Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T01:10:55.066Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Experimental data for solid–liquid flows at intermediate and high Stokes numbers

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 November 2019

Sarah E. Mena*
Affiliation:
Chemical Engineering Department, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL32611, USA
Jennifer Sinclair Curtis
Affiliation:
Chemical Engineering Department, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL32611, USACollege of Engineering, University of California, Davis, CA95616, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: sarah.mena@psri.org

Abstract

Experimental data for turbulent solid–liquid flow in a vertical pipe were collected for glass beads with diameters from 0.5 mm to 5 mm, at concentrations up to 2 % v/v, and Reynolds numbers from 200 000 to 350 000. In addition, data for crushed glass, steel shot and two sizes of stainless-steel cylinders were also collected. The experiments span from the intermediate to the inertia-dominated regimes, and the results include direct measurements for the pressure drops, the solids concentration and the three velocity components for each of the phases using laser Doppler velocimetry and phase Doppler anemometry. In addition, the results include the Reynolds stresses, the granular temperature, the kinetic energy and calculations for the turbulence modulation. The results show augmentation of turbulence for all the conditions studied. The velocity fluctuations for the solid and the liquid are reduced with increasing Reynolds numbers at all conditions. The Reynolds number dictates the behaviour of the relative velocity with concentration: for the Reynolds number of 350 000, the relative velocity increases with increasing concentrations, which can be explained by a decrease in the solid shear and an increase in the solid-phase pressure with rising concentration. In contrast, for the Reynolds number of 200 000, the relative velocity decreases with increasing concentrations, which can be attributed to an increase in drag force at higher concentration. The unique dataset presented begins to close the gap in knowledge for two-phase flow experimentation at concentrations above 0.7 % v/v and Reynolds numbers above 30 000.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© 2019 Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Experimental data previously published in Journal of Fluid Mechanics for solid–fluid flows. The $x$-axis is the log of the solids concentration (% v/v) and the $y$-axis is the Stokes number.

Figure 1

Table 1.List of variables measured at each of the experimental conditions: $d_{p}$, particle diameter; $u$, axial mean and fluctuating velocity; $v$, radial mean and fluctuating velocity; $w$, theta mean and fluctuating velocity; and $\unicode[STIX]{x0394}P$, pressure drop. Subscript ‘$l$’ is for liquid and ‘$s$’ for solid. The Reynolds $(Re)$ and Stokes $(St)$ numbers are based on the pipe diameter and the bulk liquid axial velocity $(\boldsymbol{u}_{b})$ in the presence of the particles $(\boldsymbol{u}_{c}=1.2\boldsymbol{u}_{b})$, where $u_{c}$ is the liquid centreline velocity. For the particle Reynolds number $(Re_{p})$, the relative velocity at the centreline was used. A value of $1.002\times 10^{-6}~\text{m}^{2}~\text{s}^{-1}$ was used for the kinematic viscosity of water.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Pictures of the particles used in the present study: (a) 2 mm spherical beads; (b) 2 mm crushed glass; (c) $1~\text{mm}\times 1~\text{mm}$ cylinders; (d) $0.5~\text{mm}\times 4~\text{mm}$ cylinders; and (e) 1 mm steel shot.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Diagram of the pilot-scale flow loop. Blue arrows indicate the flow direction, $L$ is the vertical position in the pipe and $D$ is the pipe diameter. (1) Centrifugal pump, (2) venturi eductor, (3) electromagnetic flow meter (used during single-phase operation only), (4) developmental section, (5) pressure transducers separated five pipe diameters from each other, (6) test section, (7) three-way-valve bypass, (8) sampling tank (not present during the velocity measurements), (9) solids separation unit and (10) water tank. Inset: FEP test section showing the compensating box and the dual-beam LDV.

Figure 4

Table 2.Phase discrimination techniques used in the study of two-phase flows.

Figure 5

Figure 4.Comparison of the LDV signal intensity for a flow at $Re=200\,000$ as measured by the LDV in a backscattered configuration at the pipe centre for a (a) single-phase flow and a (b) two-phase flow with 4 mm particles at 2 % v/v. The dashed line at 500 mV marks the signal intensity level used for the phase discrimination of the solids.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Top view of the test section radius where each velocity component was measured. Also shown is the compensating box used to minimize changes in refractive index and curvature effects.

Figure 7

Table 3.Dimensions for the measuring volume in water for the different focal lenses on the current set-up. Here $x$, $y$ and $z$ represent the Cartesian coordinates with the probe volume situated with its longest dimension along the $y$-axis.

