Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-8p88z Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-19T12:29:16.415Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Prosodic disambiguation of scopally ambiguous quantificational sentences in a discourse context1

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 February 2014

KRISTEN SYRETT*
Affiliation:
Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey – New Brunswick
GEORGIA SIMON
Affiliation:
Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey – New Brunswick
KIRSTEN NISULA
Affiliation:
The Ohio State University
*
Authors' address: (Syrett) Department of Linguistics, Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey – New Brunswick, 18 Seminary Place, New Brunswick, NJ 08901, USAk-syrett@ruccs.rutgers.edu
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Researchers have long sought to determine the strength of the relation between prosody and the interpretation of scopally ambiguous sentences in English involving quantification and negation (e.g. All the men didn't go). While Jackendoff (1972) proposed a one-to-one mapping between sentence-final contour and the scope of negation (falling contour: narrow scope, fall-rise contour: wide scope), in subsequent work, researchers (e.g. Ladd 1980; Ward & Hirschberg 1985; Kadmon & Roberts 1986) disentangled the link between prosody and scope. Even though these pragmatic accounts predict variability in production, they still allow for some correlation between scope and prosody. To date, we lack systematic evidence to bear on this discussion. Here, we present findings from two perception experiments aimed at investigating whether prosodic information – including, but not limited to, sentence-final contour – can successfully disambiguate such sentences. We show that when speakers provide consistent auditory cues to sentential interpretation, hearers can successfully recruit these cues to arrive at the correct interpretation as intended by the speaker. In light of these results, we argue that psycholinguistic studies (including language acquisition studies) investigating participants’ ability to access multiple interpretations of scopally ambiguous sentences – quantificational and otherwise – should carefully control for prosody.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2014 
Figure 0

Table 1Pattern of results for ‘negation–because’ sentences in Hirschberg & Avesani (1997, 2000).

Figure 1

Table 2Distribution of percentage of perceived interpretation of sentence-final contour for every–negation sentences in McMahon et al. (2004).

Figure 2

Figure 1Pitch tracks for two versions of the sentence All the moms didn't allow eyeliner by Speaker 1 from two different contexts, each favoring a different scopal relation.

Figure 3

Table 3Average overall percentage correct in per item type and per speaker in Perception Experiment 1.

Figure 4

Figure 2Hit and false alarm rates for participants’ responses to test items in Perception Experiment 1.

Figure 5

Table 4Participants’ categorized responses to the post-experiment survey regarding their response strategies in Perception Experiment 1.

Figure 6

Table 5Average overall percentage correct per item type and per speaker in Perception Experiment 2.

Figure 7

Figure 3Hit and false alarm rates for participants’ responses to test items in Perception Experiment 2.

Figure 8

Figure B1Target sentence: Neil doesn't enjoy most musicals; Speaker   4.

Figure 9

Figure B2Target sentence: Liam doesn't know many alumni; Speaker 1.

Figure 10

Figure B3Target sentence: All the wool lining wasn't worn; Speaker 2.

Figure 11

Figure B4Target sentence: All the moms didn't allow eyeliner; Speaker 3.

Figure 12

Figure B5Target sentence: All the magnolias won't bloom; Speaker 3.

Figure 13

Figure B6Target sentence: They're not late because of his driving; Speaker 1.

Figure 14

Figure B7Target sentence: Larry only elbowed Riley; Speaker 4.