Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T06:57:13.135Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Linear stability of a rotating liquid column revisited

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 January 2022

Pulkit Dubey
Affiliation:
Integrated Applied Mathematics Program, University of New Hampshire, Durham, NH 03824, USAEngineering Mechanics Unit, JNCASR, Bangalore, Karnataka 560064, India
Anubhab Roy
Affiliation:
Department of Applied Mechanics, Indian Institute of Technology Madras, Chennai, Tamil Nadu 600036, India
Ganesh Subramanian*
Affiliation:
Engineering Mechanics Unit, JNCASR, Bangalore, Karnataka 560064, India
*
†Email address for correspondence: sganesh@jncasr.ac.in

Abstract

We revisit the somewhat classical problem of the linear stability of a rigidly rotating liquid column in this article. Although the literature pertaining to this problem dates back to 1959, the relation between inviscid and viscous stability criteria has not yet been clarified. While the viscous criterion for stability, given by $We < n^2 + k^2 -1$, is both necessary and sufficient, this relation has only been shown to be sufficient in the inviscid case. Here, $We = \rho \varOmega ^2 a^3 / \gamma$ is the Weber number and measures the relative magnitudes of the centrifugal and surface tension forces, with $\varOmega$ being the angular velocity of the rigidly rotating column, $a$ the column radius, $\rho$ the density of the fluid and $\gamma$ the surface tension coefficient; $k$ and $n$ denote the axial and azimuthal wavenumbers of the imposed perturbation. We show that the subtle difference between the inviscid and viscous criteria arises from the surprisingly complicated picture of inviscid stability in the $We$–$k$ plane. For all $n > 1$, the viscously unstable region, corresponding to $We > n^2 + k^2-1$, contains an infinite hierarchy of inviscidly stable islands ending in cusps, with a dominant leading island. Only the dominant island, now infinite in extent along the $We$ axis, persists for $n=1$. This picture may be understood, based on the underlying eigenspectrum, as arising from the cascade of coalescences between a retrograde mode, that is the continuation of the cograde surface-tension-driven mode across the zero Doppler frequency point, and successive retrograde Coriolis modes constituting an infinite hierarchy.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.The dispersion curves for the Rayleigh–Plateau problem (a), the Rankine vortex (b) and the rotating liquid column with $We = 20$ (c). Blue curves denote neutral modes while the dotted orange curves denote growing/decaying modes. Only the first 10 of the infinite number of neutral modes are shown for the Rankine vortex and the rotating column.

Figure 1

Figure 2.The dispersion curves of the rotating liquid column with varying $We$: (a) $We = 0.1$; (b) $We = 1$; (c) $We = 10$; (d) $We = 20$. Blue curves denote neutral modes while dashed orange curves denote growing / decaying modes. A vertical dashed line drawn at $k = \sqrt {1+We}$ indicates the axial wavenumber beyond which the effects of surface tension on the neutral modes become significant.

Figure 2

Figure 3.The two figures plot the growth rates of planar perturbations as a function of $We$ and $Re$ for $n = 4$: (a) growth rates versus $We$ for various $Re$; (b) growth rates versus $Re$ for various $We$. Note the discontinuous change in the stability criterion from $We = 20$, for the inviscid case (the dotted black curve in (a)) to $We = 15$ for any finite $Re$. Dashed black lines in (b) denote the large $Re$ asymptotes obtained from the planar viscous dispersion relation due to Hocking (1960).

Figure 3

Figure 4.The inviscid dispersion curves corresponding to the different $We$ regimes for $n = 3$: (a) $We < n^2-1$ ($We = 7$); (b) $n^2 - 1 < We < n(n+1)$ ($We = 10$); (c) $n(n+1) < We < We_{{cusp}}$ ($We = 12.5$); (d) $We > We_{{cusp}}$($We = 17$); where $We_{{cusp}} \approx 16$ for $n = 3$. The neutral Coriolis modes are shown in blue and the neutral capillary modes in orange. The real part of the unstable eigenvalues are shown as dashed green curves while the imaginary parts are shown as dashed red curves.

