Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 January 2014
The 1635 ship money writ elicited a “common feeling of dissatisfaction” throughout England. It was the general belief that the tax contravened “fundamental law,” and that in its imposition Charles “had deliberately treated the nation as a stranger to his counsels, and that if his claim to levy money by his own authority were once admitted, the door would be open to other demands of which it was impossible to foresee the limits.” Contrast this account by S.R. Gardiner with a more recent analysis of the response to ship money provided by J.S. Morrill, a scholar who has acknowledged a substantial intellectual debt to Alan Everitt, the progenitor and leading exponent of the concept of the “county community” in seventeenth-century England. “The King's right to levy the rate was rarely questioned in the provinces. Ship money was hated for its costliness and its disruptive effects on the social and political calm of the communities … Above all,” the levy was detested because “it exemplified the government's insensitivity toward localist sentiment and belief.”
In these divergent accounts, a fundamental difference emerges between the traditional school of English historians and the county community school of local historians. For Gardiner, seventeenth-century Englishmen were fully aware of and vitally concerned about the actions of their national rulers, actions they evaluated against the touchstone of constitutional principle. Everitt and Morrill insist, by contrast, that even the gentry were “surprisingly ill informed” about “wider political issues”; they were “simply not concerned with affairs of state.”
This paper was originally presented at the Middle Atlantic regional meeting of the Conference on British Studies in November 1977. I am grateful to David Underdown, the commentator, and to J.H. Hexter, Derek Hirst, Linda Levy Peck, and Lawrence Stone for their criticisms.
1 Gardiner, S.R., History of England 1603-1642 (London, 1884), vol. 8, p. 85; Morrill, J.S., The Revolt of the Provinces (London, 1976), pp. 24–29.
2 The quotations are taken from Morrill, , Revolt, p. 22; Everitt, Alan, The Local Community and the Great Rebellion (London, 1969), p. 8; Everitt, , Change in the Provinces (Leicester, 1969), pp. 47,48. In fairness, it should be remarked that both Everitt and Morrill disclaim any intention of arguing that “provincialism excluded concern for general … political or constitutional issues” (Morrill's phrase). Yet Everitt believes that localism “was normally … more powerful” than any national consciousness, while in his narrative, Morrill consistently downgrades national concerns (Everitt, , Local Community, p. 5; Morrill, , Revolt, p. 14).
3 This account is distilled from Everitt, 's The Community of Kent and the Great Rebellion (Leicester, 1966).
4 See Holmes, Clive, The Eastern Association in the English Civil War (Cambridge, 1974), pp. 28–29; Cliffe, J.T., The Yorkshire Gentry (London, 1969), pp, 300–01.
5 Stone, Lawrence, “English Land Sales, 1540-1640: a reply to Mr. Russell” in Economic History Review, 2nd series, vol. 25 (1972), p. 121 note 6, and the sources cited there. For Cheshire, see Morrill, J.S., Cheshire 1630-1660: County Government and Society during the English Revolution (Oxford, 1974), pp. 2–4; for Lancashire Blackwood, B.G., “The Cavalier and Roundhead Gentry of Lancashire” in Transactions of the Lancashire and Cheshire Antiquarian Society, vol. 77 (1967), p. 83; for Dorset, J.P. Ferris, “The Gentry of Dorset on the Eve of the Civil War” in Genealogists' Magazine, vol. 15, no. 3 (1965), pp. 104–08. In Lincolnshire I find that only 17 percent of the gentry could claim pre-Tudor lineage.
6 Everitt, , Local Community, pp. 21–22; Everitt, , Suffolk and the Great Rebellion (Ipswich, 1960), pp. 17–22.
7 For Kent, see Everitt, , Community of Kent, pp. 42-43, 328; for Lancashire, B.G. Blackwood, “The Marriages of the Lancashire Gentry on the Eve of the Civil War” in Genealogists' Magazine, vol. 16, no. 7 (1970), pp. 321–28; for Essex and Hertfordshire, Holmes, , Association, pp. 13, 229.
