Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T10:13:18.828Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Statistical analysis of outer large-scale/inner-layer interactions in channel flow subjected to oscillatory drag-reducing wall motion using a multiple-variable joint-probability-density function methodology

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 July 2021

Lionel Agostini*
Affiliation:
Institut Pprime, CNRS / Université de Poitiers / ENSMA, Poitiers 86073, France
Michael Leschziner
Affiliation:
Department of Aeronautics, Imperial College London, London SW7 2AZ, UK
*
†Email address for correspondence: lionel.agostini@univ-poitiers.fr

Abstract

Full flow-field data derived from a direct numerical simulation for channel flow subjected to drag-reducing oscillatory spanwise motion are analysed by means of a recently developed methodology, which consolidates the entire simulation data set within multiple-variable joint-probability-density functions (PDFs). A wide variety of statistical data of interest are then extracted from the joint PDF without recourse to any of the original simulation data. The nominal friction Reynolds number of the baseline (unactuated) flow is 1025, and the actuation is effected at a wall-scaled period of 100, at which value the drag-reduction level is approximately 30 %, while any actuation-induced phase fluctuations in the streamwise direction are minimal. Interest focuses on the elucidation of the mechanisms by which the near-wall turbulence is modified by the action of footprints of large-scale structures in the outer parts of the log-law region, which tend to intensify as the Reynolds number rises. To elucidate these mechanisms, the Reynolds stresses and their production rates, conditional on the intensity of large-scale skin-friction fluctuations, are examined. The investigation includes a separation of the Reynolds stresses into large-scale and small-scale components by means the empirical mode decomposition, allowing the intensity of footprinting and of small-scale modulation of the near-wall turbulence to be quantified separately. The conditional statistical properties are presented in the form of maps in planes having the wall-normal distance and large-scale skin friction as coordinates, supplemented by wall-normal property profiles and an examination of large-scale and small-scale contributions to the skin friction. The analysis highlights the strongly asymmetric response of the production rate and the turbulence level in the buffer layer to positive vs. negative footprints, the former strongly enhancing small-scale turbulence. This is proposed to be at least a partial explanation of the decline in the drag-reduction effectiveness of oscillatory spanwise wall motion with increasing Reynolds number.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Streamwise-velocity fluctuations across three wall-parallel planes in channel flow at $Re_\tau \approx 1025$ with oscillatory spanwise motion at $T^+=100$: (a) $y^+\approx 200$, (b) $y^+\approx 18$ and (c) $y^+\approx 3$. The colour scales indicate wall-scaled velocity.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Contribution of different scales to streamwise turbulence energy in channel flow at $Re_\tau \approx 1025$ and $T^+=100$; (a) premultiplied spanwise spectral map; grey contours represent the total field; coloured iso-lines represent sub-spectra for the different EMD modes and the residual; (b) scale-wise contributions to streamwise energy: blue line represent small scales (modes 1 and 2, $\overline {u_{SS}u_{SS}}^+$), red line represents large scales (mode 4, mode 5 and residual, $\overline {u_{LS}u_{LS}}^+$), green line represents intermediate scales (mode 3), black line is the total stress ($\overline {u^{\prime } u^{\prime }}^+$).

