Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T03:36:31.374Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Marangoni instability in a viscoelastic binary film with cross-diffusive effect

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 January 2021

Rajkumar Sarma
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati, Guwahati, Assam 781039, India
Pranab Kumar Mondal*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati, Guwahati, Assam 781039, India
*
† Email address for correspondence: mail2pranab@gmail.com

Abstract

Viscoelastic liquids are usually blends of a polymeric solute and a Newtonian solvent. In the presence of a temperature gradient, stratification of these solutes can take place via the Soret effect. Here, we investigate the classical Marangoni instability problem for a thin viscoelastic film considering this binary aspect of the liquid. The film, bounded above by a deformable free surface, is subjected to heating from below by a solid substrate. Linear stability analysis performed numerically for perturbations of finite wavelength (short-wave perturbations) reveals that both monotonic and oscillatory instabilities can emerge in this system. In the presence of Soret diffusion, the interaction between thermocapillary and solutocapillary forces is found to give rise to two different oscillatory instabilities, of which one mode was overlooked previously, even for the Newtonian binary mixtures. As a principal result of this work, we provide a complete picture of the susceptibility to different instability modes based on model parameter values. Finally, an approximate model is developed under the framework of long-wave analysis, which can qualitatively depict the stability behaviour of the system without numerically solving the problem.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic illustration of the physical system under consideration. A thin viscoelastic film (composed of a polymeric solute in a Newtonian solvent), confined between its deformable free surface $z = h(x,t)$ and a horizontal substrate in the gravitational field g, is subjected to a vertical temperature gradient. This applied temperature gradient induces a concentration gradient in the film via the Soret effect. The surface tension gradient arising from inhomogeneities in temperature and concentration at the air–liquid interface induces Marangoni convection in the liquid layer. The dashed line corresponds to the undeformed interface in the quiescent base state.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Comparison of the present numerical result with the results of Shklyaev et al. (2009) (shown by markers ‘ο’) via the neutral stability curve at $Pr = 2$, $\chi ={-} 0.2$ and $Le = {10^{ - 3}}$. Curves marked by 1 and 2 correspond to $Bi = 0$ and $Bi = 0.1$ respectively. To represent the characteristics of a Newtonian binary liquid with a non-deformable free surface, we consider $De = 0$ and $(Ga,\varSigma ) \to \infty$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Neutral stability curves $Ma(k)$ for the monotonic instability mode. The solid line represents the stability threshold for a deformable free surface $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,{10^3})$, whereas the dotted line demonstrates the stability margin for a non-deformable free surface $(Ga,\varSigma ) \to \infty$. The dot (ο) mark on each neutral curve represents the critical point of the curve. The inset depicts the effect of free surface deformability on the stability threshold in the long-wave regime. Other parameters: $Bi = 0.01,\chi = 0.5$, $Le = {10^{ - 3}}$ and $Pr = 10$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.(a,c) Neutral stability curves $Ma\,(k)$, and (b,d) the corresponding oscillation frequency $\omega$ for the oscillatory-I instability mode for $\chi \lt 0\textrm{ }( ={-} 0.5)$ and $\chi \gt 0\textrm{ }( = 0.5)$, respectively. For panels (a,b), the lines marked by 1 and 2 correspond to $De = 0$ and ${De = 1}$, respectively; for panels (c,d), the lines marked by 1 and 2 correspond to $De = 0.1$ and $De = 1$, respectively. In each panel, the solid and the dash-dotted lines depict the results for a deformable free surface $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,{10^3})$; the adjacent dotted line represents the results for a non-deformable free surface $(Ga\textrm{,}\varSigma ) \to \infty$. The dot (ο) mark on each neutral curve denotes the critical point (or the global minimum) of the curve. Other parameters: $Bi = 0.1$, $Le = 0.01$ and $Pr = 10$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Variation of the (a) critical Marangoni number $M{a_c}$, and the corresponding critical (b) wavenumber ${k_c}$ and (c) oscillation frequency ${\omega _c}$ with Deborah number De for the oscillatory-I instability mode for $\chi \lt 0$. The solid line depicts the variation for a deformable free surface $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,{10^3})$; and the dotted line is that for a non-deformable surface $(Ga,\varSigma ) \to \infty$. The arrow marks in panels (b,c) illustrate a switchover in the instability behaviour with the increasing elasticity of the liquid. Other parameters: $Bi = 0.1$, $Le = 0.01$ and $\chi ={-} 0.5$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Neutral stability curves $Ma(k)$ for the monotonic and oscillatory-I modes in the (a,c) positive and (b) negative Soret number $\chi$ domains. The long-wave branch for the oscillatory-I mode emerges only when $\chi \lt 0$. The dot (ο) mark on each neutral curve represents the critical point of the curve. Other parameters: $Bi = 0.01$, $De = 1$, $Le = {10^{ - 3}}$ and $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,{10^3})$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Variation of the (a) critical Marangoni number $M{a_c}$, and the corresponding (b) critical wavenumber ${k_c}$ with $\chi$. In each panel, the solid, dash-dotted and dashed lines represent the variations for a deformable free surface $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,{10^3})$. The dotted lines adjacent to each instability mode represent the variations for a non-deformable free surface $(Ga,\varSigma ) \to \infty$. Other parameters: $Bi = 0.01$ and $Le = {10^{ - 3}}$.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Effect of Lewis number Le on the monotonic and oscillatory instability threshold for (a,c) $\chi \lt 0\textrm{ }( ={-} 0.5)$ and (b) $\chi \gt 0{\kern 1pt} \textrm{ }( = 0.5)$. The dot (ο) mark on each neutral curve represents the critical point of the curve. Panel (c) shows that, for a deformable free surface at higher value of Le, a different type of long-wave oscillatory instability (oscillatory-II) can emerge in the fluid layer. Other parameters: $Bi = 0.01$, $De = 1$ and $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,{10^3})$.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Comparison of the oscillation frequency of neutral perturbations for the oscillatory-II mode with oscillatory-I mode (shown in the inset). Parameters: $\chi = 0.5$, $Bi = 0.01$, $De = 1$, $Le = 0.1$ and $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,{10^3})$.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Variation of the critical Marangoni number $M{a_c}$ with $\chi$ for the oscillatory-II mode at $Bi = 0.01$, $Le = 0.1$ and $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,{10^3})$. Note that no oscillatory-II instability emerges for $\chi \le 0$.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Effect of Biot number Bi on the monotonic and oscillatory instability threshold for (a) $\chi \lt 0\textrm{ }( ={-} 0.5)$, and (b,c,d) $\chi \gt 0\textrm{ }( = 0.5)$ for a film with deformable free surface $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,{10^3})$. Other parameters: $De = 1$ and $Le = 0.01$.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Effect of liquid elasticity on the eigenvector $\mathord{\buildrel{\lower3pt\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\frown$}} \over \psi }$ profiles (normalized) at the neutral stability boundary for (a) monotonic mode, (b) oscillatory-II mode, (c) long-wave oscillatory-I mode and (d) short-wave oscillatory-I mode. Profiles in panels (a,b) correspond to the critical point of the respective neutral curve presented in figure 8(a). Profiles in panels (c,d) refer to the critical point of the long-wave and short-wave branches of the neutral curves depicted in figure 4(a). The eigenvectors are plotted for a deformable free surface $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,{10^3})$.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Effect of elasticity on the spatial profiles of (a) temperature $\mathord{\buildrel{\lower3pt\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\frown$}} \over \theta }$ and (b) concentration $\mathord{\buildrel{\lower3pt\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle\frown$}} \over c}$ eigenvectors (normalized) at the neutral stability point. Profiles for each De in panels (a,b) correspond to the critical point of the short-wave oscillatory-I branch presented in figure 4(a).

