Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-18T00:59:57.017Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The input ambiguity hypothesis and case blindness: an account of cross-linguistic and intra-linguistic differences in case errors

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 March 2010

SABRA D. PELHAM*
Affiliation:
University of Florida
*
[*]Address for correspondence: e-mail: spelham@ufl.edu
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

English-acquiring children frequently make pronoun case errors, while German-acquiring children rarely do. Nonetheless, German-acquiring children frequently make article case errors. It is proposed that when child-directed speech contains a high percentage of case-ambiguous forms, case errors are common in child language; when percentages are low, case errors are rare. Input to English and German children was analyzed for percentage of case-ambiguous personal pronouns on adult tiers of corpora from 24 English-acquiring and 24 German-acquiring children. Also analyzed for German was the percentage of case-ambiguous articles. Case-ambiguous pronouns averaged 63·3% in English, compared with 7·6% in German. The percentage of case-ambiguous articles in German was 77·0%. These percentages align with the children's errors reported in the literature. It appears children may be sensitive to levels of ambiguity such that low ambiguity may aid error-free acquisition, while high ambiguity may blind children to case distinctions, resulting in errors.

Information

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2010
Figure 0

Table 1.Case forms in English

Figure 1

Table 2.German prepositions

Figure 2

Table 3.Case in German personal pronouns and possessive determiners and pronouns

Figure 3

Table 4.Definite article declension

Figure 4

Table 5.Declension of dieser ‘this’, jener ‘that’, welcher ‘which’, jeder ‘each’, alle ‘all’, viele ‘many’

Figure 5

Table 6.Declension of -ein determiners: indefinite article, possessive pronouns, kein

Figure 6

Table 7.English pronouns spoken to children by caregivers

Figure 7

Fig. 1.Distribution of case-ambiguous pronouns in caregiver child-directed English.

Figure 8

Table 8.German pronouns spoken to children by caregivers

Figure 9

Fig. 2.Distribution of case-ambiguous pronouns in caregiver child-directed German.

Figure 10

Tables 9–10.German articles spoken to children by caregivers

Figure 11

Fig. 3.Distribution of case-ambiguous articles in caregiver child-directed German.

Figure 12

Tables 11–16.Other German determiners spoken to children by caregivers

Figure 13

Fig. 4.Distribution of case-ambiguous determiners in caregiver child-directed German.

Figure 14

Table 17.Turkish case affixes