8 Fletcher, Anthony, A County Community in Peace and War: Sussex 1600-1660 (London, 1975), pp. 44–53.
9 Ibid., p. 53.
10 Public Record Office, State Papers (hereafter SP), 14/162/58; 16/514/29.
11 Lewis, T.T. (ed.), The Letters of Lady Brilliana Harley (London, 1854), pp. 9, 27, 30, 32, 59, 68, 81, 107, 130, 161.
12 Gleason, J.H., The Justices of the Peace in England 1558-1640 (Oxford, 1969), pp. 83–95; Jordan, W.K., Philanthropy in England, 1480-1660 (London, 1959), p. 361.
13 Everitt, , Local Community, p. 6; Morrill, , Revolt, pp. 23–24; Morgan, Victor, “Cambridge University and ‘the Country’, 1560-1640” in Stone, Lawrence (ed.), The University and Society (Princeton, 1974), vol. l, pp. 183–245; quotation from p. 185.
14 Porter, H.C., Reformation and Reaction in Tudor Cambridge (Cambridge, 1958), pp. 45-46, 269–71.
15 Prest, W.R., The Inns of Court under Elizabeth I and the Early Stuarts (Totowa, 1972), pp. 32–40; for Egerton, see Knafla, L.A., Law and Politics in Jacobean England (Cambridge, 1977), pp. 48–49; for Welby, Baildon, W.P. (ed.), Les Reportes del Cases in Camera Stellata 1593-1609 (London, 1894), p. 315.
16 Aston, Thomas, A Remonstrance against Presbytery (London, 1641), passim; for the local background to this work, see Morrill, , Cheshire, pp. 45–53.
17 Douglas, D.C., English Scholars 1660-1730 (London, 1951), pp. 30–37, analyzes the fruitful scholarly interaction of Spelman (Norfolk), Dugdale (Warwickshire), and Dodsworth (Yorkshire).
18 Scot, Reginald, The Discoverie of Witchcraft (Totowa, 1973), p. xvi; Bohannon, Mary E., “A London Bookseller's Bill, 1635-1639” in The Library, 4th series, vol. 18 (1937–1938), pp. 417–46.
19 Quotations are from Stone, Lawrence, The Crisis of the Aristocracy (Oxford, 1964), p. 388 and Everitt, , Local Community, p. 6; Stone (ibid., pp. 385-98) provides a general review of the evidence for the attraction of London. In English Provincial Society from the Reformation to the Revolution (London, 1977), pp. 209, 447, Peter Clark argues that the Kentish gentry had closer ties with London than Everitt supposes; for the Yorkshire gentry, see Cliffe, , Yorkshire Gentry, pp. 21–23.
20 Everitt, , Community of Kent, p. 44.
21 Scofield, B. (ed.), The Knyvett Letters, 1620-1644 (Norwich, 1949), passim.
22 H.M.C. Buccleuch, vol. 3, pp. 307–14; Stone, Lawrence, The Causes of the English Civil War (London, 1972), p. 91; Green, M.A.E. (ed.), The Diary of John Rous (London, 1856), passim.
23 Everitt, , Local Community, p. 6.
24 Stone, , Causes, p. 95.
25 For Essex, see Samaha, Joel, Law and Order in Historical Perspective (New York, 1974), pp. 81–83 and App. IV; for Somerset, T.G. Barnes, Somerset 1625-1640 (Oxford, 1961), pp. 68–70; for Cheshire, Morrill, Cheshire, pp. 9, 16; for Sussex, Fletcher, County Community, pp. 134-36, 243.
26 SP 16/380/60. For similar local divisions within a county, see Clark, , English Provincial Society, pp. 256-57, 311 (the paradigm county, Kent) and Foster, G.F.C., “The North Riding Justices and their Sessions, 1603-1625” in Northern History, vol. 10 (1975), pp. 110-11, 115, 118.
