Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-kwt9d Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-14T09:57:37.165Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

To Group or Not to Group? Evidence from Mutual Fund Databases

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  31 October 2017

Saurin Patel and
Sergei Sarkissian
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the 'Save PDF' action button.

Despite the overwhelming trend in mutual funds toward team management, empirical studies find no performance benefits for this phenomenon. We show it is caused by large discrepancies in reported managerial structures in Center for Research in Security Prices and Morningstar Principia data sets versus U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission records, resulting in up to 50-basis-points underestimation of the team impact on fund returns. Using more accurate Morningstar Direct data, we find that team-managed funds outperform single-managed funds across various performance metrics. The relation between team size and fund performance is nonlinear. Also, team-managed funds take on no more risk than single-managed funds. Overall, team management benefits fund industry performance.

Information

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis , Volume 52 , Issue 5 , October 2017, pp. 1989 - 2021
Copyright
Copyright © Michael G. Foster School of Business, University of Washington 2017 

Footnotes

1

We appreciate the comments of an anonymous referee, Tim Adam, Laurent Barras, Stephen Brown (the editor), Craig Dunbar, Marcin Kacperczyk, Michael King, Alberto Manconi, Pedro Matos, Jeff Pontiff, Jonathan Reuter, Christopher Schwarz, Laura Starks, Lei Zhang, seminar participants at Bocconi University, Fordham University, Queens University, University of Edinburgh, University of Lethbridge, University of Cambridge, University of Western Ontario, and York University, and participants of the 2012 Luxembourg Asset Management Summit, the 2013 Asian Bureau of Finance and Economic Research meeting, and the 2014 Conference on Recent Advances in Mutual Fund and Hedge Fund Research in Berlin, Germany. Special thanks go to Chloe Fu at the Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP) and Annette Larson at Morningstar Inc. for discussions on how CRSP and Morningstar collect and update data in their mutual fund products. We acknowledge financial support from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada.

