Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-13T15:47:30.457Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Smart Beta Mirage

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 May 2023

Shiyang Huang,
Yang Song and
Hong Xiang
Shiyang Huang
Affiliation:
The University of Hong Kong HKU Business School huangsy@hku.hk
Yang Song
Affiliation:
University of Washington Foster School of Business songy18@uw.edu
Hong Xiang*
Affiliation:
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University Faculty of Business School of Accounting and Finance
*
hong.xiang@polyu.edu.hk (corresponding author)
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the 'Save PDF' action button.

We document and explain the sharp performance deterioration of smart beta indexes after the corresponding exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are launched for investment. While smart beta is purported to deliver excess returns through factor exposures, the market-adjusted return of smart beta indexes drops from about 3% “on paper” before ETF listings to about −0.50% to −1% after ETF listings. This performance decline cannot be explained by variation in factor premia, strategic timing, or diminishing returns to scale. Instead, we find strong evidence of data mining in the construction of smart beta indexes, which helps ETFs attract flows, as investors respond positively to backtests.

Information

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis , Volume 59 , Issue 6 , September 2024, pp. 2515 - 2546
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Michael G. Foster School of Business, University of Washington

Footnotes

We thank Itzhak Ben-David, Hendrik Bessembinder, Philip Bond, Jennifer Conrad, Darrell Duffie, Ralph Koijen, Charles M. C. Lee, Jiacui Li, Jeff Pontiff, Riccardo Sabbatucci, Stephan Siegel, Yuehua Tang, Yao Zeng, Zhuo Zhong, several BlackRock and Vanguard professionals, and seminar/conference participants at the University of Amsterdam, Erasmus University Rotterdam, the University of Warwick, the University of Washington, the University of Hong Kong, Victoria University of Wellington, Renmin University of China, the Joint Seminar by the University of Melbourne and the Financial Research Network (FIRN), the University of International Business and Economics, the 2021 Eastern Finance Association Annual Meeting, the 2020 Australasian Finance & Banking Conference, and the Virtual Asset Management Seminar for helpful comments.

