Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T12:45:23.729Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Dependence of wake structure on pitching frequency behind a thin panel at $Re=1000$

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 August 2021

Arnab Kumar De
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati, Assam 781039, India
Sandip Sarkar*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Jadavpur University, Kolkata 700032, India
*

Abstract

We perform computations of wake transition behind a pitching panel using an immersed boundary-based method. At a Reynolds number $Re=1000$, simulations are carried out over a wide range of pitching frequencies in the Strouhal number ($St$) range $0.2\leqslant St \leqslant 2$, for two different aspect ratio panels, given by 0.54 and 2.38. Our results reveal appearances of a reverse von Kármán vortex street at a moderate pitching frequency, which bifurcates into two distinct branches connected by strands at higher Strouhal number. In addition, the larger-aspect-ratio panel exhibits an avalanche of large, tangled three-dimensional vortex structures for $St\geqslant 1.5$. We observe strong spanwise wake compression, for the larger-aspect-ratio panel, greatly influencing the secondary instabilities at increased pitching frequency. However, no direct relationship between the growth of secondary instabilities and the spanwise pressure gradient can be established. We show that an increase in $St$ leads to a stable central region and renders a larger concentration of small-scale structures at the jet plane. The continuous wavelet transform shows complete synchronisation of the shed structure with the pitching Strouhal number of the low-aspect-ratio panel. The spectral characteristic for the high-aspect-ratio panel at $St=1$ is found to be dominated by a narrow band of low-frequency cells. We observed the period-doubling phenomena in the spanwise cells during space–time reconstruction of the velocity signals. For the present ranges of $St$, both thrust and lift signals reveal a constant amplitude oscillation, the latter being double, in magnitude, the former. Both root-mean-squared thrust and lift coefficients grow with $St$ and aspect ratio.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.List of previous studies for 3-D rigid pitching of rectangular panels. Here $N_x,N_y,N_z$ are grids used in the numerical studies with lengths $L_x,L_y,L_z$. Note, few available 3-D numerical studies on pitching, heaving and plunging motions are mentioned together, whereas the present study primarily focused on the pitching motion only.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Schematic diagram showing a uniform flow past a rigid panel pitching about the leading edge with the extent of the domain. The variation of spatial grid resolution normalised by minimum mesh sizes $( \Delta x,\Delta y,\Delta z )_{min}$ along $x$, $y$ and $z$ directions are shown at the right-hand-side panel. In the inset, panel geometry is shown in all the three planes.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Mesh convergence test results for four successively refined mesh sizes $M_1$, $M_2$, $M_3$ and $M_4$ at $AR=0.54$, $St=0.6$. (a) Temporal evolution of the coefficients of lift $C_L$ and drag $C_D$. (b) Perspective views of the 3-D instantaneous vortical structures visualised by the $Q$-criterion ($Q=1$). (c) Variations of time-averaged streamwise velocity $\langle u \rangle$ in the cross-stream $(y)$ direction. (d) Variations of time-averaged spanwise velocity $\langle w \rangle$ in the spanwise $(z)$ direction. Panels (a), (c) and (d) have the same legends. Comparison of the present numerical set-up with Borazjani & Sotiropoulos (2009) for vortex-induced vibrations of a pair of rigid cylinders with (e) time evolution of the centroids of the upstream $(y_F)$ and downstream $(y_R)$ cylinders and (f) instantaneous spanwise vorticity $(\omega _{z}=\pm 1)$ iso-surfaces.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Influence of $St$ on the wake vortex topology past a rigid pitching panel for $AR=0.54$ and $AR=2.38$. All 3-D perspective views of the vortical structures are visualised by plotting $Q$-criterion with $Q=1$. Note, all the instantaneous $Q$-criterion structures are shown at the same dimensionless instant.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Perspective views of the 3-D periodic vortex shedding cycle showing $Q=1$ surfaces at $AR=0.54$ for $St=0.6$ and 1. The temporal evolution of vortices from the trailing edge of the panel is shown in the instances (a–f) indicated on the time series of ${C_T}$, ${C_L}$ and $\theta$ in the insets.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Perspective views of the 3-D periodic vortex shedding cycle with $Q=1$ surfaces at $AR=2.38$ for $St=0.6$ and 1. In the insets, the temporal evolution of vortices from the trailing edge is shown in the instances (a–f) indicated on the time series of ${C_T}$, ${C_L}$ and $\theta$.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Dimensionless wake circulation along the spanwise $(\varGamma _z)$ and streamwise $(\varGamma _x)$ directions for various $St$. Results are shown at aspect ratios of (a,c) 0.54 and (b,d) 2.38, respectively. The proportionate panel dimensions corroborating each aspect ratio are also indicated.

