison, 1992), 78–86; Ilesanmi, T. M. “The Yoruba Worldview on Women and Warfare” in Warfare and Diplomacy, 87–92; and Awe, Bolanle and Olutoye, Omotayo, “Women and Warfare in Nineteenth Yorubaland: an Introduction” in War and Peace, 121–30.
18 Barnes, , “Ritual, Power, and Outside Knowledge,” Journal of Religion in Africa 20(1990), 248–68. On Buganda see Musisi, Nakayinke, “Women, “Elite Polygyny,” and Buganda State Formation,” Signs 16(1991), 757–86.
19 Ellis, Alfred B., The Yoruba-Speaking Peoples of the Slave Coast of West Africa: Their Religion, Manners, Customs, Laws, Language (London, 1894), 187.
20 Clapperton, journal, 6 February 1826. Cf. Lockhart, James B. and Lovejoy, Paul E., eds., Hugh Clapperton into the Interior of Africa: Records of the Second Expedition, 1825-1827 (Leiden, 2005); and Lander, , Records of Captain Clapperton's Last Expedition to Africa (2 vols.: London, 1830), 2:224–26.
21 Losi, , History of Lagos, 22, 33.
22 See Babamuboni, Isaac E., Itan Ewi, Elekole ati Ajero, (Ibadan, n.d.).
23 Crowther to William Jowett, CMS Secretary, Fourah Bay, 22 February 1837, “Detailing the Circumstances Connected with His Being Sold as a Slave,” Church Missionary Record (1837), 217–23; and Crowther, , “Report of Visit to Ketu in 1853,” CMI 4(1853), 243–52.
24 Awe, /Olutoye, , “Women and Warfare,” 127.
25 Johnson, , History, 250.
26 Oroge, “Institution of Slavery;” Barber, Karin, “Money, Self Realization and the Person in Yoruba Texts” in Guyer, Jane, ed., Money Matters: Instability, Values and Social Payments in the Modern History of West African Communities (Portsmouth, NH., 1995), 205–24; and Guyer, Jane, “Wealth in People, Wealth in Things: Introduction,” JAH 36(1995), 83–90; also see Roper, , “What I Saw in Africa,” 38; Wood, James. B., “On the Inhabitants of Lagos: Their Character, Pursuits, and Languages,” CMI 33(1881), 685; and Gollmer, Charles H., Charles Andrew Gollmer: His Life and Missionary Labours in West Africa (London, 1889), 119–20.
27 Clapperton, journal, 7 February 1826 and Lander, , Records of Clapperton, 1:106, 2:196–97.
28 Delaney, Martin R. and Campbell, , Search for a Place: Black Separatism and Africa, 1860 (Ann Arbor, 1969), 59, 191; Pinnock, , The Romance of Missions in Nigeria (Richmond, 1917), 63–64; and NAI, CMS (Y) 1/7/10, Harding to Friends, 30 September 1892,
29 Stone, , In Afric's Forest and Jungle or Six Years among the Yorubans (New York, 1899).
30 CMS, CA2/078, Phillips, journal, 26 August 1878 and NAI, Ondo Div 8/1, Hunt to Resident, 13 January 1915.
31 NAI, CMS (Y) 1/7/5, “Account of visit to Kiriji camp in March 1885” in Wood to Lang, 19 August 1885.
32 Ward, Edward, Marriage among the Yoruba (Washington, 1937), 28–40.
33 Ulsheimer, , “Voyage of 1603-4” in Jones, Adam, ed., German Sources for West African History, 1599-1669 (Wiesbaden, 1983), 24.
34 Johnson, , History, 200-201, 205.
35 Eltis, David and Richardson, David, “West Africa and the Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade: New Evidence of Long-Run Trends,” Slavery and Abolition 18(1997), 16–34; Robertson, Claire and Klein, Martin, eds., Women and Slavery in Africa (Portsmouth, NH., 1987); and Lovejoy, , “Internal Markets or an Atlantic-Sahara Divide? How Women Fit into the Slave Trade of West Africa” in Campbell, Gwyn, Miers, Suzanne, and Miller, Joseph C. eds., Women and Slavery, 1: Africa, the Western Indian Ocean Islands and the Medieval North Atlantic (Athens, OH., 2007), 259–80.
