Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T02:04:19.866Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Water–substrate physico-chemistry in wetting dynamics

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 September 2015

Petter Johansson
Affiliation:
Department of Theoretical Physics and Swedish e-Science Research Center, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, 10691 Stockholm, Sweden
Andreas Carlson*
Affiliation:
John A. Paulson School of Engineering and Applied Sciences and Wyss Institute for Biologically Inspired Engineering, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, USADepartment of Mathematics, University of Oslo, 0316 Oslo, Norway
Berk Hess*
Affiliation:
Department of Theoretical Physics and Swedish e-Science Research Center, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, 10691 Stockholm, Sweden
*
†Email addresses for correspondence: acarlson@math.uio.no, hess@kth.se
†Email addresses for correspondence: acarlson@math.uio.no, hess@kth.se

Abstract

We consider the wetting of water droplets on substrates with different chemical composition and molecular spacing, but with an identical equilibrium contact angle. A combined approach of large-scale molecular dynamics simulations and a continuum phase field model allows us to identify and quantify the influence of the microscopic physics at the contact line on the macroscopic droplet dynamics. We show that the substrate physico-chemistry, in particular hydrogen bonding, can significantly alter the flow. Since the material parameters are systematically derived from the atomistic simulations, our continuum model has only one adjustable parameter, which appears as a friction factor at the contact line. The continuum model approaches the atomistic wetting rate only when we adjust this contact line friction factor. However, the flow appears to be qualitatively different when comparing the atomistic and continuum models, highlighting that non-trivial continuum effects can come into play near the interface of the wetting front.

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© 2015 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.(a) Initial condition of the quasi-2D simulations, where a water droplet with radius $R$ is brought into contact with a solid substrate. (b) At time $t>0$ after droplet–substrate contact the droplet spreads onto the substrate with a growing wetting radius $r(t)$ and a dynamic contact angle ${\it\theta}(t)$. (c) The molecular structure of a silica-like substrate which consists of hexagonally packed rigid $\text{SiO}_{2}$ quadrupoles; $q$ denotes the atomic charge. (d) A substrate of closely packed Lennard-Jones atoms. It should be noted that the solid substrates illustrated in (c) and (d) have the same equilibrium contact angle ${\it\theta}_{0}=37^{\circ }$ when wetted by water.

Figure 1

Table 1.The first three columns give the material properties measured from equilibrium MD simulations. The values for the surface tension ${\it\gamma}$ and interface width ${\it\epsilon}$ are for the liquid–vapour (LV) interface. The final four columns give several non-dimensional numbers from the scaling analysis, describing the ratios between different physical time and length scales of the wetting dynamics.

Figure 2

Table 2.The first six columns give the interaction parameters for a generic LJ substrate atom, and the interaction parameters bond length ${\it\sigma}$ and energy ${\it\varepsilon}$ between different atom types are calculated using Lorentz–Berthelot combination rules. The LJ–O interactions of the potential and atomistic LJ substrates give an equilibrium contact angle ${\it\theta}_{0}=37^{\circ }$. The final two columns give the slip length ${\it\delta}$ measured in MD simulations of water as a function of substrate composition, where the number in parentheses denotes the error.

Figure 3

Table 3.Material parameters of the MD systems with PME and RF treatments of the electrostatics. To keep the equilibrium contact angle fixed at ${\it\theta}_{0}=37^{\circ }$ the molecular interaction parameters of the substrate atoms are slightly adjusted for PME. The water liquid–vapour surface tension changes by approximately 10 % when comparing the PME with the RF treatment, while all other bulk properties are insensitive to the treatment of the electrostatics.

Figure 4

Figure 2.The spreading radius $r(t)$ measured from MD simulations of water droplets with the PME and RF electrostatic treatments for the (a) silica, (b) atomistic LJ and (c) LJ potential substrates. Each panel contains two different simulations, and the curves for $r(t)$ are coincident. Although the equilibrium contact angle ${\it\theta}_{0}$ is fixed, it is clear that there is a large influence of the substrate physico-chemistry. In addition, we observe that the electrostatic treatment of the water molecules can significantly influence the spreading dynamics, where the full electrostatics (PME) predicts a spreading rate 2–4 times slower than the RF treatment.

