Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-w7t8q Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-19T03:47:20.804Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Real(istic) Time-Varying Probability of Consumption Disasters

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 November 2025

Xiaoyu Huang
Affiliation:
Wuhan University of Technology School of Economics xiaoyu.huang@whut.edu.cn
Tao Jin*
Affiliation:
Capital University of Economics and Business , Tsinghua University Hang Lung Center for Real Estate & PBC School of Finance, and Zhongnan University of Economics and Law Wenlan School of Business
Hao Zhou
Affiliation:
Tsinghua University PBC School of Finance, and Southern University of Science and Technology School of Business zhouh@pbcsf.tsinghua.edu.cn
*
tjin2007@gmail.com (corresponding author)
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

We model the time-varying probability of consumption disasters with international risk interactions and estimate the model using national accounts data of 42 countries back to 1833. The estimated world and country-specific disaster probabilities accord well with historical macroeconomic disasters. A match of the equity premium requires a relative risk aversion coefficient of approximately 5, which is significantly lower than previous estimates. Furthermore, the model provides notably better fits for equity volatility compared with alternative rare-disaster models. Finally, the disaster probability index estimated from the model demonstrates significant out-of-sample predictive power over long horizons, performing well not only over time but also across countries.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Michael G. Foster School of Business, University of Washington
Figure 0

Figure 1Disaster Probabilities for the United States Estimated in This Article and Implied by Wachter (2013) and Barro and Liao (2021)Figure 1 plots the time-varying consumption disaster probabilities for the United States estimated in this paper (black dashed line) compared with those implied by Wachter (2013) (red solid line) and Barro and Liao (2021) (blue dotted line). The estimates from this paper are based on the posterior mean of the disaster probability index derived from long-term national accounts data.

Figure 1

Figure 2World Disaster ProbabilityFigure 2 displays the posterior mean of the world disaster probability estimated from the model. Major historical events coinciding with probability peaks are labeled.

Figure 2

Figure 3An Illustration of a Typical Disaster DynamicsFigure 3 illustrates the evolution of consumption components during and after a simulated two-period disaster. The solid black line represents potential consumption ($ {x}_{it} $), the solid green line represents actual consumption ($ {c}_{it} $), and the dotted black line represents the disaster gap ($ {z}_{it} $). The simulation assumes a 2% annual consumption growth trend and uses parameters $ {\rho}_z=0.6 $, $ {\phi}_{it}=-0.1 $, and $ {\eta}_{it}=-0.04 $. The disaster occurs in periods 1 and 2, followed by a recovery phase where the disaster gap gradually dissipates while the permanent loss in potential consumption persists.

Figure 3

Table 1Estimated Parameters—Model with Time-Varying Probability of Disasters

Figure 4

Table 2Country-Years with the Posterior Disaster Probability of 20% or More (Outside of Global Disaster Years)

Figure 5

Figure 4Probability Density Function for the Immediate Disaster Effect $ {\phi}_{it} $Figure 4 displays the simulated probability density function for the immediate disaster effect $ {\phi}_{it} $. The distribution is derived from the estimated model parameters, where $ {\phi}_{it} $ follows an autoregressive process with error terms following an exponential distribution (see equation (8)).

Figure 6

Figure 5Probability Density Function for the Permanent Disaster Effect $ {\eta}_{it} $Figure 5 displays the simulated probability density function for the permanent disaster effect $ {\eta}_{it} $. The variable $ {\eta}_{it} $ determines the long-run impact of a disaster on potential consumption and is modeled to be correlated with the immediate effect $ {\phi}_{it} $ as specified in equation (9).

Figure 7

Figure 6Fitted Model for ChinaFigure 6 presents the time evolution of the key model variables for China. The solid black line plots the posterior mean of the disaster probability ($ {p}_{it} $, left axis). The solid red line and dashed blue line represent the posterior means of the immediate disaster effect ($ {I}_{it}{\phi}_{it} $) and permanent disaster effect ($ {I}_{it}{\eta}_{it} $), respectively (right axis). The solid green line shows the median of the model-implied consumption growth, with the yellow shaded area indicating the 5th to 95th percentile confidence interval. The black dashed line represents the actual historical consumption growth data.

Figure 8

Figure 7Fitted Model for GermanyFigure 7 presents the time evolution of the key model variables for Germany. The solid black line plots the posterior mean of the disaster probability ($ {p}_{it} $, left axis). The solid red line and dashed blue line represent the posterior means of the immediate disaster effect ($ {I}_{it}{\phi}_{it} $) and permanent disaster effect ($ {I}_{it}{\eta}_{it} $), respectively (right axis). The solid green line shows the median of the model-implied consumption growth, with the yellow shaded area indicating the 5th to 95th percentile confidence interval. The black dashed line represents the actual historical consumption growth data.

