Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T02:43:40.428Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Modulation and classification of wake transitions through vortex evolution phases in undulated cylinders at low Reynolds number

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 April 2026

Hyun Sik Yoon*
Affiliation:
Department of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering, Pusan National University, 2, Busandaehak-ro 63beon-gil, Busan, Gumjeong-Gu, 46241, Republic of Korea
Gourisaran Baiju Sony
Affiliation:
Department of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering, Pusan National University, 2, Busandaehak-ro 63beon-gil, Busan, Gumjeong-Gu, 46241, Republic of Korea
Seok Beom Hong
Affiliation:
Department of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering, Pusan National University, 2, Busandaehak-ro 63beon-gil, Busan, Gumjeong-Gu, 46241, Republic of Korea
*
Corresponding author: Hyun Sik Yoon, lesmodel@pusan.ac.kr

Abstract

This study examines how wavy orientation and undulation-induced geometric variations regulate vortex formation, wake transitions and aerodynamic performance in sinusoidally wavy cylinders. Using three-dimensional (3-D) simulations at a Reynolds number Re = 100, we analyse the transition from two-dimensional (2-D) to 3-D wakes across varying spanwise wavelengths and undulation configurations. A novel framework is introduced for classifying vortex structures, analyisng centreline trajectories and decomposing vortex structures, revealing how geometric variations induce distinct 3-D vortical structures. At short wavelengths, vortices originate from bluff regions and diminish in a continuous manner, stabilising the wake. At longer wavelengths, phase-dependent vortex onset leads to localised interactions, disrupting wake coherence and delaying stabilisation. A key discovery is the role of transverse recirculating flow in wake stabilisation, which induces reverse impingement, redirects fluid and weakens spanwise vortex coherence. Additionally, wavy orientation strongly influences vortex evolution and dislocation, altering vortex trajectories and wake stability. To further clarify these wake transitions, a classification framework is introduced, defining distinct phases such as vortex stretching, break-up and re-symmetrisation. The relationship between force characteristics and wake stabilisation is also established, with wavy orientation and undulation geometry regulating the transition from quasi-2-D spanwise vortical flow to 3-D spiral flow. A critical wavelength is identified where drag and lift fluctuations are minimised, with elliptical-section undulations achieving superior aerodynamic performance through enhanced vortex synchronisation. These findings provide new insights into vortex control strategies, with applications in bio-inspired propulsion, passive flow control and energy-efficient aerodynamic designs across engineering and industrial fields.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Geometries and their characteristic parameters for each undulation configuration: (a) streamwise undulation (SU); (b) transverse undulation (TU); (c) anti-phase undulation (APU) and (d) in-phase undulation (IPU). Key geometric quantities such as maximum/minimum local lengths and mean lengths are indicated.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) Computational domain and boundary conditions. (b) Grid distributions around the undulated cylinder.

Figure 2

Table 1.Grid dependence test for the wavy cylinder ($\lambda / L_{m} = 2.5$ and $\lambda / L_{m} = 8.0$) at $\textit{Re} = 100$. The time-averaged drag coefficient ($\overline {C_{\!D}}$), root mean square of the lift coefficient ($C_{L,\textit{rms}}$) and Strouhal number ($St$) are compared across different grid resolutions.

Figure 3

Table 2.Validation of the present numerical method for the smooth circular cylinder at $\textit{Re} = 100$, compared with previous studies. Time-averaged drag coefficient ($\overline {C_{\!D}}$), root mean square of the lift coefficient ($C_{L,\textit{rms}}$) and Strouhal number ($St$) are presented.

Figure 4

Figure 3.Comparison of (a) time-averaged drag coefficient ($\overline {C_{\!D}}$) and (b) root-mean-square lift coefficient ($C_{L,rms}$) between the present results and Lam & Lin (2009) for the wavy cylinder (IPU) at Re = 100.

