Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T23:26:30.942Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The Eckert–Weise effect and energy separation under the flow interference behind side-by-side cylinders

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 March 2021

Andrey I. Aleksyuk*
Affiliation:
Faculty of Mechanics and Mathematics, Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow 119991, Russian FederationInstitute of Mechanics, Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow 119192, Russian FederationWater Problems Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow 119333, Russian Federation
*
†Email address for correspondence: aleksyuk@mech.math.msu.su

Abstract

The total enthalpy of a uniform flow is redistributed behind a thermally insulated body such that a considerable cooling of fluid in terms of total temperature occurs near the wake centreline. This energy separation phenomenon is also observed after time averaging and can lead to the recovery temperature at the rear part of the body becoming lower than the static temperature of the incoming flow (the Eckert–Weise effect). By the numerical solution of the Navier–Stokes equations, the present work studies energy separation in the wake, the Eckert–Weise effect and their sensitivity on the flow interference behind side-by-side cylinders. The considered distances between the cylinders cover the key regimes of interference: single, bistable and coupled vortex streets. The first and second regimes amplify the efficiency of energy separation in the wake and the intensity of the Eckert–Weise effect, respectively. In the developed wake, a clear relation between the vortex structure and the total enthalpy redistribution is demonstrated as well as a limitation on the intensity of this redistribution imposed by the deficit of velocity. The connection of the Eckert–Weise effect with the vortex formation process is clarified. Among the mechanisms changing the total enthalpy in fluid particles, the non-stationarity of pressure defines the averaged distribution: the decrease of pressure in forming vortices is mainly responsible for the cooling of fluid behind the body. The balance with the heating of the rear surface by the involvement of fluid from the sides defines the intensity of the effect.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Side-by-side arrangement of two circular cylinders in a cross-flow.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Influence of temporal ($\Delta t$) and spatial (mesh M-1 has twice the cell size than mesh M-2) resolution on the coefficients of drag $C_D(t)$ (a) and lift $C_L(t)$ (b), and on the time-averaged distribution of $\overline {I_0}$ (c) at $Re=10^3$ and ${M_{\infty }}=0.4$. Aerodynamic coefficients in panels (a) and (b) for the upper and lower cylinders are shown in red and black, respectively; lines of the same type in panel (c) show contour levels $\overline {I_0}=-0.005, -0.015,\ldots , -0.055$ and various line types correspond to different resolutions (see notation to right of the plot).

Figure 2

Figure 3.Computational mesh: (a) schematic representation of nested subregions with different sizes of triangular elements (table 1), denoted by ‘Boundary layer’, ‘Near wake’, ‘Middle wake’ and ‘Far wake’; (b,c) fragments of the mesh M-1 used for calculations at $P/D=1.5$ in the near wake and close to the wall.

Figure 3

Table 1.Parameters of the main meshes. Here, $\varDelta$ is the approximate size of triangular elements of the mesh; $X_{in}$ and $X_{out}$ are the distances from the $y$-axis to the inlet and outlet of the corresponding subdomain; and $H$ is its height. The mesh size near the walls smoothly changes in annular regions from $\varDelta =0.0005$ ($0.002$) at the circle $r=0.5$ ($r=0.55$) to $\varDelta =0.002$ ($0.025$) at $r=0.55$ ($r=0.7$), where $r=\sqrt {x^2+y^2}$.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Qualitative agreement of the experimental and model surface distribution of recovery factors $\overline {r_T}$ (a) and $\overline {r_p}$ (b): the solid red line represents the present calculation; the symbols are the experimental data by Eckert & Weise (1942) ($\square$), Ryan (1951) (${\scriptstyle {\bigcirc} }$) and Nagata et al. (2020a) ($\triangle$); the dashed blue lines correspond to simulations by Singh & Mittal (2005) (an incompressible fluid model). Isentropic theory relations were used to convert $T/T_0$ and $p/p_0$ from Ryan (1951) and pressure coefficient $C_p$ from Nagata et al. (2020a) into $r_T$ and $r_p$ given by (3.1a,b).

Figure 5

Table 2.Comparison of time-averaged aerodynamic coefficients at $Re=200$ and $10^3$ and ${M_{\infty }}=0.1$ with the data of Meneghini et al. (2001), Jester & Kallinderis (2003) and Henderson (1995) (an incompressible flow model was used). In the present work, coefficients are averaged over two cylinders: $\overline {C_D}=0.5(\overline {C_{D1}}+\overline {C_{D2}})$, $|\overline {C_L}|=0.5(|\overline {C_{L1}}|+|\overline {C_{L2}}|)$ and $\Delta C_L=0.5(\Delta C_{L1}+\Delta C_{L2})$, where $\Delta C_{L1}$ and $\Delta C_{L2}$ are the differences between maximum and average values. The averaged coefficients may differ considerably from the values over one of the cylinders in a biased regime due to flow asymmetry. Two values for both cylinders at $P/D=1.5$ and $Re=10^3$ are given in (Jester & Kallinderis 2003) and divided by the forward slash in the table; in other cases the data (Meneghini et al.2001; Jester & Kallinderis 2003) are identical for both cylinders.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Redistribution of total enthalpy in the flow behind a single cylinder. (a) Schematic division of a time-averaged flow into two parts (by bold streamlines) and the key cooling/heating subregions in the time-averaged flow. (b) Examples of calculated instantaneous and time-averaged distributions of $I_0$ at $Re=10^3$ and ${M_{\infty }}=0.4$. The regions restricted by the dashed lines correspond to the most significant decay (blue colour) and growth (red colour) of $I_0$.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Similarity of the distributions of time-averaged velocity component $\bar {u}$ and total enthalpy $\overline {i_0}$: (a–c) the present calculation results for side-by-side arrangements of cylinders at $\textit {Re}=10^3$, ${M_{\infty }}=0.4$ and $P/D = 1.5$ (a,b) and 4 (c); and (d) the experimental data adopted from Goldstein & Kulkarni (2008) for a single cylinder at $\textit {Re}=9.2\times 10^4$ and ${M_{\infty }}=0.22$ ($u_\infty$ was corrected to correspond to the velocity outside the wake). Black solid lines (black squares) and dashed red lines (red circles) correspond to the profiles of $\overline {i_0}-i_{0\infty }$ and $k(\bar {u}-1)$. In panel (a) contour levels are the same for $\overline {i_0}-i_{0\infty }$ and $k(\bar {u}-1)$ at $k=0.71$ (these levels are $-0.15, -0.25, \ldots , -0.85$).

