Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T05:40:34.116Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Low- and mid-frequency wall-pressure sources in a turbulent boundary layer

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 May 2021

Bradley Gibeau
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2R3, Canada
Sina Ghaemi*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2R3, Canada
*
†Email address for correspondence: ghaemi@ualberta.ca

Abstract

Simultaneous wall-pressure and high-speed particle image velocimetry measurements were used to identify the coherent structures that generate low- and mid-frequency wall-pressure fluctuations in a turbulent boundary layer at a friction Reynolds number of $Re_\tau =2600$. The coherence function between wall pressure and velocity at a range of wall-normal locations revealed two distinct frequency bands of high coherence that span the low- and mid-frequency regions of the wall-pressure spectrum. Pressure was filtered to isolate the frequencies associated with each region of high coherence, and space–time pressure-velocity correlations were computed using the filtered signals to expose the motions responsible for the observed pressure-velocity coupling. The resulting correlation patterns were attributed to very-large-scale motions (VLSMs) and hairpin packets, revealing that these two types of coherent motions are the dominant sources of wall-pressure fluctuations at the low and mid frequencies. Although the VLSMs and hairpin packets are closely related, the mechanisms by which these motions affect wall pressure were found to be different. The VLSMs were found to cause positive and negative wall-pressure fluctuations via splatting and lifting of fluid at the wall, respectively. In contrast, hairpin packets affected wall pressure because of their low-pressure vortex cores and regions of high-pressure stagnation. The frequency at which the wall-pressure source changes from the VLSMs to the hairpin packets coincided with the peak of the wall-pressure spectrum, suggesting that the peak may be a result of the transition between pressure sources that occurs at the same point in the frequency domain.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Boundary layer parameters at the pressure measurement location and fluid properties. The viscous length scale was determined using the Clauser method with $\kappa = 0.41$ and $C = 5.0$. The boundary layer thickness is defined here as the wall-normal location at which $\langle U \rangle = 0.995U_\infty$, where $\langle \cdots \rangle$ denotes an ensemble average in time.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Schematic of the thread-on pinhole attachment for the microphone.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Schematic of the experimental set-up. The axes origin is located at the pinhole of microphone 1 and is offset here to not interfere with the fields of view.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Velocity statistics at the pressure measurement location ($x = z = 0$) from the three PIV experiments: ($a$) mean velocity profiles and ($b$) Reynolds stresses. The use of $\langle \cdots \rangle$ denotes an ensemble average in time. Here H & M (2007) refers to the hotwire measurements of Hutchins & Marusic (2007a) at $Re_\tau = 2630$. The uncertainties associated with these statistics are estimated in Appendix B.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Power spectral density of streamwise velocity fluctuation as a function of wavenumber ($\phi _u(k_x)$; $k_x = 2{{\rm \pi} }f/\langle U(y) \rangle$) computed from the high-speed PIV measurements of FOV2 and FOV3. Note that $y/\delta = 0.07$ and 0.14 coincide with roughly $y/\lambda = 180$ and 360, respectively.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Power spectral density of wall pressure ($\phi _p(\omega )$; $\omega = 2{{\rm \pi} }f$) normalized using both inner- and outer-layer variables. The divisions between the four regions of the spectrum are set as defined by Hwang et al. (2009). The upper frequency resolved by PIV is dictated by the Nyquist criterion.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Measured probability density of wall-pressure fluctuations compared with a Gaussian fit of the same data; shown on ($a$) linear and ($b$) semi-logarithmic axes. The grey outline in ($b$) is the approximate envelope of values reported by Tsuji et al. (2007) for $5870 \leq Re_\theta \leq 16\ 700$.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Space–time pressure-velocity correlations (${\boldsymbol {R}}_{pu_i}$) as defined by (3.1) calculated using the ($a$) streamwise, ($b$) wall-normal and ($c$) spanwise velocity components. The superscripts ‘$+$’ and ‘$-$’ denote correlations computed using only $p>0$ or $p<0$, respectively. The streamwise–wall-normal planes in ($a$) and ($b$) are located at $z = 0$, while those in ($c$) are located at $z = 0.2\delta$. The plots in ($c$) do not cover as much of the wall-normal distance due to the limitations of FOV3. The uncertainties associated with these correlations are estimated in Appendix B.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Visualizations of the vector fields associated with ($a$–$c$) ${\boldsymbol {R}}^+_{pu_i}$ and ($d$–$f$) $-{\boldsymbol {R}}^-_{pu_i}$. The background colour represents the streamwise component of the correlations and has the same scaling as figure 7($a$). The coloured lines in ($a$,$d$) show the locations of the spanwise–wall-normal planes that are plotted directly below. The vector lengths in ($b$,$c$,$e$,$\,f$) have been altered relative to those in ($a$,$d$) to improve the visualizations.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Estimated coherence between wall pressure and velocity fluctuation (${\boldsymbol {C}}_{pu_i}$) as a function of wall-normal distance as defined by (4.1) for the ($a$) streamwise and ($b$) wall-normal velocity components. Computed using the high-speed PIV measurements from FOV2. The power spectral density ($\phi _p(\omega )$) normalized by outer-layer variables is shown in ($c$) with the frequency axis aligned for reference.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Estimated phase between wall pressure and velocity fluctuation ($\angle \phi (\omega )_{pu_i}$) as a function of wall-normal distance for the ($a$) streamwise and ($b$) wall-normal velocity components. Computed using the measurements from FOV2. A positive phase indicates that $p$ leads $u_i$, while a negative phase indicates that $p$ lags $u_i$.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Probability density of the full spectrum of wall-pressure fluctuations compared with that of the LSP and VLSP fluctuations shown on ($a$) linear and ($b$) semi-logarithmic axes. The dashed lines represent Gaussian fits to the same data. All curves are normalized using $p_{{rms}}$, the root-mean-square value of the full spectrum of fluctuations.

