Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T11:29:16.100Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Optimizing the control of transition to turbulence using a Bayesian method

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 April 2022

Anton Pershin*
Affiliation:
Department of Physics, University of Oxford, Oxford OX1 3PU, UKSchool of Mathematics, University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK
Cédric Beaume
Affiliation:
School of Mathematics, University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK
Tom S. Eaves
Affiliation:
School of Science and Engineering, University of Dundee, Dundee DD1 4HN, UK
Steven M. Tobias
Affiliation:
School of Mathematics, University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK
*
†Email address for correspondence: anton.pershin@physics.ox.ac.uk

Abstract

The nonlinear robustness of laminar plane Couette flow is considered under the action of in-phase spanwise wall oscillations by computing properties of the edge of chaos, i.e. the boundary of its basins of attraction. Three measures are used to quantify the chosen control strategy on laminar-to-turbulent transition: the kinetic energy of edge states (local attractors on the edge of chaos), the form of the minimal seed (least energetic perturbation on the edge of chaos), and the laminarization probability (the probability that a random perturbation from the laminar flow of given kinetic energy will laminarize). A novel Bayesian approach is introduced to enable the accurate computation of the laminarization probability at a fraction of the cost of previous methods. While the edge state and the minimal seed provide useful information about the dynamics of transition to turbulence, neither measure is particularly useful to judge the effectiveness of the control strategy since they are not representative of the global geometry of the edge. In contrast, the laminarization probability provides global information about the edge and can be used to evaluate the control effectiveness by computing a laminarization score (the expected laminarization probability) and the associated expected dissipation rate of the controlled flow. These two quantities allow for the determination of optimal control parameter values subject to desired constraints. The results discussed in the paper are expected to be applied to a wide range of transitional flows and control strategies aimed at suppressing or triggering transition to turbulence.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Sketch of phase space, illustrating the edge of chaos as a thick black line, turbulence located by the shaded red region, and the laminar state as a fixed point. An attractor along the edge of chaos, called the edge state, is represented together with its one-dimensional unstable manifold in thick coloured arrows: the red side sends perturbations to turbulence, while the blue side sends them to the laminar flow. The minimal seed is indicated, as well as, in dashed blue lines, the perimeter around the laminar flow on which perturbations have the same energy as the minimal seed. The thin lines show two trajectories starting from nearby positions: the red one eventually transitions to turbulence, while the blue one eventually laminarizes.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Time-evolution of the spanwise component of the laminar flow (blue curves) in the presence of in-phase wall oscillations for $W_{osc} = 0.3$, $\omega = 1/64$ and $\textit {Re} = 500$ represented at four different phases of the oscillation, where $T = 2{\rm \pi} / \omega$ is the oscillation period. The orange and black dashed curves denote the Stokes boundary layers associated with the bottom and top walls, respectively, and defined by the following expressions: $W(y, t) =W_{osc}\,{\rm e}^{-\varOmega \tilde {y}} \sin (\omega t - \varOmega \tilde {y})$, where $\varOmega = \sqrt {\omega \,\textit {Re} /2}$, $\tilde {y} = y + 1$ for the bottom wall, and $\tilde {y} = 1 - y$ for the top wall. For these parameter values, the depth of penetration is $\delta \approx 0.5$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Distribution of the turbulent kinetic energy $E$ (blue) and the edge state kinetic energy (green; the edge state will be discussed in detail in § 3.1) plotted as a function of frequency $\omega$ for amplitudes ranging from $W_{osc} = 0$ to $W_{osc} = 0.3$. Red and blue dots denote the block maxima and minima as explained in the text. Thick lines, dark bands and light bands denote the mean, interquartile range and interdecile range of the distributions, respectively. The vertical dashed lines correspond to the reference frequency $\omega = 1/8$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.(a) Time-averaged wall-normal shear rate associated with the streamwise velocity in the presence of wall oscillations for $W_{osc} = 0.3$ and plotted for various frequencies $\omega$. (b) Laminar (dashed) and turbulent (solid) dissipation rates plotted as a function of frequency $\omega$ for amplitudes varying from $W_{osc} = 0.1$ to $W_{osc} = 0.4$. The results for $W_{osc} = 0.5$ are omitted because, at this amplitude, it was virtually impossible to sustain turbulence for the necessary time duration to compute reliably the turbulent dissipation rate. In both plots, dashed and solid black lines correspond to laminar and turbulent flows in the uncontrolled case ($W_{osc} = 0$), respectively.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Visualization of the edge tracking procedure for (a) $W_{osc} = 0.4$, $\omega = 1$, (b) $W_{osc} = 0.3$, $\omega = 1/8$, (c) $W_{osc} = 0.1$, $\omega = 1/16$, and (d) $W_{osc} = 0.2$, $\omega = 1/16$. In each panel, the top plot shows the time-evolution of the kinetic energy of the perturbation from the laminar flow used to get the edge tracking started (grey), of trajectories associated with subsequent iterations of the algorithm (colours), and of the trajectory along the edge (dashed black curve). The bottom plot of each panel shows the time-evolution of the $xy$-averaged kinetic energy of the perturbation associated with the edge trajectories. The edge trajectories are found to approach edge states that can be classified according to the dynamics of the perturbation from the laminar flow: equilibrium (a), periodic orbit (b), relative periodic orbit (c), and chaotic trajectory (d), depending on the amplitude and frequency of wall oscillations (see figure 6(a) for details). The periodic orbit in (b) and the relative periodic orbit in (c) bear clear structural resemblance to the steady edge states obtained for larger control frequencies (a), which in turn are virtually indistinguishable from the edge state in the uncontrolled system.