36 See “Endeavours to Carry the Gospel into the Interior of Africa,” CMG 3(1843), 126; “Commencement of Missionary Operations at Abbeokouta” and “Meeting of the Rev. Samuel Crowther with his Mother,” CMG 7(1847), 17-18, 63–65; Irving, “Ijebu Country;” idem., “The Sufferings and Deliverance of James Gerber, a Twice-Liberated African” and idem., “How Thomas King Became a Slave,” CMG 10(1850), 20-23,138-41; Tucker, , Abbeokuta, 220–27; CMR 23(1852): 276–86; Barber, Mary, Oshieleor Village Life in the Yoruba Country (London, 1857), 45-55, 125–36, and Hinderer, , Seventeen Years, 143-47, 292–93.
37 Johnson, , History, 324.
38 NAI, Phillips 1/1/3, Phillips to Wood, 9 January 1890,
39 Ward, , Marriage among the Yoruba, 15, 27; and NAI, CSO 26/11799, vol. iv, R. Foulke-Roberts (DO Officer, Ondo) cited in Secretary Southern Provinces to G. C. Whiteley, 17 March 1937.
40 Hopkins, , “A Report on the Yoruba, 1910,” JHSN 5(1969), 81–82.
41 Also see Peel, , Ijesha and Nigerians: The Incorporation of a Yoruba Kingdom 1890s-1970s (Cambridge, 1983).
42 NAI, Ekiti Div 4/4, Civil Record Book, 14 July 1903.
43 NAI, CMS (Y) 3/1/2, “Minutes of Abeokuta Clerical Conference, 25 September 1877.”
44 Lovejoy, , “Concubinage in the Sokoto Caliphate (1804–1903),” Slavery and Abolition 11(1990), 159–89.
45 Barber, , Oshielle, 192–93; CMS, CA2/069, George Meakin, journal, 20 April 1859; CMS, CA2/049, Hinderer, journal, 27 April 1859; NAI, CMS (Y) 3/1/2, “Abeokuta Clerical Conference;” NAI, Phillips 1/3/3, journal, 26 August and 20 November 1878; Johnson, , History, 54-55, 459, 490, 492; Hopkins, , “Report on the Yoruba,” 81–82; Oroge “Institution of Slavery;” Mann, Slavery; Byfield, Judith, “Women, Marriage, Divorce and the Emerging Colonial State in Abeokuta (Nigeria), 1892-1904,” Canadian Journal of African Studies 30(1996), 32–51; Shields, “Palm Oil and Power;” and Ojo, “Slavery, Pawnship and Marriage in Yorubaland, 1870-1900” in Engendering the Atlantic, forthcoming.
46 IUP, PP, Colonies Series, vol. 63, inclosure in no. 17, S. B. Williams, “Report of Egba Mercantile Committee, 17-18 September 1855.”
47 Johnson, , History, 226, 236, 324-26, 638.
48 Ibid., 325 and Francis C. Fuller, “Report on the Interior” in Lagos Annual Report, 1899.
49 Allman, Jean, “Adultery and the State in Asante: Reflections on Gender, Class and Power from 1800 to 1950” in Hunwick, John and Lawler, Nancy, eds., The Cloth of Many Colored Silks (Evanston, 1996), 30.
50 Hopkins, , “Report on the Yoruba,” 81–82. On the persistence of adultery see Caldwell, John C., Caldwell, Pat, and Orubuloye, Israel O., “The Family and Sexual Networking in Sub-Saharan Africa: Historical Regional Differences and Present Day Implications,” Population Studies 46(1992), 385–410.
