Published online by Cambridge University Press: 04 February 2015
If, as Thomas Flanagan has asserted, ‘the importance of John Mitchel's Jail journal to the tradition of Irish separatism has been underestimated’, the appearance of James Quinn's recent short biography of Mitchel is to be welcomed. Indeed, the remarkable thing is that Quinn's was the first book-length biography of Mitchel to be published since 1938. The biographical literature on Mitchel has veered between the hagiographic and the critical before settling, ultimately, into an apparent historiographical indifference. This essay examines Mitchel's biographies, his commemoration in periodical and ephemeral sources, and the development of the historiography of this most ardent republican, concluding that a renewed interest in Mitchel is timely.
1 Flanagan, Thomas ‘Literature in English’ in Vaughan, W.E. (ed.), A new history of Ireland v: Ireland under the Union, 1801–70 (Oxford, 1989), pp 482–522 at p. 509; Quinn, James John Mitchel (Dublin, 2008).
2 Riall, Lucy Garibaldi: invention of a hero (New Haven & London, 2007); Elliott, Marianne Robert Emmet: the making of a legend (London, 2003). See also Anderson, Benedict Imagined communities (London, 1991 ed.); Hobsbawm, Eric and Ranger, Terence (eds), The invention of tradition (Cambridge, 1992); McBride, Ian ‘Memory and national identity in modern Ireland’ in idem (ed.) History and memory in modern Ireland (Cambridge, 2001) pp 1–12.
3 Montégut, Emile John Mitchel: a study of Irish nationalism, ed. Hone, J.M. (Dublin, 1915), pp 5, 12, 30, 19, 59–60; Dillon, William Life of John Mitchel (2 vols, London, 1888), 2, 63.
4 McBride, , ‘Memory and national identity’, p. 36.
5 The Nation, 27 Mar. 1875; Dillon, , Life of John Mitchel i, 20, 22.
6 Freeman’s Journal, 22 Mar. 1875.
7 Freeman’s Journal, 22 Mar. 1875; The Nation, 27 Mar. 1875.
8 Freeman’s Journal, 22 Mar. 1875.
9 For example, Clarendon to Sir George Grey, 25 Mar. 1848 (Bodl., MS Clar. Dep. Irish vol. 2, f. 177).
10 McCarthy, Justin A history of our own times (4 vols, London, 1879), 2, 24, 28, 29, 37.
11 The Nation, 15 Apr. 1854; The Citizen, 6 May 1854.
12 William Smith O’Brien to Charles Gavan Duffy, 28 Nov. 1854 (N.L.I., William Smith O’Brien Papers, MS 2642/3489); Duffy to O’Brien, 2 Dec. 1854 (N.L.I., William Smith O’Brien Papers, MS 445/2877); McCarthy, , History of our own times, 2, 25, 24, 33, 34; McCarthy, Justin A history of our own times (London, 1890 ed.), p. 94.
13 William Dillon wrote that at the beginning of their professional association Mitchel probably never thought he would have serious political differences with Duffy: Dillon, , Life of John Mitchel, 1, 74–5, 84.
14 Duffy, Charles Gavan Four years of Irish history (Dublin, 1887 ed.), p. 209. First published in 1883.
15 Duffy, , Four years, p. 208; Sillard, P.A. Life of John Mitchel with an historical sketch of the ’48 movement in Ireland (second ed., Dublin, 1901), p. 219.
16 Duffy, , Four years, p. 208.
17 See, for example, the minutes of the Council of the Irish Confederation (R.I.A., MS 23 H 62, pp 282–305) for the extensive efforts it made to dispel the insurrectionary mood among the Dublin Confederates.
18 Clarendon to Lord John Russell, 31 May 1848 (Bodl., MS. Clar. Dep., Irish vol. 2, f. 274).
19 Duffy, , Four years, p. 209; Pearse, P.H. ‘The sovereign people’ in idem, Political writings and speeches (Dublin, 1952), pp 366–7.
