^{page 125 note 1} See my papers, ‘Agobard of Lyons’, Speculum, xxvi, No. 1 (January 1951), 50–76Google Scholar, and ‘The Personality of Amalarius’, Church History, xx. No. 3 (September 1951), 34–41.

^{page 125 note 2} Epistula vi, 7, ed. Hanssens, ii. 394 f. (see p. 127, n. 2, for full bibliographical description).

^{page 126 note 1} See Walafrid Strabo's poem addressed to Agobard, Monumenta Germaniae Historica (hereafter referred to as MGH): Poetae Latini Aevi Carolini (hereafter referred to as PLAC) ii. 356 f.

^{page 126 note 2} cf. how casually the council of Thionville (835) approved his work, and how only three years later a similar council at Kiersy with little concern condemned the same matter as heresy.

^{page 126 note 3} See especially the warm language of Liber Officialis, iv, 7: 16, ed. Hanssens, ii. 434 f. (see p. 127, n. 2).

^{page 126 note 4} Agobard's works: De Translation Reliquiarum Sanctorum Martyrum Cypriani Sperati et Pantaleonis ad Urbem Lugdunensem, c. 807/808 (MGH: PLAC, ii. 544 f.); Epitaphium Caroli Magni Imperatoris, c. 814 (MGH: PLAC, i. 407 f.); Contra Insulsam Vulgi Opinionem de Grandine et Tonitruis, c. 815 (P.L., civ. 147–158); Adversus Legem Gundobadi et Impia Certamina Quae per Earn Geruntur, c. 817 (MGH: Epistolae Karolini Aevi (hereafter referred to as EppKA), iii. 158–164); De Divinis Sententiis Digestus cum Brevissimis Adnotationibus Contra Damnabilem Opinionem Putantium Divini Judicii Veritatem Igne vel Aquis vel Conflictu Armorum Patefieri (briefly, Contra Judicium Dei), c. 817 (P.L., civ. 249–86); Adversum Dogma Felicis Urgellensis, c. 819 (P.L., civ. 29–70); Consultatio et Supplicatio de Baptismo Judaicorum Mancipiorum, c. 823 (MGH: EppKA, iii. 164–6); De Dispensatione Ecclesiasticarum Rerum, c. early 825 (MGH: EppKA, iii. 166–79); Contra Eorum Superstitionem Qui Picturis et Imaginibus Sanctorum Adorationis Obsequium Deferendum Putant, c. 825 (P.L., civ. 199–228); De Spe et Timore, c. 826 (MGH: EppKA, iii. 222 f.); Contra Praeceptum Impium de Baptismo Judaicorum Mancipiorum, c. 826 (MGH: EppKA, iii. 179–82); De Modo Regiminis Ecclesiastici, c. 826 (P.L., civ. 189–200); De Privilegio et Jure Sacerdotii, c. 826 or early 827 (P.L., civ. 127–48); De Insolentia Judaeorum, c. 827 (MGH: EppKA, iii. 182–5); De Judaicis Superstitionibus, c. 827 (MGH: EppKA, iii. 185–99); De Cavendo Convictu et Societate Judaica c. 827 (MGH: EppKA, iii. 199–201); Deploratoria de Injustitiis, c. late 827 or early 828 (MGH: EppKA, iii. 201–3); De Quorumdam Inlusione Signorum, c. 829 (MGH: EppKA, iii. 206–10); Contra Objectiones Fredigisi Abbatis, c. 830 (MGH: EppKA, iii. 210–21); Sermo, c. 829/830 (P.L., civ. 267–88); Flebilis Epistola de Divisione Imperii Francorum Inter Filios Ludovici Imperatoris, c. late 831 (MGH: EppKA, iii. 223–6); De Comparatione Regiminis Ecclesiastici et Politici, between Easter and Pentecost, 833 (MGH: EppKA, iii. 226–8); ‘Manifesto’ (Liber Apologeticus, 1–6), between Pentecost and 24 June 833 (MGH: Scriptores (cited hereafter as SS) xv. 274 f.); Chartula, November 833 (MGH: Leges, i. 369); Liber Apologeticus pro Filiis Ludovici Pii Imperatoris Adversus Patrem (chapters 7–13 only; see ‘Manifesto’ above), mid-November 833 (MGH: SS, xv. 276–9); De Divina Psalmodia, 835–8 (P.L., civ. 325–30); De Correctione Antiphonarii, 835–8 (MGH: EppKA, iii. 232–8); Contra Libros Quatuor Amalarii, 835–8 (P.L., civ. 339–50); ‘Agobardo pax sit’, 838–40 [MGH: PLAC, ii. 118 f.; Traube, L., Karolingische Dichtungen, Berlin 1888, 152–5Google Scholar].