References

Agarwal, V.; Barber, B. M.; Cheng, S.; Hameed, A.; and Yasuda, A.. “Private Company Valuations by Mutual Funds.” Review of Finance, 27 (2022), 693–738.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Agarwal, V.; Hanouna, P.; Moussawi, R.; and Stahel, C.. “Do ETFs Increase the Commonality in Liquidity of Underlying Stocks?” Working Paper, Georgia State University (2018).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Amihud, Y. “Illiquidity and Stock Returns: Cross-Section and Time-Series Effects.” Journal of Financial Markets, 5 (2002), 31–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
An, Y.; Benetton, M.; and Song, Y.. “Index Providers: Whales Behind the Scenes of ETFs.” Available at SSRN 3855836 (2021).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ang, A.; Hodrick, R. J.; Xing, Y.; and Zhang, X.. “The Cross-Section of Volatility and Expected Returns.” Journal of Finance, 61 (2006), 259–299.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Asness, C. S.; Frazzini, A.; and Pedersen, L. H.. “Quality Minus Junk.” Review of Accounting Studies, 24 (2019), 34–112.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barber, B. M.; Odean, T.; and Zheng, L.. “Out of Sight, Out of Mind: The Effects of Expenses on Mutual Fund Flows.” Journal of Business, 78 (2005), 2095–2120.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ben-David, I.; Franzoni, F.; Kim, B.; and Moussawi, R.. “Competition for Attention in the ETF Space.” National Bureau of Economic Research (2021).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ben-David, I.; Franzoni, F.; and Moussawi, R.. “Do ETFs Increase Volatility?” Journal of Finance, 73 (2018), 2471–2535.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bhattacharya, U.; Loos, B.; Meyer, S.; and Hackethal, A.. “Abusing ETFs.” Review of Finance, 21 (2017), 1217–1250.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bloomberg. “BlackRock Projects Smart Beta ETF Assets Will Reach $1 Trillion by 2020, and $2.4 Trillion by 2025” (2016). Available at https://www.bloomberg.com/press-releases/2016-05-12/blackrock-projects-smart-beta-etf-assets-will-reach-1-trillion-globally-by-2020-and-2-4-trillion-by-2025.Google Scholar
Bollen, N. P., and Pool, V. K.. “Do Hedge Fund Managers Misreport Returns? Evidence from the Pooled Distribution.” Journal of Finance, 64 (2009), 2257–2288.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bollen, N. P., and Pool, V. K.. “Suspicious Patterns in Hedge Fund Returns and the Risk of Fraud.” Review of Financial Studies, 25 (2012), 2673–2702.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Box, T.; Davis, R.; Evans, R.; and Lynch, A.. “Intraday Arbitrage Between ETFs and Their Underlying Portfolios.” Journal of Financial Economics, 141 (2021), 1078–1095.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, D. C.; Cederburg, S.; and Towner, M.. “Dominated ETFs.” Working Paper, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3694592 (2021a).Google Scholar
Brown, D. C.; Davies, S. W.; and Ringgenberg, M. C.. “ETF Arbitrage, Non-Fundamental Demand, and Return Predictability.” Review of Finance, 25 (2021b), 937–972.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, K. C.; Harlow, W. V.; and Zhang, H.. “Staying the Course: The Role of Investment Style Consistency in the Performance of Mutual Funds.” Working Paper, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1364737 (2009).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carhart, M. M. “On Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance.” Journal of Finance, 52 (1997), 57–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carhart, M. M.; Kaniel, R.; Musto, D. K.; and Reed, A. V.. “Leaning for the Tape: Evidence of Gaming Behavior in Equity Mutual Funds.” Journal of Finance, 57 (2002), 661–693.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chan, L. K.; Chen, H.-L.; and Lakonishok, J.. “On Mutual Fund Investment Styles.” Review of Financial Studies, 15 (2002), 1407–1437.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chen, H.; Cohen, L.; and Gurun, U. G.. “Don’t Take Their Word for It: The Misclassification of Bond Mutual Funds.” Journal of Finance, 76 (2021), 1699–1730.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chordia, T.; Subrahmanyam, A.; and Tong, Q.. “Have Capital Market Anomalies Attenuated in the Recent Era of High Liquidity and Trading Activity?” Journal of Accounting and Economics, 58 (2014), 41–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cici, G.; Gibson, S.; and Merrick, J. J. Jr. “Missing the Marks? Dispersion in Corporate Bond Valuations Across Mutual Funds.” Journal of Financial Economics, 101 (2011), 206–226.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Da, Z., and Shive, S.. “Exchange-Traded Funds and Asset Return Correlations.” European Financial Management, 24 (2018), 136–168.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dannhauser, C. D., and Pontiff, J.. “FLOW.” Working Paper, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3428702 (2020).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
DeHaan, E.; Song, Y.; Xie, C.; and Zhu, C.. “Obfuscation in Mutual Funds.” Journal of Accounting and Economics, 72 (2021), 101429.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Edelen, R. M.; Evans, R. B.; and Kadlec, G. B.. “Disclosure and Agency Conflict: Evidence from Mutual Fund Commission Bundling.” Journal of Financial Economics, 103 (2012), 308–326.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
