Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T09:16:36.730Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Surface layer response to heterogeneous tree canopy distributions: roughness regime regulates secondary flow polarity

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 August 2022

P. Joshi
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, The University of Texas at Dallas, 800 West Campbell Road, Richardson, TX 75080, USA
W. Anderson*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, The University of Texas at Dallas, 800 West Campbell Road, Richardson, TX 75080, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: wca140030@utdallas.edu

Abstract

Large-eddy simulation was used to model turbulent atmospheric surface layer (ASL) flow over canopies composed of streamwise-aligned rows of synthetic trees of height, $h$, and systematically arranged to quantify the response to variable streamwise spacing, $\delta _1$, and spanwise spacing, $\delta _2$, between adjacent trees. The response to spanwise and streamwise heterogeneity has, indeed, been the topic of a sustained research effort: the former resulting in formation of Reynolds-averaged counter-rotating secondary cells, the latter associated with the $k$- and $d$-type response. No study has addressed the confluence of both, and results herein show secondary flow polarity reversal across ‘critical’ values of $\delta _1$ and $\delta _2$. For $\delta _2/\delta \lesssim 1$ and $\gtrsim 2$, where $\delta$ is the flow depth, the counter-rotating secondary cells are aligned such that upwelling and downwelling, respectively, occurs above the elements. The streamwise spacing $\delta _1$ regulates this transition, with secondary cell reversal occurring first for the largest $k$-type cases, as elevated turbulence production within the canopy necessitates entrainment of fluid from aloft. The results are interpreted through the lens of a benchmark prognostic closure for effective aerodynamic roughness, $z_{0,{Eff.}} = \alpha \sigma _h$, where $\alpha$ is a proportionality constant and $\sigma _h$ is height root mean square. We report $\alpha \approx 10^{-1}$, the value reported over many decades for a broad range of rough surfaces, for $k$-type cases at small $\delta _2$, whereas the transition to $d$-type arrangements necessitates larger $\delta _2$. Though preliminary, results highlight the non-trivial response to variation of streamwise and spanwise spacing.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of tree canopy arrangements addressed as part of the research effort. Panels (a,b) show canopy visualisation in the streamwise–wall-normal and spanwise–wall-normal plane, respectively, where annotations are provided for streamwise spacing between subsequent trees, $\delta _1/\delta$, spanwise spacing between rows of trees, $\delta _2/\delta$, canopy height, $h/\delta$, and the streamwise, spanwise and vertical extent of individual tree canopy, $h_1$, $h_2$ and $h_c$, respectively. Table 1 summarises specific cases; tree ‘trunks’ are modelled as square with side length, $d_t$. Panel (c) shows the $\delta _1$–$\delta _2$ parameter space (normalised by $h$ and $\delta$), with annotations superimposed for flow-roughness regimes predicated upon $\delta _1$ ($k$- or $d$-type roughness) (Jimenez 2004) and $\delta _2$ (roughness, transitional and topography regimes) (Yang & Anderson 2017b). In panel (c), filled symbols indicate the location within $\delta _1$–$\delta _2$ parameter space corresponding to individual cases, where $d$-type cases, intermediate cases and $k$-type cases are denoted via filled black and grey circles, filled red circles and filled blue circles, respectively (see main text). Shown also are regimes R1, R2, R3 and R4, with accompanying sketches for each regime depicted on the right, for context.