^{page 127 note 1} Adversus Legem Gundobadi, 4; De Dispensatione Ecclesiasticarum Rerum, passim; the five books against the Jews, passim.

^{page 127 note 2} Unless otherwise indicated, Amalarius's works are to be found in J. M. Hanssens (ed.), Amalarii Episcopi Opera Liturgica Omnia (Studi e Testi, 138–40), 3 vols. (Biblioteca Apostolica Vaticana, 1948). Those marked with an asterisk are no longer extant.

Amalarius's works: De Scrutinio et Baptismo, c. 811/812 (Hanssens, i. 236–251);. Eclogae de Ordine Romano, c. 813/814; 2nd ed., c. 836/837 (Hanssens, iii. 229–265); Missae Expositionis Geminus Codex, c. 814 (Hanssens, i. 255–281); Canonis Missae Interpretatio, c. 814 (Hanssens, i. 284–338); Versus Marini, 813/814 (MGH: PLAC, i. 426–8); letter to Peter of Nonantula, 814 (Hanssens, i. 229–31); De Institutione Canonicorum and De Institutione Sanctimonialium, c. 817 (P.L., cv. 821–972); letters to Jeremy of Sens, Jonas of Orleans, and Rantgar of Noyon, 817–22 (Hanssens, ii. 386–91); letter to Hilduin of Saint Denis, 819–22 (Hanssens, i. 341–58); Liber Officialis, 1st ed., 820–2; 2nd ed., 827/828; 3rd ed., 832/833; 4th (?) ed., 835 (Hanssens, ii); letters to Hetdo and Guntard, 825–8 (Hanssens, ii. 391–9); letter to an unknown bishop (MGH: EppKA, iii. 266 f.); prologue to the Antiphonary, 836/837 (Hanssens, i. 361–3); ^*an Antiphonary, 836/837; ^*a prologue to the Lectionary, 836/837; ^*De Ordine Cantatorii, 836/837; ^*Embolis, 836/837; ^*De Diurnali Officio, 836/837; De Ordine Antiphonarii, 836/837 (Hanssens, iii. 13–109); ^*De Praescientia et Praedestinatione, 849/850.

^{page 127 note 3} De Grandine et Tonitruis, passim; De Quorumdam Inlusione Signorum, passim; Sermo, 2; De Spe et Timore, ad init.; De Dispensatione Ecclesiasticarum Rerum, 24.

^{page 128 note 1} Consultatio et Supplicatio, ad init.

^{page 128 note 2} De Scrutinio et Baptismo, 10.

^{page 128 note 3} See his Versus Marini.

^{page 128 note 4} De Judaicis Superstitionibus, 9 f.

^{page 128 note 5} Liber Officialis, i. 31, 7; i. 32, 3; iv. 2, 13; De Ordine Antiphonarii, 57, 19.

^{page 128 note 6} Opuscula Adversus Amalarium, i. 10 (P.L., cxix. 79 A).

^{page 128 note 7} Consultatio et Supplicatio, ad init.

^{page 128 note 8} ‘Manifesto’ (Liber Apologeticus, 1–6).

^{page 128 note 9} Liber Officialis, praefatio ‘Gloriosissime’, 7.

^{page 129 note 1} See p. 128, n. 5.

^{page 129 note 2} De Tribus Epistolis (among the works of Remigius of Lyons, but probably written by Florus), 40 (P.L., cxxi. 1054).

^{page 129 note 3} Contra Judicium Dei, ad fin.

^{page 130 note 1} De Scrutinio et Baptismo, 55 f.

^{page 130 note 2} Liber Officialis, ii. 13, 12–16.

^{page 130 note 3} Liber Officialis, iii. 35, 1.

^{page 130 note 4} Contra Libros Quatuor Amalarii, 9.

^{page 130 note 5} De Grandine et Tonitruis, 2, 16; De Quorumdam Inlusione Signorum, 11 f.

^{page 130 note 6} Agobard, Adversum Dogma Felicis, 2; Amalarius, Eclogae de Ordine Romano, prooemium, 1; Missae Expositionis Geminus Codex, i. prooemium, 1.

^{page 131 note 1} Agobard, De Dispensatione Ecclesiasticarum Rerum, 30; Amalarius, De Scrutinio et Baptismo, 39; Liber Officialis, i. 11, 12.

^{page 131 note 2} Agobard, Contra Objectiones Fredigisi, 15; Amalarius, Liber Officialis, i. 40, 10.

^{page 131 note 3} Agobard, Contra Praeceptum Impium, ad med.; Amalarius, Liber Officialis, i. 13, 17.

^{page 131 note 4} For a consideration of manuscript-traditions, see Bressolles, Mgr., Saint Agobard Évêque de Lyon (Paris, 1949), 32–4Google Scholar, and Hanssens, op. cit., i. 95–224.