Figure 5

Figure 4.Three-dimensional vortex structures and in-plane flow fields of the SU cylinder for $\lambda /L_m=2.5$. (a) Iso-surfaces of vortical structures identified using the $\lambda _2$ criterion (Jeong & Hussain 1995), viewed from the top and bottom, coloured by spanwise vorticity ($\omega _z$). (b–d) Streamlines in $x$–$y$ planes at selected spanwise locations: (b) node $z/\lambda =0.0$; (c) $z/\lambda =0.3$; and (d) saddle $z/\lambda =0.5$. The upper and lower vortex cores ($V_{{U}}$ and $V_{{L}}$) are annotated.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Three-dimensional vortex structures and in-plane flow fields of the TU cylinder for $\lambda /L_m=2.5$. (a) Iso-surfaces of vortical structures identified using the $\lambda _2$ criterion (Jeong & Hussain 1995), viewed from the top and bottom, coloured by spanwise vorticity ($\omega _z$). (b–d) Streamlines in $x$–$y$ planes at selected spanwise locations: (b) node ($z/\lambda =0.0$); (c) $z/\lambda =0.4$; and (d) saddle ($z/\lambda =0.5$). The upper and lower vortex cores ($V_{{U}}$ and $V_{{L}}$) are annotated.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Three-dimensional vortex structures and in-plane flow fields for the APU cylinder at $\lambda /L_m=2.5$. (a) Iso-surfaces of vortical structures identified using the $\lambda _2$ criterion (Jeong & Hussain 1995), viewed from the top and bottom, coloured by spanwise vorticity ($\omega _z$). (b–g) In-plane streamlines in $x$–$y$ planes at representative spanwise locations: (b) node ($z/\lambda =0.0$); (c) $z/\lambda =0.1$; (d) $z/\lambda =0.2$; (e) $z/\lambda =0.3$; ( f) $z/\lambda =0.38$; and (g) saddle ($z/\lambda =0.5$). The upper and lower vortex cores ($V_{{U}}$ and $V_{{L}}$) are indicated.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Three-dimensional vortex structures and in-plane flow fields of the SU cylinder at $\lambda /L_m = 8.0$. (a) Iso-surfaces of vortical structures identified using the $\lambda _2$ criterion (Jeong & Hussain 1995), viewed from the top and bottom, coloured by spanwise vorticity ($\omega _z$). (b–g) Streamlines in $x$–$y$ planes at selected spanwise locations: (b) saddle ($z/\lambda =0.5$); (c) $z/\lambda =0.4$; (d) $z/\lambda =0.28$; (e) $z/\lambda =0.22$; ( f) $z/\lambda =0.12$; and (g) node ($z/\lambda =0.0$). Labelled vortex cores ($V_{{U}1}$–$V_{{U}3}$, $V_{{L}1}$–$V_{{L}3}$) indicate progressive development and interaction of upper and lower vortices along the span.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Three-dimensional vortex structures of (a) TU and (b) APU cylinders at $\lambda /L_m = 8.0$, visualised by iso-surfaces of vortical structures identified using the $\lambda _2$ criterion (Jeong & Hussain 1995) and coloured by spanwise vorticity ($\omega _z$).

Figure 10

Figure 9.Three-dimensional vortex structures and in-plane flow fields for the IPU cylinder at $\lambda /L_m=4.5$. (a) Iso-surfaces of vortical structures identified using the $\lambda _2$ criterion (Jeong & Hussain 1995), viewed from the top and bottom, coloured by spanwise vorticity ($\omega _z$). (b–d) In-plane streamlines in $x$–$y$ planes at representative spanwise locations: (b) node ($z/\lambda =0.0$); (c) $z/\lambda =0.4$; and (d) saddle ($z/\lambda =0.5$). The upper and lower vortex cores ($V_{{U}}$, $V_{{L}1}$ and $V_{{L}2}$) are indicated.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Three-dimensional vortex structures at short wavelengths ($\lambda /L_m=2.5$), visualised by iso-surfaces of vortical structures identified using the $\lambda _2$ criterion (Jeong & Hussain 1995) and coloured by (a,c,e,g) streamwise vorticity $\omega _x$ and (b,d, f,h) transverse vorticity $\omega _y$, with overlaid streamlines. Results are shown for: (a,b) SU; (c,d) TU; (e, f) APU; and (g,h) IPU cylinders.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Three-dimensional vortex structures at long wavelengths ($\lambda /L_m = 8.0$), visualised by iso-surfaces of vortical structures identified using the $\lambda _2$ criterion (Jeong & Hussain 1995) and coloured by (a,c,e,g) streamwise vorticity $\omega _x$ and (b,d, f,h) transverse vorticity $\omega _y$, with overlaid streamlines. Results are shown for: (a,b) SU; (c,d) TU; (e, f) APU; (g,h) IPU cylinder configurations.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Time-averaged streamlines in the $x{-}y$ plane at three spanwise positions ($z/\lambda =0.0$, 0.1 and 0.5) for the (ai–aiii) SU, (bi–biii) TU, (ci–ciii) APU and (di–diii) IPU configurations at $\lambda /L_m = 2.5$.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Time-averaged streamlines in the $x{-}y$ plane at multiple spanwise positions ($z/\lambda = 0.0{-}0.5$) for the (ai–aiv) SU, (bi–biv) TU, (ci–civ) APU, and (di–div) IPU configurations at $\lambda /L_m = 6.0$.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Schematic representation of spanwise vortex evolution modes in wavy cylinders. (a) For short wavelengths ($\lambda /L_m = 2.5$), alternating symmetric vortex (SV) and no vortex (NV) zones are observed. (b) For long wavelengths ($\lambda /L_m = 6.0$), a four-stage evolution is identified: SV $\rightarrow$ vortex stretching and break-up (VSB) $\rightarrow$ NV $\rightarrow$ re-symmetric vortex (RSV).