Figure 1

Table 1.Summary of vegetation canopy attributes and computational domain attributes considered for this article, where $\delta = 16$ m for all cases. These cases will be referenced via the (2.3) symbol key. See also figure 1 for graphical depictions of streamwise and spanwise heterogeneity.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Vertical profiles of canopy geometric attributes for cases considered in this study. Panels (a–d) show vertical profiles of plane-averaged leaf-area density averaged for cases $k1i$ (a), $k2i$ (b), $d3i$ (c) and $d4i$ (d), where index $i$ varies between 1 and 9 for variable $\delta _2$ (see also table 1 and (2.3)), and where an annotation for the direction of decreasing $\delta _1$ has been superimposed for perspective. Panel (e) shows streamwise-averaged leaf-area density at spanwise location, $y_l$, coincident with the centre of a row of trees, where an annotation for direction of $\delta _1$ is provided. Panel (f) shows the LAI, $\lambda$ (2.2), for all table 1 cases (with the exception of the comparison cases), with the direction of decreasing $\delta _1$ indicated.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Contours of instantaneous streamwise velocity in the $y$–$z$ plane at $x = L_x/2$, with isocontours of vertical velocity superimposed for values, $\tilde {w}({\boldsymbol x},t)/u_* = 1$ (red) and $-$1 (blue). Results are shown for table 1 cases with $\delta _2/\delta = 1.5$ and $\delta _1/h = 0.25$ ($d$17, panel a), $\delta _1/h = 5.75$ ($k$37, panel b) and $\delta _1/h$ = 11.75 ($k$47, panel c). Canopy elements are denoted with green silhouettes.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Contours of Reynolds-averaged streamwise velocity in the $y$–$z$ plane at $x = L_x/2$, with isocontours of vertical velocity superimposed for values, $\langle \tilde {w} \rangle _t ({\boldsymbol x})/u_* = 1$ (red) and $-1$ (blue). Results are shown for table 1 cases with $\delta _2/\delta = 1.5$ (a–c show results for cases $d$17, $k$37 and $k$47), 2 (d–f show results for cases $d$18, $k$38 and $k$48) and 3 (g–i show results for cases $d$19, $k$39 and $k$49) and streamwise spacing $\delta _1/h = 0.25$ (a,d,g), 5.75 (b,e,h) and 11.75 (c,f,i). Canopy elements are denoted with green silhouettes.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Vertical profiles of $x$- and Reynolds-averaged vertical velocity at spanwise location, $y_l$, coincident with the centre of a row of trees. Panels (a–d) show results for cases $d1i$, $d2i$, $k3i$ and $k4i$, respectively, where $i = 1$–9 corresponds with a colour transition from red to blue. Annotations superimposed for downwelling and upwelling. The canopy elevation, $h/\delta$, is denoted by horizontal green lines, and the direction of increasing $\delta _2$ is shown for perspective.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Contours of $x$- and Reynolds-averaged streamwise–wall-normal Reynolds (turbulent) stresses, $\langle {\mathsf {T}}_{xz} \rangle _{xt}/u_*^2 = (\langle \tilde {u}^\prime \tilde {w}^\prime \rangle _{xt} + \langle \tau _{xz} \rangle _{xt})/u_*^2$, in the $y$–$z$ plane. Results are shown for table 1 cases with $\delta _2/\delta = 1.5$ (a–c shows results for cases $d$17, $k$37 and $k$47), 2 (d–f shows results for cases $d$18, $k$38 and $k$48) and 3 (g–i shows results for cases $d$19, $k$39 and $k$49) and streamwise spacing $\delta _1/h = 0.25$ (a,d,g), 5.75 (b,e,hs) and 11.75 (c,f,i). Canopy elements are denoted with green silhouettes.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Vertical profiles of $x$- and Reynolds-averaged streamwise–wall-normal Reynolds (turbulent) stresses, $\langle {\mathsf {T}}_{xz} \rangle _{xt} = \langle \tilde {u}^\prime \tilde {w}^\prime \rangle _{xt} + \langle \tau _{xz} \rangle _{xt}$, at spanwise location, $y_l$, coincident with the centre of a row of trees. Panels (a–d) show results for cases $d1i$, $d2i$, $k3i$ and $k4i$, respectively, where $i = 1$ to 9 corresponds with a colour transition from blue to red. The canopy elevation, $h/\delta$, is denoted by horizontal green lines.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Idealised depiction of $tke$ production and dissipation dynamics for the $d$- (a) and $k$-type cases (b), respectively. Red regions denote locations of elevated production, dashed grey denotes regions of elevated dissipation.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Bulk flow attributes for table 1 simulations. Panels (a,b) show compensated circulation, $\varGamma ^*$ (3.2) and effective roughness length, $z_{0,{Eff.}}/\delta$, respectively, shown against spanwise heterogeneity, $\delta _2/\delta$. Symbols correspond with $\delta _1/h$ = $0.25$ (black symbols), $1$ (grey symbols), $5.75$ (red symbols) and $11.75$ (blue symbols); direction of decreasing $\delta _1$ superimposed for perspective. Cases with upwelling and downwelling above a row of elements are denoted with filled circles and filled squares, respectively. In panel (b), the horizontal solid line shows base roughness length, $\hat {z}_0/\delta$.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Vertical profiles of plane- and Reynolds-averaged streamwise velocity, $U(z) = \langle \tilde {u} \rangle _{xyt} (z)$. Panels (a–d) show results for cases $d1i$, $d2i$, $k3i$ and $k4i$, respectively, where $i = 1$–9 corresponds with a colour transition from red to blue. The canopy elevation, $h/\delta$, is denoted by vertical green line and annotation. An idealised logarithmic profile based on roughness length, $z_0/\delta = 10^{-3}$, is superimposed for perspective.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Large-scale aerodynamic response to variable canopy attributes. Panels (a–c) show height r.m.s., $\sigma _h = ( \langle h^2 \rangle _{xy} - \langle h \rangle _{xy}^2 )^{1/2}$, a posteriori-recovered effective roughness length, $z_{0,{Eff.}}$, and (3.3) proportionality constant, $\alpha$, respectively (note that individual values for $\sigma _h$, $z_{0,{Eff.}}$ and $\alpha$ are recorded in table 1). Panel (b) illustrates how the confluence of variable $\delta _1$ and $\delta _2$ preclude automatic surface regime description. Nominal regions where $\delta _2$ renders the surface a ‘roughness’ or ‘topography’ are shown (top and bottom abscissa) against regions where $\delta _1$ renders the surface $k$- or $d$-type (left and right ordinate), where $\delta _1$ and $\delta _2$ are defined with respect to flow depth and canopy height, for perspective. This confluence yields quadrant regions R1, R2, R3 and R4, which are graphically illustrated in figure 1(c).

Figure 12

Figure 12.Canopy attributes and resultant Reynolds-averaged flow statistics for cases R1.6, R3.1 and R3.6 (salient case details summarised in table 1; cases adopted from Bailey & Stoll 2013). Panel (a) shows vertical profiles of leaf-area density; panels (b,c) show vertical profiles of plane- and time-averaged streamwise velocity and streamwise–wall-normal turbulent stresses, respectively. Solid lines show results from LES, whereas symbols show datapoints recovered from Bailey & Stoll (2013), where light grey, grey and black lines/symbols correspond with cases R3.1, R3.6 and R1.6, respectively.