Figure 9

Figure 8Fitted Model for JapanFigure 8 presents the time evolution of the key model variables for Japan. The solid black line plots the posterior mean of the disaster probability ($ {p}_{it} $, left axis). The solid red line and dashed blue line represent the posterior means of the immediate disaster effect ($ {I}_{it}{\phi}_{it} $) and permanent disaster effect ($ {I}_{it}{\eta}_{it} $), respectively (right axis). The solid green line shows the median of the model-implied consumption growth, with the yellow shaded area indicating the 5th to 95th percentile confidence interval. The black dashed line represents the actual historical consumption growth data.

Figure 10

Figure 9Fitted Model for RussiaFigure 9 presents the time evolution of the key model variables for Russia. The solid black line plots the posterior mean of the disaster probability ($ {p}_{it} $, left axis). The solid red line and dashed blue line represent the posterior means of the immediate disaster effect ($ {I}_{it}{\phi}_{it} $) and permanent disaster effect ($ {I}_{it}{\eta}_{it} $), respectively (right axis). The solid green line shows the median of the model-implied consumption growth, with the yellow shaded area indicating the 5th to 95th percentile confidence interval. The black dashed line represents the actual historical consumption growth data.

Figure 11

Figure 10Fitted Model for the United KingdomFigure 10 presents the time evolution of the key model variables for the United Kingdom. The solid black line plots the posterior mean of the disaster probability ($ {p}_{it} $, left axis). The solid red line and dashed blue line represent the posterior means of the immediate disaster effect ($ {I}_{it}{\phi}_{it} $) and permanent disaster effect ($ {I}_{it}{\eta}_{it} $), respectively (right axis). The solid green line shows the median of the model-implied consumption growth, with the yellow shaded area indicating the 5th to 95th percentile confidence interval. The black dashed line represents the actual historical consumption growth data.

Figure 12

Figure 11Fitted Model for the United StatesFigure 11 presents the time evolution of the key model variables for the United States. The solid black line plots the posterior mean of the disaster probability ($ {p}_{it} $, left axis). The solid red line and dashed blue line represent the posterior means of the immediate disaster effect ($ {I}_{it}{\phi}_{it} $) and permanent disaster effect ($ {I}_{it}{\eta}_{it} $), respectively (right axis). The solid green line shows the median of the model-implied consumption growth, with the yellow shaded area indicating the 5th to 95th percentile confidence interval. The black dashed line represents the actual historical consumption growth data.

Figure 13

Table 3Estimated Parameters for Different Periods

Figure 14

Table 4Estimated Parameters for Subsample Countries

Figure 15

Table 5Asset-Pricing Statistics—Data and Models

Figure 16

Table 6Asset-Pricing Statistics—Estimated Model with Alternative Subjective Discount Factor, Risk Aversion, and IES

Figure 17

Figure 12Long-Horizon Regressions: Excess Return and Consumption GrowthFigure 12 evaluates the model’s ability to reproduce the empirical long-horizon predictability of excess stock returns and consumption growth by the dividend yield. Graph A displays the slope coefficients from panel regressions of cumulative excess stock returns on the initial dividend yield over horizons ranging from 1 to 10 years (equation (11)). Graph B displays the coefficients from panel regressions of cumulative consumption growth on the dividend yield (equation (12)). The black dots represent point estimates from historical data (17 countries, post-1920). The blue diamonds represent the median estimates from 1,000 model simulations, with error bars indicating the 1st to 99th percentile range.

Figure 18

Table 7Regressing Dividend Yield on the Disaster Probability Index

Figure 19

Figure 13Model-Implied Predictability from the Disaster Probability IndexFigure 13 illustrates the predictive power of the disaster probability index for excess stock returns based on model simulations. Graph A plots the distribution (median and 1st–99th percentiles) of the slope coefficients ($ \beta $) from panel regressions of cumulative excess returns on the disaster probability index $ {y}_{it} $ over horizons of 1 to 10 years (equation (13)). Graph B plots the corresponding distribution of the R2 statistics.

Figure 20

Table 8Out-of-Sample Predictive Regression

Supplementary material: File

Huang et al. supplementary material

Huang et al. supplementary material
Download Huang et al. supplementary material(File)
File 10.1 MB