Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:37:04.117Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

A simple and practical model for combined wave–current canopy flows

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2015

Robert B. Zeller*
Affiliation:
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA
Francisco J. Zarama
Affiliation:
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA
Joel S. Weitzman
Affiliation:
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA
Jeffrey R. Koseff
Affiliation:
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: rzeller@stanford.edu
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Laboratory experiments were used to evaluate and improve modelling of combined wave–current flow through submerged aquatic canopies. Horizontal in-canopy particle image velocimetry (PIV) and wavemaker-measurement synchronization allowed direct volume averaging and ensemble averaging by wave phase, which were used to fully resolve the volume-averaged unsteady momentum budget. Parameterizations for the drag, Reynolds stress, vertical advection, wake production and shear production were tested against the laboratory measurements. The drag was found to have small errors due to unsteadiness and the finite aspect ratio of the canopy elements. The Smagorinsky model for the Reynolds stress showed much better agreement with the measurements than the quadratic friction parameterization used in the literature. A proposed parameterization for the vertical advection based on linear wave theory was also found to be effective and is much more computationally efficient than solving the pressure Poisson equation. A simple 1D 0-equation Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) model was developed to use these parameterizations. The basic framework of the model is an extrapolation from previous 2- and 3-box models to  $N$ boxes. While the resolution of the model is flexible, the filter length for the Smagorinsky parameterization has to be chosen appropriately. With the proper filter length, the $N$ -box model demonstrated good agreement with the measurements at both low and high resolution. Scaling analysis was used to establish a region of parameter space where the $N$ -box model is expected to be effective. The following conditions define this region: the wave-induced velocity is of similar or greater magnitude than the background current, the drag to shear length ratio is small enough to produce canopy behaviour, the wave orbital excursion is not much larger than the drag length, the Froude number is small and the canopy is under shallow submergence, yet far from emergent. Under these assumptions, the dominant balance is between pressure and unsteadiness, the drag is secondary, and the other terms are small. The simple Reynolds stress parameterization in the $N$ -box model is appropriate under these conditions because the Reynolds stress is unlikely to be the dominant source of error. This finding is important because the Reynolds stress is typically one of the dominant drivers of computational cost and model complexity. Based on these findings, the $N$ -box model is expected to be a practical tool for a wide range of combined wave–current canopy flows because of its simplicity and computational efficiency.

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© 2015 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Table 1.Summary of parameterizations.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Schematic of (a) wave-driven flow over a submerged rigid canopy, (b) the spatial discretization for the 2-box model and (c) the spatial discretization of the N-box model. Fluxes are defined at the box faces and streamwise velocity is defined at the nodes.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Plots of ${\it\alpha}$ and ${\it\beta}$ as a function of the orbital excursion to drag length ratio for four representative values of $L_{D}/L_{S}$ (see table 2). The curves are for the pure wave case and were generated by numerically integrating (1.33). The pressure gradient was assumed to be uniform throughout the water column and the inertia force and vertical advection were neglected with the intention of isolating the Reynolds stress and drag effects. Here ${\it\beta}$ was computed based on the r.m.s. Reynolds stress and drag. The open circles are for 10 s breaking waves at 1 m depth and the dots are for 20 s breaking waves at 5 m depth (see table 3). Smaller waves would be to the left on the ${\it\beta}$ curve.

Figure 3

Table 2.Parameters for representative canopies. The $L_{D}/L_{S}$ and associated $L_{D}$ values were chosen to be representative of the values in Marshall (2000), Reidenbach et al. (2006) and Luhar et al. (2010) with the assumption that $C_{D}=1$ and $C_{S}=0.17$. The $L_{S}$ and $h$ values were computed from the other two quantities.

Figure 4

Table 3.Conditions chosen for the reference extreme orbital excursions. In order to allow large waves, the $H$ values were chosen to be at the upper end of the specified submergence ratio range ($2) for very tall coral and seagrass canopy heights. The wave amplitudes were chosen to be at the breaking limit of $a_{w}/H=0.4$ (Dalrymple & Dean 1991). Based on linear wave theory, waves produce their most extreme orbital excursions when they are at their breaking limit. The wave period, $T$, values were chosen to be in the middle and the upper end of the spectrum for swell waves. The orbital excursions were computed based on the other values according to linear wave theory.