Figure 8

Table 4.LDV and PDA parameters.

Figure 9

Figure 6.Example of a running average for the centreline axial velocity component of the liquid phase: (a) mean velocity and (b) fluctuating velocity. Data for flow with 5 mm particles at $Re=200\,000$ and 0.7 % v/v. The mean of the velocity for 400 points is $3.05~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$ with a standard deviation of $0.13~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$. The dashed lines represent a 0.5 % variation for the mean and a 3 % variation for the standard deviation, which are within the 95 % confidence interval for the measurements. The data can be taken representing any of the conditions studied.

Figure 10

Table 5.Comparison of the number of points accepted for different limits of rejection. Here $u$ is the mean velocity and $u^{\prime }$ the standard deviation. Data for a flow with 5 mm particles at 0.7 % v/v and $Re=200\,000$.

Figure 11

Table 6.Uncertainty of the measured variables expressed as a 95 % confidence interval.

Figure 12

Figure 7.Single-phase velocity profiles for $Re=500\,000$: (a) mean axial velocity and (b) fluctuating velocities in the axial, radial and theta directions. Open symbols are for the data from Laufer (1954), while filled symbols are for the present data.

Figure 13

Figure 8.Solid velocity profiles measured at two different axial locations in the test section separated by four pipe diameters: (a) solid mean axial velocity and (b) solid axial fluctuations. Axial location 1 is downstream from axial location 2 (the flow is upwards). Flow with 5 mm particles at $Re=200\,000$, and 1.2 % v/v.

Figure 14

Figure 9.Velocity profiles of the liquid phase for a flow with 1 mm particles at $Re=200\,000$ and 0.7 % v/v: (a) liquid mean axial velocity and (b) liquid axial fluctuations. The inset circle represents the top view of the cross-section of the pipe and shows the location of the two radii represented by open and filled symbols, respectively. The laser source is to the right of $r2$.

Figure 15

Table 7.Taylor and Kolmogorov characteristic lengths of the single-phase data.

Figure 16

Figure 10.Size effect on the mean axial velocity at $Re=200\,000$ and 0.7 % v/v: (a) liquid and (b) solid.

Figure 17

Figure 11.Size effect on the liquid fluctuations at $Re=200\,000$ and 0.7 % v/v: (a) axial component, (b) radial component and (c) theta component.

Figure 18

Figure 12.Size effect on the solid fluctuations at $Re=200\,000$ and 0.7 % v/v: (a) axial component, (b) radial component and (c) theta component.

Figure 19

Figure 13.Solids concentration effect on the mean axial velocity for a flow with 4 mm particles at $Re=200\,000$: (a) liquid and (b) solid.

Figure 20

Figure 14.Concentration effect on liquid fluctuations for a flow with 4 mm particles at $Re=200\,000$: (a) axial component, (b) radial component and (c) theta component.

Figure 21

Figure 15.Concentration effect on solid fluctuations for a flow with 4 mm particles at $Re=200\,000$: (a) axial component, (b) radial component and (c) theta component.

Figure 22

Figure 16.Comparison of the effect of Reynolds number and concentration on the mean solid velocity for a flow with 4 mm particles: left-hand side, $Re=200\,000$; right-hand side, $Re=350\,000$.

Figure 23

Figure 17.Comparison of the effect of Reynolds number and concentration on the solid axial fluctuations for a flow with 4 mm particles: left-hand side, $Re=200\,000$; right-hand side, $Re=350\,000$.

Figure 24

Figure 18.Comparison of the effect of Reynolds number and concentration on the liquid axial fluctuations for a flow with 4 mm particles: left-hand side, $Re=200\,000$; right-hand side, $Re=350\,000$.

Figure 25

Figure 19.Profiles for the secondary velocity fluctuations for a flow with 4 mm particles at $Re=350\,000$: (a) solid radial and (b) solid and liquid theta. The liquid velocities are represented by circles and the solid velocities by squares.

Figure 26

Figure 20.Effect of the Reynolds number on the axial fluctuations for a flow with 4 mm particles at 2 % v/v: (a) liquid and (b) solid.

Figure 27

Figure 21.Reynolds-number effect on the mean axial velocity for 4 mm particles and 0.7 % v/v: (a) liquid and (b) solid.