References

Adams, R., and Ferreira, D.. “Moderation in Groups: Evidence from Betting on Ice Break-Ups in Alaska.” Review of Economic Studies, 77 (2010), 882–913.Google Scholar
Agarwal, V.; Mullally, K.; Tang, Y.; and Yang, B.. “Mandatory Portfolio Disclosure, Stock Liquidity, and Mutual Fund Performance.” Journal of Finance, 70 (2015), 2733–2776.Google Scholar
Aiken, A.; Clifford, C.; and Ellis, J.. “Out of the Dark: Hedge Fund Reporting Biases and Commercial Databases.” Review of Financial Studies, 26 (2013), 208–243.Google Scholar
Alchian, A., and Demsetz, H.. “Production, Information Costs, and Economic Organization.” American Economic Review, 62 (1972), 777–795.Google Scholar
Bar, M.; Kempf, A.; and Ruenzi, S.. “Is a Team Different from the Sum of Its Parts? Evidence from Mutual Fund Managers.” Review of Finance, 15 (2011), 359–396.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barber, B.; Heath, C.; and Odean, T.. “Good Reasons Sell: Reason-Based Choice among Group and Individual Investors in the Stock Market.” Management Science, 49 (2003), 1636–1652.Google Scholar
Barber, B., and Odean, T.. “Boys Will Be Boys: Gender, Overconfidence, and Common Stock Investment.” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 116 (2001), 261–292.Google Scholar
Barry, C., and Starks, L.. “Investment Management and Risk Sharing with Multiple Managers.” Journal of Finance, 39 (1984), 477–491.Google Scholar
Berk, J., and Green, R.. “Mutual Fund Flows and Performance in Rational Markets.” Journal of Political Economy, 112 (2004), 1269–1295.Google Scholar
Berk, J.; Van Binsbergen, J.; and Liu, B.. “Matching Capital and Labor.” Journal of Finance, forthcoming (2017).Google Scholar
Blinder, A., and Morgan, J.. “Are Two Heads Better than One? Monetary Policy by Committee.” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 37 (2005), 789–811.Google Scholar
Bliss, R.; Porter, M.; and Schwarz, C.. “Performance Characteristics of Individually-Managed versus Team-Managed Mutual Funds.” Journal of Portfolio Management, 34 (2008), 110–119.Google Scholar
Bone, J.; Hey, J.; and Suckling, J.. “Are Groups More (or Less) Consistent than Individuals?” Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 18 (1999), 63–81.Google Scholar
Carhart, M.“On Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance.” Journal of Finance, 52 (1997), 57–82.Google Scholar
Cassar, G., and Gerakos, J.. “Hedge Funds: Pricing Controls and the Smoothing of Self-Reported Returns.” Review of Financial Studies, 24 (2011), 1698–1734.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chen, J.; Hong, H.; Huang, M.; and Kubik, J.. “Does Fund Size Erode Mutual Fund Performance? The Role of Liquidity and Organization.” American Economic Review, 94 (2004), 1276–1302.Google Scholar
Chen, J.; Hong, H.; Jiang, W.; and Kubik, J.. “Outsourcing Mutual Fund Management: Firm Boundaries, Incentives, and Performance.” Journal of Finance, 68 (2013), 523–558.Google Scholar
Chen, Q.; Goldstein, I.; and Jiang, W.. “Directors’ Ownership in the U.S. Mutual Fund Industry.” Journal of Finance, 63 (2008), 2629–2677.Google Scholar
Chevalier, J., and Ellison, G.. “Are Some Mutual Fund Managers Better than Others? Cross-Sectional Patterns in Behavior and Performance.” Journal of Finance, 54 (1999), 875–899.Google Scholar
Chuprinin, O.; Massa, M.; and Schumacher, D.. “Outsourcing in the International Mutual Fund Industry: An Equilibrium View.” Journal of Finance, 70 (2015), 2275–2308.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cici, G.“The Prevalence of the Disposition Effect in Mutual Funds’ Trades.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 47 (2012), 795–820.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cooper, D., and Kagel, J.. “Are Two Heads Better than One? Team versus Individual Play in Signaling Games.” American Economic Review, 95 (2004), 477–509.Google Scholar
Daniel, K.; Grinblatt, M.; Titman, S.; and Wermers, R.. “Measuring Mutual Fund Performance with Characteristic-Based Benchmarks.” Journal of Finance, 52 (1997), 1035–1058.Google Scholar
Dass, N.; Nanda, V.; and Wang, Q.. “Allocation of Decision Rights and the Investment Strategy of Mutual Funds.” Journal of Financial Economics, 110 (2013), 254–277.Google Scholar
Deuskar, P.; Pollet, J.; Wang, Z.; and Zheng, L.. “The Good or the Bad? Which Mutual Fund Managers Join Hedge Funds?” Review of Financial Studies, 24 (2011), 3008–3024.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Elton, E.; Gruber, M.; and Blake, C.. “A First Look at the Accuracy of the CRSP Mutual Fund Database and a Comparison of the CRSP and the Morningstar Mutual Fund Database.” Journal of Finance, 56 (2001), 2415–2430.Google Scholar
Engelberg, J.; Reed, A.; and Ringgenberg, M.. “How Are Shorts Informed? Short Sellers, News, and Information Processing.” Journal of Financial Economics, 105 (2012), 260–278.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fama, E. F.“Market Efficiency, Long-Term Returns, and Behavioral Finance.” Journal of Financial Economics, 49 (1998), 283–306.Google Scholar