ETF Stream. “ETF Insight: The Dangers of Smart Beta Backtesting” (2019). Available at https://www.etfstream.com/features/etf-insight-the-dangers-of-smart-beta-backtesting/.Google Scholar
Evans, R. B. “Mutual Fund Incubation.” Journal of Finance, 65 (2010), 1581–1611.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fama, E. F. and French, K. R.. “Common Risk Factors in the Returns on Stocks and Bonds.” Journal of Financial Economics, 33 (1993), 3–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fama, E. F., and French, K. R.. “A Five-Factor Asset Pricing Model.” Journal of Financial Economics, 116 (2015), 1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Financial Times . “Smart Beta’s New Kids on the Index Block” (2015). Available at https://www.ft.com/content/1fb9d574-43c6-11e5-b3b2-1672f710807b.Google Scholar
Financial Times . “Lack of Smart Beta Benchmarks Fuels Concerns” (2017). Available at https://www.ft.com/content/d4f03f5e-a9f0-11e7-ab66-21cc87a2edde.Google Scholar
Financial Times . “Index Companies to Feel the Chill of Fund Managers’ Price War” (2019). Available at https://www.ft.com/content/e886b2d2-e852-3071-85c1-c9a57113d8a5.Google Scholar
Glosten, L.; Nallareddy, S.; and Zou, Y.. “ETF Activity and Informational Efficiency of Underlying Securities.” Management Science, 67 (2021), 22–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harvey, C. R.; Liu, Y.; and Zhu, H.. “… and the Cross-Section of Expected Returns.” Review of Financial Studies, 29 (2016), 5–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hou, K.; Xue, C.; and Zhang, L.. “Replicating Anomalies.” Review of Financial Studies, 33 (2020), 2019–2133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Huang, S.; O’Hara, M.; and Zhong, Z.. “Innovation and Informed Trading: Evidence from Industry ETFs.” Review of Financial Studies, 34 (2021), 1280–1316.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Investco. “Understanding Smart Beta” (2018). Available at https://www.invesco.com/us-rest/contentdetail?contentId=a8569b81e1c0e510VgnVCM100000c2f1bf0aRCRD.Google Scholar
Israeli, D.; Lee, C. M.; and Sridharan, S. A.. “Is There a Dark Side to Exchange-Traded Funds? An Information Perspective.” Review of Accounting Studies, 22 (2017), 1048–1083.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Johansson, A.; Sabbatucci, R.; and Tamoni, A.. “Tradable Risk Factors for Institutional and Retail Investors.” Working Paper, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3594064 (2022).Google Scholar
Kaniel, R., and Parham, R.. “WSJ Category Kings–The Impact of Media Attention on Consumer and Mutual Fund Investment Decisions.” Journal of Financial Economics, 123 (2017), 337–356.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Li, F., and West, J.. “Live from Newport Beach. It’s Smart Beta!” Research Affiliates, available at https://www.advisorperspectives.com/commentaries/2017/08/24/live-from-newport-beach-its-smart-beta (2017).Google Scholar
McLean, R. D., and Pontiff, J.. “Does Academic Research Destroy Stock Return Predictability?” Journal of Finance, 71 (2016), 5–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morningstar. “Be Wary of Strategic-Beta ETFs with Rosy Back-Tested Results” (2017). Available at https://www.morningstar.com/articles/805594/be-wary-of-strategic-beta-etfs-with-rosy-back-tested-results.Google Scholar
Morningstar. “A Global Guide to Strategic-Beta Exchange-Traded Products.” Technical Report (2019).Google Scholar
Novy-Marx, R. “Testing Strategies Based on Multiple Signals.” Working Paper, University of Rochester (2016).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pan, K., and Zeng, Y.. “ETF Arbitrage Under Liquidity Mismatch.” Working Paper, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2895478 (2019).Google Scholar
Pástor, L.; Stambaugh, R. F.; and Taylor, L. A.. “Fund Tradeoffs.” Journal of Financial Economics, 138 (2020), 614–634.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pattabiraman, M. “Data Mining in Index Construction: Why Investors Need to be Cautious” (2020). Available at https://freefincal.com/data-mining-index-construction/.Google Scholar
Weinberg, A. “ETF Providers Going in New Directions with Indexes.” Pensions & Investments, available at https://www.pionline.com/article/20181001/PRINT/181009995/etf-providers-going-in-new-directions-with-indexes (2018).Google Scholar
Suhonen, A.; Lennkh, M.; and Perez, F.. “Quantifying Backtest Overfitting in Alternative Beta Strategies.” Journal of Portfolio Management, 43 (2017), 90–104.Google Scholar
Vanguard. “Joined at the Hip: ETF and Index Development” (2012). Available at https://www.vanguardcanada.ca/documents/joined-at-the-hip.pdf.Google Scholar
Wermers, R. “Matter of Style: The Causes and Consequences of Style Drift in Institutional Portfolios.” Working Paper, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2024259 (2012).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yan, X., and Zheng, L.. “Fundamental Analysis and the Cross-Section of Stock Returns: A Data-Mining Approach.” Review of Financial Studies, 30 (2017), 1382–1423.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Supplementary material: PDF

Huang et al. supplementary material

Huang et al. supplementary material

Download Huang et al. supplementary material(PDF)
PDF 492.4 KB