Figure 13

Figure 14.Comparison of results obtained from the approximate model (solid and dash-dotted lines) with the numerical results (dotted lines) for the monotonic instability mode via the neutral stability curve (a) deformable surface $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,\,{10^3})$, and (b) non-deformable surface $(Ga,\varSigma ) \to \infty$. The dot (ο) mark on each neutral curve represents the critical point of the curve. Other parameters: $Bi = 0.01$ and $Le = 0.1$.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Comparison between results of the numerical computation (dotted lines) and the approximate model (solid and dash-dotted lines) for the oscillatory-I mode via neutral stability curve: (a) long-wave branch at $Le = 0.1$, $\chi ={-} 0.5$; and (b) short-wave branch at $Le = {10^{ - 3}}$, $\chi = 0.5$. Other parameters: $Bi = 0.01$ and $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,{10^3})$.

Figure 15

Figure 16.Comparison of results obtained from the approximate model (solid and dash-dotted lines) with the numerical results (dotted lines) for the oscillatory-II mode via the neutral stability curve at $Bi = 0.01$, $De = 1$, $Le = 0.1$ and $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,{10^3})$.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Phase diagrams for $(\chi ,\,De)$ at different Le enclosing the regimes of dominant instability mode: (a,b) deformable free surface $(Ga,\varSigma ) = (0.1,{10^3})$, and (c,d) non-deformable free surface $(Ga\textrm{,}\varSigma ) \to \infty$ at $Bi = 0.01$, $Pr = 10$. In all panels: regime 1, monotonic instability; regime 2, long-wave oscillatory-I instability; regime 3, short-wave oscillatory-I instability; and regime 4, oscillatory-II instability. At the points marked p and q in panels (a,b), the three adjacent instability modes can coexist.