20 Memoir of John Mitchel, the first victim (N.L.I. ephemera collection, P 350 (1)); Quinn, , John Mitchel, p. 72; Bannon, John Life of John Mitchel (Liverpool, 1882), pp 2, 3.
21 Bannon, Life, inside covers.
22 Bannon, , Life, p. 18.
23 The Nation, 14 July 1866, a reprint of Mitchel’s ‘usual Paris letter to the New York Daily News, dated 10th July’.
24 Bannon, , Life, p. 24.
25 Sillard, P.A. Life of John Mitchel (Dublin, 1889); O’Hegarty, P.S. John Mitchel: an appreciation, with some account of Young Ireland (Dublin, 1917); Walsh, L.J. John Mitchel (Dublin, 1934); MacCall, Seamus Irish Mitchel (London, 1938); Griffith, Arthur ‘Introduction’ in Mitchel, John Jail journal (London, 1913 ed.); MacNeill, Eoin ‘Foreword’ in Mitchel, John Letters to the Protestant farmers of Ulster (Dublin, 1917).
26 Dillon, , Life of John Mitchel, 1, 7, 197, 198.
27 Dillon, , Life of John Mitchel, 1, 9, xiv–xv, 196, 249; ii, 228; John Mitchel to Marie Thomson, 1 Nov. 1855 (P.R.O.N.I., T/413/1); William Mitchel to James Mitchel, 31 May 1888 (Columbia University Rare Books and Manuscripts Collection, New York, MS Coll. Meloney-Mitchel, Box 2); William Mitchel to James Mitchel, 11 Mar. 1889 (ibid.).
28 Dillon, , Life of John Mitchel, 2, 12, 13, 18.
29 Dillon, , Life of John Mitchel, 1, x, 8–9, 11, 14, 16, 261; ii, 24, 27, 39, 120, 122, 146–8, 192, 218, 196, 302–3. Elliott, Cf. Emmet, pp 65, 132–3.
30 Morash, Christopher ‘Making memories: the literature of the Irish famine’ in O’Sullivan, Patrick (ed.) The meaning of the famine (London, 1997), pp 40–55 at p. 50.
31 Riall, , Garibaldi, pp 128, 131.
32 O’Keeffe, Declan ‘A man for others and a beacon in the twilight: Matthew Russell, S.J. and the Irish Monthly’ in Studies, 99, no. 394 (Summer 2010), pp 1–8; Monthly, Irish 14 (Mar. 1886), pp 139, 145; xiv (Apr. 1886) pp 220–3; xiv (June 1886) pp 289–96; xvi (Aug. 1888), p. 463.
33 The Citizen, 12, 19, 26 Aug., 2, 9, 16 Sept. 1854.
34 Irish Monthly, xxxvi (July 1908) pp 361, 365.
35 McBride, , ‘Memory and national identity’, pp 32–3; The Citizen, 11 Mar. 1854; Daily Richmond Examiner, 13 Oct. 1864.
36 Irish Monthly, xxxviii (July 1910) pp 361, 363.
37 The Oxford companion to Irish literature, ed. Welch, Robert and Stewart, Bruce (Oxford, 1996), p. 263; Irish Book Lover, ii, no. 5 (Jan. 1911) p 89; vii, no. 4 (Nov. 1915) pp 57, 58, 74.
38 Irish Book Lover viii, no. 5 (Dec. 1915) pp 95–6; xiii, no. 3 (Oct. 1921), p. 43; Dillon, , Life of John Mitchel, 2, 246–7.
39 For a flavour of the Catholic Bulletin see Murphy, Brian ‘J.J. O’Kelly, the Catholic Bulletin and contemporary Irish cultural historians’ in Archivium Hibernicum, 44 (1989), pp 71–88; Catholic Bulletin, i (Aug. 1911), p. 401: iv (Nov. 1914), pp 769–71.