Figure 28

Figure 22.Reynolds-number effect on the liquid fluctuations for a flow with 4 mm particles at 0.7 % v/v: (a) axial component, (b) radial component and (c) theta component.

Figure 29

Figure 23.Reynolds-number effect on the solid fluctuations for a flow with 4 mm particles at 0.7 % v/v: (a) axial component, (b) radial component and (c) theta component.

Figure 30

Figure 24.Density effect on the mean axial velocity at $Re=200\,000$ and 0.7 % v/v for the glass particles and 0.1 % v/v for the steel particles. The liquid velocities are represented by circles and the solid velocities by squares.

Figure 31

Figure 25.Density effect on the liquid and the solid fluctuations at $Re=200\,000$ and 0.7 % v/v for the glass particles and 0.1 % v/v for the steel particles: (a) axial component, (b) radial component and (c) theta component. The liquid velocities are represented by circles and the solid velocities by squares.

Figure 32

Table 8.Characteristics of the steel cylinders.

Figure 33

Figure 26.Shape effect on the mean axial velocity at $Re=200\,000$ and 0.1 % v/v. Filled markers represent the $1~\text{mm}\times 1~\text{mm}$ and open markers the $0.5~\text{mm}\times 4~\text{mm}$. The liquid velocities are represented by circles and the solid velocities by squares.

Figure 34

Figure 27.Shape effect on the liquid and the solid fluctuations at $Re=200\,000$ and 0.1 % v/v: (a) axial component, (b) radial component and (c) theta component. Filled markers represent the $1~\text{mm}\times 1~\text{mm}$ and open markers the $0.5~\text{mm}\times 4~\text{mm}$. The liquid velocities are represented by circles and the solid velocities by squares.

Figure 35

Figure 28.Still frames of the two-phase flow with steel particles at $Re=200\,000$ and 0.1 % v/v: (a) $0.5~\text{mm}\times 4~\text{mm}$ cylinders and (b) $1~\text{mm}\times 1~\text{mm}$ cylinders.

Figure 36

Figure 29.(a) Reynolds stresses for the liquid in the presence of 3 mm particles at $Re=200\,000$ and 1.2 % v/v. (b) Kinetic energy (circles) and granular temperature (squares) for a flow with 3 mm particles at $Re=200\,000$ and 1.2 % v/v. The Stokes number is 40.

Figure 37

Figure 30.Reynolds stresses $\langle u^{\prime }v^{\prime }\rangle$ for (a) liquid phase and (b) solid phase for a flow with 3 mm, 4 mm and 5 mm particles at $Re=200\,000$ and 1.2 % v/v.

Figure 38

Figure 31.Size effect on (a) kinetic energy and (b) granular temperature at $Re=200\,000$ and 1.2 % v/v.

Figure 39

Figure 32.Concentration effect on (a) kinetic energy and (b) granular temperature for a flow with 3 mm particles at $Re=200\,000$.

Figure 40

Figure 33.Reynolds-number effect on (a) kinetic energy and (b) granular temperature for a flow with 3 mm particles at 0.7 % v/v.

Figure 41

Table 9.Turbulence modulation for the different conditions for the glass beads. Here $St_{K}$ is the Stokes number based on the Kolmogorov scale and $Pa$ is the particle momentum number.

Figure 42

Figure 34.Pressure drop (a) at 0.7 % v/v with different sizes of glass particles and (b) for a flow with 4 mm glass particles at different concentrations.

Figure 43

Table 10.Single-phase centreline velocity selected at the beginning of each experiment.

Figure 44

Table 11.Mass of particles added for the different concentrations.

Figure 45

Figure 35.Data collected for a 2 mm slurry at $Re=200\,000$ and 0.7 % v/v on three different days over a period of three weeks: (a) liquid-phase mean axial velocity, and (b) liquid-phase fluctuations.

Figure 46

Figure 36.Data collected for a 2 mm slurry at $Re=200\,000$ and 0.7 % v/v on three different days over a period of three weeks: (a) solid-phase mean axial velocity, and (b) solid-phase fluctuations.

Figure 47

Figure 37.Comparison of data obtained using new and used particles for a slurry with 3 mm particles at $Re=350\,000$ and solid volume of 0.7 %: (a) liquid mean velocity, and (b) liquid fluctuating velocity. Circles denote used particles and squares denote new particles.

Supplementary material: File

Mena and Curtis supplementary material

Mena and Curtis supplementary material

Download Mena and Curtis supplementary material(File)
File 383.2 KB