51 CMS, CA2/098/10, Young, journal, 27 June 1875; CMS, CA2/078/24, Phillips, journal, 23 November 1877; NAI, Phillips 1/1/3, Phillips to R. Lang, 13 January 1890; NAI, CMS (Y) 2/2/4, Phillips, , “A statement of the peculiar difficulties which impede the progress of the infant church at Ondo,” 14 February 1891; and NAI, CSO 26/4/30172, Bridges, A. F., “Intelligence Report on Ondo District, 1935,” 61. The proper word for “concubine” in this context is paramour, lover, or adulterer. An approved lover could sue a rival. See Fadase and Kinyokun vs. Fletcher in NAI, Phillips 3/11, Phillips, diary, 15 November–3 December 1901.
52 For an interesting discussion of how female slaves were used to incorporate male slaves and ensure their continued loyalty in the Western Sudan see Klein, Martin A., “Women in Slavery in the Western Sudan,” in Women and Slavery, 82–84.
53 PP, C4957, “Statement of the Modakeke, 28 November 1886.”
54 Lander, /Lander, , Journal, vol. 1.
55 Johnson, , History, 200-201, 205. In 1855, as Ijaye army headed for war in Sabe area, the women invoked Orisa to protect their soldiers. Cf. CMS, CA2/077, Charles Phillips, journal, 22 March 1855.
56 Millson, Alvan, “The Yoruba Country, West Africa,” Proceedings of the Royal Geographical Society 13(1891), 577–87; Mabogunje, A. L., “Some Comments on Land Tenure in Egba Division, Western Nigeria,” Africa 31(1961), 258–69; and Sudarkasa, Niara, Where Women Work: a Study of Yoruba in the Market Place and in the Home (Ann Arbor, 1973), 31.
57 See Lander, , Records of Clapperton, 2:197.
58 Johnson, , History, 307.
59 See Lloyd, , Yoruba Land Law (London, 1962), 192. Tradition also forbids the Elejelu (king) of Ijelu-Ekiti from seeing a new baby. Interviews with Madams Comfort Ogunleye, Ijelu, 30 June 2001; Abigail Ajibade and Marian Iyanda, Omu-Ekiti 24 June 2001.
60 Barnes, “Ritual, Power, and Outside Knowledge.”
61 Johnson, , History, 158–59.
62 Interviews with Oba Babington-Ashaye, the Ologere of Ogere, 1 September 1981, and J. Odusanya, Ijebu-Igbo, 29 August 1981. Cf. Sofela, Babatunde, “Egba-Ijebu Relations during the Nineteenth Century” (M.A., University of Ibadan, 1982).
63 Musisi, “Elite Polygyny” and Bay, Edna, Wives of the Leopard: Gender, Politics, and Culture in the Kingdom of Dahomey (Charlottesville, 1998).
64 Johnson, , History, 60-67, 391 and Babayemi, Solomon, Topics on Oyo History (Lagos, 1991), 97–108.
65 Interviews with Chief M. Oyapinda, Oluwo of Odo and J. O. Lamupejo, Odofin Ikija, 26 August 1981. Cf. Sofela, “Egba-Ijebu Relations.” Also see Barber, Karin, “Oríkì, Women and the Proliferation and Merging of Orisa,” Africa 60(1990), 313–37.
66 See “The Emancipados and Their Fatherland,” CMI 6(December 1855), 276; McKenzie, Peter, Hail Orisha! a Phenomenology of a West African Religion in the Mid-Nineteenth Century (Leiden, 1997); and Peel, , “Gender in Yoruba Religious Change,” Journal of Religion in Africa 32(2002), 136–66.
67 On human sacrifice see Ojo, Olatunji, “Slavery and Human Sacrifice in Nineteenth Century Yorubaland: Ondo c.1870–1894,” JAH 46(2005), 379–404.
