Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T12:24:09.503Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Understanding comparative alternation in y-adjectives: What else might we need?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 November 2017

DEBORAH CHUA*
Affiliation:
Victoria University of Wellington & National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University
*
Author’s address: National Institute of Education,Nanyang Technological University, 1 Nanyang Walk,NIE2-02-11,Singapore 637616, Singapore debchua2004@gmail.com; deborah.chua@nie.edu.sg
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper investigates the contribution of lexical spreads (or type counts) of English comparative more and -er constructions to an understanding of comparative alternation in the $y$ -adjectives, that is adjectives ending in an orthographic ${<}\text{y}>$ and an /i/ sound, e.g. lazy. Comparative $y$ -adjective constructions from seven corpora of stage plays spanning from the 17th to the 20th century were analysed with mixed-effects modelling and correlations drawn between the comparatives of $y$ -adjectives and those of other adjectives. The findings indicate that while morphological complexity in $y$ -adjectives biases them towards more, more occurrences with $y$ -adjectives may also be related to the lexical spread of more in disyllabic adjectives that are not $y$ -ones. The findings suggest moreover that predictions of comparative forms based on the syntactic positioning of $y$ -adjectives and the [±voiced] nature of their penultimate segments may make sense only with respect to the lexical spread of more in other English adjectives. To understand why $y$ -adjectives seem divided between -er regularisation and adherence to the trend in English comparisons of a more bias, this paper proposes a need to supplement accounts of comparative alternation focused on the characteristics of $y$ -adjectives with considerations related to the lexical spread of comparative constructions.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2017 
Figure 0

Table 1Factors considered for comparative alternation in $y$-adjectives.

Figure 1

Table 2Counts of comparative $y$-adjective tokens (for y-adjectives found with both more and -er across multiple periods).

Figure 2

Table 3Counts of comparative $y$-adjective tokens (for $y$-adjectives found with only more or only -er across multiple periods).

Figure 3

Table 4Counts of comparative $y$-adjective tokens (for $y$-adjectives found with only more or only -er in a single period).

Figure 4

Table 5Correlation matrix of all independent variables (IVs) proposed for inclusion in mixed-effects models (MEMs).

Figure 5

Table 6Effects of factors considered on the comparative forms of $y$-adjectives indicated from six mixed-effects models; Model 6 was accepted as best fit for the corpus data.

Figure 6

Table 7Cross-tabulation of token counts between morphology and plusminus/li/.

Figure 7

Figure 1Graph of model that best describes the corpus data.

Figure 8

Table 8Raw counts of (morphologically) complex and simple $y$-adjectives paired with more in each period.

Figure 9

Table 9Raw counts of $y$-adjectives paired with more and -er in each period.

Figure 10

Table 10Input (type counts) for correlations.

Figure 11

Table 11Input (token counts) for correlations.

Figure 12

Table 12Significant correlations between token counts of (subsets of) comparative $y$-adjective constructions and type counts of the comparatives of other items.