Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T19:31:45.328Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

An attached-eddy elliptic approximation for two-dimensional structure functions in turbulent channel flow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 June 2026

Jiao Chen
Affiliation:
School of Mathematical Sciences, Chongqing University of Technology, Chongqing 400054, PR China
Xuebo Li*
Affiliation:
School of Mathematical Sciences, Chongqing University of Technology, Chongqing 400054, PR China
Yongxiang Huang
Affiliation:
Center for Marine Meteorology and Climate Change & College of Ocean and Earth Sciences, Xiamen University, Xiamen 361102, PR China
*
Corresponding author: Xuebo Li, xbl@cqut.edu.cn

Abstract

Content of image described in text.

We investigate the equal-height, two-dimensional second-order structure function of the streamwise velocity fluctuation $u$ in turbulent channel flow. Specifically, at a given wall-normal location $z$ we consider $S_2(r_x,r_y;z)=\langle [u(x+r_x,y+r_y,z)-u(x,y,z)]^2\rangle$, where $(r_x,r_y)$ are the streamwise and spanwise separations in a wall-parallel plane and $\langle \boldsymbol{\cdot }\rangle$ denotes wall-parallel spatial averaging. Focusing on separations within the logarithmic region, we build on Townsend’s attached-eddy hypothesis and its hierarchical random additive-process formulation to introduce an attached-eddy elliptic approximation, in which the two-point geometry is represented by an elliptic in-plane footprint. The model yields a compact prediction for $S_2(r_x,r_y;z)$: its one-dimensional projections recover the canonical logarithmic forms with an asymptotically common slope, and its iso-$S_2$ contours at fixed $z$ are predicted to be self-similar ellipses whose semi-axes scale linearly with $z$ while maintaining an approximately constant aspect ratio (with mild finite-Reynolds-number effects). These predictions are assessed using direct numerical simulations at friction Reynolds numbers $Re_\tau =1000$ and $5200$, where $Re_\tau =u_\tau \delta /\nu$, and $u_\tau$ is the friction velocity, $\nu$ is the kinematic viscosity and $\delta$ is the channel half-height. When expressed in terms of $r_i/z$ ($i=x,y$), the projected structure functions collapse across wall-normal locations and vary linearly with $\ln (r_i/z)$. At fixed $z$, the iso-$S_2$ contours in the $(r_x,r_y)$ plane are well described by ellipses characterised by a single anisotropy parameter $R=b/a$, where $a$ and $b$ are the ellipse semi-axes in the $r_x$ and $r_y$ directions, respectively. A simple level-dependent parameterisation of $a$ and $b$ provides an accurate and parsimonious reconstruction of the two-dimensional fields. Collectively, these results establish a geometrically transparent and quantitatively predictive framework for the two-dimensional organisation of wall-attached motions in the logarithmic region, extending attached-eddy concepts beyond traditional one-dimensional formulations.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Figure 1 long description.Conceptual schematic of the attached-eddy picture for wall-bounded turbulence. (a) Inclined wall-attached eddies, represented as parallelograms (schematic, not to scale) in the (x$x$, z$z$) plane, where x$x$ and z$z$ denote the streamwise and wall-normal directions. Three hierarchical levels are indicated by increasing shades of red; the blue shaded regions illustrate their cumulative influence at a given height. The inclination reflects the observed tilt of coherent motions between two wall-normal locations. (b) Plan view of the logarithmic region in the (x$x$, y$y$) plane, where y$y$ is the spanwise direction. A random superposition of eddies of different sizes illustrates the hierarchical organisation; colours denote different wall-normal extents.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Figure 2 long description.One-dimensional projections of the equal-height second-order structure function in the logarithmic region: (a, b) Reτ=1000$Re_\tau =1000$; (c, d) Reτ=5200$Re_\tau =5200$. (a,c) S2(rx,0;z)$S_2(r_x,0;z)$ versus rx/z$r_x/z$; (b,d) S2(0,ry;z)$S_2(0,r_y;z)$ versus ry/z$r_y/z$. Colours denote different wall-normal locations z+$z^+$ within the logarithmic layer (see § 2). Black dashed lines show least-squares fits of S2$S_2$ against ln⁡(ri/z)$\ln (r_i/z)$ over the interval 2⩽S2⩽4$2\leqslant S_2 \leqslant 4$; the fitted slope P$P$ (to be compared with the asymptotic prediction P=2A1=2.5$P=2A_1=2.5$) is indicated in each panel.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Figure 3 long description.Contours of the 1-D projections of the equal-height second-order structure function in the (ri/δ,z/δ)$(r_i/\delta ,\,z/\delta )$ plane (log–log axes): S2(rx,0;z)$S_2(r_x,0;z)$ (left column) and S2(0,ry;z)$S_2(0,r_y;z)$ (right column). Panels (a, b) correspond to Reτ=1000$Re_\tau =1000$ and (c, d) to Reτ=5200$Re_\tau =5200$. The green dashed guides have unit slope and indicate ri∝z$r_i\propto z$ (i.e. constant ri/z$r_i/z$), which is the expected organisation of iso-levels in the logarithmic branches of (3.9)–(3.10).

