To the “moderate consequentialism” that has emerged as new moral theology in recent years and is now represented by many moral theologians an alternative is proposed: relational moral theology or relationalism. In moral theology the consequentialist or means-end model cannot bear the weight of being the fundamental model of moral norm-making and decision-making; and a relational model, which is apt for this function, should replace it. Moreover, “moderate consequentialism” developed out of an insufficient reconsideration of the traditional ethical categories, moral and physical evils, which resulted only in slight modification of these philosophical categories. Still needed is the radical reconsideration of evil that introduces a theological understanding of it into moral theology. And once introduced, this theological understanding of evil itself calls for a relational model of moral norm- and decision-making in moral theology.