Figure 5

Figure 6.(a) Classification of the edge states as equilibria (EQ), periodic orbits (PO), relative periodic orbits (RPO) and chaotic trajectories (C) as a function of $W_{osc}$ and $\omega$. (b) Dependence of the mean edge state energy $E_{edge}$ and associated standard deviation (error bars) on the amplitude $W_{osc}$ and frequency $\omega$ of the wall oscillations. The edge state results are omitted for $W_{osc} = 0.5$, $\omega = 1/4, 1/8, 1/16, 1/32$ in both (a,b) since the control strategy suppresses turbulence almost completely at these parameter values.

Figure 6

Figure 7.(a) Upper bounds for the minimal seed turbulent kinetic energy $E_c$ against $\omega$ for $W_{osc} = 0$ (horizontal black line), $W_{osc} = 0.2$ (blue) and $W_{osc} = 0.4$ (orange). Open orange symbols are parameter values where the algorithm did not converge (see text). (b–h) Time-evolution of the $xy$-averaged turbulent kinetic energy of the minimal seed perturbation and its trajectory. The colour scheme is applied following a logarithmic scale over five orders of magnitude from $10^{-6}$ (dark blue) to 0.1 (dark red). The parameter values are: (b) $W_{osc}=0$; (c,e,g) $W_{osc}=0.2$ and $\omega = 1/2$, $1/8$ and $1/32$, respectively; and (d,f,h) $W_{osc}=0.4$ and $\omega =1/2$, $1/8$ and $1/32$, respectively.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Examples of posterior distributions of the form of (4.6) plotted for $N = 10$ (blue) and $N = 30$ (orange), and three values of the fraction of laminarizing RPs: $l/N = 0$ (a), $l/N = 3/10$ (b), and $l/N = 9/10$ (c). Red dots and shaded regions denote the means and interdecile ranges of the corresponding distributions, respectively.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Schematic procedure used to approximate the laminarization probability. In step 1, we build a sample $\boldsymbol {R}$ for each RP energy level and determine the number of laminarizing events. Blue (resp. red) blocks correspond to laminarizing (resp. transitioning) RPs. Next, in step 2, we use the count obtained in each of these samples to compute the associated posterior distribution $f_{P_{lam}}(p \mid \boldsymbol {R} = \boldsymbol {r})$ based on expression (4.6) for each energy level. We then compute the point estimates of the laminarization probability based on expression (4.7) for each energy level. These points are shown using red dots on the step 2 curves and are shown on the bottom graph as pink bars. The approximate dependence of the laminarization probability on the RP energy is then obtained in step 3 via least squares fitting based on the fitting function $p(E)$ (blue curve in the bottom plot) introduced in (4.8). More details on the final fitting are shown in figure 10.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Examples of estimated laminarization probabilities $P_{lam}$ (pink bars) plotted together with the associated fitting function $p(E) = 1 - (1 - a)\,\gamma (\alpha, \beta E)$, where $\gamma (\alpha, \beta E)$ is the lower incomplete gamma function (blue curve), together with its characterizing quantities (indicated with black dots on the plot) defined in the table.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Expectations (solid lines) for the distribution of fitting functions and their interquartile (dark bands) and interdecile (light bands) ranges for the uncontrolled (a,b) and controlled (c,d) test cases. Panels (a,c) were computed using a single sample of $N = 10$ RPs per energy level, Bayesian estimation of the laminarization probability (pink bars), and drawing a large number of samples from the posterior distributions to build the associated interquartile and interdecile ranges (see the text for details). Panels (b,d) were computed by drawing $1000$ samples, where each sample corresponds to $10$ RPs per energy level, from a large database of RPs with replacement, and then building a distribution of fitting functions each of which was obtained following the procedure illustrated in figure 9. Pink bars in (b,d) correspond to the laminarization probability $P_{lam}$ estimated for all available RPs. Grey error bars correspond to the interdecile range of the laminarization probability estimated using Bayesian inference (a,c) or subsampling (b,d).

Figure 11

Figure 12.Performance of the wall oscillation control strategy as a function of the oscillation frequency $\omega$ shown via the laminarization score $S$ for the uniform (a) and exponential (b) distributions of the RP energy, $f_E(E)$, and via energies $E_{a}$ (c) and $E_{flex}$ (d). The results are shown in each panel for different forcing amplitudes as indicated by the legend. Error bars show the confidence intervals (interdecile ranges) resulting from Bayesian estimation. The case $W_{osc} = 0.5$ and $\omega = 1/8$ leads to almost complete laminarization of all RPs ($p(E) \approx 1$), so that $p(E)$ only weakly depends on $E$, thereby explaining the abnormal variation of $E_{flex}$.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Expected dissipation rates for the uniform (a) and exponential (b) distributions of the RP energy plotted as functions of $W_{osc}$ and $\omega$.

Figure 13

Figure 14.Relative errors in (a) $S$, denoted $e_S$, (b) $E_a$, denoted $e_{a}$, and (c) $E_{flex}$, denoted $e_{flex}$, as functions of $N$. These errors were computed by estimating the fitting function $p(E)$ using $N$ randomly selected RPs per energy level. Errors associated with the uncontrolled (controlled) system are shown in the top (bottom) row. The parameter values of the control are $W_{osc} = 0.3$, $\omega = 1/16$. The dark (resp. light) blue bands correspond to the interquartile (resp. interdecile) ranges. Dark blue lines show the expectations of associated errors as functions of $N$.