Figure 3

Figure 4.Figure 4 long description.Equal-height 2-D structure function S2(rx,ry;z)$S_{2}(r_x,r_y;z)$ at z/δ=0.10$z/\delta =0.10$ for (a) Reτ=1000$Re_\tau =1000$ and (b) Reτ=5200$Re_\tau =5200$. Shaded contours show DNS iso-levels S2=2,3,4,5,6$S_{2}=2,3,4,5,6$. Dashed curves are the corresponding iso-ellipses obtained from (3.11), with the parameters inferred from the 1-D projections at the same z$z$ (figure 2) and with no additional tuning.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Figure 5 long description.Schematic of the elliptic closure for the equal-height structure function. (a) Conceptual level surface of S2$S_2$ (grey) in the space (rx/δ,ry/δ,z/δ)$(r_x/\delta ,r_y/\delta ,z/\delta )$, intersected by a horizontal plane at fixed z$z$ (purple). (b) Plan view of the intersection in the (rx,ry)$(r_x,r_y)$ plane, which is an ellipse with semi-axes a$a$ and b$b$. For a prescribed level D⋆$D^\star$ in the intermediate range, (3.11) gives (rx/a)2+(ry/b)2=1$(r_x/a)^2+(r_y/b)^2=1$ with b/a=R$b/a=R$, and the intercepts on the coordinate axes recover the 1-D reductions (3.9)–(3.10). The gradual flattening of the dashed contour at large ri/δ$r_i/\delta$ indicates the onset of the outer cutoff, i.e. the approach to the plateau enforced by (3.8).