Figure 5

Figure 3.Plots of ${\it\alpha}$ and ${\it\beta}$ as a function of the orbital excursion to shear length ratio for the four representative values of $L_{D}/L_{S}$ (see table 2). The curves are for the pure wave case and were generated by the same approach as figure 2. The vertical lines mark the extreme wave cases for the shortest canopies presented in the literature, which have $L_{S}=3.5~\text{m}$ based on $h=0.1$  m and $C_{S}=0.17$. The dotted line is for the 10 s wave and the solid line is for the 20 s wave (see table 3).

Figure 6

Table 4.Parameters of the five flow conditions.

Figure 7

Figure 4.Example PIV data for the streamwise velocity ensemble-averaged by wave phase, $U~(\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1})$. The data was taken in the 5 cm 5 s wave condition at 14 cm above the bottom. The laser sheet enters from the positive $y$ direction. The vertical white streaks are regions that were masked during image pre-processing because they were in the shadows that the elements created in the laser sheet. The masked regions were filled with interpolated data, except in the immediate vicinity of the elements. The rectangle in the centre of the image indicates the ROI that was used for volume-averaging.

Figure 8

Figure 5.Example results from the 5 cm 5 s flow condition: (a) $\langle U\rangle ~(\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1})$; (b) $\langle W\rangle ~(\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1})$; (c) $\partial \langle U\rangle /\partial z~(\text{s}^{-1})$; (d) $-\langle \overline{u^{\prime }w^{\prime }}\rangle ~(\text{m}^{2}~\text{s}^{-2})$. These results were computed and interpolated from a combination of PIV and ADV measurements as described in § 2.

Figure 9

Figure 6.Relative magnitudes of the momentum budget terms for the 5 wavy flow conditions. The magnitudes were computed by taking the RMS in-canopy depth-average of each term and non-dimensionalizing by ${\it\omega}U_{w}$. The drag is based on the residual of the momentum budget.

Figure 10

Table 5.Summary of the scale for each term based on (1.33).

Figure 11

Figure 7.Example non-dimensionalized in-canopy depth-averaged momentum budgets (1.33) for (a) the 2 cm 2 s wave case and (b) the 5 cm 5 s wave case as a function of wave phase. Each term is non-dimensionalized by ${\it\omega}U_{w}$. All terms were moved to the left-hand side of (1.33), so their sum should be zero. There is a clear balance between pressure and unsteadiness, modulated by drag.

Figure 12

Table 6.Summary of the parameters for the five flow conditions. For reference, $L_{D}=26~\text{cm}$ and $L_{S}=5.4~\text{m}$ based on $C_{D}=1$ and $C_{S}=0.17$.

Figure 13

Figure 8.Estimates of $F_{D}~(\text{m}^{2}~\text{s}^{-1})$ for the (a,b) 2 cm 2 s wave case and (c,d) the 5 cm 5 s wave case estimated from (a,c) the momentum budget (1.1) and (b,d) the quadratic drag parameterization (1.10) with $C_{D}=2.4$. The momentum equation $F_{D}$ shows a more concentrated positive peak as a function of ${\it\theta}$. At the top of the canopy, the momentum equation suggests that $F_{D}$ drops off sharply, whereas the parameterization suggests that it has a sharp increase.

Figure 14

Figure 9.Comparison between the momentum budget and quadratic drag parameterization estimates of $\widehat{F}_{D}$ as a function of wave phase. The value of $C_{D}=2.4$ was chosen by fitting the quadratic drag parameterization to the local $F_{D}$ values for all flow cases.

Figure 15

Figure 10.Reynolds stress measurements compared with the $C_{f}$ parameterization for $C_{f}=0.025$. In order to take advantage of the higher sampling rate of the ADV, only ADV data was used for this figure. This is appropriate because $U_{\infty }$ and $-\langle \overline{u^{\prime }w^{\prime }}\rangle _{h}$ do not require in-canopy volume averaging. The data parameterization passes near the centre of the data for each flow condition, but does not capture the variability with phase.