Fama, E. F., and French, K.. “Luck versus Skill in the Cross Section of Mutual Fund Returns.” Journal of Finance, 65 (2010), 1915–1947.Google Scholar
Ferson, W., and Schadt, R.. “Measuring Fund Strategy and Performance in Changing Economic Conditions.” Journal of Finance, 51 (1996), 425–461.Google Scholar
Grubb, D., and Symons, J.. “Bias in Regressions with a Lagged Dependent Variable.” Econometric Theory, 3 (1987), 371–386.Google Scholar
Hamilton, B.; Nickerson, J.; and Owan, H.. “Team Incentives and Worker Heterogeneity: An Empirical Analysis of the Impact of Teams on Productivity and Participation.” Journal of Political Economy, 111 (2003), 465–497.Google Scholar
Holmstrom, B.“Moral Hazard in Teams.” Bell Journal of Economics, 13 (1982), 324–340.Google Scholar
Kacperczyk, M., and Seru, A.. “Fund Manager Use of Public Information: New Evidence on Managerial Skills.” Journal of Finance, 62 (2007), 485–528.Google Scholar
Kacperczyk, M.; Sialm, C.; and Zheng, L.. “On the Industry Concentration of Actively Managed Equity Mutual Funds.” Journal of Finance, 59 (2004), 1983–2011.Google Scholar
Kacperczyk, M.; Sialm, C.; and Zheng, L.. “Unobserved Actions of Mutual Funds.” Review of Financial Studies, 21 (2008), 2379–2416.Google Scholar
Karagiannidis, I.“Management Team Structure and Mutual Fund Performance.” Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions, and Money, 20 (2010), 197–211.Google Scholar
Kempf, A., and Ruenzi, S.. “Tournaments in Mutual Fund Families.” Review of Financial Studies, 21 (2007), 1013–1036.Google Scholar
Kostovetsky, L., and Warner, J.. “You’re Fired! New Evidence on Portfolio Manager Turnover and Performance.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 50 (2015), 729–755.Google Scholar
Kovaleski, D.“Banding Together: More Mutual Fund Companies Take a Team Approach,” Pensions and Investments. Available at http://www.pionline.com/article/20000724/PRINT/7240741? templa= (July 24, 2000).Google Scholar
Laughlin, P.; Hatch, E.; Silver, J.; and Boh, L.. “Groups Perform Better than the Best Individuals on Letters-to-Numbers Problems: Effects of Group Size.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 90 (2006), 644–651.Google Scholar
Linnainmaa, J.“Reverse Survivorship Bias.” Journal of Finance, 68 (2013), 789–813.Google Scholar
Maddala, G., and Rao, A.. “Tests for Serial Correlation in Regression Models with Lagged Dependent Variables and Serially Correlated Errors.” Econometrica, 47 (1973), 761–774.Google Scholar
Massa, M.; Reuter, J.; and Zitzewitz, E.. “When Should Firms Share Credit with Employees? Evidence from Anonymously Managed Mutual Funds.” Journal of Financial Economics, 95 (2010), 400–424.Google Scholar
Mueller, J.“Why Individuals in Larger Teams Perform Worse.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 117 (2012), 111–124.Google Scholar
Nalbantian, H., and Schotter, A.. “Productivity under Group Incentives: An Experimental Study.” American Economic Review, 87 (1997), 314–341.Google Scholar
Nohel, T.; Wang, Z.; and Zheng, L.. “Side-by-Side Management of Hedge Funds and Mutual Funds.” Review of Financial Studies, 23 (2010), 2342–2373.Google Scholar
Pastor, L., and Stambaugh, R.. “Liquidity Risk Expected Stock Returns.” Journal of Political Economy, 111 (2003), 642–685.Google Scholar
Prather, L., and Middleton, K.. “Are N + 1 Heads Better than One? The Case of Mutual Fund Managers.” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 47 (2002), 103–120.Google Scholar
Sah, R., and Stiglitz, J.. “The Architecture of Economic Systems: Hierarchies and Polyarchies.” American Economic Review, 76 (1986), 716–727.Google Scholar
Sah, R., and Stiglitz, J.. “The Quality of Managers in Centralized versus Decentralized Organizations.” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 106 (1991), 289–295.Google Scholar
Sharpe, W.“Decentralized Investment Management.” Journal of Finance, 36 (1981), 217–234.Google Scholar
Stein, J.“Information Production and Capital Allocation: Decentralized versus Hierarchical Firms.” Journal of Finance, 57 (2002), 1891–1921.Google Scholar
Stoner, J.“Risky and Cautious Shifts in Group Decisions.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 4 (1968), 442–459.Google Scholar
Sunstein, C.“The Law of Group Polarization.” Journal of Political Philosophy, 10 (2002), 175–195.Google Scholar
Toonkel, J.“Funds Move Away from Star Managers, Favor Teams,” Thomson Reuters (Dec. 2, 2011).Google Scholar
Wallach, M. A., and Kogan, N.. “The Roles of Information, Discussion, and Consensus in Group Risk Taking.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1 (1965), 1–19.Google Scholar
Wermers, R.; Yao, T.; and Zhao, J.. “Forecasting Stock Returns through an Efficient Aggregation of Mutual Fund Holdings.” Review of Financial Studies, 25 (2012), 3490–3529.Google Scholar