To the Editor—We welcome the engagement and comments of Ms. Roady in response to our research article.Reference Whiteley, Derry, Glasbey and Fahey 1 We agree that the use of rapid ATP testing has a growing body of published support. However, the lack of common acceptance for rapid ATP testing at this point in time is well expressed in the EPIC 3 Guidelines (2014) from an expert committee in the United Kingdom.Reference Loveday, Wilson, Pratt, Golsorkhi, Tingle, Bak, Browne, Prieto and Wilcox 2
Unfortunately, Ms Roady somewhat misses the point of our paper. In our study, we did not attempt to equate rapid ATP testing with detection of bacterial contamination. We showed that the variability that occurs when measuring responses to controlled quantitated microbial cultures is the same variability that occurs when controlled concentrations of pure ATP solutions are measured. The issue is therefore not correlation with detection but data variability.
This variability is undetectable to ATP device users and applies to all sources of detected ATP. The ATP variability problem (ie, imprecision in results) that we have outlined in our most recent paper is common to each of the ATP device brands we tested. This finding does have implications for sampling methodology and analysis.Reference Whiteley, Derry and Glasbey 3
We set out to validate several branded ATP devices using a standardized approach and focusing on precision and accuracy. 4 The first issue we encountered was uncontrolled variability and the lack of precision at any testing point. The issue of accuracy is problematic because the scale of relative light units (RLU) is neither universally standardized nor standardized among ATP device suppliers.
We welcome the engagement with the industry. We would like to see better quality of results for ATP testing devices, including testing for precision and the development of a common measurement scale. There remains a tremendous upside for ATP use once these issues are resolved.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Potential conflicts of interest. None of the authors has any conflict of interest to declare.