27 Everitt, , Kent, p. 95 note 2. For Bacon's comment, see Cockburn, J.S., A History of the English Assizes, 1558-1714 (Cambridge, 1972), p. 173; for examples of such presentments, see Hirst, Derek, “Court, Country and Politics before 1629” in Sharpe, Kevin (ed.), Faction and Parliament (Oxford, 1978), pp. 134–35.
28 Barnes, T.G. (ed.), Somerset Assize Orders, 1629-1640 (Frome, 1959), p. xxix. For the Gloucestershire and Worcestershire examples, see Willcox, W.B., Gloucestershire: A study in local government 1590-1640 (London, 1940), p. 43; Hunt, R.D. (ed.), “Henry Townshend's ‘Notes of the Office of a Justice of the Peace’ 1661-63” in Worcestershire Historical Miscellany, no. II (Leeds, 1967), p. 109.
29 For these examples, see Hunt, (ed.), “Townshend's Notes,” pp. 83, 85, 86-87, 88, 90, 93, 94, 95, 109, 117; The English Reports (Edinburgh, 1907), vol. 80 (2 Bulstrode), 345, 348-49, 349-50, 351-52, 355–56; vol. 123 (Hutton), 99.
30 Barnes, (ed.), Somerset Assize Orders, p. xxvii; Morrill, , Revolt, p. 22. See also Cockhurn, , English Assizes, pp. 168–72.
31 Rushworth, John, Historical Collections (London, 1680), vol. 2, pp. 294-98, 352–56; vol. 3, pp. 985-89; Oldys, William and Park, Thomas (eds.), The Harleian Miscellany (London, 1810), vol. 5, p. 568; Articles of Accusation exhibited by the Commons … against Sir John Bramston (1641), pp. 32–33.
32 Ibid., pp. 5-6; Barnes, , Somerset, p. 228 note 48; Marcotte, Elaine, “Shrieval administration of ship money in Cheshire, 1637” in Bulletin of the John Rylands Library, vol. 58 (1975–1976), p. 159; Calendar of State Papers, Domestic Series (hereafter CSPD), 1637–1638, p. 443; Cliffe, , Yorkshire Gentry, p. 309; Jessup, F.W., Sir Roger Twysden, 1597-1672 (London, 1965), pp. 37–38.
33 Morrill, , Revolt, pp. 24–29. Ashton, Robert, The English Civil War: Conservatism and Revolution 1603-1649 (London, 1978), pp. 63–66, also emphasizes the localist aspect of the opposition to ship money.
34 See Hirst's, Derek recent articles, “The Privy Council and Problems of Enforement in the 1620s in Journal of British Studies, vol. 18 (1978), pp. 46–48; and “Court, Country and Politics” in Sharpe, (ed.), Faction, pp. 105–37.
35 Barnes, , Somerset, pp. 216–17; SP 16/315/121; 331/26; 336/78.
36 Rowe, V.A., “Robert, Second Earl of Warwick, and the Payment of Ship Money in Essex” in Transactions of the Essex Archaeological Society, 3rd series, vol. 1, part 2 (1962), pp. 160–63; Halliwell, J.O. (ed.), The Autobiography and Correspondence of Sir Simonds D'Ewes (London, 1845), vol. 2, pp. 129–36.
37 Fletcher, , County Community, pp. 195-96, 212.
38 Hirst, , “Privy Council,” pp. 52–53.
39 Acts of the Privy Council (hereafter APC), 1613–1614, pp. 491-93, 557-58, 628-31, 649-50, 655–56; APC 1621-23, pp. 176-78; Spedding, James (ed.), The Works of Francis Bacon (London, 1869), vol. 5, pp. 81-83, 132–34; CSPD 1621-23, p. 393.
40 SP 16/31/30, 31.
41 SP 16/33/8; CSPD 1625-26, pp. 397, 398, 399, 404, 406, 407, 410, 413, 419, 424, 425, 428, 435.
42 SP 16/25/75, Instructions which his Majesty's commissioners for the loan of the money … are exactly and effectually to observe and follow (London, 1626), passim.