Figure 4

Figure 5.The inviscid dispersion curves corresponding to the different $We$-regimes for $n=4$: (a) $We < n^2-1$ ($We=12$); (b) $n^2 - 1 < We < n(n+1)$ ($We=18$), (c) $n(n+1) < We < We_{cusp}$ ($We=22$); (d) $We > We_{cusp}$ ($We=26$); where $We_{{cusp}} \approx 25.5$ for $n=4$. The neutral Coriolis modes are shown in blue and the neutral capillary modes in orange. The real part of the unstable eigenvalues are shown as dashed green curves while the imaginary parts are shown as dashed red curves.

Figure 5

Figure 6.A schematic showing the loci of the pairs of folding points, associated with the hysteretic dispersion curves, which leads to the inviscidly stable island in the $We$–$k$ plane.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Depiction of the stable islands in the $We$–$k$ plane for (a) $n = 2$, (b) $n = 3$, (c) $n = 4$ and (d) $n = 5$. Blue curves denote both, the outer boundary ($We = n^2+k^2-1$) and the numerically obtained boundaries of the inviscidly stable island within; the shaded region between these boundaries denotes the inviscidly unstable region. The dashed black curves denote the small-$k$ asymptotes for the island boundaries; the lower branch asymptote is $k \thicksim \sqrt {(({n^2-1})/{n(n+1)})(We-n(n+1))}$ and that for the upper branch is obtained by simultaneously solving ${\rm d}\sigma /{\rm d}k = \infty$ with (2.6) for small $k$.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Dispersion curves ($\sigma$ versus $k$) for $n = 4$ and $We$ close to $n^2 - 1$: (a) $We = 14.25$; (b) $We = 14.75$; (c) $We = 14.95$; (d) $We = 15$; (e) $We = 15.05$; (f) $We = 15.1$. At $We = n^2 - 1$ the capillary mode splits into two and yields a new retrograde mode (also shown in orange) which subsequently undergoes an infinite sequence of coalescences with the retrograde Coriolis modes for higher $We$.

Figure 8

Figure 9.An increasing number of retrograde dispersion curves exhibit a hysteretic character for $We \to (n^2-1)^+$; the figures show this behaviour for $n = 3$. (a) A single coalescence between a capillary and a Coriolis mode: $We = 9$. (b) The capillary-Coriolis coalescence plus a single hysteretic dispersion curve: $We = 8.5$. (c) The capillary-Coriolis coalescence plus three hysteretic dispersion curves: $We = 8.2$. (d)  The capillary-Coriolis coalescence plus four hysteretic dispersion curves: $We = 8.1$.

Figure 9

Figure 10.A magnified view of figure 9(d): $We = 8.1; n = 3$. Note the multiple hysteretic dispersion curves (four, besides the original) and corresponding oscillations in the growth rate.

Figure 10

Figure 11.The main and satellite islands of inviscid stability, in the $We$–$k$ plane, for (a) $n = 2$, (b) $n = 3$, (c) $n = 4$ and (d) $n = 5$. Magnified views, of five of the infinite hierarchy of satellite islands, appear in the insets.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Comparison of the inviscidly stable islands for the surface-tension (blue) and self-gravitating (orange) cases for (a) $n = 2$, (b) $n = 3$, (c) $n = 4$ and (d) $n = 5$. The insets in each figure show magnified views of the first five satellite islands for the self-gravitating column.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Dispersion curves for $n = 1$ (a–d); the solid blue curves indicate the Coriolis modes, the solid orange curves indicate the capillary modes and the dashed curves indicate real (red) and imaginary (green) parts of the unstable modes. Panel (e) depicts the stable island generated as a result of coalescence of the lowest Coriolis mode and the retrograde capillary mode. Here (a) $We = 1$, (b) $We = 2$, (c) $We = 5$, (d) $We = 10$, (e) region of stability for $n=1$.