Figure 7

Figure 7.(a) The influence of $St$ on the dimensionless spanwise circulation for various spanwise locations corresponding to different aspect ratios. (b) The effect of $St$ on the maximum dimensionless streamwise circulation $(\varGamma _{x,max})$ for different aspect ratios.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Streakline visualisations of the flow for $AR=0.54$ and at different $St$. The plan view of the motion is shown in (a–c) ($y=0$ plane), whereas (d–f) show an end view of the motion ($z=0$ plane). The strong secondary motions are noticed from the plan view, which shows progressive wake compression with increase in $St$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Streakline visualisations for $AR=2.38$ and at different $St$. The plan view of the motion ($y=0$ plane) is shown in (a–c), whereas (d–f) show an end view ($z=0$ plane) of the motion.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Isocontour lines of time-averaged spanwise pressure gradient $(\textrm {d}p/\textrm {d}z)$ superimposed on the colour map of the time-averaged spanwise velocity for (a) $St=0.6$, (b) $St=1.5$, (c) $St=2.0$ for $AR=0.54$ and (d) $St=0.6$, (e) $St=1.5$, (f) $St=2.0$ for $AR=2.38$.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Time-averaged spanwise velocity $(\langle w\rangle )$ distribution in the streamwise direction $(x)$ for different $St$ and at a spanwise location of $y=0$, $z=-S/2$ (a,c). Time-averaged spanwise velocity $(\langle w\rangle )$ distribution in the spanwise direction $(z)$ for different $St$ and at a streamwise location of $x=1.5$, $y=0$; the inset shows values at $x=5$, $y=0$ (b,d). The top and bottom figures show results for $AR=0.54$ and $2.38$.

Figure 12

Figure 12.The CWT of the $y-$velocity signals $(v)$ at a sampling location of $(2C,0,0)$. For the various $St$, CWT results are shown at $AR=0.54$ (a–d) and $AR=2.38$ (e–h) with each panel containing the source time series and CWT map. The colour map of the coefficients normalised by the global maximum is shown in the time-pseudo-frequency domain, $t-f$, depicting the influence of $St$ on the localised frequency concentration.

Figure 13

Figure 13.The CWT of the cross-stream velocity signals $(v)$ at a sampling location of $(2C,-y_{max},0)$. For various $St$, CWT results are shown at $AR=0.54$ (a–d) and $AR=2.38$ (e–h) with each panel containing the source time series and CWT map. The colour map of the coefficients normalised by the global maximum is shown in the time-pseudo-frequency domain, $t-f$, depicting the influence of $St$ on the localised frequency concentration.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Space–time reconstruction of the vertical velocity $(v)$ in the streamwise direction at a vertical section $y=A/2$ on the midspan plane $z=0$. Note that while the $x$-axis represents the streamwise direction, the time evolution is displayed in the $y$ direction.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Space–time reconstruction of the spanwise velocity $(w)$ along the span at a downstream section $x=1.5$ on the mid-vertical plane $y=0$. Note that while the $y$-axis represents the span, the time evolution is displayed in the $x$ direction.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Instantaneous 2-D vorticity contours in the $x$–$y$ plane $(\omega _z)$ for different Strouhal numbers; (a) corresponds to $AR=0.54$ and (b) corresponds to $AR=2.38$.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Instantaneous planar view of streamwise vorticity contours $(\omega _x)$ at various transverse planes (y–z) at $AR=0.54$ for $St=1$ (left panel) and $St=2$ (right panel). Interactions between vortices shown at cross-sectional planes (a–j) designate $1.2\leqslant {x}/{C}\leqslant 5.5$ with $\Delta x/{C}\approx 0.4$.

Figure 18

Figure 18.Planar view of instantaneous streamwise vorticity contours $(\omega _x)$ at various transverse planes at $AR=2.38$ for $St=1$ (left panel) and $St=2$ (right panel). Vortex interactions are shown at cross-sectional planes (a–j) designate $1.2\leqslant {x}/{C}\leqslant 5.5$ with ${\Delta x}/{C}\approx 0.4$.

Figure 19

Figure 19.Time histories of the thrust $(C_T)$ and lift $(C_L)$ coefficients for different Strouhal numbers, where $T=St^{-1}$. The corresponding $C_T-C_L$ phase portraits are shown in the right-hand panel.

Figure 20

Figure 20.(a) Coefficient of mean thrust $(\overline {C_T})$, mean lift $(\overline {C_L})$ and spanwise mean force coefficient $(\overline {C_Z})$ as a function of $St$ for different aspect ratios. (b) Variations of the r.m.s. thrust $(C_{T}^{\prime })$ and lift $(C_{L}^{\prime })$ coefficients with the Strouhal number for $AR=0.54$, $2.38$, respectively.