Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-15T14:18:25.575Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Corporate Diversification and Debt Maturity

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 October 2025

Enrico Onali
Affiliation:
University of Bristol Business School E.Onali@bristol.ac.uk
Xiaoxia Ye*
Affiliation:
University of Nottingham Nottingham University Business School
*
Xiaoxia.Ye@nottingham.ac.uk (corresponding author)
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

We are the first to study the interplay between corporate diversification and debt maturity, both theoretically and empirically. Our models predict that diversification mitigates the debt-overhang problem, making long-term debt more attractive in the presence of rollover costs. Using data on 30,135 firms from 1978 to 2022, we find that multi-division firms have debt maturities at least 1 year longer than stand-alone firms, especially when facing debt overhang. Consistent with our predictions, the excess value of Berger and Ofek (1995) and Mansi and Reeb (2002) increases with debt maturity, suggesting that traditional measures of the diversification discount could be misleading.

Information

Type
Research Article
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Michael G. Foster School of Business, University of Washington
Figure 0

Figure 1Timeline of the Possible Paths of Stand-Alone Firm $ S $’s Assets-in-PlaceFigure 1 plots all possible values of stand-alone firm $ S $’s assets-in-place on $ t=2 $ and two states $ \left\{G\hskip0.42em \mathrm{and}\hskip0.42em B\right\} $ on $ t=1 $. The probability of each path is shown along the path. Long-term and short-term face values of debt are indicated in the figure as long and short lines with corresponding legends.

Figure 1

Figure 2Timeline of the Possible Paths of Multi-Division Firm $ M $’s Assets-in-PlaceIn Figure 2, Graphs A and B plot all possible values of multi-division firm $ M $’s two assets-in-place $ {F}_m(1) $ and $ {F}_m(2) $, respectively, on $ t=2 $ and two states $ \left\{G\hskip0.42em \mathrm{and}\hskip0.42em B\right\} $ on $ t=1 $. The probability of each path is shown along the path. Graph C plots the same paths for the combined assets-in-place $ {F}_m $ for firm $ M $. Long-term and short-term face values of debt are indicated in Graph C as long and short lines with corresponding legends.

Figure 2

Figure 3Plots of the Numerical Examples of $ {P}_{\boldsymbol{s}}^{\mathbf{ST}} $ and $ {P}_{\boldsymbol{m}}^{\mathbf{ST}} $In Figure 3, the areas of the different shapes represent probability values. Graphs A and B, respectively, plot stand-alone firm $ S $ and multi-division firm $ M $’s probabilities of investing with short-term debt $ {P}_i^{\mathrm{ST}} $ and long-term debt $ {P}_i^{\mathrm{LT}} $ defined in Proposition 1. The formulae of different areas are presented in Appendix A. The numerical values of parameters are set as follows: $ {O}_s^{\mathrm{ST}}=\frac{1}{2},{O}_s^{\mathrm{LT}}=\frac{2}{3},{O}_m^{\mathrm{ST}}=\frac{1}{4},\mathrm{and}\;{O}_m^{\mathrm{LT}}=\frac{1}{3} $; $ \overline{\xi}=1 $ and $ \underline{\lambda}=0.25 $.

Figure 3

Table 1Basket Option Model Parameter Descriptions

Figure 4

Table 2Variable Definitions

Figure 5

Figure 4Debt Maturity and Overhang Change with Number of SegmentsGraph A (Graph B) of Figure 4 plots debt maturity (debt overhang) against the number of segments. The numerical values for the parameters are set as follows: $ {g}_i=r=5\% $, $ {\sigma}_i=0.4 $, $ V=100 $, $ {v}_i=\frac{100}{N} $, and $ L=60 $. The three curves in Graph A (Graph B) represent debt maturity (debt overhang) with three pairwise correlation levels ($ \rho =0,\ 0.1, $ and $ 0.3 $). The debt maturity and overhang of the comparable stand-alone firm are also plotted for reference purposes.

Figure 6

Figure 5Optimal Debt Maturity in the Presence of Noninterest Debt ExpensesThe left y-axis in Figure 5 visually compares the overhang and cost-adjusted NPVs, given various debt maturities of the multi-division firm with those of the comparable stand-alone firm. The right y-axis visually compares the corresponding market values of equity of the multi-division firm with those of the comparable stand-alone firm. The numerical values for the parameters are set as follows: $ {g}_i=r=5\% $, $ {\sigma}_i=0.4 $, $ N=6 $, $ V=100 $, $ {v}_i=\frac{100}{6} $, $ L=60 $, and $ {\rho}_{i,j}=0 $.

Figure 7

Table 3Summary Statistics and Pairwise Correlations

Figure 8

Figure 6Debt Maturity Before and After Diversification and RefocusingFigure 6 plots the median DEBT_MATURITY of firms that change from stand-alone to multi-division or the other way around, or both, over an 8-year window around the year of the switch (4 years before and 4 years after). The dashed (solid) line shows the median DEBT_MATURITY dynamic of cases in which firms change from stand-alone to multi-division (multi-division to stand-alone).

Figure 9

Table 4Debt Maturity Before and After Diversification and Refocusing

Figure 10

Table 5Debt Maturity Regression Results

Figure 11

Table 6Incremental R2 Results

Figure 12

Table 7Debt Maturity Regression Results Conditional on Total Assets Tertiles

Figure 13

Table 8Overhang as a Channel for the Debt Maturity and Corporate Diversification Association

Figure 14

Figure 7Excess Value Cross-Sectional Distribution over the YearsFigure 7 plots the cross-sectional distribution of Berger and Ofek’s (1995) excess value measure from 1978 to 2022. The solid line represents the cross-sectional median of the excess value in each year. The shadowed area around the solid line represents the 25th to 75th percentiles of the cross-sectional distribution of the excess value in each year.

Figure 15

Table 9Excess Value Regression Results

Figure 16

Table 10Excess Value Subsample Regression Results

Figure 17

Table A1Cost of Debt Regression Results

Figure 18

Table A2Leverage Regression Results

Figure 19

Table A3Cash Regression Results

Supplementary material: File

Onali and Ye supplementary material

Onali and Ye supplementary material
Download Onali and Ye supplementary material(File)
File 261.2 KB