Figure 5

Figure 6.Figure 6 long description.Ellipse metrics extracted from iso-levels of the equal-height structure function. (a) Streamwise semi-axis a$a$ normalised by z$z$ at the level D⋆=2$D^\star =2$ versus z/δ$z/\delta$; (b) spanwise semi-axis b/z$b/z$ at D⋆=2$D^\star =2$ versus z/δ$z/\delta$. Squares: Reτ=1000$Re_\tau =1000$; circles: Reτ=5200$Re_\tau =5200$. Shaded bands indicate the logarithmic-region windows used for averaging: 0.095$0.095\lt z/\delta \lt 0.15$ for Reτ=1000$Re_\tau =1000$ and 0.0416$0.0416\lt z/\delta \lt 0.15$ for Reτ=5200$Re_\tau =5200$; horizontal lines show the corresponding window means. (c) Coupling between departures of a/z$a/z$ and b/z$b/z$ quantified by kab(z)≡dln⁡(b/z)/dln⁡(a/z)$k_{ab}(z)\equiv \mathrm{d}\ln (b/z)/\mathrm{d}\ln (a/z)$; dotted/dashed lines denote window-averaged values over the same intervals. (d) Window-averaged axes M(a)≡⟨a/z⟩$M(a)\equiv \langle a/z\rangle$ and M(b)≡⟨b/z⟩$M(b)\equiv \langle b/z\rangle$ as functions of level D⋆$D^\star$, together with least-squares fits of (4.2) (labelled Fa$F_a$ and Fb$F_b$). Triangles in (a, b) indicate the corresponding axis intercepts inferred independently from the 1-D projections at the same level.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Figure 7 long description.Validation of the elliptic closure using the parameterised semi-axes. (a, d) Predicted iso-surfaces of the equal-height structure function at levels D⋆=2,3,4$D^\star =2,3,4$ (grey shades; darker indicates larger D⋆$D^\star$) for Reτ=1000$Re_\tau =1000$ and 5200$5200$, respectively. The surfaces are constructed by combining the fitted semi-axes (4.3a)–(4.3b) with the elliptic level-set relation in (3.11). Semi-transparent purple planes mark the slice heights z/δ=0.10$z/\delta =0.10$ and 0.12$0.12$. (b, c, e, f) Wall-parallel slices at the indicated heights: DNS iso-contours at D⋆=2,3,4$D^\star =2,3,4$ are shown in purple, and the corresponding predictions are shown as black dashed ellipses.

Figure 7

Table 1.Coefficients of the base-10 fits (4.2) obtained over the logarithmic-region windows used in figure 6. Here, D⋆$D^\star$ is a contour level of the dimensionless structure function S2$S_2$, and M(a)=⟨a/z⟩$M(a)=\langle a/z\rangle$ and M(b)=⟨b/z⟩$M(b)=\langle b/z\rangle$ are also dimensionless quantities; therefore, Ca1$C_{a1}$, Ca2$C_{a2}$, Cb1$C_{b1}$ and Cb2$C_{b2}$ are all dimensionless coefficients. In the ideal asymptote, one would expect equal slopes Ca1=Cb1=1/(2A1ln⁡10)$C_{a1}=C_{b1}=1/(2A_1\ln 10)$ and an offset Cb2−Ca2=log10⁡(b/a)$C_{b2}-C_{a2}=\log _{10}(b/a)$; departures quantify finite-Reτ$Re_\tau$ effects in the extracted axis ratios.

Figure 8

Table 2.Quantitative comparison between the parameterised elliptic prediction and the DNS iso-contours at the representative contour levels D⋆=2,3,4$D^\star =2,3,4$. The error metrics are reported for two representative wall distances, z/δ≈0.10$z/\delta \approx 0.10$ and 0.12$0.12$, and for both Reynolds numbers. Here, Er,mean$E_{r,\textit{mean}}$ and Er,max$E_{r,\textit{max} }$ denote the mean and maximum normalised radial deviations, and IoU$\mathrm{IoU}$ is the area-overlap ratio in the first quadrant.Table 2 long description.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Figure 8 long description.Effective logarithmic slopes extracted from the 1-D projections of the equal-height structure function. (a) Streamwise coefficient Px$P_x$ versus Reτ$Re_\tau$; (b) spanwise coefficient Py$P_y$ versus Reτ$Re_\tau$. The DNS slopes obtained from least-squares fits of S2$S_2$ against ln⁡(ri/z)$\ln (r_i/z)$ using a fixed-level window D⋆∈[2,4]$D^\star \in [2,4]$ are shown by circles in (a) and triangles in (b). The DNS fits over the geometric window 1$1\lt r_i/z\lt 10$ are shown by stars in (a) and diamonds in (b). Dark markers reproduce the compilation of Yang et al. (2017) over the same geometric window; the black star with error bar in (a) is an atmospheric surface-layer estimate over 1$1\lt r_x/z\lt 10$. The horizontal dashed line indicates the asymptotic slope P=2A1$P=2A_1$ implied by the attached-eddy counting argument in the logarithmic branch (see § 3).