Figure 16

Figure 11.Comparison of the $C_{f}$ and Smagorinsky parameterizations with $-\langle \overline{u^{\prime }w^{\prime }}\rangle _{h}$ measurements from the 5 cm 5 s flow case. Here $C_{f}=0.025$ and $C_{S}=0.14$ were used. The parameterization values were computed using the combined ADV and PIV data, whereas $-\langle \overline{u^{\prime }w^{\prime }}\rangle _{h}$ was computed from ADV measurements alone.

Figure 17

Figure 12.Estimated and measured advective flux as a function of wave phase for the 5 cm 5 s flow condition. Estimates based on integrating the pressure gradient (1.15) are provided, as well as estimates based on directly integrating the unsteadiness. The difference is that the pressure estimate assumes that pressure balances unsteadiness.

Figure 18

Figure 13.Estimates of advective flux compared with measurements from all wave cases at all heights. Estimates are based on the $\langle W\rangle$ parameterization (1.15) and measured $\langle U\rangle$ values.

Figure 19

Figure 14.Estimated advective flux at the top of the canopy compared with measurements for all wave cases. Estimates are based on the parameterization of $\langle W\rangle$ and spatial interpolation of $\langle U\rangle$ presented in (1.16).

Figure 20

Figure 15.The $C_{D}$ parameterization for $\mathscr{P}_{w}$ compared with measurements from the five flow conditions. Here $C_{D}=2.4$ was chosen to match the $F_{D}$ parameterization and ${\it\beta}_{p}=0.8$ was chosen to match the $\mathscr{P}_{w}$ data.

Figure 21

Figure 16.Lagged and unlagged versions of the in-canopy depth-averaged $C_{D}$ parameterization for $\mathscr{P}_{w}$ compared with data for the 5 cm 5 s wave case. Here $C_{D}=2.4$ and ${\it\beta}_{p}=0.8$. The phase lag is ${\it\theta}/2{\rm\pi}=0.02$, which is equivalent to 0.1 s.

Figure 22

Figure 17.Lagged $C_{D}$ parameterization for $\mathscr{P}_{w}$ compared with measurements from the five flow conditions. Here $C_{D}=2.4$, ${\it\beta}_{p}=0.8$ and the parameterization is lagged ${\it\theta}/2{\rm\pi}=0.02$ (0.1 s).

Figure 23

Figure 18.Mixing layer $\mathscr{P}_{s}$ estimates from the Smagorinsky parameterization for the 2-box model compared with laboratory measurements from the 5 cm 5 s flow condition. The mixing layer is assumed to be the region within $0.25h$ of the top of the canopy. The value of $C_{S}=0.14$ was chosen based on the results for the Reynolds stress and the value of ${\it\delta}_{S}=0.65h$ was chosen by matching the r.m.s. of the parameterization to the r.m.s. of the measurements.

Figure 24

Figure 19.Example output from each of the four models at a single snapshot in phase: (a) 2BI; (b) HRI; (c) HRE; and (d) NRI. The vertical lines are used to denote the extent of each box and the dots denote the nodes.

Figure 25

Table 7.Summary of the four implementations of the N-box model that were tested. The $R^{2}$ values are based on comparison with all of the $\langle U\rangle$ measurements from the five flow conditions.

Figure 26

Figure 20.The $N$-box model results for the streamwise velocity as a function of phase compared with laboratory results from the 5 cm 5 s flow condition: (a) 2BI and (b) NRI. The lines represent model results and the dots represent laboratory results.

Figure 27

Figure 21.Modelled momentum budget terms as a function of phase compared with laboratory results from the 5 cm 5 s flow condition: (a) 2BI’s in-canopy box and (b) NRI’s box between $3h/8$ and $h/2$. The lines represent model results and the dots represent laboratory data.

Figure 28

Figure 22.The $\langle U\rangle$ values modelled by HRE compared with laboratory measurements for all five flow conditions.