Figure 16

Figure 15.Classification maps of spanwise vortex modes across various wavelengths, plotted in the $\lambda /L_m{-}z/\lambda$ plane for (a) SU, (b) TU, (c) APU and (d) IPU configurations. The contours trace vortex trajectories, while coloured regions denote distinct vortex modes: symmetric vortex (SV, yellow), vortex stretching and break-up (VSB, orange dashed ellipses), no vortex zone (NV, purple) and re-symmetric vortex (RSV, green). The maps illustrate how wave orientation and wavelength jointly govern the spatial evolution and dislocation of spanwise vortices.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Time-averaged streamlines in the x–z planes (1st to 3rd columns) at different $y/L_m$ positions for the wavy cylinders with $\lambda /L_m$ = 3.0, for the SU, TU and APU cylinders, and $\lambda /L_m$ = 6.0 for the IPU cylinder, illustrating the evolution of transverse vortices: (ai–aiii) SU; (bi–biii) TU; (ci–ciii) APU; and (di–diii) IPU.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Time-averaged streamlines in the $y{-}z$ plane showing the development of streamwise vortices at two wavelengths $\lambda /L_m=3.0$ and 6.0: (ai–aii) SU; (bi–bii) TU; (ci–cii) APU; and (di–dii) IPU configurations.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Trajectories of streamwise (red dashed lines) and transverse (black solid lines) vortices in the $\lambda / L_m{-}z / \lambda$ plane for (a) SU, (b) TU, (c) APU and (d) IPU configurations. The wake patterns are classified as Q2-D (quasi-2-D wake, with only streamwise vortices), 2-DS (2-D spiral wake, dominated by streamwise vortices with limited transverse components) and 3-DS (fully 3-D spiral wake, with strong interaction between streamwise and transverse vortices).

Figure 20

Figure 19.Time-averaged 3-D streamlines of the wake flow field for (ai–av) SU; (bi–bv) TU; (ci–cv) APU; and (di–dv) IPU configurations at five representative wavelengths $\lambda / L_m = 1.0, 3.0, 4.5, 6.0$ and 8.0. The wake structures are categorised as Q2-D (quasi-2-D wake with limited vortex development), 2-DS (2-D spiral wake with dominant streamwise vortices) and 3-DS (fully 3-D spiral wake with strong streamwise–transverse vortex interactions).

Figure 21

Figure 20.Variation of the recirculation length $L_{\textit{CF}}$ with wavelength ($\lambda /L_m$) at the node (black squares) and saddle (red circles) planes for different wavy cylinder configurations: (a) SU; (b) TU; (c) APU; and (d) IPU. Embedded streamline views illustrate formation length variations, and the presence or absence of spanwise and transverse vortices, highlighting the impact of undulation geometry on wake stability and regime transitions. The separation angles at node $(z/\lambda = 0.0)$ and saddle $(z/\lambda = 0.50$) are marked next to the cylinders, and the spanwise variation of the $L_{\textit{CF}}$ is shown as red solid lines in the x–z plane corresponding to the midspan section $(y/\lambda = 0.5)$.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Schematic representation of transverse recirculating flows and their influence on spanwise vortex modes in the SU configuration at (a) $\lambda /L_m=3.0$ and (b) $\lambda /L_m=6.0$. The diagrams illustrate how impingement, redirection and sweeping of transverse flows affect spanwise vortex structures, including the suppression of vortex formation (NV), emergence of symmetric vortices (SV), vortex stretching and break-up (VSB) and re-symmetric vortex (RSV) transitions.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Variation of (a) time-averaged drag coefficient $\overline {C_{\!D}}$ and (b) root-mean-square lift coefficient $C_{L,\textit{rms}}$ with non-dimensional wavelength $\lambda / L_m$ for SU, TU, APU and IPU configurations. Each marker denotes the dominant wake regime – quasi-2-D (Q2-D), 2-D spiral (2-DS) or 3-D spiral (3-DS) – capturing transitions in wake structure and their correlation with aerodynamic force reduction and stabilisation behaviour.