Figure 5

Figure 3.Droplet shapes from the MD simulations with different electrostatic treatments, as they spread on three substrates with different compositions: (a) silica; (b) LJ atomistic; (c) LJ potential. The electrostatic treatment only affects the long-time regime, when $r/R>0.5$, and the water–substrate physico-chemistry affects both the spreading rate and the dynamic droplet shape. The interface is extracted at the half-density contour of the droplet.

Figure 6

Figure 4.The flow field near the contact line extracted from the MD simulations for $r/R$ of 0.2 (a,c,e) and 0.8 (b,d,f), time-averaged over 200 ps: (a,b) silica; (c,d) LJ atomistic; (e,f) LJ potential. At short times, liquid molecules are transported to the contact line from above, near the droplet interface. At long times, the flow has changed characteristics and is parallel with the substrate. We note that the droplet spreading on the silica substrate is approximately half as fast as on the atomistic LJ substrate, and a third as fast as on the potential LJ substrate.

Figure 7

Figure 5.Molecular traces of selected water molecules at the contact line on silica, at $r/R$ of 0.3 (a) and 0.8 (b), corresponding to the sampled mass flow of figure 4(a,b). The paths are subdivided into steps of 1 ps and show a history of 10 ps in (a) and 20 ps in (b). (a) Molecules in the early wetting regime approach the contact line through an advective flow, coming from the droplet centre or from the droplet interface. (b) In the later regime we see a mixed process, where the majority of molecules are jumping between the potential minima of the silica substrate through a dissipative process. Only comparatively few molecules at the contact line are arriving through an advective flow from the droplet centre or interface.

Figure 8

Figure 6.(a) The spreading radius $r(t)$ for the PME MD simulation on the silica and the atomistic LJ substrate, represented in logarithmic coordinates to highlight two different spreading regimes. In the early regime, molecules are transported to the contact line from above before a foot is formed. After the formation of the wetting foot, molecules have to traverse through its geometry. To illustrate the different regimes, the dotted lines show different power laws with respect to time as $r\sim t^{k}$. (b,c) Sketches of the molecular processes in (b) the short-time initial regime and (c) the long-time diffusive regime.

Figure 9

Figure 7.The force per area $\bar{F}$, scaled by the surface tension ${\it\gamma}$, which the substrates exert on a slab of liquid water separated by height $h$ from the substrate. On the silica, water molecules can penetrate the space between the upper oxygens, leading to a net force on the liquid in this region below substrate level. Although the driving force is of similar length for the atomistic LJ substrate and the silica with PME electrostatics, the dynamics varies greatly, which can only be connected to the substrate topology. Reaction-field electrostatics leads to a longer interaction range for the charged silica, driving flow over three molecular layers. It should be noted that the area under all curves equals ${\it\gamma}\cos {\it\theta}_{0}$.

Figure 10

Figure 8.A direct comparison of the wetting dynamics predicted by the MD and the PF simulations: (a) silica; (b) LJ atomistic; (c) LJ potential. The wetting rates show that the short-time initial regime and the long-time regime of the wetting dynamics are captured by the PF model with separate friction parameters ${\it\mu}_{f}$ (given on the graphs). In (a), to illustrate the effect of a spatially varying ${\it\mu}_{f}$ we use a switch from ${\it\mu}_{f}=0$ to ${\it\mu}_{f}=50$, which gives a matching spreading rate between the MD and PF models. Our results suggest that at short times there is a rapid equilibration of the interface, i.e. ${\it\mu}_{f}\sim 0$, and a long-time relaxation where ${\it\mu}_{f}>0$.

Figure 11

Figure 9.A comparison of the global flow from MD (left half of the droplets) and PF simulations (right half, extracted for ${\hat{C}}\geqslant 0$): (a,b) silica; (c,d) LJ atomistic; shown for the early ($r/R=0.2$) and later ($r/R=0.8$) regimes of wetting for the atomistic substrates. To decrease thermal noise the MD flow was sampled over 300 ps for the early regime (a,c) and 500 ps for the later regime (b,d). For the silica, MD is matched against PF with the switched-on ${\it\mu}_{f}=50$ contact line friction factor seen in figure 8. While the wetting rates match qualitatively, the global flow is markedly different. For MD, fluid is pulled in from the sides of the droplet, thinning it out. Thermal fluctuations occur on a length scale comparable to the droplet size. For PF, a consistent global flow is quickly established. For the atomistic LJ substrate, MD is matched against PF, with ${\it\mu}_{f}=100$. As the wetting is faster the thermal noise is decreased, and similarly to the silica a difference in the global flow between MD and PF is observed.