43 APC 1627, pp. 23-24.
44 SP 16/54/82; Birch, Thomas (ed.), The Court and Times of Charles I (London, 1848), p. 202.
45 Everitt, , Kent, pp. 52-53, 117–18.
46 SP 16/71/50. Ashton, (English Civil War, p. 47) has also emphasized that “the Commission of the Peace was by no means monolithic in its attitude to royal centralising processes.”
47 SP 16/60/31; Johnson, Robert C., Keeler, Mary Frear, Cole, Maija Jansson, Bidwell, William B. (eds.), Commons Debates, 1628 (New Haven, 1977), vol. 2, p. 254.
48 Ibid., vol. 2, p. 69; Cooper, J.P. (ed.), Wentworth Papers 1597-1628 (London, 1973) pp. 5, 314; Cliffe, , Yorkshire Gentry, pp. 282–306; Barnes, , Somerset, pp. 281–98; Ashton, , English Civil War, p. 66.
49 Johnson, et al. (eds.), Commons Debates, 1628, vol. 2, p. 33. See also Hulme, Harold, The Life of Sir John Eliot (London, 1957), pp. 173–81.
50 See Hirst, Derek, The Representative of the People? (Cambridge, 1975), pp. 166–77. The debates on March 19-20, 1624 concerning the subsidy provide the fullest example of this habit of thought (Houghton Library, Harvard, English Ms 980, pp. 123-39, 143-49: I am extremely grateful to the Yale Center for Parliamentary History for allowing me to use their transcripts of the manuscript diaries for the parliaments of 1624 and 1626).
51 Foster, E.R., “The Procedure of the House of Commons against Patents and Monopolies, 1621-1624” in Aiken, W.A. and Henning, B.D. (eds.), Conflict in Stuart England (New York, 1960), pp. 59–85, especially pp. 61-62.
52 Notestein, Wallace, Relf, Frances Helen, and Simpson, Hartley (eds.), Commons Debates, 1621 (New Haven, 1935), vol. 2, pp. 353–54; vol. 3, p. 30; Cambridge University Library, Ms Dd 12 22 f. 17v; Johnson, et al. (eds.), Commons Debates, 1628, vol. 2, p. 57.
53 Ibid., vol. 3, pp. 355, 356, 359, 360.
54 See Hirst, , Representative, pp. 164-66, 175; (SirNicholas, Edward), Proceedings and Debates in the House of Commons in 1620 (Oxford, 1766), pp. 296, 343, 352; Cooper, (ed.), Wentworth Papers, pp. 152–57.
55 Robinson, G.W. (ed.), The Winthrop Papers, vol. 1 (Boston, 1929), pp. 324–26. See also Hirst, , Representative, pp. 143, 175.
56 Bodleian Library, Tanner Ms 66 f. 65.
57 Everitt, , Kent, p. 83: see also pp. 48, 70, 98, 240-59.
58 Plumb, J.H., “The growth of the electorate in England from 1600 to 1715” in Past and Present, no. 45 (1969), pp. 105–06; Clark, , Provincial Society, pp. 385–86; Gruenfelder, J.K., “The elections to the Short Parliament, 1640” in Reinmuth, R.H. (ed.), Early Stuart Studies (Minneapolis, 1970), pp. 209-10, 223–24.
59 Underdown, David, Somerset in the Civil War and Interregnum (Newton Abbot, 1973), pp. 38–41; Manning, Brian, The English People and the English Revolution (London, 1976), pp. 210–15.
60 Hirst, , Representative, pp. 144–47; see also the analysis of the 1620s elections in Kent by K.B. Sommers in her unpublished Yale University doctoral dissertation, “Court, Country and Parliament: Electoral Influence in Five English Counties, 1586-1640” (1978), pp. 239–47.
61 SP 16/350/54.
62 SP 16/56/39; 58/110; 73/45; 78/8; 357/96 VIII; CSPD 1637, p. 104.