Figure 12

Figure 12.($a$) Streamwise, ($b$) wall-normal and ($c$) spanwise components of the space–time pressure-velocity correlations computed using pressure filtered to isolate the VLSP fluctuations (${\boldsymbol {R}}_{pu_i}^{{VLS}} = {\boldsymbol {R}}_{pu_i}|_{p=p_{{VLS}}}$) following (3.1). The superscripts ‘$+$’ and ‘$-$’ denote correlations computed using only $p_{{VLS}}>0$ or $p_{{VLS}}<0$, respectively. The streamwise–wall-normal planes in ($a$) and ($b$) are located at $z = 0$, while those in ($c$) are located at $z = 0.2\delta$. The plots in ($c$) do not cover as much of the wall-normal distance due to the limitations of FOV3. The uncertainties associated with these correlations are estimated in Appendix B.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Visualizations of the vector fields associated with ($a$–$c$) ${\boldsymbol {R}}_{pu_i}^{{VLS}+}$ and ($d$–$f$) $-{\boldsymbol {R}}_{pu_i}^{{VLS}-}$. The background colour represents the streamwise component of the correlations and has the same scaling as figure 12($a$). The coloured lines in ($a$,$d$) show the locations of the spanwise–wall-normal planes that are plotted directly below. The vector lengths in ($b$,$c$,$e$,$\,f$) have been altered relative to those in ($a$,$d$) to improve the visualizations.

Figure 14

Figure 14.($a$) Streamwise, ($b$) wall-normal and ($c$) spanwise components of the space–time pressure-velocity correlations computed using pressure filtered to isolate the LSP fluctuations (${\boldsymbol {R}}_{pu_i}^{{LS}} = {\boldsymbol {R}}_{pu_i}|_{p=p_{LS}}$) following (3.1). The superscripts ‘$+$’ and ‘$-$’ denote correlations computed using only $p_{{LS}}>0$ or $p_{{LS}}<0$, respectively. The streamwise–wall-normal planes in ($a$) and ($b$) are located at $z = 0$, while those in ($c$) are located at $z = 0.2\delta$. The plots in ($c$) do not cover as much of the wall-normal distance due to the limitations of FOV3. The uncertainties associated with these correlations are estimated in Appendix B.

Figure 15

Figure 15.($a$) Streamwise, ($b$) wall-normal and ($c$) spanwise components of the space–time pressure-velocity correlations computed using pressure filtered to isolate quartiles of the LSP band (${\boldsymbol {R}}_{pu_i}^{{LS}_q} = {\boldsymbol {R}}_{pu_i}|_{p=p_{{LS}_q}}$; $q=1$, 2, 3, 4) following (3.1). The frequency range associated with each quartile is given in table 2. Here ${\boldsymbol {R}}_{pu}^{{LS}_q}$ and ${\boldsymbol {R}}_{pv}^{{LS}_q}$ are plotted at $z=0$, while ${\boldsymbol {R}}_{pw}^{{LS}_q}$ is plotted at $z/\delta =0.25$, $0.2$, $0.15$ and $0.1$ for increasing $q$.

Figure 16

Table 2.Frequency ranges associated with the quartiles of the LSP band.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Visualizations of the vector fields associated with ($a$) ${\boldsymbol {R}}_{pu_i}^{{LS}_3+}$ and ($b$) $-{\boldsymbol {R}}_{pu_i}^{{LS}_3-}$. These visualizations represent the quartile within the LSP band defined by $4.4<{\omega \delta /U_\infty }<6.2$. The background colour represents the streamwise component of the correlations and has the same scaling as figure 15($a$). The horizontal lines in ($a$,$c$) show the location of the associated streamwise–spanwise planes plotted directly below. The vector lengths in ($b$,$d$) have been altered relative to those in ($a$,$c$) to improve the visualizations. Rotational markers have been added to clearly show the locations of the vortical motions.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Simplified schematic showing the coherent structures that contribute to the low- and mid-frequency regions of the wall-pressure spectrum ($\omega \delta /U_\infty \lesssim 4$ in the present work).

Figure 19

Figure 18.Photographs of ($a$) the quasi-anechoic chamber, ($b$) the externally supported loudspeaker and ($c$) the externally supported microphones. The microphone on the right in ($c$) is the reference and the microphone on the left is fitted with the pinhole attachment that is to be calibrated.

Figure 20

Figure 19.Measured frequency response of the pinhole resonator compared with the second-order model given by (A1).

Figure 21

Figure 20.Sample signal of white noise containing frequencies up to 3 kHz: ($a$) the pinhole microphone signal $p_{{p}}(t)$ compared with the reference microphone signal $p_{{r}}(t)$ and ($b$) the Helmholtz-corrected signal $p_0(t)$ compared with $p_{{r}}(t)$.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Power spectral density of wall pressure $\phi _p(f)$ without background noise treatment ($p_0(t)$), after subtracting the noise field signal ($p_0(t) - p_{n}(t)$), and after subtracting the background noise estimated using the Wiener filter ($p_0(t) - \hat {p}_{b}(t)$).

Figure 23

Table 3.Estimated total uncertainties associated with the mean velocity and Reynolds stresses computed from the PIV measurements conducted in the present investigation.

Figure 24

Table 4.Estimated total uncertainties associated with the pressure-velocity correlations shown in figures 7, 12 and 14. These uncertainties are given as a percentage of the upper colourbar value used to display each respective correlation.