68 Barber, , Oshiele, 55, 125–36 and CMS, CA2/043, Gollmer, journal, 15 September 1856.
69 CMS, CA2/097, Thomas B. Wright, journal, 1 May 1867.
70 Burton, , Abbeokuta, 104–06
71 Johnson, , History, 74.
72 On Yoruba marks see Lander, , Records, 1:283-84, 2:215–17; Lloyd, Peter C., “Osifekunde of Ijebu” in Curtin, Philip D., ed., Africa Remembered: Narratives by West Africans from the Era of the Slave Trade (Madison, 1967), 255–58; Baikie, William B., Narrative of an Exploring Voyage up the Rivers Kwora and Binue Commonly Known as the Niger and Tsadda in 1854 (London, 1966 [1856]), 272; Burton, , Abeokuta, 104–06; Roper, , “What I Saw in Africa,” 3436; Stone, , Afric's Forest, 30–31; Macfie, J. W. Scott, “A Yoruba Tattooer,” Man 67/68(1913), 121–22; Johnson, , History, 104–09; Oroge, , “Institution of Slavery,” 116–23; Adepegba, Cornelius “A Survey of Nigerian Body Markings and their Relationship to other Nigerian Arts” (PhD, Indiana University, 1976), 82-89, 111–17 and plates xx-xxv; Faleti, Adebayo, “Yoruba Facial Marks,” Gangan (1977), 22–27; Drewal, Henry, “Art or Accident; Yoruba Body Artists and their Deity Ogun” in Barnes, Sandra, ed., Africa's Ogun: Old World and New (Bloomington, 1997), 235–60; Okediji, Moyo, “Yoruba Facialographical Art and Oyo Expansionism” in War and Peace, 487–96; and Ayeni, Olubimpe, “Observations on the Medical and Social Aspects of Scarification in Sub-Saharan Africa,” 2004, www.med.uottawa.ca/medweb/hetenyi/ayeni.htm
73 Lander, , Records 2:215 and Lloyd, , “Osifekunde of Ijebu,” 255–56.
74 Johnson, , History, 108 and Fabunmi, Michael A., Ife: The Genesis of Yoruba Race (Lagos), 114–17.
75 NAI, Phillips 3/5, “Name of Baptismal Candidates, Ondo, 1892.”
76 Lovejoy, , “Scarification and the Loss of History in the African Diaspora,” paper presented at York University, Toronto, July 2005, 7, 14.
77 See Ogunmefun, Ade, Yoruba Legends (London, 1929), 2–3. Also Johnson, , History, 106n.
78 CMS, CA2/056, Johnson to Wright, 21 June 1878 and Asabia, David O. and Adegbesan, J.O., Idoani Past and Present: the Story of One Yoruba Kingdom (Ibadan, 1970), 5–6.
79 Elias, Teslim O., Nigerian Land Law (4th ed.: London, 1971), 139; and Oloyede, E. O., “The Laws Relating to Children and Young Persons under the Customary and Statutory Laws of Nigeria” PhD., London, 1970), 209–10. Cf. Oroge, , “Institution of Slavery,” 135.
80 Stone, , Afric's Forest, 30–31. Also see Roper, , “What I Saw in Africa,” 3436.
81 Johnson, , History, 377. Also see Lander, , Records, 1:283-84, 2:217.
82 Johnson, , History, 18, 107–09.
83 Adepegba, , “Yoruba Art and Art History” in Ogunremi, Deji and Adediran, Biodun, eds., Culture and Society in Yorbaland (Ibadan, 1998), 159–61.
84 Akinjogbin, I.A. and Ayandele, Emmanuel A., “Yorubaland up to 1800” in Ikime, Obaro, ed., Groundwork of Nigeria History (Ibadan, 1980), 121–43.
85 PP, C4957, Moloney to Rowe, 12 May 1881, encl. in Rowe to Kimberley, 2 July 1881,
86 Koelle, , Polyglotta Africana, 6.
87 Irving, , “Ijebu Country,” 71–72; Ajisafe, , History, 61–62, and Ayantuga, Olufemi O., “Ijebu and Its Neighbours” (PhD., London, 1963), 31.
88 Johnson, , History, 107. These marks probably came with Mandingo and Kemberi immigrants.
89 Lloyd, , “Osifekunde,” 257; and Fabunmi, , Ife, 114–17
90 Lovejoy, , “Scarification and Loss of History” and Patterson, Orlando, Slavery and Social Death: a Comparative Study (Cambridge, 1982).
91 Smith, H. F. C., Last, D. M., and Gubio, Gambo, “Ali Eisami Gazirmabe of Bornu” in Africa Remembered, 199–216; and Crowther to Jowett.