40 Catholic Bulletin, iii (May 1913), p. 340.
41 An extract from the “Jail journal” of John Mitchel, prisoner in the hands of the British (Paris, undated) (N.L.I. ephemera collection); colour supplement to The Shamrock, Christmas 1885; supplement to the Irish Fireside, 9 Sept. 1885; Kickham, C.J. ‘The first felon’ in Catholic Bulletin, 3 (Aug. 1913), p. 694 [first published 1849]; Commemorative programme, ‘Celebration in honour of the centenary of the birth of John Mitchel’, 4 Nov. 1915 (N.L.I. ephemera collection).
42 Elliott, , Emmet, p. 224.
43 Griffith, , ‘Preface’, pp 10, ix; Quinn, James ‘John Mitchel and the rejection of the nineteenth century’ in Eire-Ireland, 38 (Fall-Winter 2003), pp 90–108.
44 MacNeill, ‘Foreword’.
45 Pearse, P.H. ‘From a hermitage’ in idem, Political writings, pp 141–211 at p. 168; idem, ‘O’Donovan Rossa - graveside oration’, ibid., pp 133–7 at p. 135.
46 Pearse, , ‘From a hermitage’, pp 169, 170.
47 Pearse, P.H. ‘Ghosts’ in idem, Political writings, pp 219–55 at p. 235; Pearse, , ‘The sovereign people’, pp 365, 370; Augusteijn, Joost Patrick Pearse: the making of a revolutionary (Basingstoke, 2010), p. 292.
48 For O’Hegarty’s change of heart, see Flanagan, Frances ‘The disappointed revolutionary: P. S. O’Hegarty and the ambiguous victory of Sinn Féin’ in Dháibhéid, Caoimhe Nic and Reid, Colin (eds), From Parnell to Paisley: constitutional and revolutionary politics in Ireland (Dublin, 2010), pp 97–115.
49 Walsh, , John Mitchel, pp 12–13, 15, 54–5, 62, 67, 87.
50 MacCall, , Irish Mitchel, pp 9, 24, 57, 58–9, 74, 326, 331, 334, 388–9.
51 Welch, and Stewart, , eds, Irish literature, p. 158; Dublin Magazine, xiv, no. I (Jan.-Mar. 1939), p 51; Irish Book Lover, xiii, no. 3 (Oct. 1921), pp 42–3; Dublin Magazine, x, no. 3 (July-Sept. 1935) pp 82–3; Ó Cathaoir, Brendan John Mitchel (Dublin, 1978), p. 26.
52 Nowlan, Kevin B. ‘The political background’ in Edwards, R. Dudley and Williams, T. Desmond (eds) The great famine: studies in Irish history, 1845–52 (Dublin, 1994 ed.), pp 130–206 at p. 133.
53 Nowlan, , ‘The political background’, pp 152, 154; idem, The politics of repeal (London, 1965), pp 10, 12.
54 Donnelly, J.S. jr, ‘The administration of relief, 1847–51’ in Vaughan, W.E. (ed.) A new history of Ireland v: Ireland under the union, 1801–70 (Oxford, 1989) pp 316–331.
55 Quinn, , John Mitchel, p. 90; Donnelly, James S. jr, ‘The Great Famine: its interpreters, old and new’ in History Ireland, 1, no. 3 (Autumn, 1993), pp 27–33.
56 Bew, Paul Ireland: the politics ofenmity, 1789–2006 (Oxford, 2007), p. 213; Donnelly, , ‘The Great Famine: its interpreters’, p. 33; idem, ‘Mass eviction and the Great Famine: the clearances revisited’ in Pórtéir, Cathal (ed.), The Great Irish Famine (Cork, 1997), pp 155–173, at p. 173.
57 Quinn, , ‘John Mitchel and the rejection of the nineteenth century’, p. 92; Quinn, , John Mitchel, p. 89.
58 Quinn, , John Mitchel, pp 6, 57, 82, 88, 54; McGovern, Bryan P. John Mitchel: Irish nationalist, southern secessionist (Knoxville, 2009).