Figure 8

Figure 7.Distributions of vorticity (a) and normalised temperature $(T-T_\infty )/T_\infty$ (b) behind an isolated cylinder at $\textit {Re}=10^3$ and ${M_{\infty }}=0.4$.

Figure 9

Figure 8.The influence of the distance between cylinders on the distribution of time-averaged total enthalpy at $\textit {Re}=200$ and ${M_{\infty }}=0.1$, 0.4 and 0.8: (a) $\overline {I_0}$ and instantaneous wake patterns shown by the stripes of vorticity $0.7\leqslant |\omega |\leqslant 1.3$ (blue and red colours correspond to negative and positive values of $\omega$, respectively); and (b) efficiency of energy separation $E$ at the lower cylinder surface, the formation region and the developed wake ($E=|\min _{(x,y)} \overline {I_0}|$ is a local minimum); and integral efficiency $\hat {E}$ given by (4.13) and shown by horizontal red lines. Symbols in the grey circles denote the regime of interference: S, single vortex street; B, bistable vortex street; ${B}^*$, bistable vortex street, if the jet biased towards one of the wakes is not observed due to compressibility effects; and C, coupled vortex streets.

Figure 10

Figure 9.The influence of the distance between cylinders on the distribution of time-averaged total enthalpy at $\textit {Re}=10^3$ and ${M_{\infty }}=0.1$, 0.4 and 0.8: (a) $\overline {I_0}$ and instantaneous wake patterns shown by the stripes of vorticity $0.5\leqslant |\omega |\leqslant 1.5$ (blue and red colours correspond to negative and positive values of $\omega$, respectively); (b) efficiency of energy separation $E$ at the lower cylinder surface, the formation region and the developed wake ($E=|\min _{(x,y)} \overline {I_0}|$ is a local minimum); and integral efficiency $\hat {E}$ given by (4.13) and shown by horizontal red lines. Symbols in the grey circles denote the regime of interference: S, single vortex street; B, bistable vortex street; ${B}^*$, bistable vortex street, if the jet biased towards one of the wakes is not observed due to compressibility effects; C, coupled vortex streets; and ${C}^*$, coupled vortex streets, in the absence of synchronisation or for a shifted one.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Shock wave patterns at ${M_{\infty }}=0.8$: normalised pressure distribution $(p-p_\infty )/p_\infty$ (in grey), positive pressure gradients along streamlines (in blue) and lines of constant vorticity ($\omega =\pm 1$) at $\textit {Re}=200$ (a) and $\textit {Re}=10^3$ (b). Regions of positive pressure gradients along streamlines are highlighted using the expression ${M}(\boldsymbol {u}/|\boldsymbol {u}|)\boldsymbol {\cdot }(\boldsymbol {\nabla }{p}/p)$, where ${M}$ is the local Mach number. Limit values on the colour maps are not maxima and minima of functions: function values greater than the upper limit (or less than the lower limit) are filled with one colour corresponding to this limit.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Distributions of $I_0$ and $r_p$ in the formation region behind an isolated cylinder at $\textit {Re}=10^3$ and ${M_{\infty }}=0.4$ and approximately equidistant times $t_i$, such that $t_5-t_1$ is half of the vortex shedding period. Dashed lines with arrows schematically represent the streamlines; the grey area inside the cylinder shows the pressure distribution over the surface; the black dots on the body surface are extrema of time-averaged functions $\overline {I_0}(\theta )$ ($I_0$ plots) and $\overline {r_p}(\theta )$ ($r_p$ plots); and the small insets show the instantaneous vorticity pattern in the near wake.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Example of instantaneous distribution of mechanisms $\mathcal {C}$, $\mathcal {P}$, $\mathcal {A}$ and $\mathcal {Q}$ responsible for the growth (positive values) and decay (negative values) of $i_0$ (see (5.2)). The time corresponds to $t=t_1$ in figure 11. The solid lines are lines of constant vorticity $\omega =\pm \text {const}$.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Recovery factor $\overline {r_T}$ over the surface of the lower cylinder at various $\textit {Re}$ and ${M_{\infty }}$.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Distributions of $I_0$ and $r_p$ in the formation region behind side-by-side cylinders at $\textit {Re}=10^3$, ${M_{\infty }}=0.4$, $P/D=1.1$ and approximately equidistant times $t_i$. Dashed lines with arrows schematically represent the streamlines; the grey area inside the cylinder shows the pressure distribution over the surface; and the small insets show the instantaneous vorticity pattern in the near wake.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Distributions of $I_0$ and $r_p$ in the formation region behind side-by-side cylinders at $\textit {Re}=10^3$, ${M_{\infty }}=0.4$, $P/D=1.5$ and approximately equidistant times $t_i$. Dashed lines with arrows schematically represent the streamlines; the grey area inside the cylinder shows the pressure distribution over the surface; and the small insets show the instantaneous vorticity pattern in the near wake.