Figure 2

Figure 3.Illustration of EMD processing across one wall-parallel plane at $y^+\approx 3$; (a) PDF of large-scale streamwise-velocity fluctuations derived from EMD, dashed dark blue and red lines correspond to $1\,\%$ extreme events, light blue and orange lines correspond to $10\,\%$ and green line to $50\,\%$ (median of PDF); (b) large-scale fluctuations obtained by summing up all EMD modes (4 and above) across one quarter of the computational box; (c) full field of streamwise fluctuations: black and grey iso-lines correspond to the $15\,\%$ extreme large-scale positive and negative large-scale fluctuations, respectively. Inclined small-scale streaks within black islands reflect the influence of the spanwise Stokes layer.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Velocity and strain fields conditional on large-scale skin-friction fluctuations: (a) mean streamwise-velocity field relative to the average ($\overline {u}^+|_{Cf_{LS}} -\overline {u}^+$); (b) velocity profiles at the five locations marked in the PDF in figure 3(a); (c,d): as (a,b), respectively, but for the wall-normal velocity; (e,f) as (a,b), respectively, but for the streamwise shear strain rate ($\textrm {d} \overline {u}^+|_{Cf_{LS}}/{\textrm {d} y}-\textrm {d} \overline {u}^+ / {\textrm {d} y}$). Dashed lines in (b,d, f) are the respective mean profiles. Grey line and curve in (b) represent the canonical log law and viscous-layer profile, respectively. Grey curve in (a,e is the locus $y^+_{LS}\approx 12$, with $LS$ denoting scaling with large-scale friction velocity.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Response of the stresses to the large-scale skin-friction: (a) maps of $Cf_{LS}$-dependent rate of increase in the streamwise stress $(\textrm {d} \overline {u^{\prime } u^{\prime } }^+/\textrm {d} Cf_{LS})$; (b) profile of the streamwise stress ($Cf_{LS}$-wise integral of field (a); (c) and (d) correspond to (a) and (b), respectively, but for the shear stress ($-\textrm {d} \overline {u^{\prime } v^{\prime}}^+/\textrm {d} Cf_{LS})$. Solid red and blue profiles in (b) and (d) are partial integrals of the respective maps across $Cf_{LS}$ sub-ranges to the right (positive $Cf_{LS}$) and left (negative $Cf_{LS}$) of the median of the $Cf_{LS}$ PDF, respectively. Dashed red and blue lines: partial integrals over the extreme $\pm$10 % tails of the $Cf_{LS}$ PDF, respectively.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Normalised fields of stresses: (a) map of $Cf_{LS}$-dependent rate of change of streamwise stress normalised by streamwise stress $\textrm {d} \overline {u^{\prime } u^{\prime } }^+ ( y^+ ) /\textrm {d} Cf_{LS} / \overline {u^{\prime } u^{\prime } }^+ ( y^+ )$; (b) as (a) but for the shear stress $\textrm {d} \overline {u^{\prime } v^{\prime } }^+ ( y^+ ) /\textrm {d} Cf_{LS} / \overline {u^{\prime } v^{\prime } }^+ ( y^+)$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Conditional stress fields: (a) map of streamwise stress conditional on $Cf_{LS}$ (see (4.4); (b) profiles of conditional streamwise stress at locations marked in the PDF of figure 3(a); (c,e) and (d,f) as (a) and (b), respectively, for the shear stress and wall-normal stress; dashed profiles in (b,d,f ) represent averages. Grey curve is the locus $y^+_{LS}\approx 12$, with $LS$ denoting scaling with large-scale friction velocity.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Properties of streamwise stress at $y^+=20$; (a) variation of $(\textrm {d} \overline {u^{\prime } u^{\prime } }^+/\textrm {d} Cf_{LS})$ (red line) and its $Cf_{LS}$-wise integral $u^{\prime } u^{\prime }$ (blue line); (b) conditional streamwise stress $\overline {u^{\prime } u^{\prime }}^+|_{Cf_{LS}}$. The vertical straight lines correspond to those in the $Cf_{LS}$ PDF, figure 3(a).

Figure 8

Figure 9.Production of streamwise stress: (a) map of production conditional on $Cf_{LS}$; (b) profiles of conditional production at the locations marked in the PDF in figure 3(a); (c,d) as (a,b), respectively, but premultiplied by $y^+$. The dashed profiles in (b,d) represent averages.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Production of shear stress: (a) map of production conditional on $Cf_{LS}$; (b) profiles of conditional production at the locations marked in the PDF in figure 3(a); (c,d) as (a,b), respectively, but pre-multiplied by $y^+$. The dashed profiles in (b,d) represent averages.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Conditional small-scale stress fields: (a) map of streamwise stress conditional on $Cf_{LS}$ (see (4.4); (b) profiles of conditional streamwise stress at locations marked in the PDF of figure 3(a). Dashed profile identifies the mean distribution; (c,e) and (d,f) as (a) and (b), respectively, for the shear stress and wall-normal stress. The dashed profiles in (b), (d), (f) represent averages.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Profiles of stress components; (a) small-scale streamwise stress; (b) small-scale shear stress; (c) large-scale streamwise stress; (d) large-scale shear stress. Solid blue/red lines: contributions arising from the left/right of the median of the $Cf_{LS}$ PDF, respectively; dashed blue/red lines: contributions arising from partial integration across extreme $\pm$10 % tails of the $Cf_{LS}$ PDF, respectively; black lines: total level (sum of solid blue and red profiles).

Figure 12

Figure 13.Variations of buffer-layer properties across the range of $Cf_{LS}$; (a) wall-normal location of the nominal centre of the buffer layer, defined as the line of maximum streamwise energy of the small scales; figure 13(b) the magnitude of the maximum streamwise small-scale energy along the loci in (a); (c) the magnitude of the maximum streamwise small-scale energy in (b) as a function of the wall-normal distance $y^+$ of the loci in (a). The red and magenta curves pertain to the actuated case, and blue curves to the canonical case examined in Agostini & Leschziner (2019a). The $u_{\tau }$ scaling is indicated in (c).

Figure 13

Figure 14.Contributions to the skin friction via the FIK relationship, (5.1): (a) map of $(1-{y^+}/{Re_\tau })(-\overline {u^{\prime } v^{\prime }}^+|_{Cf_{LS}})$; (b) as (a) but for small-scale stress contribution; (c) as (a) but for large-scale stress contribution; (d) $Cf_{LS}$-wise gradients of $(1-{y^+}/{Re_\tau })(-\overline {u^{\prime } v^{\prime }}^+)$ in which the shear stress is either the total level (upper black curve), or the large-scale component (red area under lower curve), or the small-scale component (blue area under the middle curve); columns on the right-hand side of the figure represent the corresponding small-scale (blue) and large-scale (red) contributions to the turbulent skin friction $Cf_T$ (grey).