Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-48dgx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T23:08:58.080Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Mutual Fund Strategy: Swing for the Fences or Bat for Average

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 April 2026

John Chalmers
Affiliation:
University of Oregon Charles H. Lundquist College of Business jchalmer@uoregon.edu
Arash Dayani*
Affiliation:
Clemson University Wilbur O. and Ann Powers College of Business
*
adayani@clemson.edu (corresponding author)
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

We document two distinct mutual fund strategies: “Swinging for the Fences” (SF), in which managers hold stocks with extreme style-adjusted returns on either tail of the return distribution, and “Batting for Average” (BA), in which managers seek stocks with consistently moderate performance. We provide evidence that these strategies are persistent and deliberate. Existing measures of active management and known asset-pricing factors do not explain the strategies. SF attracts more flow, particularly when funds mention specific stock holdings in shareholder reports. SF funds charge higher fees and hold riskier portfolios; yet, they fail to deliver higher risk-adjusted returns. In falsification tests, SF strategies are not present in passive funds, supporting our conclusion that SF and BA are intentional strategies.

Information

Type
Research Article
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BYCreative Common License - NCCreative Common License - ND
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided that no alterations are made and the original article is properly cited. The written permission of Cambridge University Press or the rights holder(s) must be obtained prior to any commercial use and/or adaptation of the article.
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Michael G. Foster School of Business, University of Washington
Figure 0

Figure 1Timing of Variable Construction and EstimationFigure 1 describes the timing and process of defining home runs (HR), strikeouts (SO), and batting average (BA). In quarter $ t-2 $, we record fund holdings. Then, we observe each holding’s portfolio-adjusted return during the following quarter (i.e., returns from $ t-2 $ to $ t-1 $). A stock holding is identified as home run or strikeout if its portfolio-adjusted quarterly return is in the 90th or 10th percentile of the return distribution, respectively. A stock is identified as a hit if its portfolio-adjusted quarterly return is positive. For each stock, we use one of the FF25 portfolios, which are based on the book-to-market ratio and market capitalization. Last, for each fund at quarter $ t-1 $, we define HR, SO, and BA as the number of holdings identified as home run, strikeout, and hits during the quarter, scaled by the total number of stocks held by the fund at quarter $ t-2 $. In our estimates, we regress dependent variables of interest at quarter $ t $ on strategy variables at quarter $ t-1 $.

Figure 1

Table 1Summary Statistics

Figure 2

Table 2Home Runs and Other Forms of Extreme Returns

Figure 3

Table 3Autocorrelations of Strategy Measures

Figure 4

Figure 2Likelihood of Mentions Across HR/SO QuintilesFigure 2 shows the likelihood that a fund manager mentions home-run and strikeout holdings in the managerial discussion of performance in its N-CSR form. We identify a fund as mentioned if it mentions at least one home-run or strikeout holding when discussing factors that contributed to or detracted from the performance of the fund. Then, we sort funds according to HR (blue) and SO (orange) into quintiles and calculate the average for the mentioned indicator.

Figure 5

Table 4Likelihood of Mentioning Home Runs and Strikeouts

Figure 6

Table 5Predictive Regressions of Strategies and Performance on Fund Characteristics

Figure 7

Table 6Benchmark–Adjusted Net Returns

Figure 8

Figure 3Cross–Sectional Volatility of Fund ReturnsFigure 3 shows cross-sectional fund return volatility within portfolios sorted on HR + SO, HR, and SO. In each quarter, funds are sorted into five portfolios. For each portfolio, the standard deviation of the return distribution is calculated. Then, the time series average of the cross-sectional standard deviations is reported in the figure. Error bars report 95% confidence intervals. The sample includes active diversified equity mutual funds with a $ 3\times 3 $ Morningstar category from 1993 to 2020 that meet the inclusion criteria outlined in Section II.A. $ \ast \ast \ast $, $ \ast \ast $, and $ \ast $ represent statistical significance at the 1%, 5%, and 10% levels, respectively. All variables are defined in Section II.A as well as Table A.1 in the Supplementary Material.

Figure 9

Table 7Fund Volatility

Figure 10

Table 8Fund Flows

Figure 11

Table 9Fund Flows, Mentions of Holdings, and Contributions

Figure 12

Figure 4Distribution of Fund Expense RatioFigure 4 shows the distribution of Expense Ratios within portfolios of funds with the highest and lowest HR + SO. In each quarter, funds are sorted and funds in the 20th and 80th percentile are assigned to the Low HR + SO and High HR + SO portfolios, respectively. Expense Ratios in the following quarter for each of these funds are presented in the figure. The sample includes active diversified equity mutual funds with a $ 3\times 3 $ Morningstar category from 1993 to 2020 that meet the inclusion criteria outlined in Section II.A. All variables are defined in Section II.A as well as Table A.1 in the Supplementary Material.

Figure 13

Table 10Fund Expense Ratios

Figure 14

Table 11Fund Expense Ratios and Mentions of Holdings

Figure 15

Table 12Passive Funds—Predictive Regressions of Strategies on Fund Characteristics

Figure 16

Table 13Passive Funds—Returns, Volatility, Flows, and Expense Ratios

Supplementary material: File

Chalmers and Dayani supplementary material

Chalmers and Dayani supplementary material
Download Chalmers and Dayani supplementary material(File)
File 1.4 MB