Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T02:17:17.067Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Collapse of transitional wall turbulence captured using a rare events algorithm

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 November 2021

Joran Rolland*
Affiliation:
Laboratoire de Physique à l'ENS de Lyon, UMR CNRS 5672, Univ. Lyon, Univ. Claude Bernard Lyon 1, FranceUMR CNRS 9014 - LMFL - Laboratoire de Mécanique des Fluides de Lille - Kampé de Fériet, Univ. Lille, Centrale Lille, ENSAM, ONERA, France
*
†Email address for correspondence: joran.rolland@centralelille.fr

Abstract

This text presents one of the first successful applications of a rare events sampling method for the study of multistability in a turbulent flow without stochastic energy injection. The trajectories of collapse of turbulence in plane Couette flow, and their probability and rate of occurrence are systematically computed using adaptive multilevel splitting (AMS). The AMS computations are performed in a system of size $L_x\times L_z=24\times 18$ at Reynolds number $R=370$ with an acceleration by a factor ${O}(10)$ with respect to direct numerical simulations (DNS) and in a system of size $L_x\times L_z=36\times 27$ at Reynolds number $R=377$ with an acceleration by a factor ${O}(10^3)$. The AMS results are validated by a comparison with DNS in the smaller system. Visualisations indicate that turbulence collapses because the self-sustaining process of turbulence fails locally. The streamwise vortices decay first in streamwise elongated holes, leaving streamwise invariant streamwise velocity tubes that experience viscous decay. These holes then extend in the spanwise direction. The examination of more than a thousand trajectories in the $(E_{k,x}=\int u_x^2/2\,\textrm {d}^3\boldsymbol {x},E_{k,y-z}=\int (u_y^2/2+u_z^2/2)\,\textrm {d}^3\boldsymbol {x})$ plane in the smaller system confirms the faster decay of streamwise vortices and shows concentration of trajectories. This hints at an instanton phenomenology in the large size limit. The computation of turning point states, beyond which laminarisation is certain, confirms the hole formation scenario and shows that it is more pronounced in larger systems. Finally, the examination of non-reactive trajectories indicates that both the vortices and the streaks reform concomitantly when the laminar holes close.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Overview of transition to turbulence: the bottom axis indicates the Reynolds number and the text on the top indicates typical states. The left panel (a) displays a sketch of plane Couette flow. The middle panel (b) displays colour levels of the kinetic energy density in a $y=0$ plane at $R=370$, showing banded laminar turbulent coexistence. The green box indicates a domain of size $L_x\times L_z=36\times 27$, the blue box indicates a domain of size $L_x\times L_z= 24\times 18$. The right panel (c) displays colour levels of the kinetic energy in a $y=0$ plane at $R=500$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) Sketch of two bistable states $\mathcal {A}$ and $\mathcal {B}$ and the hypersurface $\mathcal {C}$ closely surrounding $\mathcal {A}$. Two realisations of the dynamics are sketched: a single excursion in blue and a first passage trajectory in black and red. The red part of the first passage trajectory is the reactive trajectory (figure originally made for Rolland & Simonnet 2015). (b) Sketch of the principle of AMS, showing two iterations of the algorithm, with $N=3$ clones, indicating the starting state $\mathcal {A}$ and its neighbourhood, the arrival state and its neighbourhood $\mathcal {B}$, three trajectories are ordered by their $\max _t\varPhi$. Trajectory one (dashed blue line) is suppressed and branched on another trajectory at level $\max _t\varPhi _1$ and then ran according to its natural dynamics. Trajectory $2$ is then suppressed and branched on 3 at level $\max _t\varPhi _2$ (figure originally made for Simonnet 2016). (c) Two examples of anticipation of branching level of reaction coordinate as a function of maximum reaction coordinate reached by suppressed trajectories $\varPhi _{N_c}(\varPhi _b)$ tested in anticipated branching (see Appendix A, (A1), (A2) for details, both examples use a parameter $\xi =0.25$).

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Example of a time series of kinetic energy in a domain of size $L_x\times L_z=24\times 18$ at Reynolds number $R=370$. The black dashed lines indicate where the sampling is stopped for the construction of the empirical probability density function of kinetic energy conditioned to not collapse. (b) Conditional average of the kinetic energy as a function of the Reynolds number for domains of size $L_x \times L_z=24\times 18$, $L_x\times L_z=36\times 27$. (c) Conditional variance of the kinetic energy as a function of the Reynolds number for domains of size $L_x \times L_z=24\times 18$, $L_x\times L_z=36\times 27$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Time series of the kinetic energy (a,d,g,j) with a dot indicating the point in time of each line ($t=50$, $t=174$, $t=200$, $t=400$), alongside colour levels of the streamwise velocity (b,e,h,k) and spanwise velocity (c,f,i,l), at corresponding times, in the midplane $y=0$ during a collapse trajectory in a domain of size $L_x\times L_z=24\times 18$ computed by AMS.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Time series of the kinetic energy (a,d,g,j,m) with a dot indicating the point in time of each line ($t=2$, $t=74$, $t=200$, $t=400$, $t=600$), alongside colour levels of the streamwise velocity (b,e,h,k,n) and spanwise velocity (c,f,i,l,o) in the midplane $y=0$ during a non-reactive trajectory (hole opening then closing), at corresponding times, in a domain of size $L_x\times L_z=24\times 18$ computed by AMS.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Streamwise vorticity in the midplane $y=0$ in the system of size $L_x\times L_z=24\times 18$ for last states at the last branching stage of several AMS computations. (a) Run estimating $\hat {\alpha }=0.045$, $\hat {T}=1.5\times 10^4$, (b) run estimating $\hat {\alpha }=0.086$, $\hat {T}=1.1\times 10^4$, (c) run estimating $\hat {\alpha }=0.022$, $\hat {T}=3.7\times 10^4$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Normalised distribution of duration of collapse trajectories (in logarithmic scale) sampled by AMS ($1590$ samples), by DNS ($189$ samples) and compared with a normalised Gumbel distribution, in a system of size $L_x\times L_z=24\times 18$ at Reynolds number $R=370$.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Probability density functions in the $(E_{k,x},E_{k,y-z})$ plane, conditioned on being in a collapse trajectory, for (a) trajectories from free DNS, (b) trajectories from noisy DNS, (c) 1138 trajectories from AMS. (d) Conditional average trajectories and their variances.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Logarithm of the cumulated distribution of waiting times in noiseless and noisy DNS for $L_x\times L_z=24\times 18$, $R=370$. We add the two linear functions $-t/\langle T\rangle$ for comparison.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Histograms of $T$ (a) and $\alpha$ (b) sampled by AMS in the system of size $L_x\times L_z=24\times 18$, at Reynolds number $R=370$.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Colour levels of the streamwise (a), wall normal (b) and spanwise (c) components of the velocity field, in the $y=0$, ($\boldsymbol {e}_x, \boldsymbol {e}_z$) plane for the last stage at the last branching step in an AMS computation of collapse trajectories at $R=377$ in a domain of size $L_x\times L_z=36\times$, along with (d) the streamwise vorticity. (e) Colour levels of streamwise averaged streamwise velocity as a function of $y$ and $z$ for the same state.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Following a collapse trajectory in a domain of size $L_x\times L_z=36\times 27$, $R=377$. (a,d,g,j,m,p,s) Show a time series of kinetic energy, with the dot indicating the instant at which the colour levels of streamwise velocity in the $y=0$ plane (b,e,h,k,n,q,t) and spanwise velocity (c,f,i,l,o,r,u) at corresponding times in the $y=0$ plane are shown. A movie of this collapse trajectory is provided in the supplementary material available at https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2021.957.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Following a non-reactive trajectory (hole opening then closing) in a domain of size $L_x\times L_z=36\times 27$, $R=377$. (a,d,g,j,m,p,s) Show a time series of kinetic energy, with the dot indicating the instant at which the colour levels of streamwise velocity in the $y=0$ plane (b,e,h,k,n,q,t) and spanwise velocity (c,f,i,l,o,r,u) at corresponding times in the $y=0$ plane are shown. A movie of this non-reactive trajectory is provided in the supplementary material.

Figure 13

Figure 14.Contours of $\sqrt {\int _{x=0}^{36}u_z^2\,\textrm {d}x-( \int _{x=0}^{36}u_z\,\textrm {d}x)^2}=0.03$ and $\sqrt {\int _{x=0}^{36}u_x^2\,\textrm {d}x}=0.15$ as a function of $z$ and $t$ for (a) the collapse trajectory of figure 12 and (b) the non-reactive trajectory of figure 13.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Time series of $\varPhi$ during an AMS calculation with the $24\times 16$ system leading to extinction (the laminar state corresponds to $\phi \ge 1$). The black line indicates the end of the stage 0 of AMS and the red line the maximal $\phi =0.248\pm 0.001$ reached during this stage (‘contained in the initial conditions’). The green line indicates the maximum $\phi =0.430\pm 0.001$ reached during the whole AMS calculation.

Figure 15

Figure 16.Collapse of turbulence in a very small system of size $L_x\times L_z=12\times 8$. (a,d,g,j) Time series of kinetic energy with dot indicating the instant in the simulation. (b,e,h,k) Colour levels of streamwise velocity in the horizontal midplane. (c,f,i,l) Colour levels of spanwise velocity in the horizontal midplane.

Rolland supplementary movie 1

See pdf file for movie caption

Download Rolland supplementary movie 1(Video)
Video 1.6 MB

Rolland supplementary movie 2

See pdf file for movie caption

Download Rolland supplementary movie 2(Video)
Video 1.2 MB
Supplementary material: PDF

Rolland supplementary material

Captions for movies 1-2
Download Rolland supplementary material(PDF)
PDF 12.9 KB